Skip to main content

Full text of "The unveiling of Lhasa"

See other formats


UNIFORM    WITH    THIS    VOLUME. 

A  LODGE   IN  THE  WILDERNESS.  John  Buchan. 

THE  LAND   OF   FOOTPRINTS.  Stewart  E.  White. 

WILD  LIFE  IN  A  SOUTHERN  COUNTY.  Richard  J efferies. 
PEOPLE   OF  THE  ABYSS.  Jack  London. 

THE  UNVEILING  OF   LHASA.  Edmund  Candler. 

COLLECTIONS  AND  RECOLLECTIONS.   G.  W.  E.  Russell. 

Herbert  IV.  Paul. 

R.  E.  Prothero. 

Henry  Neivlolt. 

Kenneth  Grahanie. 

Kenneth  Grahafue, 

S.  H.  Leeder. 

A.  Hilliard  Atteridge. 


LIFE  OF  GLADSTONE. 

THE  PSALMS  IN   HUMAN   LIFE. 

COLLECTED  POEMS,   1897-1907. 

DREAM  DAYS. 

THE  GOLDEN  AGE. 

THE  DESERT  GATEWAY. 

MARSHAL  MURAT. 

MY  FATHER  (LIFE  OF  W.  T.  STEAD).    Estelle  W.  Stead. 

THE   REMINISCENCES   OF  SIR  HENRY   HAWKINS. 

FROM  FIJI  TO  THE  CANNIBAL  ISLANDS.  B.Grintshaw. 

NAPOLEON:    THE   LAST  PHASE.  Lord  Rosehery. 

A  BOOK  ABOUT  ROSES.  Dean  Hole. 

THE  ALPS   FROM   END  TO  END.  Martin  Conway. 

A  MODERN  UTOPIA.  H.  G.  Wells. 

THE  PATH  TO   ROME.  Hilaire  Belloc. 

THE  GREAT  BOER  WAR.  A.  Conan  Doyle. 

FROM  A  COLLEGE  WINDOW.  A.  C.  Btmon. 


Others  to  follow. 


THE   UNVEILING 
OF   LHASA 


THE 
UNVEILING  OF  LHASA 


BY 

EDMUND    CANDLER 


^    \$Q^SI 


Qi-  1-  az. 


THOMAS   NELSON   AND    SONS,   Ltd. 

LONDON,    EDINBURGH,   AND  NEW  YORK 


THESE   PAGES, 

WRITTEN   MOSTLY   IN   THE   DRY  COLD   WIND   OF  TIBET, 

OFTEN   WHEN    INK   WAS   FROZEN   AND   ONE's   HAND 

TOO    NUMBED    TO    FEEL    A   PEN, 

ARE   DEDICATED   TO 

COLONEL   HOGGE,   C.B., 

AND 

THE  OFFICERS  OF  THE  23RD  SIKH  PIONEERS, 

WHOSE    GENIAL    SOCIETY    IS   ONE   OF   THE   MOST  ' 

PLEASANT    MEMORIES   OF    A    RIGOROUS 

CAMPAIGN. 


PREFACE 


The  recent  expedition  to  Lhasa  was  full  of  interest, 
not  only  on  account  of  the  political  issues  involved  and 
the  physical  difficulties  overcome,  but  owing  to  the 
many  dramatic  incidents  which  attended  the  Mission's 
progress.  It  was  my  good  fortune  to  witness  nearly 
all  these  stirring  events,  and  I  have  written  the  follow- 
ing narrative  of  what  I  saw  in  the  hope  that  a  continuous 
story  of  the  affair  may  interest  readers  who  have  hitherto 
been  able  to  form  an  idea  of  it  only  from  the  telegrams 
in  the  daily  Press.  The  greater  part  of  the  book  was 
written  on  the  spot,  while  the  impressions  of  events 
and  scenery  were  still  fresh.  Owing  to  wounds  I  was 
not  present  at  the  bombardment  and  relief  of  Gyantse, 
but  this  phase  of  the  operations  is  dealt  with  by  Mr. 
Henry  Newman,  Renter's  correspondent,  who  was  an 
eye-witness.  I  am  especially  indebted  to  him  for  his 
account,  which  was  written  in  Lhasa,  and  occupied 
many  mornings  that  might  have  been  devoted  to  well- 
earned  rest. 

I  a 


viii  PREFACE. 

My  thanks  are  also  due  to  the  Proprietors  of  the 
Daily  Mail  for  permission  to  use  material  of  which 
they  hold  the  copyright;  and  I  am  indebted  to  the 
Editors  of  the  Graphic  and  Black  and  White  for  allow- 
ing me  to  reproduce  certain  photographs  by  Lieutenant 
Bailey. 

The  illustrations  are  from  sketches  by  Lieutenant 
Rybot,  and  photographs  by  Lieutenants  Bailey,  Bethell, 
and  Lewis,  to  whom  I  owe  my  cordial  thanks. 

EDMUND   CANDLER. 
London,  January^  1905. 


CONTENTS 


CHAPTER  I 

THE   CAUSES   OF  THE   EXPEDITION 

PAGE 

A  retrospect — Early  visitors  to  Lhasa — The  Jesuits — The 
Capuchins  —  Van  der  Putte  —  Thomas  Manning — The 
Lazajist  fathers — Policy  of  exclusion  due  to  Chinese 
influence— The  Nepalese  invasion — Bogle  and  Turner 
—  The  Macaulay  Mission  —  Tibetans  invade  Indian 
territory  —  The  expedition  of  1888  — The  convention 
with  China — British  blundering— Our  treatment  of  the 
Shata  Shap^ — The  Yatung  trade  mart — Tibetans  repudi- 
ate the  convention — Fiction  of  the  Chinese  suzerainty — 
A  policy  of  drift — Tibetan  Mission  to  the  Czar — Dorjieff 
and  his  intrigues — The  Dalai  Lama  and  Russian  designs 
— Our  great  countermove — Boj'cotted  at  Khamba  Jong — 
The  advance  sanctioned — Winter  quarters  at  Tuna .        .        17 


CHAPTER  II 

OVER   THE   FRONTIER 

From  the  base  to  Gnatong — A  race  to  Chumbi — A  perilous 
night  ride — Forest  scenery — Gnatong  three  years  ago  and 
now — Gnatong  in  action— A  mountain  lake — The  Jelap 
la  and  beyond  —  Undefended  barriers — Yatung  and  its 
Customs  House — Chumbi — The  first  Press  message  from 
Tibet  — Arctic  clothing  —  Scenes  in  camp — A  very'  un- 
comfortable 'picnic' 


CONTENTS— Continued. 
CHAPTER  III 

THE  CHUMBI   VALLEY 

PAGE 

The  Tomos — A  hardy  race— Their  habits  and  diversions — 
Chinamen  in  exile— A  prosperous  valley— But  a  cheer- 
less clime — Kasi  and  his  statistics  —  Trade  figures  — 
Tibetan  cruelties— Kasi  as  general  provider — Mountain 
scenery — The  spirit  of  the  Himalayas— A  glorious  flora 
— The  Himalayas  and  the  Alps— The  wall  of  Gob-sorg — 
Chinamen  and  Tomos— A  future  hill-station — Lingma- 
thang— A  cosy  cave — The  Mounted  Infantry  Corps — 
Two  famous  regiments  —  Sport  at  Lingmathang — The 
Sikkim  stag— Gamebirds  and  wildfowl — Gautsa  camp     .        57  ^ 

CHAPTER   IV 

PHARI  JONG 
Gautsa  to  Phari  Jong— A  wonderful  old  fortress — Tibetan 
dirt — A  medical  armoury — The  Lamas'  library — Road- 
making  and  sport  —  The  Tibetan  gazelle  and  other 
animals — Evening  diversions— Cold,  grime,  and  misery 
— Manning's  journal— Bogle's  account  of  Phari— History 
of  the  fortress  —  The  town  and  its  occupants — The 
mystery  of  Tibet—The  significance  of  the  frescoes — 
Departure  from  Phari  —  The  monastery  of  the  Red 
Lamas — Chumulari — The  Tibetan  New  Year — Bogle's 
narrative— The  Tang  la  and  the  road  to  Lhasa         .        .        88  —■ 

CHAPTER    V 

THE   ROAD   AND   TRANSPORT 

A  transport  'show' — Difficulties  of  the  way — Vicissitudes 
of  climate — Frozen  heights  and  sweltering  vall^s  — 
Disease  amongst  transport  animals — A  tale  of  disaster 
— The  stricken  Yak  Corps— Troubles  of  the  transport 
officer — Mules  to  the  rescue- The  coolie  transport 
corps — Carrying  power  of  the  transport  items — The 
problem  and  its  solution  —  The  ekka  and  the  yak  — A 
providentially  ascetic  beast — Splendid  work  of  the  trans- 
port service — Courage  and  endurance  of  officers  and  men 
— The  12th  Mule  Corps  benighted  in  a  blizzard — Rifle- 
bolts  and  Maxims  frost-jammed— Difficulties  of  a  Russian 
advance  on  Lhasa— The  new  Ammo  Chu  cart-road .        .      113 


CONTENT  S~Continued. 
CHAPTER  VI 

THE   ACTION   AT  THE   HOT  SPRINGS 

PAGB 

The  deadlock  at  Tuna — Discomforts  of  the  garrison — The 
Lamas'  curse — The  attitude  of  Bhutan — A  diplomatic 
triumph  —  Tedious  delays  —  A  welcome  move  forward 
— The  Tibetan  camp  at  Hot  Springs— The  Lhasa  Depon 
meets  Colonel  Younghusband — Futile  conferences — The 
Tibetan  position  surrounded — Coolness  of  the  Sikhs  and 
Gurkhas— The  disarming — A  sudden  outbreak — A  des- 
perate struggle— The  action  of  the  Lhasa  General — The 
rabble  disillusioned  in  their  gods — A  beaten  and  be- 
wildered enemy — Reflections  after  the  event — Tibetans 
in  hospital — Three  months  afterwards       ....       132 

CHAPTER   VH 

A  HUMAN  MISCELLANY 
In  a  doolie  to  the  base — Tibetan  bearers — A  retrospect — A 
reverie  and  a  reminiscence — Snow-bound  at  Phari — The 
Bhutia  as  bearer — The  Lepchas  and  their  humours — 
Mongolian  odours — The  road  at  last— Platitudes  in 
epigram — Lucknow  doolie-wallahs — Their  hymn  of  the 
obvious — Meetings  on  the  road — A  motley  of  races — 
Through  a  tropical  forest — The  Tista  and  civilization      .       151 

CHAPTER  Vni 

THE  ADVANCE  OF  THE  MISSION  OPPOSED 
The  Tibetans  responsible  for  hostilities  —  Their  version  of 
the  Hot  Springs  affair — Treacherous  attack  at  Samando 
—Wall-building— The  Red  Idol  Gorge  action— A  stiff 
climb  —  The  enemy  outflanked  —  Impressed  peasants- 
First  phase  of  the  opposition — Bad  generalship — Lack 
of  enterprise  —  Erratic  shooting  —  All  quiet  at  Gyantse 
—  Enemy  occupy  Karo  la— A  booby  trap— Colonel 
Brander's  sortie  —  Frontal  attack  repulsed  —  Captain 
Bethune  killed  —  Failure  of  flanking  movement  —  A 
critical  moment  —  Sikhs  turn  the  position — Flight  and 
pursuit  —  Second  phase  of  the  opposition  —  Advanced 
tactics— Danger  of  being  cut  off— The  attack  on  Kang- 
ma  —  Desperate  gallantry  of  the  enemy — Patriots  or 
fanatics? 165 


CONTENTS— Continued. 


CHAPTER   IX 

GYANTSE   (BY    HENRY   NEWMAN) 


PAGE 


A  happy  valley — Devastated  by  war — Why  the  Jong  was 
evacuated — The  lull  before  the  storm — Tibetans  mass- 
ing— The  attack  on  the  mission — A  hot  ten  minutes— 
Pyjamaed  warriors  —  Wounded  to  the  rescue  —  The 
Gurkhas'  rally  —  The  camp  bombarded — The  labour  of 
defence  work — Hadow's  Maxim— Life  during  the  siege 
—  Tibetans  reinforced  —  They  enfilade  our  position  — 
The  taking  of  the  '  Gurkha  Post' — Terrible  carnage         .       194 


CHAPTER  X 
GYANTSE — contmued 

Attack  on  the  postal  riders— Brilliant  exploit  of  the  Mounted 
Infantry  —  Communications  threatened  —  Clearing  the 
villages — A  narrow  shave— Arrival  of  reinforcements — 
The  storming  of  Palla— House-fighting — Capture  of  the 
post — A  fantastic  display — Night  attacks— Seven  miles 
of  front — Advance  of  the  relief  column — The  Tibetans 
cornered— Naini  monastery  taken— Capture  of  Tsaden — 
Our  losses — The  armistice— Tibetans  refuse  to  surrender 
the  Jong — A  bristling  fortress — The  attack  at  dawn — 
The  breach — Gallantry  of  Lieutenat  Grant  and  his 
Gurkhas— Capture  of  the  Jong 216 


CHAPTER  XI 

GOSSIP  ON  THE   ROAD  TO  THE   FRONT 

A  garden  in  the  forest  — A  jeremiad  on  transport  — The 
servant  question  — Jung  Bir  — British  Bhutan— Kalim- 
pong  — 'The  Bhutia  tat'— Father  Desgodins  —  An 
adventurous  career  —  A  lost  opportunity  —  Chinese 
duplicity — Phuntshog — New  arms  and  new  friends  for 
Tibet  —  A  mysterious  Lama  — Dorjieff  again — The  in- 
scrutable Tibetan 246 


CONTENTS— Continued. 
CHAPTER  XII 

TO   THE   GREAT   RIVER 

PAGE 

Failure  of  peace  negotiations — Opposition  expected — Details 
of  force — March  to  the  Karo  la — Villages  deserted — 
The  second  Karo  la  action— The  Gurkhas'  climb— The 
Tibetan  rout  —  The  Kham  prisoners  — Hopelessness  of 
the  Tibetans'  struggle  —  Their  troops  disheartened  — 
Arrival  at  Nagartse — Tedious  delegates — The  victory 
of  a  personality— Brush  with  Tibetan  cavalry — The 
last  shot — The  Shapes  despoiled — Modern  rifles — Ex- 
aggerated reports  of  Russian  assistance — The  Yamdok 
Tso  —  Dorje  Phagmo — Legends  of  the  lake — The  in- 
cubus of  an  army — Why  men  travel — Wildfowl — Pehte — 
View  from  the  Khamba  Pass — From  the  desert  to 
Arcadia — The  Tibetan  of  the  tablelands  —  The  Tuna 
plateau  —  Homely  scenes  —  A  mood  of  indolence — The 
course  of  the  Tsangpo — The  Brahmaputra  Irawaddy 
controversy — The  projected  Tsangpo  trip— Legendary 
geography — Lost  opportunities 261 

CHAPTER  XIII 

LHASA   AND    ITS   VANISHED   DEITY 

The  passage  of  the  river — Major  Bretherton  drowned — The 
Kyi  Chu  valley — Tropical  heat — Atisa's  tomb — Forag- 
ing in  holy  places — First  sight  of  the  Potala — Hidden 
Lhasa  —  Symbols  of  remonstrance — Prophecies  of  in- 
vasion—  And  decay  of  Buddhism — Medieval  Tibet — 
Spiritual  terrorism — Lamas'  fears  of  enlightenment — 
The  last  mystery  unveiled  —  Arrival  at  Lhasa — View 
from  the  Chagpo  Ri — Entry  into  the  city — Apathy  of 
the  people  —  The  Potala — Magnificence  and  squalor — 
The  secret  of  romance — A  vanished  deity — '  Thou  sh«lt 
not  kill' — Secret  assassinations — A  marvellous  disap- 
pearance— The  Dalai  Lama  joins  Dorjieff — His  person- 
ality and  character  —  The  verdict  of  the  Nepalcse 
Resident — The  voice  without  a  soul — The  wisdom  of 
his  flight — A  romantic  picture — The  place  of  the  dead     .       297 


CON  TE  N  TS—  Continued. 


CHAPTER  XIV 

THE   CITY   AND    ITS   TEMPLES 

PAGE 

Sullen  monks — A  Lama  runs  amok — The  environs  of  Lhasa 
—  The  Lingkhor  —  The  Ragyabas  —  The  cathedral  — 
Service  before  the  Great  Huddhas — The  Lamas'  chant — 
Vessels  of  gold  —  'Hell'  —  White  mice  —  The  many- 
handed  Buddha — Silence  and  abstraction — The  bazaar — 
Hats — The  Mongolians — Curio-hunting — The  Ramo-che 
— Sorcery  —  The  adventures  of  a  soul  —  Lamaism  and 
Roman  Catholicism  —  The  decay  of  Buddhism  —  The 
three  great  monasteries  —  Their  political  influence— 
Depung  —  An  ecclesiastical  University  —  The  'impos- 
sible' Tibetan  —  An  ultimatum — Consternation  at 
Depung — Temporizing  and  evasion— An  ugly  mob — A 
political  deadlock 329 

CHAPTER  XV 

THE      SETTLEMENT 

An  irresponsible  administration — An  insolent  reply — Tibetan 
haggling — Release  of  the  Lachung  men — Social  relations 
with  the  Tibetans — A  guarded  ultimatum — A  diplomatic 
triumph  — The  signing  of  the  treaty— Colonel  Young- 
husband's  speech — The  terms — Political  prisoners  liber- 
ated— Deposition  of  the  Dalai  Lama — The  Tashe  Lama 
— Prospect  of  an  Anglophile  Pope — The  practical  results 
of  the  expedition— Russia  discredited — Why  a  Resident 
should  be  left  at  Lhasa — China  hesitates  to  sign  the 
Treaty — The  '  vicious  circle  '  again — Her  acquiescence 
not  of  vital  importance— The  attitude  of  Tibet  to  Great 
Britain — Fear  and  respect  the  only  guarantee  of  future 
good  conduct 354 


THE 
UNVEILING  OF   LHASA 


T 


CHAPTER   I 

THE   CAUSES   OF  THE   EXPEDITION 

HE  conduct  of  Great  Britain  in  her  relations 
with  Tibet  puts  me  in  mind  of  the  dilemma 
of  a  big  boy  at  school  who  submits  to  the  attacks 
of  a  precocious  youngster  rather  than  incur  the 
imputation  of  '  bully.'  At  last  the  situation  be- 
comes intolerable,  and  the  big  boy,  bully  if  you 
will,  turns  on  the  youth  and  administers  the  de- 
served thrashing.  There  is  naturally  a  good  deal 
of  remonstrance  from  spectators  who  have  not 
observed  the  by-play  which  led  to  the  encounter. 
But  S3mipathy  must  be  sacrificed  to  the  restitution 
of  fitting  and  respectful  relations. 

The  aim  of  this  record  of  an  individual's  impres- 
sions of  the  recent  Tibetan  expedition  is  to  convey 
some  idea  of  the  life  we  led  in  Tibet,  the  scenes 


X6  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

through  which  we  passed,  and  the  strange  people 
we  fought  and  conquered.  We  killed  several  thou- 
sand of  these  brave,  ill-armed  men  ;  and  as  the 
story  of  the  fighting  is  not  always  pleasant  reading, 
I  think  it  right  before  describing  the  punitive  side 
of  the  expedition  to  make  it  quite  clear  that  military 
operations  were  unavoidable — that  we  were  drawn 
into  the  vortex  of  war  against  our  will  by  the  folly 
and  obstinacy  of  the  Tibetans. 

The  briefest  review  of  the  rebuffs  Great  Britain 
has  submitted  to  during  the  last  twenty  years  will 
suffice  to  show  that,  so  far  from  being  to  blame  in 
adopting  punitive  measures,  she  is  open  to  the  charge 
of  unpardonable  weakness  in  allowing  affairs  to  reach 
the  crisis  which  made  such  punishment  necessary. 

It  must  be  remembered  that  Tibet  has  not  always 
been  closed  to  strangers.  The  history  of  European 
travellers  in  Lhasa  forms  a  Hterature  to  itself. 
Until  the  end  of  the  eighteenth  century  only  phys- 
ical obstacles  stood  in  the  way  of  an  entry  to  the 
capital.  Jesuits  and  Capuchins  reached  Lhasa, 
made  long  stays  there,  and  were  even  encouraged 
by   the   Tibetan   Government.     The   first  *    Euro- 

*  Friar  Odcric  of  Portenone  is  supposed  to  have  visited  Lhasa 
in  1325,  but  the  authenticity  of  this  record  is  open  to  doubt. 


CAUSES  OF  THE  EXPEDITION.  19 

peans  to  visit  the  city  and  leave  an  authentic  record 
of  their  journey  were  the  Fathers  Grueber  and 
d'Orville,  who  penetrated  Tibet  from  China  in  1661 
by  the  Sining  route,  and  stayed  in  Lhasa  two 
months.  In  1715  the  Jesuits  Desideri  and  Freyre 
reached  Lhasa ;  Desideri  stayed  there  thirteen 
years.  In  1719  arrived  Horace  de  la  Penna  and 
the  Capuchin  Mission,  who  built  a  chapel  and  a 
hospice,  made  several  converts,  and  were  not  fin- 
ally expelled  till  1740.*  The  Dutchman  Van  der, 
Putte,  first  layman  to  penetrate  to  the  capital; 
arrived  in  1720,  and  stayed  there  some  years.  After 
this  we  have  no  record  of  a  European  reaching 
Lhasa  until  the  adventurous  journey  in  1811  of 
Thomas  Manning,  the  first  and  only  Englishman 
to  reach  the  city  before  this  year.  Manning  arrived 
in  the  retinue  of  a  Chinese  General  whom  he  had 
met  at  Phari  Jong,  and  whose  gratitude  he  had  won 
for  medical  services.  He  remained  in  the  capital 
four  months,  and  during  his  stay  he  made  the  ac- 
quaintance of  several  Chinese  and  Tibetan  officials, 

*  When  in  Lhasa  I  sought  in  vain  for  any  trace  of  these  build- 
ings. The  most  enlightened  Tibetans  are  ignorant,  or  pretend 
to  be  so,  that  Christian  missionaries  have  resided  in  the  city. 
In  the  cathedral,  however,  we  found  a  bell  with  the  inscription, 
'  TE  DEUM  LAUDAMUS,'  which  is  probably  a  relic  of  the  Capuchins. 


20  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

and  was  even  presented  to  the  Dalai  Lama  himself. 
The  influence  of  his  patron,  however,  was  not  strong 
enough  to  insure  his  safety  in  the  city.  He  was 
warned  that  his  life  was  endangered,  and  returned 
to  India  by  the  same  way  he  came.  In  1846  the 
Lazarist  missionaries  Hue  and  Gabet  reached  Lhasa 
in  the  disguise  of  Lamas  after  eighteen  months' 
wanderings  through  China  and  Mongoha,  during 
which  they  must  have  suffered  as  much  from  pri- 
vations and  hardships  as  any  travellers  who  have 
survived  to  tell  the  tale.  They  were  received 
kindly  by  the  Amban  and  Regent,  but  permission 
to  stay  was  firmly  refused  them  on  the  grounds 
that  they  were  there  to  subvert  the  religion  of 
the  State.  Despite  the  attempts  of  several  deter- 
mined travellers,  none  of  whom  got  within  a  hun- 
dred miles  of  Lhasa,  the  Lazarist  fathers  were  the 
last  Europeans  to  set  foot  in  the  city  until  Colonel 
Younghusband  rode  through  the  Pargo  Kaling 
gate  on  August  4,  1904. 

The  records  of  these  travellers  to  Lhasa,  and  of 
others  who  visited  different  parts  of  Tibet  before 
the  end  of  the  eighteenth  century,  do  not  point  to 
any  serious  poHtical  obstacles  to  the  admission  of 
strangers.     Two   centuries   ago,    Europeans   might 


CAUSES  OF  THE  EXPEDITION.         21 

travel  in  remote  parts  of  Asia  with  greater  safety 
than  is  possible  to-day.  Suspicions  have  naturally 
increased  with  our  encroachments,  and  the  white 
man  now  inspires  fear  where  he  used  only  to  awake 
interest.* 

The  policy  of  strict  exclusion  in  Tibet  seems  to 
have  been  synchronous  with  Chinese  ascendancy. 
At  the  end  of  the  eighteenth  century  the  Nepalese 
invaded  and  overran  the  country.  The  Lamas 
turned  to  China  for  help,  and  a  force  of  70,000  men 
was  sent  to  their  assistance.  The  Chinese  drove 
the  Gurkhas  over  their  frontier,  and  practically 
annihilated  their  army  within  a  day's  march  of 
Khatmandu.  From  this  date  China  has  virtually 
or  nominally  ruled  in  Lhasa,  and  an  important  re- 
sult of  her  intervention  has  been  to  sow  distrust  of 


*  Suspicion  and  jealousy  of  foreigners  seems  to  have  been  the 
guiding  principle  both  of  Tibetans  and  Chinese  even  in  the  earlier 
history  of  the  country.  The  attitude  is  well  illustrated  by  a 
letter  written  in  1774  by  the  Regent  at  Lhasa  to  the  Teshu  Lama 
with  reference  to  Bogle's  mission  :  '  He  had  heard  of  two  Fringies 
being  arrived  in  the  Deb  Raja's  dominions,  with  a  great  retinue 
of  servants  ;  that  the  Fringies  were  fond  of  war,  and  after  in- 
sinuating themselves  into  a  country  raised  disturbances  and 
made  themselves  masters  of  it ;  that  as  no  Fringies  had  ever  been 
admitted  into  Tibet,  he  advised  the  Lama  to  find  some  method 
of  sending  them  back,  either  on  account  of  the  violence  of  the 
small-pox  or  on  any  other  pretence.' 


22  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

the  British.  She  represented  that  we  had  insti- 
gated the  Nepalese  invasion,  and  warned  the  Lamas 
that  the  only  way  to  obviate  our  designs  on  Tibet 
was  to  avoid  all  communication  with  India,  and 
keep  the  passes  strictly  closed  to  foreigners. 

Shortly  before  the  Nepalese  War,  Warren  Hast- 
ings had  sent  the  two  missions  of  Bogle  and  Turner 
to  Shigatze.  Bogle  was  cordially  received  by  the 
Grand  Teshu  Lama,  and  an  intimate  friendship 
was  established  between  the  two  men.  On  his 
return  to  India  he  reported  that  the  only  bar  to 
a  complete  understanding  with  Tibet  was  the  ob- 
stinacy of  the  Regent  and  the  Chinese  agents  at 
Lhasa,  who  were  inspired  by  Peking.  An  attempt 
was  arranged  to  influence  the  Chinese  Government 
in  the  matter,  but  both  Bogle  and  the  Teshu  Lama 
died  before  it  could  be  carried  out.  Ten  years  later 
Turner  was  despatched  to  Tibet,  and  received  the 
same  welcome  as  his  predecessor.  Everything 
pointed  to  the  continuance  of  a  steady  and  con- 
sistent policy  by  which  the  barrier  of  obstruction 
might  have  been  broken  down.  But  Warren  Hast- 
ings was  recalled  in  1785,  and  Lord  Cornwalhs,  the 
next  Governor-General,  took  no  steps  to  approach 
and  conciliate  the  Tibetans.     It  was  in  1792  that 


CAUSES  OF  THE  EXPEDITION.  23 

the  Tibetan-Nepalese  War  broke  out,  which,  owing 
to  the  misrepresentations  of  China,  precluded  any 
possibihty  of  an  understanding  between  India  and 
Tibet.  Such  was  the  uncompromising  spirit  of  the 
Lamas,  that,  until  Lord  Dufferin  sanctioned  the 
commercial  mission  of  Mr.  Colman  Macaulay  in 
1886,  no  succeeding  Viceroy  after  Warren  Hastings 
thought  it  worth  while  to  renew  the  attempt  to 
enter  into  friendly  relations  with  the  country. 

The  Macaulay  Mission  incident  was  the  beginning 
of  that  weak  and  abortive  policy  which  lost  us  the 
respect  of  the  Tibetans,  and  led  to  the  succession 
of  affronts  and  indignities  which  made  the  recent 
expedition  to  Lhasa  inevitable.  The  escort  had 
already  advanced  into  Sikkim,  and  Mr.  Macaulay 
was  about  to  join  it,  when  orders  were  received  from 
Government  for  its  return.  The  withdrawal  was  a 
concession  to  the  Chinese,  with  whom  we  were  then 
engaged  in  the  delimitation  of  the  Burmese  frontier. 
This  display  of  weakness  incited  the  Tibetans  to 
such  a  pitch  of  vanity  and  insolence  that  they  in- 
vaded our  territory  and  established  a  mihtary  post 
at  Lingtu,  only  seventy  miles  from  Darjeeling. 

We  allowed  the  invaders  to  remain  in  the  pro- 
tected State  of  Sikkim  two  years  before  we  made 


24  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

any  reprisal.  In  1888,  after  several  vain  appeals 
to  China  to  use  her  influence  to  withdraw  the  Tibetan 
troops,  we  reluctantly  decided  on  a  military  expedi- 
tion. The  Tibetans  were  driven  from  their  position, 
defeated  in  three  separate  engagements,  and  pur- 
sued over  the  frontier  as  far  as  Chumbi.  We  ought 
to  have  concluded  a  treaty  with  them  on  the  spot, 
when  we  were  in  a  position  to  enforce  it,  but  we 
were  afraid  of  offending  the  susceptibilities  of  China, 
whose  suzerainty  over  Tibet  we  still  recognised, 
though  she  had  acknowledged  her  inabihty  to  re- 
strain the  Tibetans  from  invading  our  territory. 
At  the  conclusion  of  the  campaign,  in  which  the 
Tibetans  showed  no  military  instincts  whatever, 
we  returned  to  our  post  at  Gnatong,  on  the  Sikkim 
frontier. 

After  two  years  of  fruitless  discussion,  a  conven- 
tion was  drawn  up  between  Great  Britain  and  China, 
by  which  Great  Britain's  exclusive  control  over 
the  internal  administration  and  foreign  relations  of 
Sikkim  was  recognised,  the  Sikkim-Tibet  boundary 
was  defined,  and  both  Powers  undertook  to  prevent 
acts  of  aggression  from  their  respective  sides  of  the 
frontier.  The  questions  of  pasturage,  trade  facili- 
ties, and  the  method  in  which  official  communica- 


CAUSES  OF  THE  EXPEDITION.  25 

tions  should  be  conducted  between  the  Government 
of  India  and  the  authorities  at  Lhasa  were  deferred 
for  future  discussion.  Nearly  three  more  years 
passed  before  the  trade  regulations  were  drawn  up 
in  Darjeeling — in  December,  1903.  The  negotiations 
were  characterized  by  the  same  shuffling  and  equivo- 
cation on  the  part  of  the  Chinese,  and  the  same 
weak-kneed  policy  of  forbearance  and  conciliation  on 
the  part  of  the  British.  Treaty  and  regulations  were 
ahke  impotent,  and  our  concessions  went  so  far  that 
we  exacted  nothing  as  the  fruit  of  our  victory  over 
the  Tibetans — not  even  a  fraction  of  the  cost  of  the 
campaign. 

Our  ignorance  of  the  Tibetans,  their  Government, 
and  their  relations  with  China  was  at  this  time  so 
profound  that  we  took  our  cue  from  the  Chinese, 
who  always  referred  to  the  Lhasa  authorities  as 
'  the  barbarians.'  The  Shata  Shap6,  the  most  in- 
fluential of  the  four  members  of  Council,  attended 
the  negotiations  on  behalf  of  the  Tibetans.  He  was 
officially  ignored,  and  no  one  thought  of  asking  him 
to  attach  his  signature  to  the  treaty.  The  omis- 
sion was  a  blunder  of  far-reaching  consequences. 
Had  we  realized  that  Chinese  authority  was  practi- 
cally non-existent  in  Lhasa,  and  that  the  temporal 


26  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

affairs  of  Tibet  were  mainly  directed  by  the  four 
Shap6s  and  the  Tsong-du  (the  very  existence  of 
which,  by  the  way,  was  unknown  to  us),  we  might 
have  secured  a  diplomatic  agent  in  the  Shata  Shap^ 
who  would  have  proved  invaluable  to  us  in  our 
future  relations  with  the  country.  Unfortunately, 
during  his  stay  in  Darjeehng  the  Shape's  feehngs 
were  lacerated  by  ill-treatment  as  well  as  neglect. 
In  an  unfortunate  encounter  with  British  youth, 
which  was  said  to  have  arisen  from  his  jostUng 
an  English  lady  off  the  path,  he  was  taken  by  the 
scruff  of  the  neck  and  ducked  in  the  public  foun- 
tain. So  he  returned  to  Tibet  with  no  love  for  the 
EngUsh,  and  after  certain  courteous  overtures  from 
the  agents  of  *  another  Power,'  became  a  confirmed 
though  more  or  less  accidental,  Russophile.  Though 
deposed,*  he  has  at  the  present  moment  a  large 
following  among  the  monks  of  the  Gaden  monastery. 
In  the  regulations  of  1893  it  was  stipulated  that 
a  trade  mart  should  be  established  at  Yatung,  a 
small  hamlet  six  miles  beyond  our  frontier.  The 
place  is  obviously  unsuitable,  situated  as  it  is  in 
a  narrow  pine-clad  ravine,  where  one  can  throw  a 

*  The  Shata  Shap6  and  his  three  colleagues  were  deposed  by 
the  Dalai  Lama  in  October,  1903. 


CAUSES  OF  THE  EXPEDITION.  27 

stone  from  cliff  to  cliff  across  the  valley.  No  traders 
have  ever  resorted  there,  and  the  Tibetans  have 
studiously  boycotted  the  place.  To  show  their 
contempt  for  the  treaty,  and  their  determination  to 
ignore  it,  they  built  a  wall  a  quarter  of  a  mile  be- 
yond the  Customs  House,  through  which  no  Tibetan 
or  British  subject  was  allowed  to  pass,  and,  to  nullify 
the  object  of  the  mart,  a  tax  of  10  per  cent,  on 
Indian  goods  was  levied  at  Phari.  Every  attempt 
was  made  by  Sheng  Tai,  the  late  Amban,  to  induce 
the  Tibetans  to  substitute  Phari  for  Yatung  as  a 
trade  mart.  But,  as  an  of&cial  report  admits,  '  it 
was  found  impossible  to  overcome  their  reluctance. 
Yatung  was  eventually  accepted  both  by  the 
Chinese  and  British  Governments  as  the  only  alter- 
native to  breaking  off  the  negotiations  altogether.' 
This  confession  of  weakness  appears  to  me  abject 
enough  to  quote  as  typical  of  our  attitude  through- 
out. In  deference  to  Tibetan  wishes,  we  allowed 
nearly  every  clause  of  the  treaty  to  be  separately 
stultified. 

The  Tibetans,  as  might  be  expected,  met  our  for- 
bearance by  further  rebuffs.  Not  content  with  evad- 
ing their  treaty  obligations  in  respect  to  trade,  they 
proceeded  to  overthrow  our  boundary  pillars,  vio- 


28  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

late  grazing  rights,  and  erect  guard-houses  at  Gia- 
gong,  in  Sikkim  territory.  When  called  to  question 
they  repudiated  the  treaty,  and  said  that  it  had 
never  been  shown  them  by  the  Amban.  It  had 
not  been  sealed  or  confirmed  by  any  Tibetan  repre- 
sentative, and  they  had  no  intention  of  observ- 
ing it. 

Once  more  the  *  solemn  farce  '  was  enacted  of 
an  appeal  to  China  to  use  her  influence  with  the 
Lhasa  authorities.  And  it  was  only  after  repeated 
representations  had  been  made  by  the  Indian  Gov- 
ernment to  the  Secretary  of  State  that  the  Home 
Government  realized  the  seriousness  of  the  situa- 
tion, and  the  hopelessness  of  making  any  progress 
through  the  agency  of  China.  *  We  seem,'  said 
Lord  Curzon,  '  in  respect  to  our  policy  in  Tibet, 
to  be  moving  in  a  vicious  circle.  If  we  apply  to 
Tibet  we  either  receive  no  reply  or  are  referred  to 
the  Chinese  Resident ;  if  we  apply  to  the  latter, 
he  excuses  his  failure  by  his  inabiUty  to  put  any 
pressure  upon  Tibet.'  In  the  famous  despatch  of 
January  8,  1903,  the  Viceroy  described  the  Chinese 
suzerainty  as  *  a  political  fiction,'  only  maintained 
because  of  its  convenience  to  both  parties.  China 
no  doubt  is  capable  of  sending  sufficient  troops  to 


CAUSES  OF  THE  EXPEDITION.  29 

Lhasa  to  coerce  the  Tibetans.  But  it  has  suited 
her  book  to  maintain  the  present  elusive  and  anom- 
alous relations  with  Tibet,  which  are  a  securer  but- 
tress to  her  western  dependencies  against  encroach- 
ment than  the  strongest  army  corps.  For  many 
years  we  have  been  the  butt  of  the  Tibetans,  and 
China  their  stalking-horse. 

The  Tibetan  attitude  was  clearly  expressed  by 
the  Shigatze  officials  at  Khamba  Jong  in  September 
last  year,  when  they  openly  boasted  that  '  where 
Chinese  policy  was  in  accordance  with  their  own 
views  they  were  ready  enough  to  accept  the  Am- 
ban's  advice  ;  but  if  this  advice  ran  counter  in  any 
respect  to  their  national  prejudices,  the  Chinese 
Emperor  himself  would  be  powerless  to  influence 
them.*  China  has  on  several  occasions  confessed 
her  inability  to  coerce  the  Tibetans.  She  has  proved 
herself  unable  to  enforce  the  observance  of  treaties 
or  even  to  restrain  her  subjects  from  invading  our 
territory,  and  during  the  recent  attempts  at  nego- 
tiations she  had  to  admit  that  her  representative 
in  Lhasa  was  officially  ignored,  and  not  even  allowed 
transport  to  travel  in  the  country.  In  the  face  of 
these  facts  her  exceedingly  shadowy  suzerainty  may 
be  said  to  have  entirely  evaporated,  and  it  is  un- 


30  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

reasonable  to  expect  us  to  continue  our  relations 
with  Tibet  through  the  medium  of  Peking. 

It  was  not  until  nine  years  after  the  signing  of 
the  convention  that  we  made  any  attempt  to  open 
direct  communications  with  the  Tibetans  them- 
selves. It  is  astonishing  that  we  allowed  ourselves 
to  be  hoodwinked  so  long.  But  this  policy  of  drift 
and  waiting  is  characteristic  of  our  foreign  relations 
all  over  the  world.  British  Cabinets  seem  to  be- 
lieve that  cure  is  better  than  prevention,  and  when 
faced  by  a  dilemma  have  seldom  been  known  to 
act  on  the  initiative,  or  take  any  decided  course 
until  the  very  existence  of  their  dependency  is  im- 
perilled. 

In  1901  Lord  Curzon  was  permitted  to  send  a 
despatch  to  the  Dalai  Lama  in  which  it  was  pointed 
out  that  his  Government  had  consistently  defied 
and  ignored  treaty  rights  ;  and  in  view  of  the  con- 
tinued occupation  of  British  territory,  the  destruc- 
tion of  frontier  pillars,  and  the  restrictions  imposed 
on  Indian  trade,  we  should  be  compelled  to  resort 
to  more  practical  measures  to  enforce  the  observ- 
ance of  the  treaty,  should  he  remain  obstinate  in 
his  refusal  to  enter  into  friendly  relations.  The 
letter  was  returned  unopened,  with  the  verbal  ex- 


CAUSES  OF  THE  EXPEDITION.  31 

cuse  that  the  Chinese  did  not  permit  him  to  receive 
communications  from  any  foreign  Power.  Yet  so 
great  was  our  reluctance  to  resort  to  mihtary  coer- 
cion that  we  might  even  at  this  point  have  let 
things  drift,  and  submitted  to  the  rebuffs  of  these 
impossible  Tibetans,  had  not  the  Dalai  Lama  chosen 
this  moment  for  publicly  flaunting  his  relations  with 
Russia. 

The  second  *  Tibetan  Mission  reached  St.  Peters- 
burg in  June,  1901,  carrying  autograph  letters  and 
presents  to  the  Czar  from  the  Dalai  Lama.  Count 
Lamsdorff  declared  that  the  mission  had  no  political 
significance  whatever.  We  were  asked  to  believe 
that  these  Lamas  travelled  many  thousand  miles 
to  convey  a  letter  that  expressed  the  hope  that 
the  Russian  Foreign  Minister  was  in  good  health 
and  prosperous,  and  informed  him  that  the  Dalai 
Lama  was  happy  to  be  able  to  say  that  he  himself 
enjoyed  excellent  health. 

It  is  possible  that  the  mission  to  St.  Petersburg 
was  of  a  purely  religious  character,  and  that  there 
was  no  secret  understanding  at  the  time  between 
the  Lhasa  authorities  and  Russia.     Yet  the  fact 

*  A  previous  mission  had  been  received  by  the  Czar  at  Livadia 
in  October,  1900. 


32  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

that  the  mission  was  despatched  in  direct  contra- 
diction to  the  national  pohcy  of  isolation  that  had 
been  respected  for  over  a  century,  and  at  a  time 
when  the  Tibetans  were  aware  of  impending  British 
activity  to  exact  fulfilment  of  the  treaty  obhgations 
so  long  ignored  by  them,  points  to  some  secret  in- 
fluence working  in  Lhasa  in  favour  of  Russia,  and 
opposed  to  British  interests.  The  process  of  Russifi- 
cation  that  has  been  carried  on  with  such  marked 
success  in  Persia  and  Turkestan,  Merv  and  Bok- 
hara, was  being  applied  in  Tibet.  It  has  long  been 
known  to  our  Intelhgence  Department  that  certain 
Buriat  Lamas,  subjects  of  the  Czar,  and  educated 
in  Russia,  have  been  acting  as  intermediaries  be- 
tween Lhasa  and  St.  Petersburg.  The  chief  of 
these,  one  Dorjieff,  headed  the  so-called  religious 
mission  of  1901,  and  has  been  employed  more  than 
once  as  the  Dalai  Lama's  ambassador  to  St.  Peters- 
burg. Dorjieff  is  a  man  of  fifty-eight,  who  has 
spent  some  twenty  years  of  his  life  in  Lhasa,  and 
is  known  to  be  the  right-hand  adviser  of  the  Dalai 
Lama.  No  doubt  Dorjieff  played  on  the  fears  of 
the  Buddhist  Pope  until  he  really  beUeved  that 
Tibet  was  in  danger  of  an  invasion  from  India,  in 
which  eventuality  the  Czar,   the  great   Pan-Bud- 


CAUSES  OF  THE  EXPEDITION.  33 

dhist  Protector,  would  descend  on  the  British  and 
drive  them  back  over  the  frontier.  The  Lamas  ol 
Tibet  imagine  that  Russia  is  a  Buddhist  country, 
and  this  behef  has  been  fostered  by  adventurers  like 
Dorjieff,  Tsibikoff,  and  others,  who  have  inspired 
dreams  of  a  consolidated  Buddhist  church  under 
the  spiritual  control  of  the  Dalai  Lama  and  the 
military  aegis  of  the  Czar  of  All  the  Russias. 

These  dreams,  full  of  political  menace  to  our- 
selves, have,  I  think,  been  dispelled  by  Lord  Cur- 
zon's  timely  expedition  to  Lhasa.  The  presence 
of  the  British  in  the  capital  and  the  helplessness 
of  Russia  to  lend  any  aid  in  such  a  crisis  are  facts 
convincing  enough  to  stultify  the  effects  of  Russian 
intrigue  in  Buddhist  Central  Asia  during  the  last 
half-century. 

The  fact  that  the  first  Dalai  Lama  who  has  been 
allowed  to  reach  maturity  has  plunged  his  country 
into  war  by  intrigue  with  a  foreign  Power  proves 
the  astuteness  of  the  cold-blooded  poHcy  of  re- 
moving the  infant  Pope,  and  the  investiture  of 
power  in  the  hands  of  a  Regent  inspired  by  Peking. 
It  is  believed  that  the  present  Dalai  Lama  was 
permitted  to  come  of  age  in  order  to  throw  off  the 
Chinese  yoke.  This  aim  has  been  secured,  but 
2 


34  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

it  has  involved  other  issues  that  the  Lamas  could 
not  foresee. 

And  here  it  must  be  observed  that  the  Dalai 
Lama's  inclination  towards  Russia  does  not  re- 
present any  considerable  national  movement.  The 
desire  for  a  rapprochement  was  largely  a  matter  of 
personal  ambition  inspired  by  that  arch-intriguer 
Dorjieff,  whose  ascendancy  over  the  Dalai  Lama 
was  proved  beyond  a  doubt  when  the  latter  joined 
him  in  his  flight  to  Mongolia  on  hearing  the  news 
of  the  British  advance  on  Lhasa.  Dorjieff  had  a 
certain  amount  of  popularity  with  the  priest  popu- 
lation of  the  capital,  and  the  monks  of  the  three 
great  monasteries,  amongst  whom  he  is  known  to 
have  distributed  largess  royally.  But  the  traditional 
policy  of  isolation  is  so  inveterately  ingrained  in 
the  Tibetan  character  that  it  is  doubtful  if  he  could 
have  organized  a  popular  party  of  any  strength. 

It  may  be  asked,  then,  What  is,  or  was,  the  nature 
of  the  Russian  menace  in  Tibet  ?  It  is  true  that  a 
Russian  invasion  on  the  North-East  frontier  is  out 
of  the  question.  For  to  reach  the  Indian  passes 
the  Russians  would  have  to  traverse  nearly  1,500 
miles  of  almost  uninhabited  country,  presenting 
difficulties  as  great  as  any  we  had  to  contend  with 


CAUSES  OF  THE  EXPEDITION.  35 

during  the  recent  campaign.  But  the  establish- 
ment of  Russian  influence  in  Lhasa  might  mean 
mihtary  danger  of  another  kind.  It  would  be  easy 
for  her  to  stir  up  the  Tibetans,  spread  disaffection 
among  the  Bhutanese,  send  secret  agents  into  Nepal, 
and  generally  undermine  our  prestige.  Her  aim 
would  be  to  create  a  diversion  on  the  Tibet  frontier 
at  any  time  she  might  have  designs  on  the  North- 
West.  The  pioneers  of  the  movement  had  begun 
their  work.  They  were  men  of  the  usual  type — 
astute,  insidious,  to  be  disavowed  in  case  of  prema- 
ture discovery,  or  publicly  flaunted  when  they  had 
prepared  any  ground  on  which  to  stand. 

Our  countermove — the  Tibet  Expedition — must 
have  been  a  crushing  and  unexpected  blow  to  Rus- 
sia. For  the  first  time  in  modern  history  Great 
Britain  had  taken  a  decisive,  almost  high-handed 
step  to  obviate  a  danger  that  was  far  from  immi- 
nent. We  had  all  the  best  cards  in  our  hands. 
Russia's  designs  in  Lhasa  became  obvious  at  a  time 
when  we  could  point  to  open  defiance  on  the  part 
of  the  Tibetans,  and  provocation  such  as  would 
have  goaded  any  other  European  nation  to  a  puni- 
tive expedition  years  before.  We  could  go  to  Lhasa, 
apparently  without  a  thought  of  Russia,  and  yet 


36  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

undo  all  the  effects  of  her  scheming  there,  and  deal 
her  prestige  a  blow  that  would  be  felt  throughout 
the  whole  of  Central  Asia.  Such  was  Lord  Curzon's 
policy.  It  was  adopted  in  a  half-hearted  way  by 
the  Home  Government,  and  eventually  forced  on 
them  by  the  conduct  of  the  Tibetans  themselves. 
Needless  to  say,  the  discovery  of  Russian  designs 
was  the  real  and  prime  cause  of  the  despatch  of 
the  mission,  while  Tibet's  violation  of  treaty  rights' 
and  refusal  to  enter  into  any  relations  with  us  were 
convenient  as  ostensible  motives.  It  cannot  be 
denied  that  these  grievances  were  valid  enough  to 
justify  the  strongest  measures. 

In  June,  1903,  came  the  announcement  of  Colonel 
Younghusband's  mission  to  Khamba  Jong.  I  do 
not  think  that  the  Indian  Government  ever  ex- 
pected that  the  Tibetans  would  come  to  any  agree- 
ment with  us  at  Khamba  Jong.  It  is  to  their  credit 
that  they  waited  patiently  several  months  in  order 
to  give  them  every  chance  of  settling  things  ami- 
cably. However,  as  might  have  been  expected, 
the  Commission  was  boycotted.  Irresponsible  dele- 
gates of  inferior  rank  were  sent  by  the  Tibetans  and 
Chinese,  and  the  Lhasa  delegates,  after  some  fruit- 
less parleyings,  shut  themselves  up  in  the  fort,  and 


CAUSES  OF  THE  EXPEDITION.  37 

declined  all  intercourse,  official  or  social,  with  the 
Commissioners.* 

At  the  end  of  August  news  came  that  the  Tibetans 
were  arming.  Colonel  Younghusband  learnt  that 
they  had  made  up  their  minds  to  have  no  negotiations 
with  us  inside  Tibet.  They  had  decided  to  leave 
us  alone  at  Khamba  Jong,  and  to  oppose  us  by 
force  if  we  attempted  to  advance  further.  They 
believed  themselves  fully  equal  to  the  English,  and 
far  from  our  getting  anything  out  of  them,  they 
thought  that  they  would  be  able  to  force  some- 
thing out  of  us.  This  is  not  surprising  when  we 
consider  the  spirit  of  concession  in  which  we  had 
met  them  on  previous  occasions. 

At  Khamba  Jong  the  Commissioners  were  in- 
formed by  Colonel  Chao,  the  Chinese  delegate,  that 
the  Tibetans  were  relying  on  Russian  assistance. 
This  was  confirmed  later  at  Guru  by  the  Tibetan 
officials,  who  boasted  that  if  they  were  defeated 
they  would  fall  back  on  another  Power. 

*  Their  attitude  was  thus  summed  up  by  Captain  O'Connor, 
secretary  to  the  mission :  'We  cannot  accept  letters  ;  we  cannot 
write  letters  ;  we  cannot  let  you  into  our  zone  ;  we  cannot  let 
you  travel ;  we  cannot  discuss  matters,  because  this  is  not  the 
^proper  place  ;  go  back  to  Giogong  and  send  away  all  your  soldiers, 
and  we  will  come  to  an  agreement '  (Tibetan  Blue-Book). 


38  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

In  September  the  Tibetans  aggravated  the  situa- 
tion by  seizing  and  beating  at  Shigatze  two  British 
subjects  of  the  Lachung  Valley  in  Sikkim.  These 
men  were  not  restored  to  liberty  until  we  had 
forced  our  way  to  Lhasa  and  demanded  their  Hbera- 
tion,  twelve  months  afterwards. 

The  mission  remained  in  its  ignominious  posi- 
tion at  Khamba  Jong  until  its  recall  in  November. 
Almost  at  the  same  time  the  expedition  to  Gyantse 
was  announced.* 

In  the  face  of  the  gross  and  deliberate  affront  to 
which  we  had  been  subjected  at  Khamba  Jong  it 
was  now,  of  course,  impossible  to  withdraw  from 
Tibetan  territory  until  we  had  impressed  on  the 
Lamas  the  necessity  of  meeting  us  in  a  reasonable 

*  The  situation  was  thus  eloquently  summarized  by  the  Gov- 
ernment of  India  in  a  despatch  to  Mr.  Brodrick,  November  5, 
1903  :  *  It  is  not  possible  that  the  Tibet  Government  should  be 
allowed  to  ignore  its  treaty  obligations,  thwart  trade,  encroach 
upon  our  territory,  destroy  our  boundary  pillars,  and  refuse  even 
to  receive  our  communications.  Still  l«ss  do  we  think  that 
when  an  amicable  conference  has  been  arranged  for  the  settle- 
ment of  these  difficulties  we  should  acquiesce  in  our  mission  being 
boycotted  by  the  very  persons  who  have  been  deputed  to  meet 
it,  our  officers  insulted,  our  subjects  arrested  and  ill-used,  and 
our  authority  despised  by  a  petty  Power  which  only  mistakes 
our  forbearance  for  weakness,  and  which  thinks  that  by  an 
attitude  of  obstinate  inertia  it  can  once  again  compel  us,  as  it  has 
done  in  the  past,  to  desist  from  our  intentions.' 


CAUSES  OF  THE  EXPEDITION.         39 

spirit.  It  was  clear  that  the  Tibetans  meant  fight- 
ing, and  the  escort  had  to  be  increased  to  2,500 
men.  The  patience  of  Government  was  at  last 
exhausted,  and  it  was  decided  that  the  mission  was 
to  proceed  into  Tibet,  dictate  terms  to  the  Lamas, 
and,  if  necessary,  enforce  compliance.  The  advance 
to  Gyantse  was  sanctioned  in  the  first  place.  But 
it  was  quite  expected  that  the  obstinacy  of  the 
Tibetans  would  make  it  necessary  to  push  on  to 
Lhasa. 

Colonel  Youn^husband  crossed  tbe  Jelap  la  into 
Tibet  on  December  13,  meeting  with  no  opposition. 
Phari  Jong  was  reached  on  the  20th,  and  the  fort 
surrendered  without  a  shot  being  fired.  Thence  the 
mission  proceeded  on  January  7  across  the  Tang 
Pass,  and  took  up  its  quarters  on  the  cold,  wind- 
swept plateau  of  Tuna,  at  an  elevation  of  15,300 
feet.  Here  it  remained  for  three  months,  while 
preparations  were  being  made  for  an  advance  in 
the  spring.  Four  companies  of  the  23rd  Pioneers, 
a  machine-gun  section  of  the  Norfolk  Regiment, 
and  twenty  Madras  sappers,  were  left  to  garrison 
the  place,  and  General  Macdonald,  with  the  re- 
mainder of  the  force,  returned  to  Chumbi  for  winter 
quarters.     Chumbi  (10,060  feet)  is  well  within  the 


40  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

wood  belt,  but  even  here  the  thermometer  falls  to 
15°  below  zero. 

A  more  miserable  place  to  winter  in  than  Tuna 
cannot  be  imagined.  But  for  political  reasons,  it 
was  inadvisable  that  the  mission  should  spend  the 
winter  in  the  Chumbi  Valley,  which  is  not  geo- 
graphically a  part  of  Tibet  proper.  A  retrograde 
movement  from  Khamba  Jong  to  Chumbi  would  be 
interpreted  by  the  Tibetans  as  a  sign  of  yielding, 
and  strengthen  them  in  their  opinion  that  we  had 
no  serious  intention  of  penetrating  to  Gyantse. 

With  this  brief  account  of  the  facts  that  led  to 
the  expedition  I  abandon  poUtics  for  the  present, 
and  in  the  succeeding  chapters  will  attempt  to  give 
a  description  of  the  Chumbi  Valley,  which,  I  be- 
lieve, was  untrodden  by  any  European  before  Colonel 
Younghusband's  arrival  in  December,  1903. 

I  was  in  India  when  I  received  permission  to  join 
the  force.  I  took  the  train  to  Darjeeling  without 
losing  a  day,  and  rode  into  Chumbi  in  less  than 
forty-eight  hours,  reaching  the  British  camp  on 
January  10. 


CHAPTER   II 

over  the  frontier 

Chumbi, 
January  13. 

FROM  Darjeeling  to  Lhasa  is  380  miles.  These, 
as  in  the  dominions  of  Namgay  Doola's  Raja, 
are  mostly  on  end.  The  road  crosses  the  Tibetan 
frontier  at  the  Jelap  la  (14,350  feet)  eighty  miles 
to  the  north-east.  From  Observatory  Hill  in  Dar- 
jeeling one  looks  over  the  bleak  hog-backed  ranges 
of  Sikkim  to  the  snows.  To  the  north  and  north- 
west lie  Kinchenjunga  and  the  tremendous  chain  of 
mountains  that  embraces  Everest.  To  the  north- 
east stretches  a  lower  line  of  dazzling  rifts  and  spires, 
in  which  one  can  see  a  thin  gray  wedge,  like  a  slice 
in  a  Christmas  cake.  That  is  the  Jelap.  Beyond 
it  lies  Tibet. 

There  is  a  good  military  road  from  SiHguri,  the 
base  station  in  the  plains  to  Rungpo,  forty-eight 


42  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

miles  along  the  Teesta  Valley.  By  following  the 
river-bed  it  avoids  the  two  steep  ascents  to  Kalim- 
pong  and  An.  The  new  route  saves  at  least  a  day, 
and  conveys  one  to  Rungli,  nearly  seventy  miles 
from  the  base,  without  compassing  a  single  tedi- 
ous incline.  It  has  also  the  advantage  of  being 
practicable  for  bullock-carts  and  ekkas  as  far  as 
Rungpo.  After  that  the  path  is  a  6-foot  mule-track, 
at  its  best  a  rough,  dusty  incline,  at  its  worst  a 
succession  of  broken  rocks  and  frozen  puddles, 
which  give  no  foothold  to  transport  animals.  From 
Rungpo  the  road  skirts  the  stream  for  sixteen  miles 
to  Rungh,  along  a  fertile  valley  of  some  2,000  feet, 
through  rice-fields  and  orange-groves  and  peaceful 
villages,  now  the  scene  of  military  bustle  and  prepa- 
ration. From  Rungh  it  follows  a  winding  mountain 
torrent,  whose  banks  are  sometimes  sheer  precipit- 
ous crags.  Then  it  strikes  up  the  mountain  side, 
and  becomes  a  ladder  of  stone  steps  over  which  no 
animal  in  the  world  can  make  more  than  a  mile 
and  a  half  an  hour.  From  the  valley  to  Gnatong 
is  a  climb  of  some  10,000  feet  without  a  break. 
The  scenery  is  most  magnificent,  and  I  doubt  if  it  is 
possible  to  find  anywhere  in  the  same  compass  the 
characteristics  of  the  different  zones  of  vegetation — 


OVER  THE  FRONTIER.  43 

from  tropical  to  temperate,  from  temperate  to  al- 
pine— so  beautifully  exhibited. 

At  ordinary  seasons  transport  is  easy,  and  one 
can  take  the  road  in  comfort ;  but  now  every  mule 
and  pony  in  Sikkim  and  the  Terai  is  employed  on 
the  hues  of  communication,  and  one  has  to  pay  300 
rupees  for  an  animal  of  the  most  modest  pretensions. 
It  is  reckoned  eight  days  from  Darjeehng  to  Chumbi, 
but,  riding  all  day  and  most  of  the  night,  I  com- 
pleted the  journey  in  two.  Newspaper  corres- 
pondents are  proverbially  in  a  hurry.  To  send 
the  first  wire  from  Chumbi  I  had  to  leave  my  kit 
behind,  and  ride  with  poshteen  *  and  sleeping-bag 
tied  to  my  saddle.  I  was  racing  another  corres- 
pondent. At  Rungpo  I  found  that  he  was  five 
hours  ahead  of  me,  but  he  rested  on  the  road,  and 
I  had  gained  three  hours  on  him  before  he  left  the 
next  stage  at  Rora  Thang.  Here  I  learnt  that  he 
intended  to  camp  at  Lingtam,  twelve  miles  further 
on,  in  a  tent  lent  him  by  a  transport  officer.  I 
made  up  my  mind  to  wait  outside  Lingtam  until  it 
was  dark,  and  then  to  steal  a  march  on  him  unob- 
served. But  I  beUeved  no  one.  Wayside  reports 
were  probably  intended  to  deceive  me,  and  no 
*  Sheepskin. 


44  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

doubt  my  informant  was  his  unconscious  confed- 
erate. 

Outside  Rungli,  six  miles  further  on,  I  stopped  at 
a  Httle  Bhutia's  hut,  where  he  had  been  resting. 
They  told  me  he  had  gone  on  only  half  an  hour 
before  me.  I  loitered  on  the  road,  and  passed  Ling- 
tam  in  the  dark.  The  moon  did  not  rise  till  three, 
and  riding  in  the  dark  was  exciting.  At  first  the 
white  dusty  road  showed  clearly  enough  a  few  yards 
ahead,  but  after  passing  Lingtam  it  became  a  nar- 
row path  cut  out  of  a  thickly-wooded  cliff  above  a 
torrent,  a  wall  of  rock  on  one  side,  a  precipice  on 
the  other.  Here  the  darkness  was  intense.  A 
white  stone  a  few  yards  ahead  looked  like  the 
branch  of  a  tree  overhead.  A  dim  shapeless  object 
to  the  left  might  be  a  house,  a  rock,  a  bear — any- 
thing. Uphill  and  downhill  could  only  be  distin- 
guished by  the  angle  of  the  saddle.  Every  now 
and  then  a  firefly  lit  up  the  white  precipice  an  arm's- 
length  to  the  right.  Once  when  my  pony  stopped 
panting  with  exhaustion  I  struck  a  match  and 
found  that  we  had  come  to  a  sharp  zigzag.  Part 
of  the  revetment  had  fallen  j  there  was  a  yard  of 
broken  path  covered  with  fern  and  bracken,  then 
a  drop  of  some  hundred  feet  to  the  torrent  below. 


OVER  THE  FRONTIER.  45 

After  that  I  led  my  beast  for  a  mile  until  we  came 
to  a  charcoal-burner's  hut.  Two  or  three  Bhutias 
were  sitting  round  a  log  fire,  and  I  persuaded  one 
to  go  in  front  of  me  with  a  lighted  brand.  So  we 
came  to  Sedongchen,  where  I  left  my  beast  dead- 
beat,  rested  a  few  hours,  bought  a  good  mule,  and 
pressed  on  in  the  early  morning  by  moonlight. 
The  road  to  Gnatong  lies  through  a  magnificent  forest 
of  oak  and  chestnut.  For  five  miles  it  is  nothing 
but  the  ascent  of  stone  steps  I  have  described. 
Then  the  rhododendron  zone  is  reached,  and  one 
passes  through  a  forest  of  gnarled  and  twisted 
trunks,  writhing  and  contorted  as  if  they  had  been 
thrust  there  for  some  penance.  The  place  suggested 
a  scene  from  Dante's  '  Inferno.*  As  I  reached  the 
saddle  of  Lingtu  the  moon  was  paling,  and  the  east- 
ern sky-line  became  a  faint  violet  screen.  In  a  few 
minutes  Kinchenjunga  and  Kabru  on  the  north- 
west caught  the  first  rays  of  the  sun,  and  were 
suffused  with  the  delicate  rosy  glow  of  dawn. 

I  reached  Gnatong  in  time  to  breakfast  with  the 
8th  Gurkhas.  The  camp  Hes  in  a  little  cleft  in  the 
hills  at  an  elevation  of  12,200  feet.  When  I  last 
visited  the  place  I  thought  it  one  of  the  most  deso- 
late spots  I  had  seen.     My  first  impressions  were  a 


46  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

wilderness  of  gray  stones  and  gray,  uninhabited 
houses,  felled  tree-trunks  denuded  of  bark,  white 
and  spectral  on  the  hillside.  There  was  no  life,  no 
children's  voices  or  chattering  women,  no  bazaar 
apparently,  no  dogs  barking,  not  even  a  pariah  to 
greet  you.  If  there  was  a  sound  of  life  it  was  the 
bray  of  some  discontented  mule  searching  for 
stray  blades  of  grass  among  the  stones.  There  were 
some  fifty  houses  nearly  all  smokeless  and  vacant. 
Some  had  been  barracks  at  the  time  of  the  last 
Sikkim  War,  and  of  the  soldiers  who  inhabited 
them  fifteen  still  lay  in  Gnatong  in  a  httle  gray 
cemetery,  which  was  the  first  indication  of  the 
nearness  of  human  life.  The  inscriptions  over  the 
graves  were  all  dated  1888, 1889,  or  1890,  and  though 
but  fourteen  years  had  passed,  many  of  them  were 
barely  decipherable.  The  houses  were  scattered 
about  promiscuously,  with  no  thought  of  neigh- 
bourliness or  convenience,  as  though  the  people 
were  living  there  under  protest,  which  was  very 
probably  the  case.  But  the  place  had  its  pictur- 
esque feature.  You  might  mistake  some  of  the 
houses  for  tumbledown  Swiss  chalets  of  the  poorer 
sort  were  it  not  for  the  miniature  fir-trees  planted 
on  the  roofs,  with  their  burdens  of  prayers  hanging 


OVER  THE  FRONTIER.  47 

from  the  branches  Hke  parcels  on  a  Christmas- 
tree. 

These  were  my  impressions  a  year  or  two  ago^ 
but  now  Gnatong  is  all  life  and  bustle.  In  the 
bazaar  a  convoy  of  300  mules  was  being  loaded. 
The  place  was  crowded  with  Nepalese  coolies  and 
Tibetan  drivers,  picturesque  in  their  woollen  knee- 
boots  of  red  and  green  patterns,  with  a  white  star 
at  the  foot,  long  russet  cloaks  bound  tightly  at  the 
waist  and  bulging  out  with  cooking-utensils  and 
changes  of  dress,  embroidered  caps  of  every  variety 
and  description,  as  often  as  not  tied  to  the  head 
by  a  wisp  of  hair.  In  Rotten  Row — the  inscription 
of  1889  still  remains — I  met  a  subaltern  with  a 
pair  of  skates.  He  showed  me  to  the  mess-room, 
where  I  enjoyed  a  warm  breakfast  and  a  good  deal 
of  chaff  about  correspondents  who  *  were  in  such 
a  devil  of  a  hurry  to  get  to  a  God-forsaken  hole 
where  there  wasn't  going  to  be  the  ghost  of  a  show.' 

I  left  Gnatong  early  on  a  borrowed  pony.  A 
mile  and  a  half  from  the  camp  the  road  crosses  the 
Tuko  Pass,  and  one  descends  again  for  another  two 
miles  to  Kapup,  a  temporary  transport  stage.  The 
path  Ues  to  the  west  of  the  Bidang  Tso,  a  beautiful 
lake  with  a  moraine  at  the  north-west  side.     The 


48  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

mountains  were  strangely  silent,  and  the  only  sound 
of  wild  life  was  the  whistling  of  the  red-billed 
choughs,  the  commonest  of  the  Corvidce  at  these 
heights.  They  were  flying  round  and  round  the 
lake  in  an  unsettled  manner,  whisthng  querulously, 
as  though  in  complaint  at  the  intrusion  of  their 
solitude. 

I  reached  the  Jelap  soon  after  noon.  No  snow 
had  fallen.  The  approach  was  over  broken  rock 
and  shale.  At  the  summit  was  a  row  of  cairns, 
from  which  fluttered  praying-flags  and  tattered 
bits  of  votive  raiment.  Behind  us  and  on  both 
sides  was  a  thin  mist,  but  in  front  my  eyes  explored 
a  deep  narrow  valley  bathed  in  sunshine.  Here, 
then,  was  Tibet,  the  forbidden,  the  mysterious.  In 
the  distance  all  the  land  was  that  yellow  and  brick- 
dust  colour  I  had  often  seen  in  pictures  and  thought 
exaggerated  and  unreal.  Far  to  the  north-east 
Chumulari  (23,930  feet),  with  its  magnificent  white 
spire  rising  from  the  roof-Hke  mass  behind,  looked 
Uke  an  immense  cathedral  of  snow.  Far  below  on 
a  yellow  hillside  hung  the  Kan  jut  Lamasery  above 
Rinchengong.  In  the  valley  beneath  lay  Chumbi 
and  the  road  to  Lhasa. 

There  is  a  descent  of  over  4,000  feet  in  six  miles 


OVER  THE  FRONTIER.  49 

from  the  summit  of  the  Jelap.  The  valley  is  per- 
fectly straight,  without  a  bend,  so  that  one  can 
look  down  from  the  pass  upon  the  Kan  jut  monas- 
tery on  the  hillside  immediately  above  Yatung. 
The  pass  would  afford  an  impregnable  military  posi- 
tion to  a  people  with  the  rudiments  of  science  and 
martial  spirit.  A  few  riflemen  on  the  cliffs  that 
command  it  might  annihilate  a  column  with  per- 
fect safety,  and  escape  into  Bhutan  before  any 
flanking  movement  could  be  made.  Yet  miles  of 
straggling  convoy  are  allov/ed  to  pass  daily  with 
the  supplies  that  are  necessary  for  the  existence 
of  the  force  ahead.  The  road  to  Phari  Jong  passes 
through  two  military  walls.  The  first  at  Yatung, 
six  miles  below  the  pass,  is  a  senseless  obstruction, 
and  any  able-bodied  Tommy  with  hobnailed  boots 
might  very  easily  kick  it  down.  It  has  no  block- 
houses, and  would  be  useless  against  a  flank  attack. 
Before  our  advance  to  Chumbi  the  wall  was  in- 
habited by  three  Chinese  officials,  a  dingpon,  or 
Tibetan  sergeant,  and  twenty  Tibetan  soldiers.  It 
served  as  a  barrier  beyond  which  no  British  subject 
was  allowed  to  pass.  The  second  wall  lies  across 
the  valley  at  Gob-sorg,  four  miles  beyond  our  camp 
at  Chumbi.     It  is  roofed  and  loop-holed  Hke  the 


50  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

Yatung  barrier,  and  is  defended  by  block-houses. 
This  fortification  and  every  mile  of  valley  between 
the  Jelap  and  Gautsa  might  be  held  by  a  single 
company  against  an  invading  force.  Yet  there 
are  not  half  a  dozen  Chinese  or  Tibetan  soldiers  in 
the  valley.  No  opposition  is  expected  this  side  of 
the  Tang  la,  but  nondescript  troops  armed  with 
matchlocks  and  bows  hover  round  the  mission  on 
the  open  plateau  beyond.  Our  evacuation  of 
Khamba  Jong  and  occupation  of  Chumbi  were  so 
rapid  and  unexpected  that  it  is  thought  the  Tibetans 
had  no  time  to  bring  troops  into  the  valley ;  but 
to  anyone  who  knows  their  strategical  incompetence, 
no  explanation  is  necessary. 

Yatung  is  reached  by  one  of  the  worst  sections  of 
road  on  the  march  ;  one  comes  across  a  dead  trans- 
port mule  at  almost  every  zigzag  of  the  descent. 
For  ten  years  the  village  has  enjoyed  the  distinction 
of  being  the  only  place  in  Southern  Tibet  accessible 
to  Europeans.  Not  that  many  Europeans  avail 
themselves  of  its  accessibiUty,  for  it  is  a  dreary 
enough  place  to  live  in,  shrouded  as  it  is  in  cloud 
more  than  half  the  year  round,  and  embedded  in  a 
valley  so  deep  and  narrow  that  in  winter-time  the 
sun  has  hardly  risen  above  one  cUff  when  it  sinks 


OVER  THE  FRONTIER  51 

behind  another.  The  privilege  of  access  to  Yatung 
was  the  result  of  the  agreement  between  Great 
Britain  and  China  with  regard  to  trade  communica- 
tions between  India  and  Tibet  drawn  up  in  Dar- 
jeeling  in  1893,  subsequently  to  the  Sikkim  Con- 
vention. It  was  then  stipulated  that  there  should 
be  a  trade  mart  at  Yatung  to  which  British  sub- 
jects should  have  free  access,  and  that  there  should 
be  special  trade  facilities  between  Sikkim  and  Tibet. 
It  is  reported  that  the  Chinese  Amban  took  good 
care  that  Great  Britain  should  not  benefit  by  these 
new  regulations,  for  after  signing  the  agreement 
which  was  to  give  the  Indian  tea-merchants  a  mar- 
ket in  Tibet,  he  introduced  new  regulations  the 
other  side  of  the  frontier,  which  prohibited  the 
purchase  of  Indian  tea.  Whether  the  story  is  true 
or  not,  it  is  certainly  characteristic  of  the  evasion 
and  duplicity  which  have  brought  about  the  present 
armed  mission  into  Tibet. 

To-day,  as  one  rides  through  the  cobbled  street 
of  Yatung,  the  only  visible  effects  of  the  Convention 
are  the  Chinese  Customs  House  with  its  single  Euro- 
pean officer,  and  the  residence  of  a  lady  missionary, 
or  trader,  as  the  exigencies  of  international  diplo- 
macy oblige  her  to  term  herself.    The  Customs  House, 


52  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

which  was  opened  on  May  i,  1894,  was  first  estab- 
lished with  the  object  of  estimating  the  trade  be- 
tween India  and  Tibet — traffic  is  not  permitted  by 
any  other  route  than  the  Jelap — and  with  a  view 
to  taxation  when  the  trade  should  make  it  worth 
while.  It  was  stipulated  that  no  duties  should 
be  levied  for  the  period  of  five  years.  Up  to  the 
present  no  tariff  has  been  imposed,  and  the  only 
apparent  use  the  Customs  House  serves  is  to  collect 
statistics,  and  perhaps  to  remind  Tibet  of  the  shadowy 
suzerainty  of  China.  The  natives  have  boycotted 
the  place,  and  refuse  to  trade  there,  and  no  Euro- 
pean or  native  of  India  has  thought  it  worth  while 
to  open  a  market.  Phari  is  the  real  trade  mart  on 
the  frontier,  and  Kalimpong,  in  British  Bhutan, 
is  the  foreign  trade  mart.  But  the  whole  trade 
between  India  and  Tibet  is  on  such  a  small 
scale  that  it  might  be  in  the  hands  of  a  single 
merchant. 

The  Customs  House,  the  missionary  house,  and 
the  houses  of  the  clerks  and  servants  of  the  Customs 
and  of  the  headman,  form  a  little  block.  Beyond 
it  there  is  a  quarter  of  a  mile  of  barren  stony  ground, 
and  then  the  wall  with  military  pretensions.  I 
rode  through  the  gate  unchallenged. 


OVER  THE  FRONTIER.  53 

At  Rinchengong,  a  mile  beyond  the  barrier,  the 
Yatung  stream  flows  into  the  Ammo  Chu.  The 
road  follows  the  eastern  bank  of  the  river,  pass- 
ing through  Cheuma  and  Old  Chumbi,  where  it 
crosses  the  stream.  After  crossing  the  bridge, 
a  mile  of  almost  level  ground  takes  one  into 
Chumbi  camp.  I  reached  Chumbi  on  the  even- 
ing of  January  12,  and  was  able  to  send  the 
Daily  Mail  the  first  cable  from  Tibet,  having 
completed  the  journey  from  Darjeeling  in  two 
days*  hard  riding. 

The  camp  lies  in  a  shallow  basin  in  the  hills,  and 
is  flanked  by  brown  fir-clad  hills  which  rise  some 
1,500  feet  above  the  river-bed,  and  preclude  a  view 
of  the  mountains  on  all  sides.  The  situation  is  by 
no  means  the  best  from  the  view  of  comfort,  but 
strategic  reasons  make  it  necessary,  for  if  the  camp 
were  pitched  half  a  mile  further  up  the  valley,  the 
gorge  of  the  stream  which  debouches  into  the 
Ammo  River  to  the  north  of  Chumbi  would  give 
the  Tibetans  an  opportunity  of  attacking  us  in 
the  rear.  Despite  the  protection  of  almost  Arctic 
clothing,  one  shivers  until  the  sun  rises  over  the 
eastern  hill  at  ten  o'clock,  and  shivers  again  when 
it  sinks  behind  the  opposite  one  at  three.      Icy 


54  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

winds  sweep  the  valley,  and  hurricanes  of  dust 
invade  one's  tent.  Against  this  cold  one  clothes 
one's  self  in  flannel  vest  and  shirt,  sweater,  flannel- 
lined  coat,  poshteen  or  Cashmere  sheepskin,  wool- 
lined  Gilgit  boots,  and  fur  or  woollen  cap  with  flaps 
meeting  under  the  chin.  The  general  effect  is  bar- 
baric and  picturesque.  In  after-days  the  trimness 
of  a  miUtary  club  may  recall  the  scene — officers 
clad  in  gold-embroidered  poshteen,  yellow  boots, 
and  fur  caps,  bearded  hke  wild  Kerghizes,  and  hud- 
dling round  the  camp  fire  in  this  bhck  cauldron- 
like valley  under  the  stars. 

Officers  are  settling  down  in  Chumbi  as  com- 
fortably as  possible  for  winter  quarters.  Primi- 
tive dens  have  been  dug  out  of  the  ground,  walled 
up  with  boulders,  and  roofed  in  with  green  fir- 
branches.  In  some  cases  a  natural  rock  affords  a 
whole  wall.  The  den  where  I  am  now  writing  is 
warmed  by  a  cheerful  pinewood  blaze,  a  luxury 
after  the  angeiti  in  one's  tent.  I  write  at  an  operat- 
ing-table after  a  dinner  of  minal  (pheasant)  and 
yak's  heart.  A  gramophone  is  dinning  in  my  ears. 
It  is  destined,  I  hope,  to  resound  in  the  palace  of 
Potala,  where  the  Dalai  Lama  and  his  suite  may 
wonder   what   heathen   ritual   is   accompanied   by 


'm^-*^: 


OVER  THE  FRONTIER.  55 

*  A  jovial  monk  am  I,'  and  '  Her  golden  hair  was 
hanging  down  her  back.' 

Both  at  home  and  in  India  one  hears  the  Tibet 
Mission  spoken  of  enviously  as  a  picnic.  There  is 
an  idea  of  an  encampment  in  a  smiling  valley,  and 
easy  marches  towards  the  mysterious  city.  In 
reality  there  is  plenty  of  hard  and  uninteresting 
work.  The  expedition  is  attended  with  all  the  dis- 
comforts of  a  campaign,  and  very  little  of  the  ex- 
citement. Colonel  Younghusband  is  now  at  Tuna, 
a  desolate  hamlet  on  the  Tibetan  plateau,  exposed 
to  the  coldest  winds  of  Asia,  where  the  thermometer 
falls  to  25°  below  zero.  Detachments  of  the  escort 
are  scattered  along  the  line  of  communications  in 
places  of  varying  cold  and  discomfort,  where  they 
must  wait  until  the  necessary  supplies  have  been 
carried  through  to  Phari.  It  is  not  likely  that 
Colonel  Younghusband  will  be  able  to  proceed  to 
Gyantse  before  March.  In  the  meanwhile,  imagine 
the  Pioneers  and  Gurkhas,  too  cold  to  wash  or 
shave,  shivering  in  a  dirty  Tibetan  fort,  half  suffo- 
cated with  smoke  from  a  yak-dung  fire.  Then  there 
is  the  transport  officer  shut  up  in  some  narrow  valley 
of  Sikkim,  trying  to  make  half  a  dozen  out  of  three 
with  his  camp  of  sick  beasts  and  sheaf  of  urgent 


56  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

telegrams  calling  for  supplies.  He  hopes  there  will 
be  '  a  show,'  and  that  he  may  be  in  it.  Certainly 
if  anyone  deserves  to  go  to  Lhasa  and  get  a  medal 
for  it,  it  is  the  supply  and  transport  man.  But  he 
will  be  left  behind. 


CHAPTER   III 

the  chumbi  valley 

Chumbi, 
February,  1904. 

THE  Chumbi  Valley  is  inhabited  by  the  Tomos, 
who  are  said  to  be  descendants  of  ancient 
cross-marriages  between  the  Bhutanese  and  Lep- 
chas.  They  only  intermarry  among  themselves, 
and  speak  a  language  which  would  not  be  under- 
stood in  other  parts  of  Tibet.  As  no  Tibetan  proper 
is  allowed  to  pass  the  Yatung  barrier,  the  Tomos 
have  the  monopoly  of  the  carrying  trade  between 
Phari  and  Kalimpong.  The}^  are  voluntarily  under 
the  protection  of  the  Tibetans,  who  treat  them 
liberally,  as  the  Lamas  realize  the  danger  of  their 
geographical  position  as  a  buffer  state,  and  are 
shrewd  enough  to  recognise  that  any  ill  treatment 
or  oppression  would  drive  them  to  seek  protection 
from  the  Bhutanese  or  British. 


58  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

The  Tomos  are  merry  people,  hearty,  and  good- 
natured.  They  are  wonderfully  hardy  and  endur- 
ing. In  the  coldest  winter  months,  when  the 
thermometer  is  20°  below  zero,  they  will  camp 
out  at  night  in  the  snow,  forming  a  circle  of  their 
loads,  and  sleep  contentedly  inside  with  no  tent  or 
roofing.  The  women  would  be  comely  if  it  were 
not  for  the  cutch  that  they  smear  over  their  faces. 
The  practice  is  common  to  the  Tibetans  aad  Bhu- 
tanese,  but  no  satisfactory  reason  has  been  found 
for  it.  The  Jesuit  Father,  Johann  Grueber,  who 
visited  Tibet  in  1661,  attributed  the  custom  to  a 
religious  whim : — *  The  women,  out  of  a  religious 
whim,  never  wash,  but  daub  themselves  with  a 
nasty  kind  of  oil,  which  not  only  causes  them  to 
stink  intolerably,  but  renders  them  extremely  ugly 
and  deformed.'  A  hundred  and  eighty  years  after- 
wards Hue  noticed  the  same  habit,  and  attributed 
it  to  an  edict  issued  by  the  Dalai  Lama  early  in  the 
seventeenth  century.  *  The  women  of  Tibet  in  those 
days  were  nwich  given  to  dress,  and  Hbertinage,  and 
corrupted  the  Lamas  to  a  degree  to  bring  their  holy 
order  into  a  bad  repute.*  The  then  Nome  Khan 
(deputy  of  the  Dalai  Lama)  accordingly  issued  an 
order  that  the  women  should  never  appear  in  pubHc 


THE  CHUMBI  VALLEY.  59 

without  smearing  their  faces  with  a  black  dis- 
figuring paste.  Hue  recorded  that  though  the  order 
was  still  obeyed,  the  practice  was  observed  without 
much  benefit  to  morals.  If  you  ask  a  Tomo  or 
Tibetan  to-day  why  their  women  smear  and  daub 
themselves  in  this  unbecoming  manner,  they  in- 
variably reply,  like  the  Mussulman  or  Hindu,  that 
it  is  custom.  Mongolians  do  not  bother  themselves 
about  causes. 

The  Tomo  women  wear  a  flat  green  distinctive 
cap,  with  a  red  badge  in  the  front,  which  harmon- 
izes with  their  complexion — a  coarse,  brick  red,  of 
which  the  primal  ingredients  are  dirt  and  cutch, 
erroneously  called  pig's  blood,  and  the  natural 
ruddiness  of  a  healthy  outdoor  life  in  a  cold  climate. 
A  procession  of  these  sirens  is  comely  and  pictur- 
esque— at  a  hundred  yards.  They  wrap  themselves 
round  and  round  with  a  thick  woollen  blanket  of 
pleasing  colour  and  pattern,  and  wear  on  their  feet 
high  woollen  boots  with  leather  or  rope  soles.  If  it 
was  not  for  their  disfiguring  toilet  many  of  them 
would  be  handsome.  The  children  are  generally 
pretty,  and  I  have  seen  one  or  two  that  were  really 
beautiful.  When  we  left  a  camp  the  villagers  would 
generally  get  wind  of  it,  and  come  down  for  loot. 


6o  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

Old  newspapers,  tins,  bottles,  string,  and  cardboard 
boxes  were  treasured  prizes.  We  threw  these  out  of 
our  cave,  and  the  children  scrambled  for  them,  and 
even  the  women  made  dives  at  anything  particu- 
larly tempting.  My  last  impression  of  Lingmathan^ 
was  a  group  of  women  giggling  and  gesticulating 
over  the  fashion  plates  and  advertisements  in  a 
niunber  of  the  Lady,  which  somebody's  memsahih 
had  used  for  the  packing  of  a  ham. 

The  Tomos,  though  not  naturally  given  to  cleanli- 
ness, realize  the  hygienic  value  of  their  hot  springs. 
There  are  resorts  in  the  neighbourhood  of  Chumbi 
as  fashionable  as  Homburg  or  Salsomaggiore ; 
mixed  bathing  is  the  rule,  without  costumes.  These 
healthy  folk  are  not  morbidly  conscious  of  sex. 
The  springs  contain  sulphur  and  iron,  and  are 
undoubtedly  efficacious.  Where  they  are  not  hot 
enough,  the  Tomos  bake  large  boulders  in  the 
ashes  of  a  log  fire,  and  roll  them  into  the  water  to 
increase  the  temperature. 

Tomos  and  Tibetans  are  fond  of  smoking.  They 
dry  the  leaves  of  the  wild  rhubarb,  and  mix  them 
with  tobacco  leaves.  The  mixture  is  called  dopta, 
and  was  the  favourite  blend  of  the  country.  Now 
hundreds  of  thousands  of  cheap  American  cigarettes 


THE  CHUMBI  VALLEY.  6i 

are  being  introduced,  and  a  lucrative  tobacco-trade 
has  sprung  up.  Boxes  of  ten,  which  are  sold  at  a 
pice  in  Darjeeling,  fetch  an  anna  at  Chumbi,  and 
two  annas  at  Phari.  Sahibs  smoke  them,  sepoys 
smoke  them,  drivers  and  followers  smoke  them,  and 
the  Tomo  coolies  smoke  nothing  else.  Tibetan 
children  of  three  appreciate  them  hugely,  and  the 
road  from  Phari  to  Rungpo  is  literally  strewn  with 
the  empty  boxes. 

There  is  a  considerable  Chinese  element  in  the 
Chumbi  Valley — a  frontier  officer,  with  the  local 
rank  of  the  Fourth  Button,  a  colonel,  clerks  of  the 
Customs  House,  and  troops  numbering  from  one 
to  two  hundred.  These,  of  course,  were  not  in 
evidence  when  we  occupied  the  valley  in  December. 
The  Chinese  are  not  accompanied  by  their  wives, 
but  take  to  themselves  women  of  the  country, 
whose  offspring  people  the  so-called  Chinese  villages. 
The  pure  Chinaman  does  not  remain  in  the  country 
after  his  term  of  office.  Life  at  Chumbi  is  the  most 
tedious  exile  to  him,  and  he  looks  down  on  the 
Tomos  as  barbarous  savages.  He  is  as  unhappy 
as  a  Frenchman  in  Tonquin,  cut  off  from  all  the 
diversions  of  social  and  intellectual  life.  The  frontier 
officer  at  Bibi-thang  told  me  that  he  had  brought 


62  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

his  wife  with  him,  and  the  poor  lady  had  never  left 
the  house,  but  cried  incessantly  for  China  and 
civilization.  Yet  to  the  uninitiated  the  Chinese 
villages  of  Gob-sorg  and  Bibi-thang  might  have 
been  taken  from  the  far  East  and  plumped  down 
on  the  Indian  frontier.  There  is  the  same  far- 
Eastern  smell,  the  same  doss-house,  the  same  hang- 
ing lamps,  the  same  red  lucky  paper  over  the  lintels 
of  the  doors,  and  the  same  red  and  green  abortions 
on  the  walls. 

Much  has  been  written  and  duly  contradicted 
about  the  fertility  of  the  Chumbi  Valley.  If  one 
does  not  expect  orange-groves  and  rice-fields  at 
12,000  feet,  it  must  be  admitted  that  the  valley  is, 
relatively  speaking,  fertile — that  is  to  say,  its 
produce  is  sufficient  to  support  its  three  or  four 
thousand  inhabitants. 

The  lower  valley  produces  buckwheat,  turnips, 
potatoes,  radishes,  and  barley.  The  latter,  the 
staple  food  of  the  Tibetans,  has,  when  ground,  an 
appetizing  smell  very  like  oatmeal.  The  upper 
valley  is  quite  sterile,  and  produces  nothing  but 
barley,  which  does  not  ripen ;  it  is  gathered  for 
fodder  when  green,  and  the  straw  is  sold  at  high 
prices  to  the  merchants  who  visit  Phari  from  Tibet 


THE  CHUMBI  VALLEY.  63 

and  Bhutan.  This  year  the  Tibetan  merchants  are 
afraid  to  come,  and  the  commissariat  benefits  by  a 
very  large  supply  of  fodder  which  ought  to  see  them 
through  the  summer. 

The  idea  that  the  valley  is  unusually  fertile  prob- 
ably arose  from  the  well-to-do  appearance  of  the 
natives  of  Rinchengong  and  Chumbi,  and  their 
almost  palatial  houses,  which  give  evidence  of  a 
prosperity  due  to  trade  rather  than  agriculture. 

The  hillsides  around  Chmnbi  produce  wild  straw- 
berries, raspberries,  currants,  and  cherries  ;  but  these 
are  quite  insipid  in  this  sunless  climate. 

The  Chinese  Customs  officer  at  Yatung  tells  me 
that  the  summer  months,  though  not  hot,  are  re- 
laxing and  enervating.  The  thermometer  never 
rises  above  70°.  The  rainfall  does  not  average 
quite  50  inches ;  but  almost  daily  at  noon  a  mist 
creeps  up  from  Bhutan,  and  a  constant  drizzle  falls. 
In  June,  July,  and  August,  1901,  there  were  only 
three  days  without  rain. 

At  Phari  I  met  a  venerable  old  gentleman  who 
gave  me  some  statistics.  The  old  man,  Katsak 
Kasi  by  name,  was  a  Tibetan  from  the  Kham 
province,  acting  at  Phari  as  trade  agent  for  the 
Bhutanese  Government.    His  face  was  seared  and 


64  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

parchment-like  from  long  exposure  to  cold  winds 
and  rough  weather.  His  features  were  compara- 
tively aquiline — that  is  to  say,  they  did  not  look 
as  if  they  had  been  flattened  out  in  youth.  He 
wore  a  very  large  pair  of  green  spectacles,  with  a 
gold  bulb  at  each  end  and  a  red  tassel  in  the  middle, 
which  gave  him  an  air  of  wisdom  and  distinction. 
He  answered  my  rather  inquisitive  questions  with 
courtesy  and  decision,  and  yet  with  such  a  serious* 
care  for  details  that  I  felt  quite  sure  his  figures 
must  be  accurate. 

If  statistics  were  any  gauge  of  the  benefits  Indian 
trade  would  derive  from  an  open  market  with  Tibet, 
the  present  mission,  as  far  as  commercial  interests 
are  concerned,  would  be  wasted.  According  to 
Kasi's  statistics,  the  cost  of  two  dozen  or  thirtj; 
mules  would  balance  the  whole  of  the  annual  revenue 
on  Indian  imports  into  the  country.  The  idea  that 
duties  are  levied  at  the  Yatung  and  Gob-sorg  barriers 
is  a  mistake.  The  only  Customs  House  is  at  Phari, 
where  the  Indian  and  Bhutanese  trade-routes  meet. 
The  Customs  are  under  the  supervision  of  the  two 
jongpens,  who  send  the  revenue  to  Lhasa  twice  a  year. 

The  annual  income  on  imports  from  India,  Kasi 
assured  me,  is  only  6,000  rupees,  whereas  the  in- 


THE  CHUMBI  VALLEY. 


65 


come  on  exports  amounts  to  20,000.    Tibetan  trade 

with  India  consists  almost  entirely  of  wool,  yaks'- 

tails,  and  ponies.    There  is  a  tax  of  2  rupees  8  annas 

on  ponies,  i  rupee  a  maund  on  wool,  and  i  rupee 

8  annas  a  maund  on  yaks'-tails.     Our  imports  into 

Tibet,  according  to  Kasi's  statistics,  are  practically 

nil.     Some  piece  goods,  iron  vessels,  and  tobacco 

leaves  find  their  way  over  the  Jelap,  but  it  is  a 

common  sight  to  see  mules  returning  into  Tibet  with 

nothing  but  their  drivers'  cooking  utensils  and  warm 

clothing.* 

*  The  only  articles  imported  to  the  value  of  £1,000  are  cotton 
goods,  woollen  cloths,  metals,  chinaware,  coral,  indigo,  maize, 
silk,  fur,  and  tobacco. 

The  only  exports  to  the  value  of  £1,000  are  musk,  ponies,  skins, 
wool,  and  yaks'-tails. 
Appended  are  the  returns  for  the  years  1895-1902  : 


Value  of  Articles 

Value  of  Articles 

Total  Value  of 

Year. 

Imported  into 

Exported  from 

Imports  and 
Exports. 

Tibet. 

Tibet. 

Rs. 

Rs. 

Rs. 

1895 

416,218 

634,086 

1,050,304 

1896 

561,395 

781,269 

1,342,664 

1897 

674.139 

820,300 

1,494,436 

1898 

718,475 

817,851 

1,536,326 

1899 

962,637 

822,760 

1,785,397 

1900 

730,502 

710,012 

1,440,514 

1901 

734,075 

783,480 

1,517,555 

1902 

761,837 

805,338 

1,567,075 

Customs  House  Returns,  Yatung. 


66  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

At  present  no  Indian  tea  passes  Yatung.  That 
none  is  sold  at  Phari  confirms  the  rumour  I  men- 
tioned that  the  Chinese  Amban,  after  signing  the 
trade  regulations  between  India  and  Tibet  in  Dar- 
jeeling,  1893,  crossed  the  frontier  to  introduce  new 
laws,  virtually  annulling  the  regulations.  Indian 
tea  might  be  carried  into  Tibet,  but  not  sold  there. 
Tibet  has  consistently  broken  all  her  promises  and 
treaty  obligations.  She  has  placed  every  obstacle 
in  the  way  of  Indian  trade,  and  insulted  our  Com- 
missioners ;  yet  the  despatch  of  the  present  mission 
with  its  armed  escort  has  been  called  an  act  of 
aggression. 

When  I  asked  Kasi  if  the  Tibetans  would  be 
angry  with  him  for  helping  us,  he  said  they  would 
certainly  cut  off  his  head  if  he  remained  in  the  fort 
after  we  had  left.  There  is  some  foundation  in 
travellers'  stories  about  the  punishment  inflicted  on 
the  guards  of  the  passes  and  other  officials  who  fail 
to  prevent  Europeans  entering  Tibet  or  pushing  on 
towards  Lhasa. 

Some  Chumbi  traders  who  were  in  Lhasa  when  we 
entered  the  valley  are  still  detained  there,  as  far 
as  I  can  gather,  as  hostages  for  the  good  behaviour 
of  their  neighbours.     In  Tibet  the  punishment  does 


THE  CHUMBI  VALLEY.  67 

not  fit  the  crime.  The  guards  of  a  pass  are  punished 
for  letting  white  men  through,  quite  irrespective  of 
the  opposing  odds. 

The  commonest  punishment  in  Tibet  is  flogging, 
but  the  ordeal  is  so  severe  that  it  often  proves  fatal. 
I  asked  Kasi  some  questions  about  the  magisterial 
powers  of  the  two  jongpens,  or  district  officers,  who 
remained  in  the  fort  some  days  after  we  occupied 
it.  He  told  me  that  they  could  not  pass  capital 
sentence,  but  they  might  flog  the  prisoners,  and  if 
they  died,  nothing  was  said.  Several  victims  have 
died  of  flogging  at  Phari. 

The  natives  in  Darjeeling  have  a  story  of  Tibetan 
methods,  which  have  always  seemed  to  me  the 
refinement  of  cruelty.  At  Gyantse,  they  say,  the 
criminal  is  flung  into  a  dark  pit,  where  he  cannot 
tell  whether  it  is  night  or  day.  Cobras  and  scorpions 
and  reptiles  of  various  degrees  of  venom  are  his  com- 
panions ;  these  he  may  hear  in  the  darkness,  for  it 
is  still  enough,  and  seek  or  avoid  as  he  has  courage. 
Food  is  sometimes  thrown  in  to  tempt  any  faint- 
hearted wretch  to  prolong  his  agony.  I  asked  Kasi 
if  there  were  any  truth  in  the  tale.  He  told  me 
that  there  were  no  venomous  snakes  in  Tibet,  but 
he  had  heard  that  there  was  a  dark  prison  in  Gyantse, 


68  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

where  criminals  sometimes  died  of  scorpion  bites  ; 
he  added  that  only  the  worst  offenders  were  punished 
in  this  way.  The  modified  version  of  the  story  is 
gruesome  enough. 

It  is  usual  for  Tibetan  and  Bhutanese  officials  to  re- 
ceive their  pay  in  grain,  it  being  understood  that  their 
position  puts  them  in  the  way  of  obtaining  the  other 
necessaries  of  life,  and  perhaps  a  few  of  its  luxuries. 
Kasi,  being  an  important  official,  receives  from  the 
Bhutan  Government  forty  maunds  of  barley  and 
forty  maunds  of  rice  annually.  He  receives,  in 
addition,  a  commission  on  the  trade  disputes  that 
he  decides  in  proportion  to  their  importance.  He 
is  now  an  invaluable  servant  of  the  British  Govern- 
ment. At  his  nod  the  barren  solitudes  round  Phari 
are  wakening  into  life.  From  the  fort  bastions  one 
^sees  sometimes  on  the  hills  opposite  an  indistinct 
black  line,  like  a  caterpillar  gradually  assuming 
shape.  They  are  Kasi's  yaks  coming  from  some 
blind  valley  which  no  one  but  a  hunter  or  mountain- 
eer would  have  imagined  to  exist.  Ponies,  grain, 
and  fodder  are  also  imported  from  Bhutan  and  sold 
to  the  mutual  gratification  of  the  Bhutanese  and 
ourselves.  The  vaks  are  hired  and  employed  on  the 
Jine  of  rommnnications. 


THE  CHUMBI  VALLEY.  69 

It  is  to  be  hoped  that  the  Bhutanese,  when  they 
hear  of  our  good  prices,  will  send  supplies  over  the 
frontier  to  hasten  our  advance.  But  we  must  take 
care  that  no  harm  befalls  Kasi  for  his  good  services. 
When  I  asked  him  how  he  stood  with  the  Tibetan 
Government,  he  laid  his  hand  in  a  significant  manner 
across  his  throat. 

LiNGMATHANG, 

February. 

Before  entering  the  bare,  unsheltered  plateau  of 
Tibet,  the  road  to  Lhasa  winds  through  seven  miles 
of  pine  forest,  which  recalls  some  of  the  most  beau- 
tiful valleys  of  Switzerland. 

The  wood-line  ends  abruptly.  After  that  there 
is  nothing  but  barrenness  and  desolation.  The 
country  round  Chumbi  is  not  very  thickly  forested. 
There  are  long  strips  of  arable  land  on  each  side  of 
the  road,  and  villages  every  two  or  three  miles. 
The  fields  are  terraced  and  enclosed  within  stone 
walls.  Scattered  on  the  hillside  are  stone-built 
houses,  with  low,  over-hanging  eaves,  and  long 
wooden  tiles,  each  weighed  down  with  a  gray 
boulder.  One  might  imagine  one's  self  in  Kan- 
dersteg  or  Lauterbrunnen ;  only  lofty  praying 
flags  and  wam-walls  brightly  painted  with  Bud- 


70  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

dhistic  pictures  and  inscriptions  dispel  the  illu- 
sion. 

There  is  no  lack  of  colour.  In  the  winter  months 
a  brier  with  large  red  berries  and  a  low,  foxy- 
brown  thombush,  like  a  young  osier  in  March,  lend 
a  russet  hue  to  the  landscape.  Higher  on  the  hills 
the  withered  grass  is  yellow,  and  the  blending  of 
these  quiet  tints,  russet,  brown,  and  yellow,  gives 
the  valley  a  restful  beauty ;  but  in  cloud  it  is 
sombre  enough. 

Three  years  ago  I  visited  Yatung  in  May.  In 
springtime  there  is  a  profusion  of  colour.  The 
valley  is  beautiful,  beyond  the  beauty  of  the  grandest 
Alpine  scenery,  carpeted  underfoot  with  spring 
flowers,  and  ablaze  overhead  with  flowering  rhodo- 
dendrons. To  try  to  describe  mountains  and  forests 
is  a  most  unprofitable  task ;  all  the  adjectives  of 
scenic  description  are  exhausted ;  the  coinage  has 
been  too  long  debased.  For  my  own  part,  it  has 
been  almost  a  pain  to  visit  the  most  beautiful  parts 
of  the  earth  and  to  know  that  one's  sensations  are 
incommunicable,  that  it  is  impossible  to  make 
people  believe  and  understand.  To  those  who  have 
not  seen,  scenery  is  either  good,  bad,  or  indifferent ; 
there  are  no  degrees.    Ruskin,  the  greatest  master  of 


THE  CHUMBI  VALLEY.  71 

description,  is  most  entertaining  when  he  is  telling 
us  about  the  domestic  circle  at  Heme  Hill.  But 
mountain  scenery  is  of  all  the  most  difficult  to 
describe.  The  sense  of  the  Himalayas  is  intangible. 
There  are  elusive  lights  and  shades,  and  sounds  and 
whispers,  and  unfamiliar  scents,  and  a  thousand 
fleeting  manifestations  of  the  genius  of  the  place 
that  are  impossible  to  arrest.  Magnificent,  majestic, 
splendid,  are  weak,  colourless  words  that  depict 
nothing.  It  is  the  poets  who  have  described  what 
they  have  not  seen  who  have  been  most  successful. 
Milton's  hell  is  as  real  as  any  landscape  of  Byron's, 
and  the  country  through  which  Childe  Roland  rode 
to  the  Dark  Tower  is  more  vivid  and  present  to  us 
than  any  of  Wordsworth's  Westmoreland  tarns 
and  valleys.  So  it  is  a  poem  of  the  imagination — 
'  Kubla  Khan ' — that  seems  to  me  to  breathe  some- 
thing of  the  spirit  of  the  Yatung  and  Chumbi 
Valleys,  only  there  is  a  little  less  of  mystery  and 
gloom  here,  and  a  little  more  of  sunshine  and  bright- 
ness than  in  the  dream  poem.  Instead  of  attempt- 
ing to  describe  the  valley — Paradise  would  be  easier 
to  describe — I  will  try  to  explain  as  logically  as  pos- 
sible why  it  fascinated  me  more  than  any  scenery 
I  have  seeji. 


72  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

I  had  often  wondered  if  there  were  any  place  in 
the  East  where  flowers  grow  in  the  same  profusion 
as  in  Europe — in  England,  or  in  Switzerland.  The 
nearest  approach  I  had  seen  was  in  the  plateau  of 
the  Southern  Shan  States,  at  about  4,000  feet,  where 
the  flora  is  very  homelike.  But  the  ground  is  not 
carpeted  ;  one  could  tread  without  crushing  a  blos- 
som. Flowers  are  plentiful,  too,  on  the  southern 
slopes  of  the  Himalayas,  and  on  the  hills  on  the 
Siamese  side  of  the  Tennasserim  frontier,  but  I  had 
seen  nothing  Uke  a  field  of  marsh-marigolds  and 
cuckoo-flowers  in  May,  or  a  meadow  of  buttercups 
and  daisies,  or  a  bank  of  primroses,  or  a  wood  car- 
peted with  bluebells,  or  a  hillside  with  heather,  or 
an  Alpine  slope  with  gentians  and  ranunculus.  I 
had  been  told  that  in  Persia  in  springtime  the  valleys 
of  the  Shapur  River  and  the  Karun  are  covered 
profusely  with  lilies,  also  the  forests  of  Manchuria 
in  the  neighbourhood  of  the  Great  White  Moun- 
tain *  but  until  I  crossed  the  Jelapla  and  struck 
down  the  valley  to  Yatung  I  thought  I  would  have 
to  go  West  to  see  such  things  again.  Never  was 
such  profusion.     Besides  the  primulas  * — I  counted 

*  Between  Gnatong  and  Gautsa,  thirteen  different  species  of 
primulas  are  found.     They  are  :    Primula  Pctiolaris,  P.  glabra. 


THE  CHUMBI  VALLEY.  73 

eight  different  kinds  of  them — and  gentians  and 
anemones  and  celandines  and  wood  sorrel  and  wild 
strawberries  and  irises,  there  were  the  rhododen- 
drons glowing  like  coals  through  the  pine  forest. 
As  one  descended  the  scenery  became  more  fascin- 
ating ;  the  valley  narrowed,  and  the  stream  was 
more  boisterous.  Often  the  cHffs  hung  sheer  over 
the  water's  edge ;  the  rocks  were  coated  with 
green  and  yellow  moss,  which  formed  a  bed  for 
the  dwarf  rhododendron  bushes,  now  in  full  flower, 
white  and  crimson  and  cream,  and  every  hue  be- 
tween a  dark  reddish  brown  and  a  light  sulphury 
yellow — not  here  and  there,  but  everywhere,  jost- 
ling one  another  for  nooks  and  crannies  in  the  rock.* 
These  delicate  flowers  are  very  different  from 
their  dowdy  cousin,  the  coarse  red  rhododendron 
of  the  Enghsh  shrubbery.  At  a  Uttle  distance  they 
resemble  more  hothouse  azaleas,  and  equal  them  in 
wealth  of  blossom. 

p.  Sapphirina,  P.  pusilla,  P.  Kingii,  P.  Elwesiana,  P.  Capitata, 
P.  Sikkimensis,  P.  Involucra,  P.  Deniiculata,  P.  Stuartii,  P. 
Soldanelloides,  P.  Stirtonia. 

*  The  species  are :  Rhododendron  catnpanulatutn,  purple 
flowers ;  R.  Fulgens,  scarlet ;  R.  Hodgsonii,  rose-coloured ; 
R.  Anthopogon,  white  ;  R.  Virgatum,  purple ;  R.  Nivale,  rose- 
red ;  R.  Wightii,  yellow ;  R.  Falconeri,  cream-coloured ;  R» 
cinnabannum,  brick-red  C  The  Gates  of  Tibet,'  Appendix  I., 
J.  A.  H.  Louis). 

3« 


74  THE  Um^TLTNG  OF  LHASA. 

The  great  moss-grown  rocks  in  the  bed  of  the 
stream  were  covered  with  equal  profusion.  Look- 
ing behind,  the  snows  crowned  the  pine-trees,  and 
over  them  rested  the  blue  sky.  And  here  is  the 
second  reason — as  I  am  determined  to  be  logical 
in  my  preference — why  I  found  the  valley  so  fascin- 
ating. In  contrasting  the  Himalayas  with  the  Alps, 
there  is  always  something  that  the  former  is  with- 
out. Never  the  snows,  and  the  water,  and  the 
greenery,  at  the  same  time ;  if  the  greenery  is  at 
your  feet,  the  snows  are  far  distant ;  where  the 
Himalayas  gain  in  grandeur  they  lose  in  beauty. 
So  I  thought  the  wild  valley  of  Lauterbrunnen, 
lying  at  the  foot  of  the  Jungfrau,  the  perfection  of 
Alpine  scenery  until  I  saw  the  valley  of  Yatung, 
a  pine-clad  mountain  glen,  green  as  a  hawthorn 
hedge  in  May,  as  brilUantly  variegated  as  a  beech- 
wood  copse  in  autumn,  and  culminating  in  the 
snowy  peak  that  overhangs  the  Jelapla.  The  valley 
has  besides  an  intangible  fascination,  indescribable 
because  it  is  illogical.  Certainly  the  Hght  that 
played  upon  all  these  colours  seemed  to  me  softer 
than  everyday  sunshine ;  and  the  opening  spring 
foliage  of  larch  and  birch  and  mountain  ash  seemed 
more  delicate  and  varied  than  on  common  ground. 


THE  CHUMBI  VALLEY.  75 

Perhaps  it  was  that  I  was  approaching  the  forbidden 
land.  But  what  irony,  that  this  seductive  valley 
should  be  the  approach  to  the  most  bare  and  un- 
sheltered country  in  Asia  ! 

Even  now,  in  February,  I  can  detect  a  few  salrnon- 
coloured  leaf-buds,  which  remind  me  that  the  month 
of  May  will  be  a  revelation  to  the  mission  force, 
when  their  veins  are  quickened  by  the  unfamiliar 
warmth,  and  their  eyes  dazzled  by  this  unexpected 
treasure  which  is  now  germinating  in  the  brown 
earth. 

Four  miles  beyond  Chumbi  the  road  passes 
through  the  second  military  wall  at  the  Chinese 
village  of  Gob-sorg,  Riding  through  the  quiet 
gateway  beneath  the  grim,  hideous  figure  of  the 
goddess  Dolma  carved  on  the  rock  above,  one 
feels  a  silent  menace.  One  is  part  of  more  than  a 
material  invasion  ;  one  has  passed  the  gate  that  has 
been  closed  against  the  profane  for  centuries ;  one 
has  committed  an  irretrievable  step.  Goddess  and 
barrier  are  symbols  of  Tibet's  spiritual  and  material 
agencies  of  opposition.  We  have  challenged  and 
defied  both.  We  have  entered  the  arena  now,  and 
are  to  be  drawn  into  the  vortex  of  all  that  is  most 
sacred  and  hidden,  to  struggle  there  with  an  im- 


76  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

placable  foe,   who  is  protected  by  the  elemental 
forces  of  nature. 

Inside  the  wall,  above  the  road,  stands  the  Chinese 
village  of  Gob-sorg.  The  Chinamen  come  out  of 
their  houses  and  stand  on  the  revetment  to  watch 
us  pass.  They  are  as  quiet  and  ugly  as  their  gods. 
They  gaze  down  on  our  convoys  and  modern  con- 
trivances with  a  silent  contempt  that  imphes  a 
consciousness  of  immemorial  superiority.  Who  can 
tell  what  they  think  or  what  they  wish,  these  un- 
divinable  creatures  ?  They  love  money,  we  know, 
and  they  love  something  else  that  we  cannot  know. 
It  is  not  country,  or  race,  or  religion,  but  an  in- 
scrutable something  that  may  be  allied  to  these 
things,  that  induces  a  mental  obstinacy,  an  un- 
fathomable reserve  which  may  conceal  a  wisdom 
beyond  our  philosophy  or  mere  callousness  and 
indifference.  The  thing  is  there,  though  it  has  no 
European  name  or  definition;  It  has  caused  many 
curious  and  unexplained  outbreaks  in  different 
parts  of  the  world,  and  it  is  no  doubt  symbolized 
in  their  inexpressibly  hideous  flag.  The  element  is 
non-conductive,  and  receives  no  current  from  prog- 
ress, and  it  is  therefore  incommunicable  to  us  who 
are  wrapped  in  the  pride  of  evolution.     The  ques- 


THE  CHUMBI  VALLEY.  ^j 

tion  here  and  elsewhere  is  whether  the  Chinese  love 
money  more  or  this  inscrutable  dragon  element. 
If  it  is  money,  their  masks  must  have  concealed  a 
satisfaction  at  the  prospect  of  the  increased  trade 
that  follows  our  flag  ;  if  the  dragon  element,  a  grim 
hope  that  we  might  be  cut  off  in  the  wilderness 
and  annihilated  by  Asiatic  hordes. 

Unlike  the  Chinese,  the  Tomos  are  unaffectedly 
glad  to  see  us  in  the  valley.  The  humblest  peasant 
is  the  richer  by  our  presence,  and  the  landowners 
and  traders  are  more  prosperous  than  they  have 
been  for  many  years.  Their  uncompromising  re- 
ception of  us  makes  a  withdrawal  from  the  Chumbi 
Valley  impossible,  for  the  Tibetans  would  punish 
them  relentlessly  for  the  assistance  they  have  given 
their  enemies. 

A  mile  beyond  Gob-sorg  is  the  Tibetan  village  of 
Gahng-ka,  where  the  praying-flags  are  as  thick  as 
masts  in  a  dockyard,  and  streams  of  paper  prayers 
•are  hung  across  the  valley  to  prevent  the  entrance 
of  evil  spirits.  Chubby  little  children  run  out  and 
salute  one  with  a  cry  of  *  Backsheesh  1  '  the  first 
ahen  word  in  their  infant  vocabulary. 

A  mile  further  a  sudden  turn  in  the  valley  brings 
one  to  a  level  plain — a  phenomenally  flat  piece  of 


78  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

ground  where  one  can  race  two  miles  along  the 
straight.  No  one  passes  it  without  remarking  that 
it  is  the  best  site  for  a  hill-station  in  Northern  India. 
Where  else  can  one  find  a  racecourse,  polo-ground, 
fishing,  and  shooting,  and  a  rainfall  that  is  little 
more  than  a  third  of  that  of  Darjeeling  ?  Three 
hundred  feet  above  the  stream  on  the  west  bank 
is  a  plateau,  apparently  intended  for  building  sites. 
The  plain  in  the  valley  was  naturally  designed  for 
the  training  of  mounted  infantry,  and  is  now,  prob- 
ably for  the  first  time,  being  turned  to  its  proper 
use. 

LiNGMATHANG, 

March  i8. 
I  have  left  the  discomforts  of  Phari,  and  am  camp- 
ing now  on  the  Lingmathang  Plain.  I  am  writing 
in  a  natural  cave  in  the  rock.  The  opening  is  walled 
in  by  a  sangar  of  stones  5  feet  high,  from  which 
pine-branches  support  a  projecting  roof.  On  fine 
days  the  space  between  the  roof  and  wall  is  left 
open,  and  called  the  window ;  but  when  it  snows, 
gunny-bags  are  let  down  as  purdahs,  and  the  den 
becomes  very  warm  and  comfortable.  There  is  a 
natural   hearth,   a   natural   chimney-piece,    and   a 


THE  CHUMBI  VALLEY.  79 

natural  chimney  that  draws  excellently.  The  place 
is  sheltered  by  high  cliffs,  and  it  is  very  pleasant  to 
look  out  from  this  snugness  on  a  wintry  landscape, 
and  ground  covered  deep  with  snow. 

Outside,  seventy  shaggy  Tibetan  ponies,  rough 
and  unshod,  averaging  12.2  hands,  are  tethered  under 
the  shelter  of  a  rocky  cliff.  They  are  being  trained 
according  to  the  most  approved  methods  of  modern 
warfare.  The  Mounted  Infantry  Corps,  mostly  vol- 
unteers from  the  23rd  and  32nd  Pioneers  and  8th 
Gurkhas,  are  under  the  command  of  Captain  Ottley 
of  the  23rd.  The  corps  was  raised  at  Gnatong  in 
December,  and  though  many  of  the  men  had  not 
ridden  before,  after  two  months'  training  they  cut 
a  very  respectable  figure  in  the  saddle.  A  few  years 
ago  a  proposal  was  made  to  the  military  authorities 
that  the  Pioneers,  like  other  regiments,  should  go 
in  for  a  course  of  mounted  infantry  training.  The 
reply  caused  much  amusement  at  the  time.  The 
suggestion  was  not  adopted,  but  orders  were  issued 
that  '  every  available  opportunity  should  be  taken 
of  teaching  the  Pioneers  to  ride  in  carts.'  A  wag 
in  the  force  naturally  suggests  that  the  new  Ekka 
Corps,  now  running  between  Phari  and  Tuna,  should 
be  utilized  to  carry  out  the  spirit  of  this  order. 


8o  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

Certainly  on  the  road  beyond  the  Tangla  the  ekkas 
would  require  some  sitting. 

The  present  mission  is  the  third  *  show  '  on  which 
the  23rd  and  32nd  have  been  together  during  the 
last  nine  years.  In  Chitral  and  Waziristan  they 
fought  side  by  side.  It  is  no  exaggeration  to  say 
that  these  regiments  have  been  on  active  service 
three  years  out  of  five'  since  they  were  raised  in 
1857.  The  original  draft  of  the  32nd,  it  will  be 
remembered,  was  the  unarmed  volunteer  corps  of 
Mazbi  Sikhs,  who  offered  themselves  as  an  escort 
to  the  convoy  from  Lahore  to  Delhi  during  the 
siege.  The  Mazbis  were  the  most  lawless  and 
refractory  folk  in  the  Punjab,  and  had  long  been 
the  despair  of  Government.  On  arrival  at  Delhi 
they  were  employed  in  the  trenches,  rushing  in  to 
fill  up  the  places  of  the  killed  and  wounded  as  fast 
as  they  fell.  It  will  be  remembered  that  they 
formed  the  fatigue  party  who  carried  the  powder- 
bags  to  blow  up  the  Cashmere  Gate.  A  hundred 
and  fifty-seven  of  them  were  killed  during  the  siege. 
With  tliis  brilHant  opening  it  is  no  wonder  that 
they  have  been  on  active  service  almost  continually 
since. 

A  frontier  campaign  would  be  incomplete  with- 


THE  CHUMBI  VALLEY.  8i 

out  the  32nd  or  23rd.  It  was  the  32nd  who  cut 
their  way  through  5  feet  of  snow,  and  carried  the 
battery  guns  to  the  reUef  of  Chitral.  The  23rd 
Pioneers  were  also  raised  from  the  Mazbi  Sikhs  in 
the  same  year  of  the  Mutiny,  1857.  The  history  of 
the  two  regiments  is  very  similar.  The  23rd  dis- 
tinguished themselves  in  China,  Abyssinia,  Afghan- 
istan, and  numerous  frontier  campaigns.  One  of 
the  most  brilliant  exploits  was  when,  with  the  Gor- 
don Highlanders  under  Major  (now  Sir  George) 
White,  they  captured  the  Afghan  guns  at  Kandahar. 
To-day  the  men  of  the  two  regiments  meet  again  as 
members  of  the  same  corps  on  the  Lingmathang 
Plain.  Naturally  the  most  cordial  relations  exist 
between  the  men,  and  one  can  hear  them  discussing 
old  campaigns  as  they  sit  round  their  pinewood 
fires  in  the  evenings.  They  and  the  twenty  men 
of  the  8th  Gurkhas  (of  Manipur  fame)  turn  out  to- 
gether every  morning  for  exercise  on  their  diminu- 
tive steeds.  They  ride  without  saddle  or  stirrups, 
and  though  they  have  only  been  horsemen  for  two 
months,  they  seldom  fall  off  at  the  j  umps.  The  other 
day,  when  a  Mazbi  Sikh  took  a  voluntary  into  the 
hedge,  a  genial  Gurkha  reminded  him  of  the  eccentric 
order  '  to  practise  riding  in  carts.' 


82  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

At  Lingmathang  we  have  had  a  fair  amount  of 
sport  of  a  desultory  kind.  The  neighbouring  forests 
are  the  home  of  that  very  rare  and  httle-known 
animal,  the  shao,  or  Sikkim  stag.  The  first  animal 
of  the  species  to  fall  to  a  European  gun  was  shot 
by  Major  Wallace  Dunlop  on  the  Lingmathang 
Hills  in  January,  A  month  later  Captain  Ottley 
wounded  a  buck  which  he  was  not  able  to  follow 
up  on  account  of  a  heavy  fall  of  snow.  Lately  one 
or  two  shao — does  in  all  cases — have  come  down  to 
visit  the  plain.  While  we  were  breakfasting  on  the 
morning  of  the  i6th,  we  heard  a  great  deal  of 
shouting  and  halloaing,  and  a  Gurkha  jemadar  ran 
up  to  tell  us  that  a  female  shao,  pursued  by  village 
dogs,  had  broken  through  the  jungle  on  the  hill- 
side and  emerged  on  the  plain  a  hundred  yards 
from  our  camp.  We  mounted  at  once,  and  Ottley 
deployed  the  mounted  infantry,  who  were  ready 
for  parade,  to  head  the  beast  from  the  hills.  The 
shao  jinked  like  a  hare,  and  crossed  and  recrossed 
the  stream  several  times,  but  the  poor  beast  was 
exhausted,  and,  after  twenty  minutes'  exciting 
chase,  we  surrounded  it.  Captain  Ottley  threw 
himself  on  the  animal's  neck  and  held  it  down 
until  a  sepoy  arrived  with  ropes  to  bind  its  hind- 


THE  CHUMBI  VALLEY.  83 

legs.  The  chase  was  certainly  a  unique  incident  in 
the  history  of  sport — a  field  of  seventy  in  the  Hima- 
layas, a  clear  spurt  in  the  open,  no  dogs,  and  the 
quarry  the  rarest  zoological  specimen  in  the  world. 
The  beast  stood  nearly  14  hands,  and  was  remarkable 
for  its  long  ears  and  elongated  jaw.  The  sequel  was 
sad.  Besides  the  fright  and  exhaustion,  the  cap- 
tured shao  sustained  an  injury  in  the  loin  ;  it 
pined,  barely  nibbled  at  its  food,  and,  after  ten 
da3^s,  died. 

Sikkim  stags  are  sometimes  shot  by  native  shik- 
aris, and  there  is  great  rivalry  among  members  of 
the  mission  force  in  buying  their  heads.  They 
are  shy,  inaccessible  beasts,  and  they  are  not  met 
with  beyond  the  wood  limit. 

The  shooting  in  the  Chumbi  Valley  is  interesting 
to  anyone  fond  of  natural  history,  though  it  is  a 
httle  disappointing  from  the  sportsman's  point  of 
view.  When  officers  go  out  for  a  day's  shooting, 
they  think  they  have  done  well  if  they  bring  home 
a  brace  of  pheasants.  When  the  sappers  and  miners 
began  to  work  on  the  road  below  Gautsa,  the  blood- 
pheasants  used  to  come  down  to  the  stream  to  watch 
the  operations,  but  now  one  sees  very  few  game- 
birds  in  the  valley.     The  minal  is  occasionally  shot. 


84  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

The  cock-bird,  as  all  sportsmen  know,  is,  with  the 
exception  of  the  Argus-eye,  the  most  beautiful 
pheasant  in  the  world.  There  is  a  lamasery  in  the 
neighbourhood,  where  the  birds  are  almost  tame. 
The  monks  who  feed  them  think  that  they  are 
inhabited  by  the  spirits  of  the  blest.  Where  the 
snow  melts  in  the  pine-forests  and  leaves  soft  patches 
and  moist  earth,  you  will  find  the  blood-pheasant. 
When  you  disturb  them  they  will  run  up  the  hill- 
side and  call  vociferously  from  their  new  hiding- 
place,  so  that  you  may  get  another  shot.  Pheasant- 
shooting  here  is  not  sport ;  the  birds  seldom  rise, 
and  when  they  do  it  is  almost  impossible  to  get  a 
shot  at  them  in  the  thick  jungle.  One  must  shoot 
them  running  for  the  pot.  Ten  or  a  dozen  is  not 
a  bad  bag  for  one  gun  later  in  the  year,  when  more 
snow  has  fallen. 

At  a  distance  the  blood-pheasant  appears  a  dowdy 
bird.  The  hen  is  quite  insignificant,  but,  on  a  closer 
acquaintance,  the  cock  shows  a  deUcate  colour- 
scheme  of  mauve,  pink,  and  green,  which  is  quite 
different  from  the  plumage  of  any  other  bird  I 
have  seen.  The  skins  fetch  a  good  price  at  home, 
as  fishermen  find  them  useful  for  making  flies.  A 
sportsman  who  has  shot  in  the  Yatung  Valley  regu- 


THE  CHUMBI  VALLEY.  85 

larly  for  four  years  tells  me  that  the  cock-bird  of 
this  species  is  very  much  more  numerous  than  the 
hen.  Another  Chumbi  pheasant  is  the  tracopan,  a 
smaller  bird  than  the  minal,  and  very  beautifully 
marked.  I  have  not  heard  of  a  tracopan  being  shot 
this  season  ;  the  bird  is  not  at  all  common  any- 
where on  this  side  of  the  Himalayas. 

Snow-partridge  sometimes  come  down  to  the 
Lingmathang  hills  ;  in  the  adjacent  Kongbu  Valley 
they  are  plentiful.  These  birds  are  gregarious,  and 
are  found  among  the  large,  loose  boulders  on  the 
hill-tops.  In  appearance  they  are  a  cross  between 
the  British  grouse  and  the  red-legged  partridge, 
having  red  feet  and  legs  uncovered  with  feathers, 
and  a  red  bill  and  chocolate  breast.  The  feathers 
of  the  back  and  rump  are  white,  with  broad,  de- 
fined bars  of  rich  black. 

Another  common  bird  is  the  snow-pigeon.  Large 
flocks  of  them  may  be  seen  circUng  about  the  valley 
anywhere  between  Phari  and  Chumbi.  Sometimes, 
when  we  are  sitting  in  our  cave  after  dinner,  we 
hear  the  tweek  of  solitary  snipe  flying  overhead, 
but  we  have  never  flushed  any.  Every  morning 
before  breakfast  I  stroll  along  the  river  bank  with 
a  gun,  and  often  put  up  a  stray  duck.     I  have  fre- 


86  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

quently  seen  goosanders  on  the  river,  but  not  more 
than  two  or  three  in  a  party.  They  never  leave 
the  Himalayas.  The  only  migratory  duck  I  have 
observed  are  the  common  teal  and  Brahminy  or 
ruddy  sheldrake,  and  these  only  in  pairs.  The  latter, 
though  despised  on  the  plains,  are  quite  edible  up 
here.  I  discredit  the  statement  that  they  feed  on 
carrion,  as  I  have  never  seen  one  near  the  carcasses 
of  the  dead  transport  animals  that  are  only  too 
plentiful  in  the  valley  just  now.  After  comparing 
notes  with  other  sportsmen,  I  conclude  that  the 
Ammo  Chu  Valley  is  not  a  regular  route  for  migra- 
tory duck.  The  odd  teal  that  I  shot  in  February 
were  probably  loiterers  that  were  not  strong  enough 
to  join  in  the  flight  southwards. 

Near  Lingmathang  I  shot  the  ibis  bill  (Ibidorhyn- 
chus  Struthersi),  a  bird  which  is  allied  to  the  oyster 
catchers.  This  was  the  first  Central  Asian  species 
I  met. 

Gautsa, 
February. 

Gautsa,  which  lies  five  miles  north  of  Lingmathang, 
nearly  half-way  between  Chumbi  and  Phari,  must  be 
added  to  the  map.  A  week  or  two  ago  the  place 
was  deserted  and  unnamed  i  it  did  not  boast  a  single 


THE  CHUMBI  VALLEY.  ^,7 

cowherd's  hut.  Now  it  is  a  busy  camp,  and  Ukely 
to  be  a  permanent  halting-place  on  the  road  to 
Phari.  The  camp  lies  in  a  deep,  moss-carpeted 
h'^Uow,  with  no  apparent  egress.  On  three  sides 
it  is  flanked  by  rocky  cliffs,  densely  forested  with 
pine  and  silver  birch  ;  on  the  fourth  rises  an  abrupt 
wall  of  rock,  which  is  suffused  with  a  glow  of  amber 
Hght  an  hour  before  sunset.  The  Ammo  Chu, 
which  is  here  nothing  but  a  20-foot  stream  frozen 
over  at  night,  bisects  the  camp.  The  valley  is 
warm  and  sheltered,  and  escapes  much  of  the  bitter 
wind  that  never  spares  Chumbi.  After  dinner  one 
prefers  the  open-air  and  a  camp  fire.  Officers  who 
have  been  up  the  line  before  turn  into  their  tents 
regretfully,  for  they  know  that  they  are  saying 
good-bye  to  comfort,  and  will  not  enjoy  the  genial 
warmth  of  a  good  fire  again  until  they  have  crossed 
the  bleak  Tibetan  tablelands  and  reached  the 
sparsely-wooded  Valley  of  Gyantse. 


CHAPTER    IV 

PHARI   JONG 

February  15. 

ICY  winds  and  suffocating  smoke  are  not  con- 
ducive to  a  literary  style,  though  they  some- 
times inspire  a  rude  eloquence  that  is  quite  unfit 
for  pubHcation.  As  I  write  we  are  huddhng  over 
the  mess-room  brazier — our  youngest  optimist 
would  not  call  it  a  fire.  Men  drop  in  now  and  then 
from  fatigue  duty,  and  utter  an  incisive  phrase 
that  expresses  the  general  feehng,  while  we  who 
write  for  an  enlightened  public  must  sacrifice  force 
for  euphemism.  A  week  at  Phari  dispels  all  illu- 
sions ;  only  a  bargee  could  adequately  describe 
the  place.  Yet  the  elements,  which  *  feelingly 
persuade  us  *  what  we  are,  sometimes  inspire  us 
with  the  eloquence  of  discomfort. 

At  Gautsa  the  air  was  scented  with  the  fragrance 
of  warm  pine-trees,  and  there  was  no  indication  of 
winter  save  the  ice  on  the  Ammo  Chu.     The  torrent 


PHARI  JONG.  89 

roared  boisterously  beneath  its  frozen  surface,  and 
threw  up  httle  tentacles  of  frozen  spray,  which 
glistened  fantastically  in  the  sun.  Three  miles 
further  up  the  stream  the  wood-belt  ends  abruptly ; 
then,  after  another  three  miles,  one  passes  the  last 
stunted  bush ;  after  that  there  is  nothing  but 
brown  earth  and  yellow  withered  grass. 

Five  miles  above  Gautsa  is  Dotah,  the  most  cheer- 
less camp  on  the  march.  The  wind  blows  through 
the  gorge  unceasingly,  and  penetrates  to  the  bone. 
On  the  left  bank  of  the  stream  is  the  frozen  water- 
fall, which  might  be  worshipped  by  the  fanciful  and 
superstitious  as  embodying  the  genius  of  the  place, 
hard  and  resistless,  a  crystallized  monument  of  the 
implacable  spirit  of  Nature  in  these  high  places. 

At  Kamparab,  where  we  camped,  two  miles  higher 
up  the  stream,  the  thermometer  fell  to  14°  below 
zero.  Close  by  is  the  meeting-place  of  the  sources 
of  the  Ammo  Chu.  All  the  plain  is  undermined 
with  the  warrens  of  the  long-haired  marmots  and 
voles,  who  sit  on  their  thresholds  like  a  thousand 
little  spies,  and  curiously  watch  our  approach,  then 
dive  down  into  their  burrows  to  tell  their  wives  of 
the  strange  bearded  invaders.  They  are  the  despair 
of  their  rivals,  the  sappers  and    miners,  who  are 


90  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

trying  to  make  a  level  road  for  the  new  light  ekkas. 
One  envies  them  their  warmth  and  snugness  as 
one  rides  against  the  bitter  penetrating  winds. 

Twelve  miles  from  Gautsa  a  txirn  in  the  valley 
brings  one  into  view  of  Phari  Jong.  At  first  sight 
it  might  be  a  huge  isolated  rock,  but  as  one  ap- 
proaches the  bastions  and  battlements  become  more 
distinct.  Distances  are  deceptive  in  this  rarefied 
air,  and  objects  that  one  imagines  to  be  quite  close 
are  sometimes  found  to  be  several  miles  distant. 

The  fort  is  built  on  a  natural  mound  in  the  plain. 
It  is  a  huge  rambling  building  six  stories  high,  sur- 
rounded by  a  courtyard,  where  mules  and  ponies 
are  stabled.  As  a  military  fortification  Phari  Jong 
is  by  no  means  contemptible.  The  walls  are  of 
massive  stonework  which  would  take  heavy  guns 
to  demolish.  The  angles  are  protected  from  attack- 
ing parties  by  machicolated  galleries,  and  three 
enormous  bastions  project  from  each  flank.  These 
are  crumbling  in  places,  and  the  Pioneers  might 
destroy  the  bastion  and  breach  the  wall  with  a  bag 
or  two  of  guncotton.  On  the  eastern  side  there  is 
a  square  courtyard  like  an  Arab  caravanserai,  where 
cattle  are  penned.  The  fortress  would  hold  the 
whole  Tibetan  army,  with  provisions  for  a  year. 


PHARI  JONG.  91 

It  was  evacuated  the  night  before  we  reconnoitred 
the  valley. 

The  interior  of  the  Jong  is  a  warren  of  stairs, 
landings,  and  dark  cavernous  rooms,  which  would 
take  a  whole  day  to  explore.  The  walls  are  built 
of  stone  and  mud,  and  coated  with  century-old 
smoke.  There  are  no  chimneys  or  adequate  win- 
dows, and  the  filth  is  indescribable.  When  Phari 
was  first  occupied,  eighty  coolies  were  employed  a 
whole  week  clearing  away  refuse.  Judging  by  the 
accretion  of  dirt,  a  new-comer  might  class  the  build- 
ing as  medieval ;  but  filth  is  no  criterion  of  age, 
for  everything  left  in  the  same  place  becomes 
quickly  coated  with  grime  an  inch  thick.  The  dust 
that  invades  one's  tent  at  Chumbi  is  clean  and 
wholesome  compared  to  the  Phari  dirt,  which  is 
the  filth  of  human  habitation,  the  secretion  of  cen- 
turies of  foul  living.  It  falls  from  the  roof  on 
one's  head,  sticks  to  one's  clothes  as  one  brushes 
against  the  wall,  and  is  blown  up  into  one's  eyes 
and  throat  from  the  floor. 

The  fort  is  most  insanitary,  but  a  military  occu- 
pation is  necessary.  The  hacking  coughs  which  are 
prevalent  among  officers  and  men  are  due  to  im- 
purities of  the  air  which  affect  the  lungs.    Cart- 


92  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA 

loads  of  dirt  are  being  scraped  away  every  day,  but 
gusts  of  wind  from  the  lower  stories  blow  up  more 
dust,  which  penetrates  every  nook  and  cranny  of 
the  draughty  rooms,  so  that  there  is  a  fresh  layer 
by  nightfall.  To  clear  the  lower  stories  and  cellars 
would  be  a  hopeless  task  ;  even  now  rooms  are 
found  in  unexpected  places  which  emit  clouds  of 
dust  whenever  the  wind  eddies  round  the  basement. 
I  explored  the  ground-floor  with  a  lantern,  and 
was  completely  lost  in  the  maze  of  passages  and 
dark  chambers.  When  we  first  occupied  the  fort, 
they  were  filled  with  straw,  gunpowder,  and  old 
arms.  A  hundred  and  forty  maunds  of  inferior 
gunpowder  was  destroyed,  and  the  arms  now  litter 
the  courtyard.  These  the  Tibetans  themselves  aban- 
doned as  rubbish.  The  rusty  helmets,  shields,  and 
breastplates  are  made  of  the  thinnest  iron  plates 
interlaced  with  leathern  thongs,  and  would  not  stop 
an  arrow.  The  old  bell-mouthed  matchlocks,  with 
their  wooden  ground-rests,  would  be  more  dan- 
gerous to  the  Tibetan  marksmen  than  the  enemy. 
The  slings  and  bows  and  arrows  are  reckoned  ob- 
solete even  by  these  primitive  warriors.  Perhaps 
they  attribute  more  efficacy  to  the  praying-wheels 
which  one  encounters  at  every  comer  of  the  fort. 


PHARI  JONG.  93 

The  largest  are  in  niches  in  the  wall  to  left  and 
right  of  the  gateway  ;  rows  of  smaller  ones  are 
attached  to  the  banisters  on  the  landings  and  to 
the  battlements  of  the  roof.  The  wheels  are 
covered  with  grime — the  grime  of  Lamas'  hands. 
Dirt  and  religion  are  inseparable  in  Tibet.  The 
Lamas  themselves  are  the  most  filthy  and  mal- 
odorous folk  I  have  met  in  the  country.  From 
this  it  must  not  be  inferred  that  one  class  is  more 
cleanly  in  its  habits  than  another,  for  nobody  ever 
thinks  of  washing.  Soap  is  not  included  in  the  list 
of  sundries  that  pass  the  Customs  House  at  Yatung. 
If  the  Lamas  are  dirtier  than  the  yakherds  and 
itinerant  merchants  it  is  because  they  lead  an  in- 
door life,  whereas  the  pastoral  folk  are  continually 
exposed  to  the  purifying  winds  of  the  tablelands, 
which  are  the  nearest  equivalent  in  Tibet  to  a  cold 
bath. 

I  once  read  of  a  Tibetan  saint,  one  of  the  pupils 
of  Naropa,  who  was  credited  with  a  hundred  mirac- 
ulous gifts,  one  of  which  was  that  he  could  dive 
into  the  water  like  a  fish.  Wherein  the  miracle  lay 
had  often  puzzled  me,  but  when  I  met  the  Lamas 
of  the  Kanjut  Gompa  I  understood  at  once  that  it 
was  the  holy  man's  contact  with  the  water. 


94  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

Phari  is  eloquent  of  piety,  as  it  is  understood  in 
Tibet.  The  better  rooms  are  frescoed  with  Bud- 
dhistic paintings,  and  on  the  third  floor  is  a  library, 
now  used  as  a  hospital,  where  xylograph  editions  of 
the  I^maist  scriptures  and  lives  of  the  saints  are 
pigeon-holed  in  lockers  in  the  wall.  The  books  are 
printed  on  thin  oblong  sheets  of  Chinese  paper, 
enclosed  in  boards,  and  illuminated  with  quaint 
coloured  tailpieces  of  holy  men  in  devotional  atti- 
tudes. Phari  fort,  with  its  casual  hlendmg  of  East 
and  West,  is  full  of  incongruous  effects,  but  the 
oddest  and  most  pathetic  incongruity  is  the  chorten 
on  the  roof,  from  which,  amidst  praying-flags  and 
pious  offerings  of  coloured  raiment,  flutters  the 
Union  Jack. 

February  i8. 

The  troops  are  so  busy  making  roads  that  they 
have  very  little  time  for  amusements.  The  8th 
Gurkhas  have  already  constructed  some  eight  miles 
of  road  on  each  side  of  Phari  for  the  ekka  transport. 
Companies  of  the  23rd  Pioneers  are  repairing  the 
road  at  Dotah,  Chumbi,  and  Rinchengong.  The 
32nd  are  working  at  Rinchengong,  and  the  sappers 
and  miners  on  the  Nathula  and  at  Gautsa. 

We  have  started  football,  and  the  Gurkhas  have 


PHARI  JONG.  95 

a  very  good  idea  of  the  game.  One  loses  one's 
wind  completely  at  this  elevation  after  every  spurt 
of  twenty  yards,  but  recovers  it  again  in  a  wonderfully 
short  time.  Other  amusem.ents  are  sliding  and 
tobogganing,  which  are  a  little  disappointing  to 
enthusiasts.  The  ice  is  lumpy  and  broken,  and  the 
streamlets  that  run  down  to  the  plain  are  so  tortuous 
that  fifty  yards  without  a  spill  is  considered  a  good 
run  for  a  toboggan.  The  funniest  sight  is  to  see  the 
Gurkha  soldiers  trying  to  drag  the  toboggan  uphill, 
slipping  and  tumbling  and  sprawling  on  the  ice, 
and  immensely  enjoying  one  another's  discomfiture. 
To  clear  the  dust  from  one's  throat  and  shake  off 
the  depression  caused  by  weeks  of  waiting  in  the 
same  place,  there  is  nothing  like  a  day's  shooting 
or  exploring  in  the  neighbourhood  of  Phari.  I  get 
up  sometimes  before  daybreak,  and  spend  the  whole 
day  reconnoitring  with  a  small  party  of  mounted 
infantry.  Yesterday  we  crossed  a  pass  which  looked 
down  into  the  Kongbu  Valley— a  likely  camping- 
ground  for  the  Tibetan  troops.  The  valley  is  con- 
nected to  the  north  with  the  Tuna  plateau,  and  is 
almost  as  fertile  in  its  lower  stretches  as  Chumbi. 
A  gray  fortress  hangs  over  the  cliff  on  the  western 
side  of  the  valley,  and  above  it  tower  the  glaciers 


9b  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

of  Shudu-Tsenpa  and  the  Gora  Pass  into  Sikkim. 
On  the  eastern  side,  at  a  creditable  distance  from 
the  fort,  we  could  see  the  Kongbu  nunnery,  which 
looked  from  where  we  stood  like  an  old  Roman 
viaduct.  The  nuns,  I  was  told,  are  rarely  celibate  ; 
they  shave  the  head  and  wear  no  ornaments. 

Riding  back  we  saw  some  burrhel  on  the  opposite 
hills,  too  far  off  to  make  a  successful  stalk  possible. 
The  valley  is  full  of  them,  and  a  week  later  some 
officers  from  Phari  on  a  yak-collecting  expedition 
got  several  good  heads.  The  Tibetan  gazelle,  or 
goa  (Gazella  hirticaudata) ,  is  very  common  on  the 
Phari  plateau,  and  we  bagged  two  that  afternoon. 
When  the  force  first  occupied  the  Jong,  they  were 
so  tame  that  a  sportsman  could  walk  up  to  within 
100  yards  of  a  herd,  and  it  was  not  an  uncommon 
thing  for  three  buck  to  fall  to  the  same  gun  in  a 
morning.  Now  one  has  to  manoeuvre  a  great  deal 
'to  get  within  300  yards  of  them. 

Sportsmen  who  have  travelled  in  other  parts  of 
Tibet  say  the  goa  are  very  shy  and  inaccessible. 
Perhaps  their  comparative  tameness  near  Phari 
may  be  accounted  for  by  the  fact  that  the  old  trade 
route  crosses  the  plateau,  and  they  have  never  been 
molested  by  the  itinerant  merchants  and  carriers. 


PHARI  JONG.  97 

Gazelle  meat  is  excellent.  It  has  been  a  great 
resource  for  the  garrison.  No  epicure  could  wish 
for  anything  better. 

Another  unfamiliar  beast  that  one  meets  in  the 
neighbourhood  of  Phari  is  the  kyang,  or  Tibetan 
wild  ass  (Equus  hemionus),  one  or  two  of  which 
have  been  shot  for  specimens.  The  kyang  is  more 
like  a  zebra  than  a  horse  or  donkey.  Its  flesh,  I 
believe,  is  scorned  even  by  camp-followers.  Hare 
are  fairly  plentiful,  but  they  are  quite  flavourless. 
A  huge  solitary  gray  wolf  {Cams  laniger)  was  shot 
the  other  day,  the  only  one  of  its  kind  I  have  seen. 
Occasionally  one  puts  up  a  fox.  The  Tibetan  species 
has  a  very  fine  brush  that  fetches  a  fancy  price  in  the 
bazaar.  At  present  there  is  too  much  ice  on  the 
plain  to  hunt  them,  but  they  ought  to  give  good 
sport  in  the  spring. 

It  was  dark  when  we  rode  into  the  Jong.  After 
a  long  day  in  the  saddle,  dinner  is  good,  even  though 
it  is  of  yak's  flesh,  and  it  is  good  to  sit  in  front  of  a 
fire  even  though  the  smoke  chokes  you.  I  went 
so  far  as  to  pity  the  cave-dwellers  at  Chumbi.  Phari 
is  certainly  very  much  colder,  but  it  has  its  diver- 
sions and  interests.  There  is  still  some  shooting  to 
be  had,  and  the  place  has  a  quaint  old-world  indi- 


98  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

viduality  of  its  own,  which  seasons  the  monotony 
of  life  to  a  contemplative  man.  One  is  on  the 
borderland,  and  one  has  a  Micawber-like  feeling 
that  something  may  turn  up.  After  dinner  there  is 
bridge,  which  fleets  the  time  considerably,  but  at 
Chumbi  there  were  no  diversions  of  any  kind — 
nothing  but  dull,  blank,  uninterrupted  monotony. 

Fehrtiary  20. 
For  two  days  half  a  blizzard  has  been  blowing, 
and  expeditions  have  been  impossible.  Everything 
one  eats  and  drinks  has  the  same  taste  of  argol 
smoke.  At  breakfast  this  morning  we  had  to  put 
our  chapatties  in  our  pockets  to  keep  them  clean, 
and  kept  our  meat  covered  with  a  soup-plate, 
making  surreptitious  dives  at  it  with  a  fork.  After 
a  few  seconds'  exposure  it  was  covered  with  grime. 
Sausages  and  bully  beef,  which  had  just  been  boiled, 
were  found  to  be  frozen  inside.  The  smoke  in  the 
mess-room  was  suffocating.  So  to  bed,  wrapped  in 
sheepskins  and  a  sleeping-bag.  Under  these  de- 
pressing conditions  I  have  been  reading  the  narra- 
tives of  Bogle  and  Manning,  old  English  worthies 
who  have  left  on  record  the  most  vivid  impressions 
of  the  dirt  and  cold  and  misery  of  Phari. 


PHARI  JONG.  99 

It  is  ninety  years  since  Thomas  Manning  passed 
through  Phari  on  his  way  to  Lhasa.  Previously  to 
his  visit  we  only  know  of  two  Englishmen  who 
have  set  foot  in  Phari — Bogle-. in  1774,  and  Turner 
in  1783,  both  emissaries  of  Warren  Hastings. 
Manning's  journal  is  mostly  taken  up  with  com- 
plaints of  his  Chinese  servant,  who  seems  to  have 
gained  some  mysterious  ascendancy  over  him,  and 
to  have  exercised  it  most  unhandsomely.  As  a 
traveller  Manning  had  a  genius  for  missing  effects  ; 
it  is  characteristic  of  him  that  he  spent  sixteen  days 
at  Phari,  yet  except  for  a  casual  footnote,  evidently 
inserted  in  his  journal  after  his  return,  he  makes 
no  mention  of  the  Jong.  Were  it  not  for  Bogle's 
account  of  thirty  years  before,  we  might  conclude 
that  the  building  was  not  then  in  existence. 

On  October  21,  181 1,  Manning  writes  in  his  diary  : 
*  We  arrived  at  Phari  Jong.  Frost.  Frost  also 
two  days  before.  I  was  lodged  in  a  strange  place, 
but  so  were  the  natives.'  On  the  27th  he  sum- 
marized his  impressions  of  Phari : — *  Dirt,  dirt, 
grease,  smoke,  misery,  but  good  mutton.' 

Manning's  journal  is  expressive,  if  monosyllabic. 
He  was  of  the  class  of  subjective  travellers,  who 
visit  the  ends  of  the  earth  to  record  their  own 


100  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

personal  discomforts.  Sensitive,  neurotic,  ever  on 
the  look-out  for  slights,  he  could  not  have  been  a 
happy  vagabond.  A  dozen  lines  record  the  impres- 
sions of  his  first  week  at  Phari.  He  was  cheated ; 
he  was  treated  civilly ;  he  slighted  the  magistrates, 
mistaking  them  for  idle  fellows  ;  he  was  turned  out 
of  his  room  to  make  way  for  Chinese  soldiers ;  he 
quarrelled  with  his  servant.  A  single  extract  por- 
trays the  man  to  the  life,  as  if  he  were  sitting  de- 
jectedly by  his  yak-dung  fire  at  this  hour  brooding 
over  his  wrongs  : — 

* "  The  Chinaman  was  cross  again."  Sajrs  I, 
"  Was  that  a  bird  at  the  magistrate's  that  flapped 
so  loud  ?  "  Answer  :  "  What  signifies  whether  it 
was  a  bird  or  not  ?  "  Where  he  sat  I  thought  he 
might  see  ;  and  I  was  curious  to  know  if  such  large 
birds  frequented  the  building.  These  are  the  an- 
swers I  get.  He  is  always  discontented  and  grum- 
bling, and  takes  no  trouble  off  my  hands.  Being 
younger,  and,  like  all  Asiatics,  able  to  stoop  and 
crouch  without  pain  or  difficulty,  he  might  assist  me 
in  many  things  without  trouble  to  himself.  A 
younger  brother  or  any  English  young  gentleman 
would  in  his  place  of  course  lay  the  cloth,  and  do 
other  little  sersdces  when  I  am  tired  ;    but  he  does 


PHARI  JONG.  loi 

not  seem  to  have  much  of  the  generous  about  him, 
nor  does  he  in  any  way  serve  me,  or  behave  to  me 
with  any  show  of  affection  or  good-will :  conse- 
quently I  grow  no  more  attached  to  him  than  the 
first  day  I  saw  him.  I  could  not  have  thought  it 
possible  for  me  to  have  lived  so  long  with  anyone 
without  either  disliking  him  or  caring  sixpence  for 
him.  He  has  good  qualities,  too.  The  strangeness 
of  his  situation  may  partly  excuse  him.  (I  am 
more  attached  to  my  guide,  with  all  his  faults,  who 
has  been  with  me  but  a  few  days.)  My  guide  has 
behaved  so  damnably  ill  since  I  wrote  that,  that  I 
wish  it  had  not  come  into  my  mind.' 

I  give  the  extract  at  length,  not  only  as  an 
illuminating  portrait  of  Manning,  but  as  an  inci- 
dental proof  that  he  visited  the  Jong,  and  that  it 
was  very  much  the  same  building  then  as  it  is  to- 
day. But  had  it  not  been  for  the  flapping  of  the 
bird  which  occasioned  the  quarrel  with  his  Chinese 
servant,  Manning  would  have  left  Phari  without  a 
reference  to  the  wonderful  old  fortress  which  is  the 
most  romantic  feature  on  the  road  from  India  to 
Gyantse.  Appended  to  the  journal  is  tliis  footnote 
to  the  word  building,  which  I  have  italicized  in  the 
extract :    '  The  building  is  im.mensely  large,  six  or 


102  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

more  stories  high,  a  sort  of  fortress.  At  a  distance 
it  appears  to  be  all  Phari  Jong.  Indeed,  most  of 
it  consists  of  miserable  galleries  and  holes.* 

Members  of  the  mission  force  who  have  visited 
Phari  will  no  doubt  attribute  Manning's  evident 
ill-humour  arid  depression  during  his  stay  there  to 
the  environments  of  the  place,  wliich  have  not 
changed  much  in  the  last  ninety  years.  But  his 
spirits  improved  as  he  continued  his  journey  to 
Gyantse  and  Lhasa,  and  he  reveals  himself  the 
kindly,  eccentric,  and  affectionate  soul  who  was  the 
friend  and  intimate  of  Charles  Lamb. 

Bogle  arrived  at  Phari  on  October  23,  1774.  He 
and  Turner  and  Manning  all  entered  Tibet  through 
Bhutan.  '  As  we  advanced,'  he  wrote  in  his  journal, 
*  we  came  in  sight  of  the  castle  of  Phari  Jong,  which 
cuts  a  good  figure  from  without.  It  rises  into 
several  towers  with  the  balconies,  and,  having  few 
windows,  has  the  look  of  strength  ;  it  is  surrounded 
by  the  town.*  The  only  other  reference  he  makes  to 
the  Jong  shows  us  that  the  fortress  was  in  bad  repair 
so  long  ago  as  1774.  *  The  two  Lhasa  officers  who 
have  the  government  of  Phari  Jong  sent  me  some 
butter,  tea,  etc.,  the  day  after  my  arrival ;  and 
letting  me  know  that  they  expected  a  visit  from 


PHARI  JONG.  103 

me,  I  went.  The  inside  of  the  castle  did  not  answer 
the  notion  I  had  formed  of  it.  The  stairs  are 
ladders  worn  to  the  bone,  and  the  rooms  are  little 
better  than  garrets.* 

The  origin  of  the  fort  is  unknown.  Some  of  the 
inhabitants  of  Phari  say  that  it  was  built  more  than 
a  hundred  years  ago,  when  the  Nepalese  were  over- 
running Sikkim.  But  this  is  obviously  incorrect,  as 
the  Tibetan-Nepalese  War,  in  which  the  Chinese 
drove  the  Gurkhas  out  of  Tibet,  and  defeated  their 
army  within  a  day's  march  of  Khatmandu,  took 
place  in  1788-1792,  whereas  Bogle's  description  of 
the  Jong  was  written  fourteen  years  earlier.  A 
more  general  impression  is  that  centuries  ago  orders 
came  from  Lhasa  to  collect  stones  on  the  hillsides, 
and  the  building  was  constructed  by  forced  labour 
in  a  few  months.  That  is  a  tale  of  endurance  and 
suffering  that  might  very  likely  be  passed  from 
father  to  son  for  generations. 

Bogle's  description  of  the  town  might  have  been 
written  by  an  ofhcer  of  the  garrison  to-day,  only 
he  wrote  from  the  inmate's  point  of  view.  He 
noticed  the  houses  '  so  huddled  together  that  one 
may  chance  to  overlook  them,'  and  the  fiat  roofs 
covered  with  bundles  of  straw.     He  knocked  his 


104  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

head  against  the  low  ceilings,  and  ran  against  the 
pillars  that  supported  the  beams.  '  In  the  middle 
of  the  roof,'  he  wrote,  '  is  a  hole  to  let  out  smoke, 
which,  however,  departs  not  without  making  the 
whole  room  as  black  as  a  chimney.  The  opening 
serves  also  to  let  in  the  light ;  the  doors  are  full  of 
holes  and  crevices,  through  which  the  women  and 
children  keep  peeping.'  Needless  to  say  nothing 
has  changed  in  the  last  hundred  and  thirty  years, 
unless  it  is  that  the  women  are  bolder.  I  looked 
down  from  the  roof  this  morning  on  Phari  town, 
lying  like  a  rabbit-warren  beneath  the  fort.  All 
one  can  see  from  the  battlement  are  the  flat  roofs 
of  low  black  houses,  from  which  smoke  issues  in 
dense  fumes.  The  roofs  are  stacked  with  straw, 
and  connected  by  a  web  of  coloured  praying-fiags 
running  from  house  to  house,  and  sometimes  over 
the  narrow  alleys  that  serve  as  streets.  Enormous 
fat  ravens  perch  on  the  wall,  and  innumerable  flocks 
of  twittering  sparrows.  For  warmth's  sake  most  of 
the  rooms  are  underground,  and  in  these  subter- 
ranean dens  Tibetans,  black  as  coal-heavers,  huddle 
together  with  yaks  and  mules.  Tibetan  women, 
equally  dirty,  go  about,  their  faces  smeared  and 
blotched  with  caoutchouc,  wearing  a  red,  hoop-like 


PHARI  JONG.  105 

head-dress,  ornamented  with  alternate  turquoises 
and  ruby-coloured  stones. 

In  the  fort  the  first  thing  one  meets  of  a  morning 
is  a  troop  of  these  grimy  sirens,  climbing  the  stairs, 
burdened  with  buckets  of  chopped  ice  and  sacks  of 
yak-dung,  the  two  necessaries  of  life.  The  Tibetan 
coolie  women  are  merry  folk ;  they  laugh  and 
chatter  over  their  work  all  day  long,  and  do  not  in 
the  least  resist  the  familiarities  of  the  Gurkha 
soldiers.  Sometimes  as  they  pass  one  they  giggle 
coyly,  and  put  out  the  tongue,  which  is  tlieir  way 
of  showing  respect  to  those  in  high  places ;  but 
when  one  hears  their  laughter  echoing  down  the 
stairs  it  is, difficult  to  believe  that  it  is  not  intended 
for  saucy  impudence.  Their  merriment  sounds  un- 
natural in  all  this  filth  and  cold  and  discomfort. 
Certainly  if  Bogle  returned  to  Phari  he  would  find 
the  women  very  much  bolder,  though,  I  am  afraid, 
not  any  cleaner.  Could  he  see  the  Englishmen  in 
Phari  to-day,  he  might  not  recognise  his  compatriots. 

Often  in  civilized  places  I  shall  think  of  the  group 
at  Phari  in  the  mess-room  after  dinner — a  group 
of  i^uffianly-looking  bandits  in  a  blackened,  smut-be- 
grimed room,  clad  in  wool  and  fur  from  head  to  foot, 

bearded  like  wild  men  of  the  woods,  and  sitting  round 
4a 


lo6  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASa. 

a  yak-dung  fire,  drinking  rum.  After  a  week  at  Phari 
the  best-groomed  man  might  qualify  for  a  caricature 
of  Bill  Sikes.  Perhaps  one  day  in  Piccadilly  one 
may  encounter  a  half-remembered  face,  and  some- 
thing familiar  in  walk  or  gait  may  reveal  an  old 
friend  of  the  Jong.  Then  in  *  Jimmy's,'  memories 
of  argol-smoke  and  frozen  moustaches  will  give  a 
zest  to  a  bottle  of  beaune  or  chablis,  which  one  had 
almost  forgotten  was  once  dreamed  of  among  the 
unattainable  luxuries  of  life. 

March  26-28. 
Orders  have  come  to  advance  from  Phari  Jong. 
It  seems  impossible,  unnatural,  that  we  are  going 
on.  After  a  week  or  two  the  place  becomes  part  of 
one's  existence ;  one  feels  incarcerated  there.  It 
is  difficult  to  imagine  life  anywhere  else.  One  feels 
as  if  one  could  never  again  be  cold  or  dirty,  or 
miserably  uncomfortable,  without  thinking  of  that 
gray  fortress  with  its  strange  unknown  history, 
standing  alone  in  the  desolate  plain.  For  my  own 
part,  speaking  figuratively — and  unfigurative  lan- 
guage is  impotent  on  an  occasion  like  this — the 
place  will  leave  an  indelible  black  streak — very 
black  indeed — on  a  kaleidoscopic  past.  There  can 
be  no  faint  impressions  in  one's  memories  of  Phari 


PHARI  JONG.  107 

Jong.  The  dirt  and  smoke  and  dust  are  elemental, 
and  the  cold  is  the  cold  of  the  Lamas*  frigid 
heU. 

All  the  while  I  was  in  Phari  I  forgot  the  mystery 
of  Tibet,  I  have  felt  it  elsewhere,  but  in  the  Jong 
I  only  wondered  that  the  inscrutable  folk  who  had 
lived  in  the  rooms  where  we  slept,  and  fled  in  the 
night,  were  content  with  their  smut-begrimed  walls, 
blackened  ceilings,  and  chimneyless  roofs,  and  still 
more  how  amidst  these  murky  environments  any 
spiritual  instincts  could  survive  to  inspire  the  re- 
ligious frescoings  on  the  walls.  Yet  every  figure 
in  this  intricate  blending  of  designs  is  significant 
and  symbolical.  One's  first  impression  is  that  these 
allegories  and  metaphysical  abstractions  must  have 
been  meaningless  to  the  inmates  of  the  Jong  ;  for 
we  in  Europe  cannot  dissociate  the  artistic  expres- 
sion of  religious  feeling  from  cleanline^  and  refine- 
ment, or  at  least  pious  care.  One  feels  that  they 
must  be  the  relics  of  a  decayed  spirituality,  preserved 
not  insincerely,  but  in  ignorant  superstition,  like 
other  fetishes  all  over  the  world.  Yet  this  feeling 
of  scepticism  is  not  so  strong  after  a  month  or  two 
in  Tibet.  At  first  one  is  apt  to  think  of  these  dirty 
people  as  merely  animal  and  sensual,  and  to  attribute 


io8  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

their  religious  observances  to  the  fear  of  demons 
who  will  punish  the  most  trivial  omission  in  ritual. 

Next  one  begins  to  wonder  if  they  really  believe 
in  the  efficacy  of  mechanical  prayer,  if  they  take 
the  trouble  to  square  their  conscience  with  their 
inclinations,  and  if  they  have  any  sincere  desire  to 
be  absorbed  in  the  universal  spirit.  Then  there 
may  come  a  suspicion  that  the  better  classes, 
though  not  given  to  inquiry,  have  a  settled  dogma 
and  definite  convictions  about  things  spiritual  and 
natural  that  are  not  easily  upset.  Perhaps  before 
we  turn  our  backs  on  the  mystery  of  Tibet  we 
will  realize  that  the  Lamas  despise  us  as  gross 
materialists  and  philistines — we  who  are  always 
groping  and  grasping  after  the  particular,  while 
they  are  absorbed  in  the  sublime  and  universal. 

After  all,  devious  and  unscrupulous  as  their  policy 
may  have  been,  the  Tibetans  have  had  one  definite 
aim  in  view  for  centuries — the  preservation  of 
their  Church  and  State  by  the  exclusion  of  all  foreign 
and  heretical  influences.  When  we  know  that  the 
Mongol  cannot  conceive  of  the  separation  of  the 
spiritual  and  temporal  Government,  it  is  only 
natural  to  infer  that  the  first  mission,  spiritual 
or  otherwise,  to  a  foreign  Court  should  introduce 


PHARI  JONG:  £09 

the  first  elements  of  dissolution  in  a  system  of 
Government  that  has  held  the  country  intact  for 
centuries.  And  let  it  be  remarked  that  Great 
Britain  is  not  responsible  for  this  deviation  in  a 
hitherto  inveterate  policy. 

But  to  return  to  Phari.  My  last  impression  of 
the  place  as  I  passed  out  of  its  narrow  alleys  was 
a  very  dirty  old  man,  seated  on  a  heap  of  yak- 
dung  over  the  gutter.  He  was  turning  his  prayer- 
wheel,  and  muttering  the  sacred  formula  that  was 
to  release  him  from  all  rebirth  in  this  suffering 
world.    The  wish  seemed  natural  enough. 

It  was  a  bright,  clear  morning  when  we  turned 
our  backs  on  the  old  fort  and  started  once  more  on 
the  road  to  Lhasa.  Five  miles  from  Phari  we 
passed  the  miserable  little  village  of  Chuggya, 
which  is  apparently  inhabited  by  ravens  and  spar- 
rows, and  a  diminutive  mountain-finch  that  looks 
Uke  a  half -starved  robin.  A  mile  to  the  right  before 
entering  the  village  is  the  monastery  of  the  Red 
Lamas,  which  was  the  lodging-place  of  the  Bhutanese 
Envoy  during  his  stay  at  Phari.  The  building, 
which  is  a  landmark  for  miles,  is  stone-built,  and 
coated  over  with  red  earth,  which  gives  it  the  appear- 
ance of  brick.    Its  overhanging  gables,  mullioned 


no  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

windows  without  glass,  that  look  like  dominoes 
in  the  distance,  the  pendent  bells,  and  the  gay 
decorations  of  Chinese  paper,  look  quaint  and 
mystical,  and  are  in  keeping  with  the  sacred  char- 
acter of  the  place.  Bogle  stopped  here  on  October 
27,  1774,  and  drank  tea  with  the  Abbot.  It  is  very 
improbable  that  any  other  white  man  has  set  foot 
in  the  monastery  since,  until  the  other  day,  when 
some  of  the  garrison  paid  it  a  visit  and  took  photo- 
graphs of  the  interior.  The  Lamas  were  a  little 
deprecatory,  but  evidently  amused.  I  did  not 
expect  them  to  be  so  tolerant  of  intrusion,  and 
their  clamour  for  backsheesh  on  our  departure 
dispelled  one  more  illusion. 

At  Chuggya  we  were  at  the  very  foot  of  Chumu- 
lari  (23,930  feet),  which  seems  to  rise  sheer  from 
the  plain.  The  western  flank  is  an  abrupt  wall  of 
rock,  but,  as  far  as  one  can  see,  the  eastern  side  is  a 
gradual  ascent  of  snow,  which  would  present  no 
difficulties  to  the  trained  mountaineer.  One  could 
ride  up  to  17,000  feet,  and  start  the  climb  from  a 
base  2,000  feet  higher  than  Mont  Blanc.  Chumu- 
lari  is  the  most  sacred  mountain  in  Tibet,  and  it  is 
usual  for  devout  Buddhists  to  stop  and  offer  a 
sacrifice    as    they    pass.     Bogle    gives    a    detailed 


PHARI  JONG.  Ill 

account  of  the  service,  the  rites  of  which  are  very 
similar  to  some  I  witnessed  at  Galingka  on  the 
Til)etan  New  Year,  February  i6. 

'  Here  we  halted,*  he  wrote  in  his  journal,  *  and 
the  servants  gathering  together  a  parcel  of  dried 
cow -dung,  one  of  them  struck  fire  with  his  tinder- 
box  and  lighted  it.  When  the  fire  was  well  kindled, 
Parma  took  out  a  book  of  prayers,  one  brought  a 
copper  cup,  another  filled  it  with  a  kind  of  fer- 
mented liquor  out  of  a  new-killed  sheep's  paunch, 
mixing  in  some  rice  and  flour ;  and  after  throwing 
some  dried  herbs  and  flour  into  the  flame,  they 
began  their  rites.  Parma  acted  as  chaplain.  He 
chanted  the  prayers  in  a  loud  voice,  the  others  accom- 
panying him,  and  every  now  and  then  the  little  cup 
was  emptied  towards  the  rock,  about  eight  or  ten  of 
these  libations  being  poured  forth.  The  ceremony 
was  finished  by  placing  upon  the  heap  of  stones  the 
little  ensign  which  my  fond  imagination  had  before 
offered  up  to  my  own  vanity.' 

Most  of  the  flags  and  banners  one  sees  to-day  on 
the  chortens  and  roofs  of  houses,  and  cairns  on  the 
mountain-tops,  must  be  planted  with  some  such 
inaugural  ceremony. 

Facing  Chumulari  on  the  west,  and  apparently 


112  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

only  a  few  miles  distant,  are  the  two  vSikkim  peaks 
of  Powhunri  (23,210  feet)  and  Shudu-Tsenpa 
(22,960  feet).  From  Chuggya  the  Tangla  is  reached 
by  a  succession  of  gradual  rises  and  depressions. 
The  pass  is  not  impressive,  like  the  Jelap,  as  a 
passage  won  through  a  great  natural  barrier.  One 
might  cross  it  without  noticing  the  summit,  were 
it  not  for  the  customary  cairns  and  praying-flags 
which  the  Lamas  raise  in  all  high  places. 

From  a  slight  rise  on  the  east  of  the  pass  one 
can  look  down  across  the  plateau  on  Tuna,  an 
irregular  black  line  like  a  caterpillar,  dotted  with 
white  spots,  which  glasses  reveal  to  be  tents.  The 
Bamtso  lake  lies  shimmering  to  the  east  beneath 
brown  a^d  yellow  hills.  At  noon  objects  dance 
elusively  in  the  mirage.  Distances  are  deceptive. 
Yaks  grazing  are  like  black  Bedouin  tents.  Llere, 
then,  is  the  forbidden  land.  The  approach  is  as  it 
should  be.  One's  eyes  explore  the  road  to  Lhasa 
dimly  through  a  haze.  One  would  not  have  it 
laid  out  with  the  precision  of  a  diagram. 


CHAPTER   V 

THE   ROAD   AND   TRANSPORT 

TO  write  of  any  completed  phase  of  the  expedi- 
tion at  this  stage,  when  I  have  carried  my 
readers  only  as  far  as  Tuna,  is  a  lapse  in  continuity 
that  requires  an  apology.  My  excuse  is  that  to  all 
transport  officers,  and  everyone  who  was  in  touch 
with  them,  the  Tuna  and  Phari  plains  will  be 
remembered  as  the  very  backbone  of  resistance, 
the  most  implacable  barriers  to  our  advance. 

The  expedition  was  essentially  a  transport 
'  show.'  It  is  true  that  the  Tibetans  proved  them- 
selves brave  enemies,  but  their  acquired  military 
resources  are  insignificant  when  compared  with  the 
obstacles  Nature  has  planted  in  the  path  of  their 
enemies.  The  difficulty  of  the  passes,  the  severity 
of  the  climate,  the  sterility  of  the  mountains  and 
tablelands,  make  the  interior  of  the  country  almost 
inaccessible  to  an  invading  army.     That  we  went 


114  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

through  these  obstacles  and  reached  Lhasa  itself 
was  a  matter  of  surprise  not  only  to  the  Tibetans,  but 
to  many  members  of  the  expeditionary  force. 

To  appreciate  the  difficulties  the  mission  force 
had  to  contend  with,  one  must  first  realize  the 
extraordinary  changes  of  climate  that  are  experi- 
enced in  the  journey  from  Siliguri  to  Tuna.  Choose 
the  coldest  day  in  the  year  at  Kew  Gardens,  ex- 
pose yourself  freely  to  the  wind,  and  then  spend 
five  minutes  in  the  tropical  house,  and  you  may 
gather  some  idea  of  the  sensation  of  sleeping  in 
the  Rungpo  Valley  the  night  after  crossing  the 
Jelapla. 

When  I  first  made  the  journey  in  early  January, 
even  the  Rungpo  Valley  was  chilly,  and  the  vicissi- 
tudes were  not  so  marked ;  but  I  felt  the  change 
very  keenly  in  March,  when  I  made  a  hurried  rush 
into  Darjeeling  for  equipment  and  supplies.  Our 
camp  at  Lingmathang  was  in  the  pine-forest  at  an 
elevation  of  10,500  feet.  It  was  warm  and  sunny 
in  the  daytime,  in  places  where  there  was  shelter 
from  the  wind.  Leaf -buds  were  beginning  to  open, 
frozen  waterfalls  to  thaw,  migratory  duck  were 
coming  up  the  valley  in  twos  and  threes  from  the 
plains  of  India — even  a  few  vultures  had  arrived  to 


THE  ROAD  AND  TRANSPORT.         115 

fatten  on  the  carcasses  of  the  dead  transport  animals. 
The  morning  after  leaving  Lingm.athang  I  left  the 
pine-forest  at  13,000  feet,  and  entered  a  treeless 
waste  of  shale  and  rock.  When  I  crossed  the  Jelapla 
half  a  hurricane  was  blowing.  The  path  was  a 
sheet  of  ice,  and  I  had  to  use  hands  and  knees,  and 
take  advantage  of  every  protuberance  in  the  rock 
to  prevent  myself  from  being  blown  over  the  khud. 
The  road  was  impassable  for  mules  and  ponies. 
The  cold  was  numbing.  The  next  evening,  in  a 
valley  13,000  feet  beneath,  I  was  suffering  from 
the  extreme  of  heat.  The  change  in  scenery  and 
vegetation  is  equally  striking — from  glaciers  and 
moraines  to  tropical  forests  brilliant  with  the  scarlet 
cotton-flower  and  purple  Baleria.  In  Tibet  I  had 
not  seen  an  insect  of  any  kind  for  two  months,  but 
in  the  Sikkim  valleys  the  most  gorgeous  butterflies 
were  abundant,  and  the  rest-house  at  Rungpo  was 
invested  by  a  plague  of  flies.  In  the  hot  weather 
the  climate  of  the  Sikkim  valleys  is  more  trying 
than  that  of  most  stations  in  the  plains  of  India. 
The  valleys  are  close  and  shut  in,  and  the  heat  is 
intensified  by  the  radiation  from  the  rocks,  cliffs, 
and  boulders.  In  the  rains  the  climate  is  relaxing 
and  malarious.    The  Supply  and  Transport  Corps, 


no  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

who  were  left  behind  at  stages  Uke  Rungpo  through 
the  hot  weather,  had,  to  my  mind,  a  much  harder 
time  on  the  whole  than  the  half-frozen  troops  at 
the  front,  and  they  were  left  out  of  all  the  fun. 

Besides  the  natural  difficulties  of  the  road,  the 
severity  of  climate,  and  the  scarcity  of  fodder  and 
fuel,  the  Transport  Corps  had  to  contend  with  every 
description  of  disease  and  misfortune — anthrax, 
rinderpest,  foot  and  mouth  disease,  aconite  and 
rhododendron  poisoning,  falling  over  precipices, 
exhaustion  from  overwork  and  underfeeding.  The 
worst  fatalities  occurred  on  the  Khamba  Jong  side 
in  1903.  The  experiments  with  the  transport  were 
singularly  unsuccessful.  Out  of  two  hundred  buf- 
faloes employed  at  low  elevations,  only  three  sur- 
vived, and  the  seven  camels  that  were  tried  on  the 
road  between  Siliguri  and  Gantok  all  died  by  way 
of  protest.  Later  on  in  the  year  the  yak  corps 
raised  in  Nepal  was  practically  exterminated.  From 
four  to  five  thousand  were  originally  purchased,  of 
which  more  than  a  thousand  died  from  anthrax 
before  they  reached  the  frontier.  All  the  drinking- 
water  on  the  route  was  infected  ;  the  Nepalese  did 
not  believe  the  disease  was  contagious,  and  took  no 
precautions.    The  disease  spread  almc^t  universally 


THE  ROAD  AND  TRANSPORT.         117 

among  the  cattle,  and  at  the  worst  time  twenty  or 
thirty  died  a  day.  The  beasts  were  massed  on  the 
Nepal  frontier.  Segregation  camps  were  formed, 
and  ultimately,  after  much  patient  care,  the  disease 
was  stamped  out. 

Then  began  the  historic  march  through  Sikkim, 
which,  as  a  protracted  struggle  against  natural 
calamities,  might  be  compared  to  the  retreat  of 
the  Ten  Thousand,  or  the  flight  of  the  Kalmuck 
Tartars.  Superstitious  natives  might  well  think 
that  a  curse  had  fallen  on  us  and  our  cattle.  As 
soon  as  they'  were  immune  from  anthrax,  the  re- 
duced corps  were  attacked  by  rinderpest,  which 
carried  off  seventy.  When  the  herds  left  the  Singli- 
la  range  and  descended  into  the  valley,  the  sudden 
change  in  climate  overwhelmed  hundreds.  No  real 
yak  survived  the  heat  of  the  Sikkim  valleys.  All 
that  were  now  left  were  the  zooms,  or  halfbreeds 
from  the  bull-yaks  and  the  cow,  and  the  cross  from 
the  bull  and  female  yaks.  In  Sikkim,  which  is 
always  a  hotbed  of  contagious  cattle  diseases,  the 
wretched  survivors  were  infected  with  foot  and 
mouth  disease.  The  epidemic  is  not  often  fatal, 
but  visiting  an  exhausted  herd,  fever-stricken,  and 
weakened  by  every  vicissitude  of  climate,  it  carried 


Ii8  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

off  scores.  Then,  to  avoid  spreading  contagion, 
the  yaks  were  driven  through  trackless,  unfre- 
quented country,  up  and  down  precipitous  moun- 
tain-sides, and  through  dense  forests.  Again  segre- 
gation camps  were  formed,  and  the  dead  cattle  were 
burnt,  twenty  and  thirty  at  a  time.  Every  day 
there  was  a  holocaust.  Then  followed  the  ascent 
into  high  altitudes,  where  a  more  insidious  evil 
awaited  the  luckless  corps.  The  few  survivors  were 
exterminated  by  pleuro-pneumonia.  When,  on 
January  23,  the  3rd  Yak  Corps  reached  Chumbi,  it 
numbered  437 ;  two  months  afterwards  all  but  70 
had  died.  On  March  21,  80  exhausted  beasts 
straggled  into  Chumbi ;  they  were  the  remainder 
of  the  1st  and  2nd  Yak  Corps,  which  originally 
numbered  2,300  heads.  The  officers,  who,  bearded 
and  weather-beaten,  deserted  by  many  of  their 
followers,  after  months  of  wandering,  reached  our 
camp  with  the  remnants  of  the  corps,  told  a  story 
of  hardship  and  endurance  that  would  provide  a 
theme  for  an  epic. 

The  epic  of  the  yaks  does  not  comprise  the  whole 
tale  of  disaster.  Rinderpest  carried  off  77  pack- 
bullocks  out  of  500,  and  a  whole  corps  was  segregated 
for   two   months    with    foot    and    mouth    disease. 


THE  ROAD  AND  TRANSPORT.         119 

Amongst  other  casualties  there  were  heavy  losses 
among  the  Cashmere  pony  corps,  and  the  Tibet  pony 
corps  raised  locally.  The  animals  were  hastily 
mobilized  and  incompletely  equipped,  overworked 
and  underfed.  Cheap  and  inferior  saddlery  was 
issued,  which  gave  the  animals  sore  backs  within  a 
week.  The  transport  officer  was  in  a  constant 
dilemma.  He  had  to  overwork  his  animals  or  delay 
the  provisions,  fodder,  atnd  warm  clothing  so  urgently 
needed  at  the  front.  Ponies  and  mules  had  no 
rest,  but  worked  till  they  dropped.  Of  the  original 
draft  of  mules  that  were  employed  on  the  line  to 
Khamba  Jong,  fully  50  per  cent.  died.  It  is  no 
good  trying  to  blink  the  fact  that  the  expedition 
was  unpopular,  and  that  at  the  start  many  econom- 
ical shifts  were  attempted  which  proved  much  more 
expensive  in  the  end.  Our  party  system  is  to 
blame.  The  Opposition  must  be  appeased,  ex- 
penses kept  down,  and  the  business  is  entered  into 
half-heartedly.  In  the  usual  case  a  few  companies 
are  grudgingly  sent  to  the  front,  and  then,  when 
something  like  a  disaster  falls  or  threatens,  John 
Bull  jumps  at  the  sting,  scenting  a  national  insult. 
A  brigade  follows,  and  Government  wakes  to  the 
necessity  of  grappling  with  the  situation  seriously. 


120  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

But  to  return  to  the  spot  where  the  evil  effects 
of  the  system  were  felt,  and  not  merely  girded  at. 
To  replace  and  supplement  the  local  drafts  of 
animals  that  were  dying,  trained  Government  mule 
corps  were  sent  up  from  the  plains,  properly  equipped 
and  under  experienced  officers.  These  did  excellent 
work,  and  2,600  mules  arrived  in  Lhasa  on  August  3 
in  as  good  condition  as  one  could  wish.  Of  all 
transport  animals,  the  mule  is  the  hardiest  and 
most  enduring.  He  does  not  complain  when  he  is 
overloaded,  but  will  go  on  all  day,  and  when  he 
drops  there  is  no  doubt  that  he  has  had  enough. 
Nine  times  out  of  ten  when  he  gives  up  he  dies. 
No  beast  is  more  indifferent  to  extremes  of  heat  and 
cold.  On  the  road  from  Kamparab  to  Phari  one  day, 
three  mules  fell  over  a  cliff  into  a  snowdrift,  and 
were  almost  totally  submerged.  Their  drivers  could 
not  pull  them  out,  and,  to  solve  the  dilemma,  went 
on  and  reported  them  dead.  The  next  day  an 
ofl&cer  found  them  and  extricated  them  alive. 
They  had  been  exposed  to  46°  of  frost.  They  still 
survive. 

Nothing  can  beat  the  Sircar  mule  when  he  is  in 
good  condition,  unless  it  is  the  Balti  and  Ladaki 
coolie.     Several    hundred    of    these    hardy    moun- 


THE  ROAD  AND  TRANSPORT.         121 

taineers  were  imported  from  the  North-West 
frontier  to  work  on  the  most  dangerous  and  diffi- 
cult sections  of  the  road.  They  can  bear  cold  and 
fatigue  and  exposure  better  than  any  transport 
animal  on  the  line,  and  they  are  surer-footed. 
Mules  were  first  employed  over  the  Jelap,  but  were 
afterwards  abandoned  for  coolies.  The  Baltis  are 
excellent  workers  at  high  altitudes,  and  sing  cheerily 
as  they  toil  up  the  mountains  with  their  loads.  I 
have  seen  them  throw  down  their  packs  when  they 
reached  the  summit  of  a  pass,  make  a  rush  for  the 
shelter  of  a  rock,  and  cheer  lustily  like  school-boys. 
But  the  coolies  were  not  all  equally  satisfactory. 
Those  indented  from  the  Nepal  durbar  were  prac- 
tically an  impressed  gang.  Twelve  rupees  a  month 
with  rations  and  warm  clothing  did  not  seem  to 
reconcile  them  to  hard  work,  and  after  a  month  or 
two  they  became  discontented  and  refractory. 
Their  officers,  however,  were  men  of  tact  and  de- 
cision, and  they  were  able  to  prevent  what  might 
have  been  a  serious  mutiny.  The  discontented  ones 
were  gradually  replaced  by  Baltis,  Ladakis,  and 
Garwhalis,  and  the  coolies  became  the  most  reliable 
transport  corps  on  the  line. 
Thus,  the  whole  menagerie,  to  use  the  expression 


122  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

current  at  the  time,  was  got  into  working  order, 
and  a  sj'stem  was  gradually  developed  by  which 
the  right  animal,  man,  or  conveyance  was  working 
in  the  right  place,  and  supplies  were  sent  through 
at  a  pace  that  was  very  creditable  considering  the 
coimtry  traversed. 

From  the  railway  base  at  Siliguri  to  Gantok,  a 
distance  of  sixty  miles,  the  ascent  in  the  road  is 
scarcely  perceptible.  With  the  exception  of  a  few 
contractors'  ponies,  the  entire  carrying  along  this 
section  of  the  hne  was  worked  by  bullock-carts. 
Government  carts  are  built  to  carry  ii  maunds 
(880  pounds),  but  contractors  often  load  theirs  with 
15  or  16  maunds.  As  the  carrying  power  of  mules, 
ponies,  and  pack-bullocks  is  only  2  maunds,  it  will 
be  seen  at  once  that  transport  in  a  mountainous 
coimtry,  where  there  can  be  no  road  for  vehicles, 
is  nearly  five  times  as  difficult  and  complicated  as 
in  the  plains.  And  this  is  without  making  any 
allowance  for  the  inevitable  mortality  among  trans- 
port animals  at  high  elevations,  or  taking  into  account 
the  inevitable  congestion  on  mountain-paths,  often 
blocked  by  snow,  carried  away  by  the  rains,  and 
always  too  narrow  to  admit  of  any  large  volume 
of  traffic. 


THE  ROAD  AND  TRANSPORT.         123 

In  the  beginning  of  March,  when  the  line  was  in 
its  best  working  order,  from  1,500  to  2,000  maunds 
were  poured  into  Rungpo  daily.  Of  these,  only 
400  or  500  maunds  reached  Phari ;  the  rest  was 
stored  at  Gantok  or  consumed  on  the  road.  Later, 
v>hen  the  line  was  extended  to  Gyantse,  not  more 
than  100  maunds  a  day  reached  the  front. 

In  the  first  advance  on  Gyantse,  our  column  was 
practically  launched  into  the  unknown.  As  far  as 
we  knew,  no  local  food  or  forage  could  be  obtained. 
It  was  too  early  in  the  season  for  the  spring  pasturage. 
We  could  not  live  on  the  country.  The  ever- 
lengthening  line  of  communication  behind  us  was 
an  artery,  the  severing  of  which  would  be  fatal  to 
our  advance. 

One  can  best  realize  the  difficulties  grappled  with 
by  imagining  the  extreme  case  of  an  army  entering 
an  entirely  desert  country.  A  mule,  it  must  be 
remembered,  can  only  carry  its  own  food  for  ten 
days.  That  is  to  say,  in  a  country  where  there  is 
no  grain  or  fodder,  a  convoy  can  make  at  the  most 
nine  marches.  On  the  ninth  day  beasts  and  drivers 
will  have  consumed  all  the  supplies  takan  with  them. 
Supposing  on  the  tenth  day  no  supply-base  has 
been   reached,    the   convoy   is   stranded,   and   can 


124  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

neither  advance  nor  retire.  Nor  must  we  forget 
that  our  imaginary  convoy,  which  has  perished  in 
the  desert,  has  contributed  nothing  to  the  advance 
of  the  army.  Food  and  clothing  for  the  troops,  tents, 
bedding,  guns,  ammunition,  field-hospital,  treasury, 
still  await  transport  at  the  base. 

Fortunately,  the  country  between  our  frontier 
and  Lhasa  is  not  all  desert.  Yet  it  is  barren  enough 
to  make  it  a  matter  of  wonder  that,  with  such  short 
preparation,  we  were  able  to  push  through  troops 
to  Gyantse  in  April,  when  there  was  no  grazing  on 
the  road,  and  to  arrive  in  Lhasa  in  August  with  a 
force  of  more  than  4,000  fighting  men  and  followers. 

Before  the  second  advance  to  Gyantse  the  spring 
crops  had  begun  to  appear.  Without  them  we 
could  not  have  advanced.  All  other  local  produce 
on  the  road  was  exhausted.  That  is  to  say,  for 
160  miles,  with  the  important  exception  of  wayside 
fodder,  we  subsisted  entirely  on  our  own  supplies. 
The  nuiles  carried  their  own  grain,  and  no  more. 
Gyantse  once  reached,  the  Tibetan  Government 
granaries  and  stores  from  the  monasteries  produced 
enough  to  carry  us  on.  But  besides  the  transport 
mules,  there  were  100  Maxim  and  battery  mules,  as 
well  as  some  200  mounted  infantry  ponies,  and  at 


THE  ROAD  AND  TRANSPORT.         125 

least  100  officers'  mounts,  to  be  fed,  and  these  carried 
nothing — contributed  nothing  to  the  stomach  of 
the  army. 

How  were  these  beasts  to  be  fed,  and  how  was 
the  whole  apparatus  of  an  army  to  be  carried  along, 
when  every  additional  transport  animal  was  a  tax 
on  the  resources  of  the  transport  ?  There  were 
two  possible  solutions,  each  at  first  sight  equally 
absurd  and  impracticable : — wheeled  transport  in 
Tibet,  or  animals  that  did  not  require  feeding. 
The  Supply  and  Transport  men  were  resourceful  and 
fortunate  enough  to  provide  both.  It  was  due  to 
the  light  ekka  and  that  providentially  ascetic  beast, 
the  yak,  that  we  were  able  to  reach  Lhasa. 

The  ekkas  were  constructed  in  the  plains,  and 
carried  by  coolies  from  the  cart-road  at  Rungpo 
eighty  miles  over  the  snow  passes  to  Kamparab  on 
the  Phari  Plain.  The  carrying  capacity  of  these 
light  carts  is  400  pounds,  two  and  a  half  times  that 
of  a  mule,  and  there  is  only  one  mouth  to  feed.  They 
were  the  first  vehicles  ever  seen  in  Tibet,  and  they 
saved  the  situation. 

The  ekkas  worked  over  the  Phari  and  Tuna  plains, 
and  down  the  Nyang  Chu  Valley  as  far  as  Kangma. 
They  were  supplemented  by  the  yaks. 


125  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

The  yak  is  the  most  extraordinary  animal  Nature 
has  provided  the  transport  ofiicer  in  his  need.  He 
carries  i6o  pounds,  and  consumes  nothing.  He  sub- 
sists solely  on  stray  blades  of  grass,  tamarisk,  and 
tufts  of  hchen,  that  he  picks  up  on  the  road.  He 
moves  slowly,  and  wears  a  look  of  ineffable  resig- 
nation. He  is  the  most  melancholy  disillusioned 
beast  I  have  seen,  and  dies  on  the  slightest 
provocation.  The  red  and  white  tassels  and 
favours  of  cowrie-shells  the  Tibetans  hang  about 
his  neck  are  as  incongruous  on  the  poor  beast 
as  gauds  and  frippery  on  the  heroine  of  a 
tragedy. 

If  only  he  were  dependable,  our  transport  diffi- 
culties would  be  reduced  to  a  minimum.  But  he 
is  not.  We  have  seen  how  the  four  thousand  died 
in  their  passage  across  Sikkim  without  doing  a 
day's  work.  Local  diafts  did  better.  Yet  I  have 
often  passed  the  Lieutenant  in  command  of  the 
corps  lamenting  their  lack  of  grit.  *  Two  more  of 
my  cows  died  this  morning.  Look,  there  goes  an- 
other I  D — n  the  beasts !  I  beheve  they  do  it 
out  of  spite ! '  And  the  chief  Supply  and  Trans- 
port officer,  always  a  humorist  in  adversity,  when 
asked  why  they  were  dying  off  every  day,  said : 


THE  ROAD  AND  TRANSPORT.         127 

*I  think  it  must  be  due  to  overfeeding.*  But  we 
owe  much  to  the  yak. 

The  final  advance  from  Gyantse  to  Lhasa  was 
a  comparatively  easy  matter.  Crops  were  plenti- 
ful, and  large  supplies  of  grain  were  obtained  from 
the  monasteries  and  jongs  on  the  road.  We  found, 
contrary  to  anticipation,  that  the  produce  in  this  part 
of  Tibet  was  much  greater  than  the  consumption. 
In  many  places  we  found  stores  that  would  last  a 
village  three  or  four  years.  Our  transport  animals 
lived  on  the  country.  We  arrived  at  Lhasa  with 
2,600  mules  and  400  coolies.  The  yak  and  donkey 
corps  were  left  at  the  river  for  convoy  work.  It 
would  have  been  impossible  to  have  pushed  through 
in  the  winter. 

All  the  produce  we  consumed  on  the  road  was 
paid  for.  In  this  way  the  expense  of  the  army's 
keep  fell  on  the  Lhasa  Government,  who  had  to 
pay  the  indemnity,  and  our  presence  in  the  country 
was  not  directly,  at  any  rate,  a  burden  on  the  agri- 
cultural population  of  the  villages  through  which 
we  passed. 

Looking  back  on  the  splendid  work  accomplished 
by  the  transport,  it  is  difficult  to  select  any  special 
phase  more  memorable  than  another.     The  com- 


128  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

plete  success  of  the  organization  and  the  endurance 
and  grit  displayed  by  officers  and  men  are  equally 
admirable.  I  could  cite  the  coolness  of  a  single 
officer  in  a  mob  of  armed  and  mutinous  coolies, 
when  the  compelling  will  of  one  man  and  a  few 
blows  straight  from  the  shoulder  kept  the  discon- 
tented harnessed  to  their  work  and  quelled  a  revolt  ; 
or  the  case  of  another  who  drove  his  diseased  yaks 
over  the  snow  passes  into  Chumbi,  and  after  two 
days'  rest  started  with  a  fresh  corps  on  ten  months 
of  the  most  tedious  labour  the  mind  of  man  can 
imagine,  rising  every  da}^  before  daybreak  in  an 
almost  Arctic  cold,  traversing  the  same  featureless 
tablelands,  and  camping  out  at  night  cheerfully  in 
the  open  plain  with  his  escort  of  thirty  rifles.  There 
was  always  the  chance  of  a  night  attack,  but  no 
other  excitement  to  break  the  eternal  monotony. 
But  it  was  all  in  the  day's  work,  and  the  subaltern 
took  it  like  a  picnic.  Another  supreme  test  of  en- 
durance in  man  and  beast  were  the  convoys  between 
Chumbi  and  Tuna  in  the  early  part  of  the  year, 
which  for  hardships  endured  remind  me  of  Skobe- 
leff's  dash  through  the  Balkans  on  Adrianople. 
Only  our  labours  were  protracted,  Skobeleff' s  the 
struggle  of  a  few  days.     Even  in  mid-March  a  con- 


THE  ROAD  AND  TRANSPORT.         129 

voy  of  the  12th  Mule  Corps,  escorted  by  two  com- 
panies of  the  23rd  Pioneers,  were  overtaken  by  a 
bhzzard  on  their  march  between  Phari  and  Tuna, 
and  camped  in  two  feet  of  snow  with  the  thermom- 
eter 18°  below  zero.  A  driving  hurricane  made  it 
impossible  to  light  a  fire  or  cook  food.  The  officers 
were  reduced  to  frozen  bully  beef  and  neat  spirits, 
while  the  sepoys  went  without  food  for  thirty-six 
hours.  The  fodder  for  the  mules  was  buried  deep  in 
snow.  The  frozen  flakes  blowing  through  the  tents 
cut  hke  a  knife.  While  the  detachment  was  cross- 
ing a  stream,  the  mules  fell  through  the  ice,  and 
were  only  extricated  with  great  difficulty.  The 
drivers  arrived  at  Tuna  frozen  to  the  waist.  Twenty 
men  of  the  12th  Mule  Corps  were  frost-bitten,  and 
thirty  men  of  the  23rd  Pioneers  were  so  incapacitated 
that  they  had  to  be  carried  in  on  mules.  On  the 
same  day  there  were  seventy  cases  of  snow-blindness 
among  the  8th  Gurkhas. 

Until  late  in  April  all  the  plain  was  intersected  by 
frozen  streams.  Blankets  were  stripped  from  the 
mules  to  make  a  pathway  for  them  over  the  ice.  Often 
they  went  without  water  at  night,  and  at  mid-day, 
when  the  surface  of  the  ice  was  melted,  their  thirst 
was  so  great  that  many  died  from  over-drinking. 
5 


130  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

Had  the  Tibetans  attacked  us  in  January,  they 
would  have  taken  us  at  a  great  disadvantage.  The 
bolts  of  our  rifles  jammed  with  frozen  oil.  Oil 
froze  in  the  Maxims,  and  threw  them  out  of  gear. 
More  often  than  not  the  mounted  infantry  found 
the  butts  of  their  rifles  frozen  in  the  buckets,  and 
had  to  dismount  and  use  both  hands  to  extricate 
them. 

I  think  these  men  who  took  the  convoys  through 
to  Tuna  ;  the  23rd,  who  wintered  there  and  supphed 
most  of  the  escort ;  and  the  8th  Gurkhas,  who  cut 
a  road  in  the  frost-bound  plain,  may  be  said  to 
have  broken  the  back  of  the  resistance  to  our  ad- 
vance. They  were  the  pioneers,  and  the  troops 
who  followed  in  spring  and  summer  httle  reahzed 
what  they  owed  to  them. 

The  great  difi&culties  we  experienced  in  pushing 
through  supplies  to  Tuna,  which  is  less  than  150 
miles  from  our  base  railway-station  at  SiUguri, 
show  the  absurdity  of  the  idea  of  a  Russian  advance 
on  Lhasa.  The  nearest  Russian  outpost  is  over 
1,000  miles  distant,  and  the  country  to  be  traversed 
is  even  more  barren  and  inhospitable  than  on  our 
frontier. 

Up  to  the  present  the  route  to  Chumbi  has  been 


THE  ROAD  AND  TRANSPORT.         131 

via  Siliguri  and  the  Jelap  and  Nathu  Passes,  but 
the  natural  outlet  of  the  valley  is  by  the  Ammo 
Chu,  which  flows  through  Bhutan  into  the  Dooars, 
where  it  becomes  the  Torsa.  The  Bengal-Dooars 
Railway  now  extends  to  Madhari  Hat,  fifteen  miles 
from  the  point  where  the  Torsa  crosses  the  fron- 
tier, whence  it  is  only  forty-eight  miles  as  the  crow 
flies  to  Rinchengong  in  the  Chumbi  Valley.  When 
the  projected  Ammo  Chu  cart-road  is  completed, 
all  the  difiiculty  of  carrying  stores  into  Chumbi  will 
be  obviated.  Engineers  are  already  engaged  on 
the  first  trace,  and  the  road  will  be  in  working 
order  within  a  few  months.  It  avoids  all  snow 
passes,  and  nowhere  reaches  an  elevation  of  more 
than  9,000  feet.  The  direct  route  will  shorten  the 
journey  to  Chumbi  by  several  days,  bring  Lhasa 
within  a  month's  journey  of  Calcutta,  and  consid- 
erably improve  trade  faciUties  between  Tibet  and 
India. 


T 


CHAPTER  VI 

THE  ACTION   AT  THE  HOT  SPRINGS 

HE  village  of  Tuna,  which  lies  at  the  foot  of  bare 
-■-  yellow  hills,  consists  of  a  few  deserted  houses. 
The  place  is  used  mainly  as  a  halting-stage  by  the 
Tibetans.  The  country  around  is  sterile  and  unpro- 
ductive, and  wood  is  a  luxury  that  must  be  carried 
from  a  distance  of  nearly  fifty  miles. 

It  was  in  these  dismal  surroundings  that  Colonel 
Younghusband's  mission  spent  the  months  of  Jan- 
uary, February,  and  March.  The  small  garrison 
suffered  all  the  discomforts  of  Phari.  The  dirt  and 
grime  of  the  squalid  little  houses  became  so  depress- 
ing that  they  pitched  their  tents  in  an  open  court- 
yard, preferring  the  numbing  cold  to  the  filth  of 
the  Tibetan  hovels.  Many  of  the  sepoys  fell  vic- 
tims to  frost-bite  and  pneumonia,  and  nearly  every 
case  of  pneumonia  proved  fatal,  the  patient  dying 
of  suffocation  owing  to  the  rarefied  air. 


THE  ACTION  AT  HOT  SPRINGS.       133 

Colonel  Younghusband  had  not  been  at  Tuna 
many  days  before  it  became  clear  that  there  could 
be  no  hope  of  a  peaceful  solution.  The  Tibetans 
began  to  gather  in  large  numbers  at  Guru,  eight 
miles  to  the  east,  on  the  road  to  Lhasa.  The 
Depon,  or  Lhasa  General,  whom  Colonel  Young- 
husband  met  on  two  occasions,  repeated  that  he 
was  only  empowered  to  treat  on  condition  that 
we  withdrew  to  Yatung.  Messages  were  sent  from 
the  Tibetan  camp  to  Tuna  almost  daily  asking  us 
to  retire,  and  negotiations  again  came  to  a  dead- 
lock. After  a  month  the  tone  of  the  Tibetans  be- 
came minatory.  They  threatened  to  invest  our 
camp,  and  an  attack  was  expected  on  March  i, 
the  Tibetan  New  Year.  The  Lamas,  however, 
thought  better  of  it.  They  held  a  Commination 
Service  instead,  and  cursed  us  solemnly  for  five 
days,  hoping,  no  doubt,  that  the  British  force  would 
dwindle  away  by  the  act  of  God.  Nobody  was 
*  one  penny  the  worse.' 

Though  we  made  no  progress  with  the  Tibetans 
during  this  time,  Colonel  Younghusband  utilized 
the  halt  at  Tuna  in  cementing  a  friendship  with 
Bhutan.  The  neutrality  of  the  Bhutanese  in  the 
case  of  a  war  with  Tibet  was  a  matter  of  the 


134  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

utmost  importance.  Were  these  people  unfriendly 
or  disposed  to  throw  in  their  lot  with  their  co- 
religionists, the  Tibetans,  our  line  of  communica- 
tions would  be  exposed  to  a  flank  attack  along  the 
whole  of  the  Tuna  Plain,  which  is  conterminous 
with  the  Bhutan  frontier,  as  well  as  a  rear  attack 
anywhere  in  the  Chumbi  Valley  as  far  south  as 
Rinchengong.  The  Bhutanese  are  men  of  splendid 
physique,  brave,  warlike,  and  given  to  pillage. 
Their  hostiUty  would  have  involved  the  despatch 
of  a  second  force,  as  large  as  that  sent  to  Tibet, 
and  might  have  landed  us,  if  unprepared,  in  a  seri- 
ous reverse.  The  complete  success  of  Colonel  Young- 
husband's  diplomacy  was  a  great  reUef  to  the  Indian 
Government,  who  were  waiting  with  some  anxiety 
to  see  what  attitude  the  Bhutanese  would  adopt. 
Having  secured  from  them  assiuances  of  their  good 
will,  Colonel  Younghusband  put  their  friendship  to 
immediate  test  by  broaching  the  subject  of  the 
Ammo  Chu  route  to  Chumbi  through  Bhutanese 
territory.  Very  little  time  was  lost  before  the  con- 
cession was  obtained  from  the  Tongsa  Penlop,  ruler 
of  Bhutan,  who  himself  accompanied  the  mission 
as  far  as  Lhasa  in  the  character  of  mediator  between 
the  Dalai  Lama  and  the  British  Government.     The 


THE  ACTION  AT  HOT  SPRINGS.       135 

importance  of  the  Ammo  Chu  route  in  our  future 
relations  with  Tibet  I  have  emphasized  elsewhere. 

I  doubt  if  ever  an  advance  was  more  welcome 
to  waiting  troops  than  that  which  led  to  the  engage- 
ment at  the  Hot  Springs. 

For  months,  let  it  be  remembered,  we  had  been 
marking  time.  When  a  move  had  to  be  made  to 
escort  a  convoy,  it  was  along  narrow  mountain- 
paths,  where  the  troops  had  to  march  in  single  file. 
There  was  no  possibility  of  an  attack  this  side  of 
Phari.  The  ground  covered  was  familiar  and  monot- 
onous. One  felt  cooped  in,  and  was  thoroughly 
bored  and  tired  of  the  delay,  so  that  when  General 
Macdonald  marched  out  of  Phari  with  his  Uttle 
army  in  three  columns,  a  feehng  of  exhilaration 
communicated  itself  to  the  troops. 

Here  was  elbow-room  at  last,  and  an  open  plain, 
where  all  the  army  corps  of  Europe  might  manoeuvre. 
At  Tuna,  on  the  evening  of  the  29th,  it  was  given 
out  in  orders  that  a  reconnaissance  in  force  was  to 
be  made  the  next  morning,  and  two  companies  of  the 
32nd  Pioneers  would  be  left  at  Guru.  The  Tibetan 
camp  at  the  Hot  Springs  lay  right  across  our  hue 
of  march,  and  the  hill  that  flanked  it  was  lined  with 
their  sangars.     They  must  either  fight  or  retire. 


136         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

Most  of  us  thought  that  the  Tibetans  would  fade 
away  in  the  mysterious  manner  they  have,  and 
build  another  futile  wall  further  on.  The  extraor- 
dinary affair  that  followed  must  be  a  unique  event 
in  mihtary  history. 

The  morning  of  the  30th  was  bitterly  cold.  An 
icy  wind  was  blowing,  and  snow  was  lying  on  the 
ground.  I  put  on  my  thick  sheepskin  for  the  first 
time  for  two  months,  and  I  owe  my  life  to  it. 

About  an  hour  after  leaving  Tuna,  two  or  three 
Tibetan  messengers  rode  out  from  their  camp  to 
interview  Colonel  Younghusband.  They  got  down 
from  their  ponies  and  began  chattering  in  a  very 
excited  manner,  like  a  flock  of  frightened  parrots. 
It  was  evident  to  us,  not  understanding  the  lan- 
guage, that  they  were  entreating  us  to  go  back,  and 
the  constant  reference  to  Yatung  told  us  that  they 
were  repeating  the  message  that  had  been  sent 
into  the  Tuna  camp  almost  daily  during  the  past 
few  months — that  if  we  retired  to  Yatung  the  Dalai 
Lama  would  send  an  accredited  envoy  to  treat 
with  us.  Being  met  with  the  usual  answer,  they 
mounted  dejectedly,  and  rode  off  at  a  gallop  to 
their  camp. 

Soon  after  they  had  disappeared  another  group 


THE  ACTION  AT  HOT  SPRINGS.       137 

of  horsemen  were  seen  riding  towards  us.  These 
proved  to  be  the  Lhasa  Depon,  accompanied  by 
an  influential  Lama  and  a  small  escort  armed  with 
modern  rifles.  The  rifles  were  naturally  inspected 
with  great  interest.  They  were  of  different  pat- 
terns— Martini-Henry,  Lee-Metford,  Snider — but  the 
clumsily-painted  stocks  alone  were  enough  to  show 
that  they  were  shoddy  weapons  of  native  manufac- 
ture.    They  left  no  mark  on  our  troops. 

According  to  Tibetan  custom,  a  rug  was  spread 
on  the  ground  for  the  interview  between  Colonel 
Younghusband  and  the  Lhasa  Depon,  who  con- 
ferred sitting  down.  Captain  O'Connor,  the  secre- 
tary of  the  mission,  interpreted.  The  Lhasa  Depon 
repeated  the  entreaty  of  the  messengers,  and  said 
that  there  would  be  trouble  if  we  proceeded.  Colonel 
Younghusband's  reply  was  terse  and  to  the  point. 

*  Tell  him,'  he  said  to  Captain  O'Connor,  '  that 
we  have  been  negotiating  with  Tibet  for  fifteen 
years ;  that  I  myself  have  been  waiting  for  eight 
months  to  meet  responsible  representatives  from 
Lhasa,  and  that  the  mission  is  now  going  on  to 
Gyantse.  Tell  him  that  we  have  no  wish  to  fight, 
and  that  he  would  be  well  advised  if  he  ordered 
his  soldiers  to  retire.     Should  they  remain  block- 


138  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

ing  our  path,  I  will  ask  General  Macdonald  to  re- 
move them.' 

The  Lhasa  Depon  was  greatly  perturbed.  He 
said  that  he  had  no  wish  to  fight,  and  would  try 
and  stop  his  men  firing  upon  us.  But  before  he  left 
he  again  tried  to  induce  Colonel  Younghusband  to 
turn  back.  Then  he  rode  away  to  join  his  men. 
What  orders  he  gave  them  will  never  be  known. 

I  do  not  think  the  Tibetans  ever  believed  in  our 
serious  intention  to  advance.  No  doubt  they  at- 
tributed our  evacuation  of  Kharaba  Jong  and  our 
long  delay  in  Chumbi  to  weakness  and  vacillation. 
And  our  forbearance  since  the  negotiations  of  1890 
must  have  lent  itself  to  the  same  interpretation. 

As  we  advanced  we  could  see  the  Tibetans  run- 
ning up  the  hill  to  the  left  to  occupy  the  sangars. 
To  turn  their  position.  General  Macdonald  deployed 
the  8th  Gurkhas  to  the  crest  of  the  ridge  ;  at  the 
same  time  the  Pioneers,  the  Maxim  detachment  of 
the  Norfolks,  and  Mountain  Battery  were  deployed 
on  the  right  until  the  Tibetan  position  was  sur- 
rounded. 

The  manoeuvre  was  completely  successful.  The 
Tibetans  on  the  hill,  finding  themselves  outflanked 
by  the  Gurkhas,  ran  down  to  the  cover  of  the  wall 


THE  ACTION  AT  HOT  SPRINGS.       139 

by  the  main  camp,  and  the  whole  mob  was  encircled 
by  our  troops. 

It  was  on  this  occasion  that  the  Sikhs  and  Gurkhas 
displayed  that  coolness  and  discipline  which  won 
them  a  European  reputation.  They  had  orders  not 
to  hre  unless  they  were  fired  upon,  and  they  walked 
right  up  to  the  walls  of  the  sangars  until  the  muzzles 
and  prongs  of  the  Tibetan  matchlocks  were  almost 
touching  their  chests.  The  Tibetans  stared  at  our 
men  for  a  moment  across  the  wall,  and  then  turned 
and  shambled  down  sulkily  to  join  their  comrades 
in  the  redan. 

No  one  dreamed  of  the  sanguinary  action  that  was 
impending.  I  dismounted,  and  hastily  scribbled  a 
despatch  on  my  saddle  to  the  effect  that  the  Tibetan 
position  had  been  taken  without  a  shot  being  fired. 
The  mounted  orderly  who  carried  the  despatch  bore 
a  similar  message  from  the  mission  to  the  Foreign 
Office.  Then  the  disarming  began.  The  Tibetans 
were  told  that  if  they  gave  up  their  arms  they  would 
be  allowed  to  go  off  unmolested.  But  they  did  not 
wish  to  give  up  their  arms.  It  was  a  ridiculous 
position,  Sikh  and  Mongol  swaying  backwards  and 
forwards  as  they  wrestled  for  the  possession  of  swords 
and  matchlocks.     Perhaps  the  humour  of  it  made 


140  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

one  careless  of  the  underlying  danger.  Accounts 
differ  as  to  how  this  wrestUng  match  developed  into 
war,  how,  to  the  delight  of  the  troops,  the  toy  show 
became  the  *  real  thing.*  Of  one  thing  I  am  cer- 
tain, that  a  rush  was  made  in  the  south-east  comer 
before  a  shot  was  fired.  If  there  had  been  any 
firing,  I  would  not  have  been  wandering  about  by 
the  Tibetan  fiank  without  a  revolver  in  my  hand. 
As  it  was,  my  revolver  was  buried  in  the  breast 
pocket  of  my  Norfolk  jacket  under  my  posh  teen. 

I  have  no  excuse  for  this  folly  except  a  misplaced 
contempt  for  Tibetan  arms  and  courage  —  a  con- 
tempt which  accounted  for  our  only  serious  casualty 
in  the  affair  of  1888.*  Also  I  think  there  was  in 
the  margin  of  my  consciousness  a  feeling  that  one 
individual  by  an  act  of  rashness  might  make  him- 
self responsible  for  the  lives  of  hundreds.  Hemmed 
in  as  the  Tibetans  were,  no  one  gave  them  credit 
for  the  spirit  they  showed,  or  imagined  that  they 
would  have  the  folly  to  resist.  But  we  had  to  deal 
with  the  most  ignorant  and  benighted  people  on 
earth,  most  of  whom  must  have  thought  our  maga- 

♦  When  G)lonel  Bromhead  ptirsued  a  Tibetan  unarmed.  Called 
upon  to  surrender,  the  Tibetan  turned  on  Colonel  Bromhead, 
cut  ofi  his  right  arm,  and  badly  mutilated  the  left. 


THE  ACTION  AT  HOT  SPRINGS.       141 

zine  rifles  and  Maxims  as  harmless  as  their  own 
obsolete  matchlocks,  and  believed  that  they  bore 
charms  by  which  they  were  immune  from  death. 

The  attack  on  the  south-east  corner  was  so  sudden 
that  the  first  man  was  on  me  before  I  had  time  to 
draw  my  revolver.*  He  came  at  me  with  his  sword 
hfted  in  both  hands  over  his  head.  He  had  a  clear 
run  of  ten  yards,  and  if  I  had  not  ducked  and  caught 
him  by  the  knees  he  must  have  smashed  my  skull 
open.  I  threw  him,  and  he  dragged  me  to  the 
ground.  Trying  to  rise,  I  was  struck  on  the  temple 
by  a  second  swordsman,  and  the  blade  glanced  off 
my  skull.  I  received  the  rest  of  my  wounds,  save 
one  or  two,  on  my  hands — as  I  lay  on  my  face  I 
used  them  to  protect  my  head.  After  a  time  the 
blows  ceased  ■  my  assailants  were  all  shot  down  or 
had  fled.  I  lay  absolutely  still  for  a  while  until  I 
thought  it  safe  to  raise  my  head.    Then  I  looked 

*  The  reports  sent  home  at  the  time  of  the  Hot  Springs  affair 
were  inaccurate  as  to  the  manner  in  which  I  was  wounded,  and 
also  Major  Wallace  Dimlop,  who  was  the  only  European  any- 
where near  me  at  the  time.  Major  Dunlop  shot  his  own  man,  but 
at  such  close  quarters  that  the  Tibetan's  sword  slipped  down 
the  barrel  of  his  rifle  and  cut  ofE  two  fingers  of  his  left  hand. 
General  Macdonald  and  Captain  Bignell,  who  shot  several  men 
with  their  revolvers,  were  standing  at  the  comer  where  the  wall 
joined  the  ruined  house,  and  did  not  see  the  attack  on  myself 
and  Dunlop. 


142  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

round,  and,  seeing  no  Tibetans  near  in  an  erect 
position,  I  got  up  and  walked  out  of  the  ring  be- 
tween the  rifles  of  the  Sikhs.  The  firing  line  had 
been  formed  in  the  meantime  on  a  mound  about 
thirty  yards  behind  me,  and  I  had  been  exposed 
to  the  bullets  of  our  own  men  from  two  sides,  as 
well  as  the  promiscuous  fire  of  the  Tibetans. 

The  Tibetans  could  not  have  chosen  a  spot  more 
fatal  for  their  stand — a  bluff  hill  to  the  north,  a 
marsh  and  stream  on  the  east,  and  to  the  west  a 
stone  wall  built  across  the  path,  which  they  had 
to  scale  in  their  attempted  assault  on  General  Mac- 
donald  and  his  escort.  Only  one  man  got  over. 
Inside  there  was  barely  an  acre  of  ground,  packed 
so  thickly  with  seething  humanity  that  the  cross- 
fire which  the  Pioneers  poured  in  offered  little 
danger  to  their  own  men. 

The  Lhasa  General  must  have  fired  off  his  revolver 
after  I  was  struck  down.  I  cannot  credit  the 
rumour  that  his  action  was  a  signal  for  a  general 
attack,  and  that  the  Tibetans  allowed  themselves 
to  be  herded  together  as  a  ruse  to  get  us  at  close 
quarters.  To  begin  with,  the  demand  that  they 
should  give  up  their  arms,  and  the  assurance  that 
they  might  go  off  unmolested,   must  have  been 


THE  ACTION  AT  HOT  SPRINGS.       143 

quite  unexpected  by  them,  and  I  doubt  if  they 
realized  the  advantage  of  an  attack  at  close  quarters. 

My  own  impression  is  that  the  shot  was  the  act 
of  a  desperate  man,  ignorant  and  regardless  of 
what  might  ensue.  To  return  to  Lhasa  with  his 
army  disarmed  and  disbanded,  and  without  a  shot 
having  been  fired,  must  have  meant  ruin  to  him, 
and  probably  death.  When  we  reached  Gyantse 
we  heard  that  his  property  had  been  confiscated 
from  his  family  on  account  of  his  failure  to  prevent 
our  advance. 

The  Depon  was  a  man  of  fine  presence  and  bear- 
ing. I  only  saw  him  once,  in  his  last  interview 
with  Colonel  Younghusband,  but  I  cannot  dissoci- 
ate from  him  a  personal  courage  and  a  pride  that 
must  have  rankled  at  the  indignity  of  his  position. 
Probably  he  knew  that  his  shot  was  suicidal. 

The  action  has  been  described  as  one  of  extreme 
folly.  But  what  was  left  him  if  he  lived  except 
shame  and  humiliation  ?  And  what  Englishman 
with  the  same  prospect  to  face,  caught  in  this  dark 
eddy  of  circumstance,  would  not  have  done  the 
same  thing  ?  He  could  only  fire,  and  let  his  men 
take  their  chance,  God  help  them  ! 

And  the  rabble  ?     They  have  been  called  treach- 


144  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

erous.  Why,  I  don't  know.  They  were  mostly 
impressed  peasants.  They  did  not  wish  to  give 
up  their  arms.  Why  should  they  ?  They  knew 
nothing  of  the  a\vful  odds  against  them.  They 
were  being  hustled  by  white  men  who  did  not 
draw  knives  or  fire  gmis.  Amid  that  babel  of 
1,500  men,  many  of  them  may  not  have  heard  the 
command ;  they  may  not  have  believed  that  their 
lives  would  have  been  spared. 

Looking  back  on  the  affair  with  all  the  sanity 
of  experience,  nothing  is  more  natural  than  what 
happened.  It  was  folly  and  suicide,  no  doubt  i 
but  it  was  hiunan  nature.  They  were  not  going 
to  give  in  without  having  a  fling.  I  hope  I  shall 
not  be  considered  a  pro-Tibetan  when  I  say  that 
I  admire  their  gallantry  and  dash. 

As  my  wounds  were  being  dressed  I  peered  over 
the  mound  at  the  rout.  They  were  walking  away ! 
Why,  in  the  name  of  all  their  Bodhisats  and 
Munis,  did  they  not  nm  ?  There  was  cover  be- 
hind a  bend  in  the  hill  a  few  hundred  yards  dis- 
tant, and  they  were  exposed  to  a  devastating  hail 
of  bullets  from  the  Maxims  and  rifles,  that  seemed 
to  mow  down  every  third  or  fourth  man.  Yet 
they  walked  I 


THE  ACTION  AT  HOT  SPRINGS,  s    145 

It  was  the  most  extraordinary  procession  I  have 
ever  seen.  My  friends  have  tried  to  explain  the 
phenomenon  as  due  to  obstinacy  or  ignorance,  or 
Spartan  contempt  for  Hfe.  But  I  think  I  have  the 
solution.  They  were  bewildered.  The  impossible 
had  happened. 

Prayers,  and  charms,  and  mantras,  and  the 
holiest  of  their  holy  men,  had  failed  them.  I 
believe  they  were  obsessed  with  that  one  thought. 
They  walked  with  bowed  heads,  as  if  they  had 
been  disillusioned  in  their  gods. 

After  the  last  of  the  retiring  Tibetans  had  dis- 
appeared round  the  comer  of  the  Guru  road,  the 
8th  Gurkhas  descended  from  the  low  range  of  hills 
on  the  right  of  the  position,  and  crossed  the  Guru 
Plain  in  extended  order  with  the  2nd  Mounted 
Infantry  on  their  extreme  left.  Orders  were  then 
received  by  Major  Row,  commanding  the  detach- 
ment, to  take  the  left  of  the  two  houses  which 
were  situated  under  the  hills  at  the  further  side 
of  the  plain.  This  movement  was  carried  out  in 
conjunction  with  the  mounted  infantry.  The 
advance  was  covered  by  the  7-pounder  guns  of 
the  Gurkhas  under  Captain  Luke,  R.A.  The 
attacking  force  advanced  in  extended  order  by  a 


146  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

•eries  of  small  rushes.  Cover  was  scanty,  but  the 
Tibetans,  though  firing  vigorously,  fired  high,  and 
there  were  no  casualties.  At  last  the  force  reached 
the  outer  wall  of  the  house,  and  regained  breath 
under  cover  of  it.  A  few  men  of  the  Gurkhas 
then  climbed  on  to  the  roof  and  descended  into 
the  house,  making  prisoners  of  the  inmates,  who 
numbered  forty  or  fifty.  Shortly  afterwards  the 
door,  which  was  strongly  barricaded,  was  broken 
in,  and  the  remainder  of  the  force  entered  the 
house. 

During  the  advance  a  munber  of  the  Tibetans 
attempted  to  escape  on  mules  and  ponies,  but 
the  greater  number  of  these  were  followed  up  and 
killed.    The  Tibetan  casualties  were  at  least  700. 

Perhaps  no  British  victory  has  been  greeted 
with  less  enthusiasm  than  the  action  at  the  Hot 
Springs.  Certainly  the  ofiicers,  who  did  their 
duty  so  thoroughly,  had  no  heart  in  the  business 
at  all.  After  the  first  futile  rush  the  Tibetans 
made  no  further  resistance.  There  was  no  more 
fighting,  only  the  slaughter  of  helpless  men. 

It  is  easy  to  criticise  after  the  event,  but  it 
seems  to  me  that  the  only  way  to  have  avoided 
the  lamentable  affair  at   the  Hot   Springs  would 


THE  ACTION  AT  HOT  SPRINGS.       147 

have  been  to  have  drawn  up  more  troops  round 
the  redan,  and,  when  the  Tibetans  were  hemmed 
in  with  the  diff  in  their  rear,  to  have  given  them 
at  least  twenty  minutes  to  lay  down  their  arms. 
In  the  interval  the  situation  might  have  been 
made  clear  to  everyone.  If  after  the  time-limit 
they  still  hesitated,  two  shots  might  have  brought 
them  to  reason.  Then,  if  they  were  mad  enough 
to  decide  on  resistance,  their  suicide  would  be  on 
their  own  heads.  But  to  send  two  dozen  sepoys 
into  that  sullen  mob  to  take  away  their  arms  was 
to  invite  disaster.  Given  the  same  circumstances, 
and  any  mob  in  the  world  of  men,  women,  or 
children,  civilized  or  savage,  and  there  would  be 
found  at  least  one  rash  spirit  to  explode  the  mine 
and  set  a  spark  to  a  general  conflagration. 

It  was  thought  at  the  time  that  the  lesson  would 
save  much  future  bloodshed.  But  the  Tibetan 
is  so  stubborn  and  convinced  of  his  self-sufficiency 
that  it  took  many  lessons  to  teach  him  the  dis- 
parity between  his  armed  rabble  and  the  resources 
of  the  British  Raj.  In  the  light  of  after-events 
it  is  clear  that  we  could  have  made  no  progress 
without  inflicting  terrible  punishment.  The 
slaughter  at  Guru  only  forestalled  the  inevitable. 


148  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

We  were  drawn  into  the  vortex  of  war  by  the 
Tibetans*  own  folly.  There  was  no  hope  of  their 
regarding  the  British  as  a  formidable  Power,  and 
a  force  to  be  reckoned  with,  until  we  had  killed 
several  thousand  of  their  men. 

After  the  action  the  Tibetan  wounded  were 
brought  into  Tuna,  and  an  abandoned  dwelling- 
house  was  fitted  up  as  a  hospital.  An  empty 
cowshed  outside  served  as  an  operating-theatre. 
The  patients  showed  extraordinary  hardihood  and 
stoicism.  After  the  Dzama  Tang  engagement 
many  of  the  wounded  came  in  riding  on  yaks  from 
a  distance  of  fifty  or  sixty  miles.  They  were  con- 
sistently cheerful,  and  always  ready  to  appreciate 
a  joke.  One  man,  who  lost  both  legs,  said :  '  In 
my  next  battle  I  must  be  a  hero,  as  I  cannot  run 
away.'  Some  of  the  wounded  were  terribly  muti- 
lated by  shell.  Two  men  who  were  shot  through 
the  brain,  and  two  who  were  shot  through  the 
lungs,  survived.  For  two  days  Lieutenant  Davys, 
Indian  Medical  Service,  was  operating  nearly  all 
day.  I  think  the  Tibetans  were  really  impressed 
with  our  humanity,  and  looked  upon  Davys  as 
some  incarnation  of  a  medicine  Buddha.  They 
never   hesitated   to   undergo   operations,   did   not 


THE  ACTION  AT  HOT  SPRINGS.       149 

flinch  at  pain,  and  took  chloroform  without  fear. 
Their  recuperative  power  was  marvellous.  Of 
the  168  who  were  received  in  hospital,  only  20 
died ;  148  were  sent  to  their  homes  on  hired  yaks 
cured.  Everyone  who  visited  the  hospital  at 
Tuna  left  it  with  an  increased  respect  for  the 
Tibetans. 

***** 
Three  months  after  the  action  I  found  the 
Tibetans  still  lying  where  they  fell.  One  shot 
through  the  shoulder  in  retreat  had  spun  as  he 
fell  facing  our  rifles.  Another  tore  at  the  grass 
with  futile  fingers  through  which  a  delicate  pink 
primula  was  now  blossoming.  Shrunk  arms  and 
shanks  looked  hideously  dwarfish.  By  the  stream 
the  bodies  lay  in  heaps  with  parched  skin,  Hke 
mummies,  rusty  brown.  A  knot  of  coarse  black 
hair,  detached  from  a  skull,  was  circling  round  in 
an  eddy  of  wind.  Everything  had  been  stripped 
from  the  corpses  save  here  and  there  a  wisp  of 
cloth,  looking  more  grim  than  the  nakedness  it 
covered,  or  round  the  neck  some  inexpensive 
charm,  which  no  one  had  thought  worth  taking 
for  its  occult  powers.  Nature,  more  kindly,  had 
strewn    round    them    beautiful    spring    flowers — 


150  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA, 

primulas,  buttercups,  potentils.  The  stream 
*  bubbled  oilily,'  and  in  the  ruined  house  bees 
were  swarming. 

Ten  miles  beyond  the  Springs  an  officer  was 
watering  his  horse  in  the  Bamtso  Lake.  The 
beast  swung  round  trembling,  with  eyes  astare. 
Among  the  weeds  lay  the  last  victim. 


CHAPTER  VII 

A   HUMAN   MISCELLANY 

THE  Tibetans  stood  on  the  roofs  of  their  houses 
like  a  row  of  cormorants,  and  watched  the 
doolie  pass  underneath.  At  a  httle  distance  it 
was  hard  to  distinguish  the  children,  so  motionless 
were  they,  from  the  squat  praying-flags  wrapped 
in  black  skin  and  projecting  from  the  parapets  of 
the  roof.  The  very  babes  were  impassive  and 
inscrutable.  Beside  them  perched  ravens  of  an 
ebony  blackness,  sleek  and  well  groomed,  and  so 
consequential  that  they  seemed  the  most  human 
element  of  the  group. 

My  Tibetan  bearers  stopped  to  converse  with 
a  woman  on  the  roof  who  wore  a  huge  red  hoop  in 
her  hair,  which  was  matted  and  touzled  like  a 
negress's.  A  child  behind  was  searching  it,  with 
apparent  success.  The  woman  asked  a  question, 
and  the  bearers  jerked  out  a  few  guttural  mono- 


152  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

syllables,  which  she  received  with  indifference. 
She  was  not  visiVjly  elated  when  she  heard  that 
the  doolie  contained  the  first  victim  of  the  Tibetan 
arms.  I  should  like  to  have  heard  her  views  on 
the  political  situation  and  the  question  of  a  settle- 
ment. Some  of  her  relatives,  perhaps,  were  killed 
in  the  mel^e  at  the  Hot  Springs,  Others  who 
had  been  taken  prisoners  might  be  enhsted  in  the 
new  doolie  corps,  and  receiving  an  unexpected 
wage ;  othei'S,  perhaps,  were  wounded  and  being 
treated  in  our  hospitals  with  all  the  skill  and 
resources  of  modern  science ;  or  they  were  bring- 
ing in  food-stuffs  for  our  troops,  or  setting  booby- 
traps  for  them,  and  lying  in  wait  IxOnml  ^nurai-s 
to  snipe  them  in  the  Ked  Idol  Gor^ 

The  bearers  started  again ;  the  hot  sun  and 
the  continued  exertion  made  them  stink  intoler- 
ably. Every  now  and  then  they  put  down  the 
doolie,  and  began  discussing  their  loot— ear-rings 
and  cliarmSi  rough  turquoises  and  ruby-coloured 
stones,  torn  from  the  btxiies  of  the  dead  and 
wounded.    For  the  moment  I  was  tired  of  Tibet. 

I  remembered  iuiother  exodus  wheji  I  was  dis- 
gusted with  the  country,  I  hud  been  allured 
across   tl><-   iTlin.l  i\as  by  the  daziUng  purity  ol 


A  HUMAN  MISCELLANY.  153 

che  snows.  I  had  escaped  the  Avemus  of  the 
plains,  and  I  might  have  been  content,  but  there 
was  the  seduction  of  the  snows.  I  had  gained  an 
upper  story,  but  I  must  cHmb  on  to  the  roof. 
Every  morning  the  Sun-god  threw  open  the  mag- 
nificent portals  of  his  domain,  dazzling  rifts  and 
spires,  black  chffs  glacier-bitten,  the  flawless 
vaulted  roof  of  Kinchenjunga — 

'  Myriads  of  topaz  lights  and  jacinth  work 
Of  subtlest  jewellery.' 

One  morning  the  roof  of  the  Sun-god's  palace 
was  clear  and  cloudless,  but  about  its  base  hung 
little  clouds  of  snow-dust,  as  though  the  Olympians 
had  been  holding  tourney,  and  the  dust  had  risen 
in  the  tracks  of  their  chariots.  All  this  was  seen 
over  galvanized  iron  roofs.  The  Sun-god  had 
thrown  open  his  palace,  and  we  were  playing  pitch 
and  toss  on  the  steps.  While  I  was  so  engrossed 
I  looked  up.  Columns  of  white  cloud  were  rising 
to  obscure  the  entrance.  Then  a  sudden  shaft 
of  sunlight  broke  the  fumes.  There  was  a  vivid 
flash,  a  dazzle  of  jewel-work,  and  the  portals 
closed,    I  was  covered  with  bashfulnc  '    •lamc. 

It  was  a  direct  invitation.    I  made  xcuse 


154  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

to   my   companion,   said   I   had    an    engagement, 
went  straight  to  my  rooms,  and  packed. 

But  while  the  aroma  of  my  carriers  insulted 
the  pure  air,  and  their  chatter  over  their  tawdry 
spoil  profaned  the  silent  precincts  of  Chumulari, 
their  mountain  goddess,  I  thought  more  of  the  dis- 
enchantment of  that  earUer  visit.  I  remembered 
sitting  on  a  hillside  near  a  lamasery,  which  was 
surrounded  by  a  small  village  of  Lamas'  houses. 
Outside  the  temple  a  priest  was  operating  on  a 
yak  for  vaccine.  He  had  bored  a  large  hole  in 
the  shoulder,  into  which  he  alternately  buried  his 
forearm  and  squirted  hot  water  copiously.  A 
hideous  yellow  trickle  beneath  indicated  that  the 
poor  beast  was  entirely  perforated.  A  crowd  of 
admiring  Httle  boys  and  girls  looked  on  with 
reUsh.  The  smell  of  the  poor  yak  was  distressing, 
but  the  smell  of  the  Lama  was  worse.  I  turned 
away  in  disgust — turned  my  back  contentedly 
and  without  regret  on  the  mysterious  land  and 
the  road  to  the  Forbidden  City.  At  that  moment, 
if  the  Dalai  Lama  himself  had  sent  me  a  chaise 
with  a  dozen  outriders  and  implored  me  to  come, 
I  would  not  have  visited  him,  not  for  a  thousand 
yaks.    The  scales  of  vagabondage   fell   from   my 


A  HUMAN  MISCELLANY.  155 

eyes  j  the  spirit  of  unrest  died  within  me.  I  had 
a  longing  for  fragrant  soap,  snowy  white  linen, 
fresh-complexioned  ladies  and  clean-shaven,  well- 
groomed  men. 

And  here  again  I  was  returning  very  slowly  to 
civilization  j  but  I  was  coming  back  with  half  an 
army  corps  to  shake  the  Dalai  Lama  on  his  throne 
—or  if  there  were  no  throne  or  Dalai  Lama,  to  do 
what  ?  I  wondered  if  the  gentlemen  sitting 
snugly  in  Downing  Street  had  any  idea. 

At  Phari  I  was  snow-bound  for  a  week,  and 
there  were  no  doolie-bearers.  The  Darjeeling 
dandy-wallahs  were  no  doubt  at  the  front,  where 
they  were  most  wanted,  as  the  trained  army  doolie 
corps  are  plainsmen,  who  can  barely  breathe, 
much  less  work,  at  these  high  elevations.  At  last 
we  secured  some  Bhutias  who  were  returning  to 
the  front. 

The  Bhutia  is  a  type  I  have  long  known,  though 
not  in  the  capacity  of  bearer.  These  men  regarded 
the  dooHe  with  the  invahd  inside  as  a  piece  of 
baggage  that  had  to  be  conveyed  from  one  camp 
to  another,  no  matter  how.  Of  the  art  of  their 
craft  they  knew  nothing,  but  they  battled  with  the 
elements  so  stoutly  that  one  forgave  them  their 


156  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

awkwardness.  They  carried  me  along  mountain- 
paths  so  slippery  that  a  mule  could  find  no  foot- 
hold, through  snow  so  deep  and  clogging  that 
with  all  their  toil  they  could  make  barely  half  a 
mile  an  hour ;  and  they  took  shelter  once  from  a 
hailstorm  in  which  exposure  without  thick  head- 
covering  might  have  been  fatal.  Often  they 
dropped  the  doolie,  sometimes  on  the  edge  of  a 
precipice,  in  places  where  one  perspired  with 
fright ;  they  collided  quite  unnecessarily  with 
stones  and  rocks ;  but  they  got  through,  and 
that  was  the  main  point.  Men  who  have  carried 
a  dooHe  over  a  difiicult  mountain-pass  (14,350  feet), 
slipping  and  stumbhng  through  snow  and  ice  in 
the  face  of  a  hurricane  of  wind,  deserve  well  of 
the  great  Raj  which  they  serve. 

On  the  road  into  DarjeeUng,  owing  to  the  absence 
of  trained  doolie-bearers,  I  met  a  human  miscellany 
that  I  am  not  hkely  to  forget.  Eight  miles  beyond 
the  Jelap  Ues  the  fort  of  Gnatong,  whence  there  is 
a  continual  descent  to  the  plains  of  India.  The 
neighbouring  hills  and  valleys  had  been  searched 
for  men  ;  high  wages  were  offered,  and  at  last 
from  some  remote  village  in  Sikkim  came  a  dozen 
weedy    Lepchas,    simian    in    appearance,    and    of 


A  HUMAN  MISCELLANY.  157 

uncouth  speech,  who  understood  no  civilized 
tongue.  They  had  never  seen  a  doolie,  but  in 
default  of  better  they  were  employed.  It  was 
nobody's  fault  j  bearers  must  be  had,  and  the 
profession  was  unpopular.  I  was  their  *  first  job.* 
I  settled  myself  comfortably,  all  unconscious  of 
my  impending  fate.  They  started  off  with  a  wild 
whoop,  threw  the  dooHe  up  in  the  air,  caught  it 
on  their  shoulders,  and  played  cup  and  ball  with 
the  contents  until  they  were  tired.  I  swore  at 
them  in  Spanish,  English,  and  Hindustani,  but  it 
was  small  reUef,  as  they  didn't  take  the  slightest 
notice,  and  I  had  neither  hands  to  beat  them  nor 
feet  to  kick  them  over  the  khud.  My  orderly 
followed  and  told  them  in  a  mild  North-Country 
accent  that  they  would  be  punished  if  they  did  it 
again  ;  there  is  some  absurd  army  regulation  about 
British  soldiers  striking  followers.  For  all  they 
knew,  he  was  addressing  the  stars.  They  dropped 
the  thing  a  dozen  times  in  ten  miles,  and  thought 
it  the  hugest  joke  in  the  world.  I  shall  shy  at  a 
hospital  dooUe  for  the  rest  of  my  natural  life. 

There  is  a  certain  Mongol  smell  which  is  the 
most  unpleasant  human  odour  I  know.  It  is 
common    to    Lepchas.    Bhutanese,    and    Tibetans 


158  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

but  it  is  found  in  its  purest  essence  in  these  low- 
country,  cross-bred  Lepchas,  who  were  my  close 
companions  for  two  days.  When  we  reached  the 
heat  of  the  valley,  they  jumped  into  the  stream 
and  bathed,  but  they  emerged  more  unsavoury 
than  ever.  It  was  a  rehef  to  pass  a  dead  mule. 
At  the  next  village  they  got  drunk,  after  which 
they  developed  an  amazing  surefootedness,  and 
carried  me  in  without  mishap. 

After  two  days  with  my  Lepchas  we  reached 
Rungli  (2,000  feet),  whence  the  road  to  the  plains 
is  almost  level.  Here  a  friend  introduced  me  to 
a  Jemadar  in  a  Gurkha  regiment. 

*  He  writes  all  about  our  soldiers  and  the  fighting 
in  Tibet,'  he  said.  *  It  all  goes  home  to  England 
on  the  telegraph-wire,  and  people  at  home  are 
reading  what  he  says  an  hour  or  two  after  he  has 
given  khubher  to  the  office  here.' 

'  Oh  yes,'  said  the  Jemadar  in  Hindustani,  *  and 
if  things  are  well  the  people  in  England  will  be 
very  glad ;  and  if  we  are  ill  and  die,  and  there  is 
too  much  cold,  they  will  be  very  sorry.* 

The  Jemadar  smiled.  He  was  most  sincere  and 
sympathetic.  If  an  EngUshman  had  said  the  same 
thing,   he   would  have  been  thought   half-witted. 


A  HUMAN  MISCELLANY.  159 

but  Orientals  have  a  way  of  talking  platitudes  as 
if  they  were  epigrams. 

The  Jemadar's  speech  was  so  much  to  the  point 
that  it  called  up  a  little  picture  in  my  mind  of 
the  London  Underground  and  a  liveried  official 
dealing  out  Daily  Mails  to  crowds  of  inquirers 
anxious  for  news  of  Tibet.  Only  the  sun  blazed 
overhead  and  the  stream  made  music  at  our  feet. 

I  left  the  little  rest-hut  in  the  morning,  resigned 
to  the  inevitable  jolting,  and  expecting  another 
promiscuous  collection  of  humanity  to  do  duty  as 
kahars.  But,  to  my  great  joy,  I  found  twelve 
Lucknow  doolie-wallahs  waiting  by  the  veranda, 
lithe  and  erect,  and  part  of  a  drilled  corps.  Drill 
discipine  is  good,  but  in  the  art  of  their  trade 
these  men  needed  no  teaching.  For  centuries 
their  ancestors  had  carried  palanquins  in  the  plains, 
bearing  Rajas  and  ladies  of  high  estate,  perhaps 
even  the  Great  Mogul  himself.  The  running  step 
to  their  strange  rhythmic  chants  must  be  an  instinct 
to  them.  That  morning  I  knew  my  troubles  were 
at  an  end.  They  started  off  with  steps  of  velvet, 
improvising  as  they  went  a  kind  of  plaintive  song 
like  an  intoned  litany. 

The  leading  man  chanted  a  dimeter  Hue,  gener- 


i6o         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

ally  with  an  iambus  in  the  first  foot ;  but  when 
the  road  was  difficult  or  the  ascent  toilsome,  the 
metre  became  trochaic,  in  accordance  with  the 
best  traditions  of  classical  poetry.  The  hind-men 
responded  with  a  sing-song  trochaic  dimeter  which 
sounded  hke  a  long-drawn-out  monosyllable.  They 
never  initiated  anything.  It  was  not  custom  ;  it 
had  never  been  done.  The  laws  of  Nature  are  not 
so  immutable  as  the  ritual  of  a  Hindu  guild. 

We  sped  on  smoothly  for  eight  miles,  and  when 
I  asked  the  kahars  if  they  were  tired,  they  said 
they  would  not  rest,  as  relays  were  waiting  on  the 
road.  All  the  way  they  chanted  their  hymn  of 
the  obvious : — 

'  Moxintaias  are  steep  ; 

Chorus  :  Yes,  they  are. 
The  road  is  narrow  ; 

Yes,  it  is. 
The  sahib  is  wounded  ; 

That  is  so. 
With  many  wounds ; 

They  are  many. 
The  road  goes  down  ; 

Yes,  it  does. 
Now  we  are  hurrying  ; 

Yes,  we  are.' 

Here  they  ran  swiftly  till  the  next  rise  in  the  hill. 
Waiting  in  the  shade  for  relays,   I  heard  two 


A  HUMAN  MISCELLANY.  i6i 

Englishmen  meet  on  the  road.  One  had  evidently 
been  attached,  and  was  going  down  to  join  his 
regiment ;  the  other  was  coming  up  on  special 
service.  I  caught  fragments  of  our  crisp  expres- 
sive argot. 

Officer  going  down  [apparently  disillusioned)  : 
'  Oh,  it's  the  same  old  bald-headed  maidan  we 
usually  muddle  into.' 

Officer  coming  up :  *  .  .  .  Up  above  Phari  ideal 
country  for  native  cavalry,  isn't  it  ?  ...  A  few 
men  with  lances  prodding  those  fellows  in  the 
back  would  soon  put  the  fear  of  God  into  them. 
Why  don't  they  send  up  the  — ^th  Light  Cavalry  ?  * 

Officer  going  down  :  *  They've  Walers,  and  you 
can't  feed  'em,  and  the  — th  are  all  Jats.  They're 
no  good  ;  can't  do  without  a  devil  of  a  lot  of  milk. 
They  want  bucketsful  of  it.  Well,  bye-bye  ;  you'll 
soon  get  fed  up  with  it.' 

The  doolie  was  hitched  up,  and  the  kahars  re- 
sumed their  chant : 

*  A  sahib  goes  up  ; 
Yes,  he  does. 
A  sahib  goes  down  ; 
That  is  so.' 

The  heat  and  the  monotonous  cadence  induced 
6 


i62  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

drowsiness,  and  one  fell  to  thinking  of  this  odd 
motley  of  men,  all  of  one  genus,  descended  from 
the  anthropoid  ape,  and  exhibiting  various  phases 
of  evolution — ^the  primitive  Lepcha,  advanced 
little  further  than  his  domestic  dog  ;  the  Tibetan 
kahar  caught  in  the  wheel  of  civiUzation,  and 
forming  part  of  the  mechanism  used  to  bring  his 
own  people  into  line  ;  the  Lucknow  dooUe-bearer 
and  the  Jemadar  Sahib,  products  of  a  hoary 
civilization  that  have  escaped  complexity  and 
nerves  •  and  lord  of  all  these,  by  virtue  of  his 
race,  the  most  evolved,  the  English  subaltern. 
All  these  folk  are  brought  together  because  the 
people  on  the  other  side  of  the  hills  will  insist  on 
being  obsolete  anachronisms,  who  have  been  asleep 
for  hundreds  of  years  while  we  have  been  develop- 
ing the  sense  of  our  duty  towards  our  neighbour. 
They  must  come  into  Une;  it  is  the  will  of  the 
most  evolved. 

The  next  day  I  was  carried  for  miles  through  a 
tropical  forest.  The  damp  earth  sweated  in  the 
sun  after  last  night's  thunder-storm,  and  the  vegeta- 
tion seemed  to  grow  visibly  in  the  steaming  moisture. 
Gorgeous  butterflies,  the  epicures  of  a  season,  came 
out  to  indulge  a  love  of  sunshine  and  suck  nectar 


A  HUMAN  MISCELLANY.  163 

from  all  this  profusion.  Overhead,  birds  shrieked 
and  whistled  and  beat  metal,  and  did  everything 
but  sing.  The  cicadas  raised  a  deafening  din  in 
praise  of  their  Maker,  seeming  to  think,  in  their 
natural  egoism,  that  He  had  made  the  forest, 
oak,  and  gossamer  for  their  sakes.  We  were  not 
a  thousand  feet  above  the  sea.  Thousands  of 
feet  above  us,  where  we  were  camping  a  day  or 
two  ago,  our  troops  were  marching  through  snow. 

The  next  morning  we  crossed  the  Tista  River, 
and  the  road  led  up  through  sal  forests  to  a  tea- 
garden  at  3,500  feet.  Here  we  entered  the  most 
perfect  climate  in  the  world,  and  I  enjoyed  genial 
hospitality  and  a  foretaste  of  civilization :  a  bed, 
sheets,  a  warm  bath,  clean  linen,  fruit,  sparkling 
soda,  a  roomy  veranda  with  easy-chairs,  and  out- 
side roses  and  trellis-work,  and  a  garden  bright 
with  orchids  and  wild-turmeric  and  a  profusion  of 
semi-tropical  and  English  flowers — all  the  things 
which  the  spoilt  children  of  civilization  take  as  a 
matter  of  course,  because  they  have  never  slept 
under  the  stars,  or  known  what  it  is  to  be  hungry 
and  cold,  or  exhausted  by  struggling  against  the 
forces  of  untamed  Nature. 

At  noon  next  day,  in  the  cantonments  at  Jela- 


l64         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

pahar,  an  officer  saw  a  strange  sight — a  field- 
hospital  doolie  with  the  red  cross,  and  twelve  kahars, 
Lucknow  men,  whose  plaintive  chant  must  have 
recalled  old  days  on  the  North-West  frontier. 
Behind  on  a  mule  rode  a  British  orderly  of  the  King's 
Own  Scottish  Borderers,  bearded  and  weather- 
stained,  and  without  a  trace  of  the  spick-and-spanness 
of  cantonments.  I  saw  the  officer's  face  lighten ; 
he  became  visibly  excited ;  he  could  not  restrain 
himself — he  swung  round,  rode  after  my  orderly, 
and  began  to  question  him  without  shame.  Here 
was  civilization  longing  for  the  wilderness,  and  over 
there,  beyond  the  mist,  under  that  snow-clad  peak, 
were  men  in  the  wilderness  longing  for  civilization. 

A  cloud  swept  down  and  obscured  the  Jelap,  as 
if  the  chapter  were  closed.  But  it  is  not.  That 
implacable  barrier  must  be  crossed  again,  and 
then,  when  we  have  won  the  most  secret  places  of 
the  earth,  we  may  cry  with  Burton  and  his  Arabs, 
'  Voyaging  is  victory  I ' 


CHAPTER   VIII 

THE   ADVANCE   OF  THE   MISSION   OPPOSED 

THE  intention  of  the  Tibetans  at  the  Hot  Springs 
has  not  been  made  clear.  They  say  that 
their  orders  were  to  oppose  our  advance,  but  to 
avoid  a  battle,  just  as  our  orders  were  to  take  away 
their  arms,  if  possible,  without  firing  a  shot.  The 
muddle  that  ensued  lends  itself  to  several  inter- 
pretations, and  the  Tibetans  ascribe  their  loss  to 
British  treachery.  They  say  that  we  ordered  them 
to  destroy  the  fuses  of  their  matchlocks,  and  then 
fired  on  them.  This  story  was  taken  to  Lhasa, 
with  the  result  that  the  new  levies  from  the  capital 
were  not  deterred  by  the  terrible  punishment  in- 
flicted on  their  comrades.  Orders  were  given  to 
oppose  us  on  the  road  to  Gyantse,  and  an  armed 
force,  which  included  many  of  the  fugitives  from 
Guru,  gathered  about  Kangma. 

The  peace  delegates  always  averred  that  we  fired 


i66         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

the  first  shot  at  Guru.  But  even  if  we  give  the 
Tibetans  the  benefit  of  the  doubt,  and  admit  that 
the  action  grew  out  of  the  natural  excitement  of 
two  forces  struggling  for  arms,  both  of  whom  were 
originally  anxious  to  avoid  a  conflict,  there  is  still 
no  doubt  that  the  responsibiUty  of  continuing  the 
hostilit^i  nes  with  the  Tibetans. 

On  tlie  morning  of  April  7  ten  scouts  of  the  2nd 
Mounted  Infantry,  under  Captain  Peterson,  found 
the  Tibetans  occup3dng  the  village  of  Samando, 
seventeen  miles  beyond  Kalatso.  As  our  men  had 
orders  not  to  fire  or  provoke  an  attack,  they  sent 
a  messenger  up  to  the  walls  to  ask  one  of  the  Tibetans 
to  come  out  and  parley.  They  said  they  would  send 
for  a  man,  and  invited  us  to  come  nearer.  When 
we  had  ridden  up  to  within  a  hundred  yards  of  the 
village,  they  opened  a  heavy  fire  on  us  with  their 
matchlocks.  Our  scouts  spread  out,  rode  back  a 
few  hundred  yards,  and  took  cover  behind  stones. 
Not  a  man  or  pony  was  hit.  Before  retiring,  the 
mounted  infantry  fired  a  few  volleys  at  the  Tibetans 
who  were  lining  the  roofs  of  two  large  houses  and 
a  wall  that  connected  them,  their  heads  only  ap- 
pearing above  the  low  turf  parapets.  Twice  the 
Tibetans  sent  off  a  mounted  man  for  reinforcements. 


ADVANCE  OF  MISSION  OPPOSED.      167 

but  our  shooting  was  so  good  that  each  time  the 
horse  returned  riderless.  The  next  morning  we 
found  the  village  unoccupied,  and  discovered  six 
dead  left  on  the  roofs,  most  of  whom  were  wounded 
about  the  chest.  Our  bullets  had  penetrated  the 
two  feet  of  turf  and  killed  the  man  behind.  Putting 
aside  the  question  of  Guru,  the  Samando  affair  was 
the  first  overt  act  of  hostility  directed  against  the 
mission. 

After  Samando  there  was  no  longer  any  doubt 
that  the  Tibetans  intended  to  oppose  our  advance. 
On  the  8th  the  mounted  infantry  discovered  a  wall 
built  across  the  valley  and  up  the  hills  just  this 
side  of  Kangma,  which  they  reported  as  occupied 
by  about  1,000  men.  As  it  was  too  late  to  attack 
that  night,  we  formed  camp.  The  next  morning 
we  found  the  wall  evacuated,  and  the  villagers  re- 
ported that  the  Tibetans  had  retired  to  the  gorge 
below.  This  habit  of  building  formidable  barriers 
across  a  valley,  stretching  from  crest  to  crest  of  the 
flanking  hills,  is  a  well-known  trait  of  Tibetan 
Wcirfare.  The  wall  is  often  built  in  the  night  and 
abandoned  the  next  morning.  One  would  imagine 
that,  after  toiling  all  night  to  make  a  strong  posi- 
tion, the  Tibetans  would  hold  their  wall  if  they 


i68  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

intended  to  make  a  stand  anywhere.  But  they  do 
not  grudge  the  labour.  Wall-building  is  an  instinct 
with  them.  When  a  Tibetan  sees  two  stones  by  the 
roadside,  he  cannot  resist  placing  one  on  the  top 
of  the  other.  So  wherever  one  goes  the  whole 
countryside  is  studded  with  these  monuments  of 
wasted  labour,  erected  to  propitiate  the  genii  of 
the  place,  or  from  mere  force  of  habit  to  while  away 
an  idle  hour.  During  the  campaign  of  1888  it  was 
this  practice  of  strengthening  and  abandoning  posi- 
tions more  than  anything  else  which  gained  the 
Tibetans  the  reputation  of  cowardice,  which  they 
have  since  shown  to  be  totally  undeserved. 

On  April  8,  owing  to  the  delay  in  reconnoitring 
the  wall,  we  made  only  about  eight  miles,  and 
camped.  The  next  morning  we  had  marched 
about  two  miles,  when  we  found  the  high  ridge 
on  the  left  flank  occupied  by  the  enemy,  and  the 
mounted  infantry  reported  them  in  the  gorge  be- 
yond. Two  companies  of  the  8th  Gurkhas  under 
Major  Row  were  sent  up  to  the  hill  on  the  left  to 
turn  the  enemy's  right  flank,  and  the  mountain 
battery  (No.  7)  came  into  action  on  the  right  at 
over  3,000  yards.  The  enemy  kept  up  a  continuous 
but  ineffectual  fire  from  the  ridge,  none  of  their 


ADVANCE  OF  MISSION  OPPOSED.      169 

jingal  bullets  falling  anywhere  near  us.  The 
Gurkhas  had  a  very  difficult  climb.  The  hill  was 
quite  2,000  feet  above  the  valley ;  the  lower  and 
a  good  deal  of  the  other  slopes  were  of  coarse  sand 
mixed  with  shale,  and  the  rest  nothing  but  slippery 
rock.  The  summit  of  the  hill  was  approached  by  a 
number  of  step-like  shale  terraces  covered  with 
snow.  When  only  a  short  way  up,  a  snowstorm 
came  on  and  obscured  the  Gurkhas  from  view.  The 
cold  was  intense,  and  the  troops  in  the  valley  began 
to  collect  the  sparse  brushwood,  and  made  fires  to 
keep  themselves  warm. 

On  account  of  the  nature  of  the  hillside  and  the 
high  altitude,  the  progress  of  the  Gurkhas  was  very 
slow,  and  it  took  them  nearly  three  hours  to  reach 
the  ridge  held  by  the  enemy.  When  about  two- 
thirds  of  the  way  up,  they  came  under  fire  from 
the  ridge,  but  all  the  shots  went  high.  The  jingals 
carried  well  over  them  at  about  1,200  yards.  The 
enemy  also  sent  a  detachment  to  meet  them  on  the 
top,  but  these  did  not  fire  long,  and  retired  as  the 
Gurkhas  advanced.  When  the  8th  reached  the 
summit,  the  Tibetans  were  in  full  flight  down  the 
opposite  slope,  which  was  also  snow-covered. 
Thirty  were  shot  down  in  the  rout,  and  fifty- 
6a 


170  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

four  who  were  hiding  in  the  caves  were  made 
prisoners. 

In  the  meanwhile  the  battery  had  been  making 
very  good  practice  at  3,000  yards.  Seven  men 
were  found  dead  on  the  stunmit,  and  four  wounded, 
evidently  by  their  fire. 

But  to  return  to  the  main  action  in  the  gorge. 
The  Tibetans  held  a  very  strong  position  among 
some  loose  boulders  on  the  right,  two  miles  beyond 
the  gully  which  the  Gurkhas  had  ascended  to  make 
their  flank  attack.  The  rocks  extended  from  the 
bluff  cliff  to  the  path  which  skirted  the  stream. 
No  one  could  ask  for  better  cover  ;  it  was  most  diffi- 
cult to  distinguish  the  drab-coated  Tibetans  who 
lay  concealed  there.  To  attack  this  strong  posi- 
tion General  Macdonald  sent  Captain  Bethune  with 
one  company  of  the  32nd  Pioneers,  placing  Lieu- 
tenant Cook  with  his  Maxim  on  a  mound  at  500 
yards  to  cover  Bethune's  advance.  Bethune  led  a 
frontal  attack.  The  Tibetans  fired  wildly  until 
the  Sikhs  were  within  eighty  yards,  and  then  fled 
up  the  valley.  Not  a  single  man  of  the  32nd  was 
hit  during  the  attack,  though  one  sepoy  was  wounded 
in  the  pursuit  by  a  bullet  in  the  hand  from  a  man 
who   lay  concealed  behind  a  rock  within  a  few 


ADVANCE  OF  MISSION  OPPOSED.     171 

yards  of  him.  While  the  32nd  were  dislodging  the 
Tibetans  from  the  path  and  the  rocks  above  it,  the 
mounted  infantry  galloped  through  them  to  recon- 
noitre ahead  and  cut  off  the  fugitives  in  the  valley. 
They  also  came  through  the  enemy's  fire  at  very 
close  quarters  without  a  casualty.  On  emerging 
from  the  gorge  the  mounted  infantry  discovered 
that  the  ridge  the  Tibetans  had  held  was  shaped 
like  the  letter  S,  so  that  by  doubling  back  along 
an  almost  parallel  valley  they  were  able  to  intercept 
the  enemy  whom  the  Gurkhas  had  driven  down  the 
cliffs.  The  unfortunate  Tibetans  were  now  hemmed 
in  between  two  fires,  and  hardly  a  man  of  them 
escaped. 

The  Tibetan  casualties,  as  returned  at  the  time, 
were  much  exaggerated.  The  killed  amounted  to 
100,  and,  on  the  principle  that  the  proportion  of 
wounded  must  be  at  least  two  to  one,  it  was  esti- 
mated that  their  losses  were  300.  But,  as  a  matter 
of  fact,  the  wounded  could  not  have  numbered 
more  than  two  dozen. 

The  prisoners  taken  by  the  Gurkhas  on  the  top 
of  the  ridge  turned  out  to  be  impressed  peasants, 
who  had  been  compelled  to  fight  us  by  the  Lamas. 
They  were  not  soldiers  by  inclination  or  instinct. 


172         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

and   I   believe  their  greatest  fear  was   that  they 
might  be  released  and  driven  on  to  fight  us  again. 

The  action  at  the  Red  Idol  Gorge  may  be  re- 
garded as  the  end  of  the  first  phase  of  the  Tibetan 
opposition.  We  reached  Gyantse  on  April  ii,  and 
the  fort  was  surrendered  without  resistance.  Noth- 
ing had  occurred  on  the  march  up  to  disturb  our 
estimate  of  the  enemy.  Since  the  campaign  of 
1888  no  one  had  given  the  Tibetans  any  credit  for 
martial  instincts,  and  until  the  Karo  la  action  and 
the  attack  on  Gyantse  they  certainly  displayed 
none.  It  would  be  hard  to  exaggerate  the  strategical 
difficulties  of  the  country  through  which  we  had  to 
pass.  The  progress  of  the  mission  and  its  escort 
under  similar  conditions  would  have  been  impossible 
on  the  North-West  frontier  or  in  any  country  in- 
habited by  a  people  with  the  rudiments  of  sense  or 
spirit.  The  difficulties  of  transport  were  so  great 
that  the  escort  had  to  be  cut  down  to  the  finest 
possible  figure.  There  were  barely  enough  men  for 
pickets,  and  many  of  the  ordinary  precautions  of 
field  manoeuvres  were  out  of  the  question.  But  the 
Tibetan  failed  to  realize  his  opportunities.  He 
avoided  the  narrow  forest-clad  ravines  of  Sikkim 
and  Chumbi,  and  made  his  first  staj^d  on  the  open 


ADVANCE  OF  MISSION  OPPOSED.     173 

plateau  at  Guru.  Fortunately  for  us,  he  never 
learnt  what  transport  means  to  a  civilized  army. 
A  bag  of  barley-meal,  some  weighty  degchies,  and 
a  massive  copper  teapot  slung  over  the  saddle  are 
all  he  needs ;  evening  may  produce  a  sheep  or  a 
yak.  His  movements  are  not  hampered  by  sup- 
plies. If  the  importance  of  the  transport  question 
had  ever  entered  his  head,  he  would  have  avoided 
the  Tuna  camp,  with  its  Maxims  and  mounted  in- 
fantry, and  made  a  dash  upon  the  line  of  com- 
munications. A  band  of  hardy  mountaineers  in 
their  own  country  might  very  easily  surprise  and 
annihilate  an  ill-guarded  convoy  in  a  narrow  valley 
thickly  forested  and  flanked  by  steep  hills.  To 
furtively  cut  an  artery  in  your  enemy's  arm  and 
let  out  the  blood  is  just  as  effective  as  to  knock  him 
on  the  head  from  in  front.  But  in  this  first  phase 
of  the  operations  the  Tibetans  showed  no  strategy ; 
they  were  badly  led,  badly  armed,  and  apparently 
devoid  of  all  soldier-like  qualities.  Only  on  one  or 
two  occasions  they  displayed  a  desperate  and  fatal 
courage,  and  this  new  aspect  of  their  character  was 
the  first  indication  that  we  might  have  to  revise  the 
views  we  had  formed  sixteen  years  ago  of  an  enemy 
who  has  seemed  to  us  since  a  unique  exception  to 


174         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

the  rule  that  a  hardy  mountain  people  are  never 
deficient  in  courage  and  the  instinct  of  self-defence. 
The  most  extraordinary  aspect  of  the  fighting  up 
to  our  arrival  at  Gyantse  was  that  we  had  only  one 
casualty  from  a  gunshot  wound — the  Sikh  who  was 
shot  in  the  hand  at  the  Dzama  Tang  affair  by  a 
Tibetan  whose  jezail  was  almost  touching  him. 
Yet  at  the  Hot  Springs  the  Tibetans  fired  off  their 
matchlocks  and  rifles  into  the  thick  of  us,  and  at 
Guru  an  hour  afterwards  the  Gurkhas  walked  right 
up  to  a  house  held  by  the  enemy,  under  heavy  fire, 
and  took  it  without  a  casualty.  The  mounted  in- 
fantry were  exposed  to  a  volley  at  Samando  at 
100  yards,  and  again  in  the  Red  Idol  Gorge  they 
rode  through  the  enemy's  fire  at  an  even  shorter 
range.  In  the  same  action  the  32nd  made  a  frontal 
attack  on  a  strong  position  which  was  held  until 
they  were  within  eighty  yards,  and  not  a  man  was 
hit.  No  wonder  we  had  a  contempt  for  the  Tibetan 
arms.  Their  matchlocks,  weapons  of  the  rudest 
description,  must  have  been  as  dangerous  to  their 
own  marksmen  as  to  the  enemy  ;  their  artillery  fire, 
to  judge  by  our  one  experience  of  it  at  Dzama  Tang, 
was  harmless  and  erratic  ;  and  their  modem  Lhasa- 
made  rifles  had  not  left  a  mark  on  our  men.    The 


ADVANCE  OF  MISSION  OPPOSED.      175 

Tibetans'  only  chance  seemed  to  be  a  rush  at  close 
quarters,  but  they  had  not  proved  themselves  com- 
petent swordsmen.  My  own  individual  case  was 
sufficient  to  show  that  they  were  bunglers.  Besides 
the  twelve  wounds  I  received  at  the  Hot  Springs, 
I  found  seven  sword-cuts  on  my  poshteen,  none  of 
which  were  driven  home.  During  the  whole  cam- 
paign we  had  only  one  death  from  sword-woimds. 

Arrived  at  Gyantse,  we  settled  down  with  some 
sense  of  security.  A  bazaar  was  held  outside  the 
camp.  The  people  seemed  friendly,  and  brought 
in  large  quantities  of  supplies.  Colonel  Young- 
husband,  in  a  despatch  to  the  Foreign  Office,  re- 
ported that  with  the  surrender  of  Gyantse  Fort 
on  April  12  resistance  in  that  part  of  Tibet  was 
ended.  A  letter  was  received  from  the  Amban 
stating  that  he  would  certainly  reach  Gyantse 
within  the  next  three  weeks,  and  that  competent 
and  trustworthy  Tibetan  representatives  would 
accompany  him.  The  Lhasa  officials,  it  was  said, 
were  in  a  state  of  panic,  and  had  begged  the 
Amban  to  visit  the  British  camp  and  effect  a  settle- 
ment. 

On  April  20  General  Macdonald's  staff,  with  the 
lo-pounder   guns,    three    companies   of    the    23rd 


176         THE  UNVEILING  OF  XHASA. 

Pioneers,  and  one  and  a  half  companies  of  the  8th 
Giirkhas,  returned  to  Chumbi  to  relieve  the  strain 
on  the  transport  and  strengthen  the  line  of  com- 
munications. Gyantse  Jong  was  evacuated,  and 
we  occupied  a  position  in  a  group  of  houses,  as  we 
thought,  well  out  of  range  of  fire  from  the  fort. 

Everything  was  quiet  until  the  end  of  April,  when 
we  heard  that  the  Tibetans  were  occupying  a  wall 
in  some  strength  near  the  Karo  la,  forty-two  miles 
from  Gyantse,  on  the  road  to  Lhasa.  Colonel 
Brander,  of  the  32nd  Pioneers,  who  was  left  in  com- 
mand at  Gyantse,  sent  a  small  party  of  mounted 
infantry  and  pioneers  to  reconnoitre  the  position. 
They  discovered  2,000  of  the  enemy  behind  a  strong 
loopholed  wall  stretching  across  the  valley,  a  dis- 
tance of  nearly  600  yards.  As  the  party  explored 
the  ravine  they  had  a  narrow  escape  from  a  booby- 
trap,  a  formidable  device  of  Tibetan  warfare,  which 
was  only  employed  against  our  troops  on  this  occa- 
sion. An  artificial  avalanche  of  rocks  and  stones 
is  so  cunningly  contrived  that  the  removal  of  one 
stone  sends  the  whole  engine  of  destruction  thun- 
dering down  the  hillside.  Luckily,  the  Tibetans  did 
not  wait  for  our  main  body,  but  loosed  the  machine 
on  an  advance  guard  of  mounted  infantry,  who 


ADVANCE  OF  MISSION  OPPOSED.      177 

were  in  extended  order  and  able  to  take  shelter 
behind  rocks. 

On  the  return  of  the  reconnaissance  Colonel 
Brander  decided  to  attack,  as  he  considered  the 
gathering  threatened  the  safety  of  the  mission.  The 
Karo  Pass  is  an  important  strategical  position,  lying 
as  it  does  at  the  junction  of  the  two  roads  to 
India,  one  of  which  leads  to  Kangma,  the  other  to 
Gyantse.  A  strong  force  holding  the  pass  might  at 
any  moment  pour  troops  down  the  valley  to  Kangma, 
cut  us  off  in  the  rear,  and  destroy  our  line  of  com- 
munications. When  Colonel  Brander  led  his  small 
force  to  take  the  pass,  it  was  not  with  the  object 
of  clearing  the  road  to  Lhasa.  The  measure  was 
purely  defensive  :  the  action  was  undertaken  to  keep 
the  road  open  for  convoys  and  reinforcements,  and 
to  protect  isolated  posts  on  the  line.  The  force 
with  the  mission  was  still  an  *  escort,*  and  so  far 
its  operations  had  been  confined  to  dispersing  the 
armed  levies  that  blocked  the  road. 

On  May  3  Colonel  Brander  left  Gyantse  with  his 
column  of  400  rifles,  comprising  three  companies  of 
the  32nd  Pioneers,  under  Captains  Bethune  and 
Cullen  and  Lieutenant  Hodgson  ;  one  company  of 
the  8th,  under  Major  Row  and  Lieutenant  Coleridge, 


178  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

with  two  7-pounder  guns ;  the  Maxim  detachment 
of  the  Norfolks,  under  Lieutenant  Hadow ;  and 
forty-five  of  the  ist  Mounted  Infantry,  under  Cap- 
tain Ottley.  On  the  first  day  the  column  marched 
eighteen  miles,  and  halted  at  Gobshi.  On  the  second 
day  they  reached  Ralung,  eleven  miles  further,  and 
on  the  third  marched  up  the  pass  and  encamped  on 
an  open  spot  about  two  miles  from  where  the 
Tibetans  had  built  their  wall.  A  reconnaissance 
that  afternoon  estimated  the  enemy  at  2,000,  and 
they  were  holding  the  strongest  position  on  the 
road  to  Lhasa.  They  had  built  a  wall  the  whole 
length  of  a  narrow  spur  and  up  the  hill  on  the  other 
side  of  the  stream,  and  in  addition  held  detached 
sangars  high  up  the  steep  hills,  and  well  thrown 
forward.  Their  flanks  rested  on  very  high  and 
nearly  precipitous  rocks.  It  was  only  possible  to 
climb  the  ridge  on  our  right  from  a  mile  behind, 
and  on  the  left  from  nearly  three-quarters  of  a  mile. 
Colonel  Brander  at  first  considered  the  practica- 
bility of  delaying  the  attack  on  the  main  wall  imtil 
the  Gurkhas  had  completed  their  flanking  move- 
ments, cleared  the  Tibetans  out  of  the  sangars  that 
enfiladed  our  advance  in  the  valley,  and  reached  a 
position  on  the  hills  beyond  the  wall,  whence  they 


ADVANCE  OF  MISSION  OPPOSED.      179 

could  fire  into  the  enemy's  rear.  But  the  cliffs  were 
so  sheer  that  the  ascent  was  deemed  impracticable, 
and  the  next  morning  it  was  decided  to  make  a 
frontal  attack  without  waiting  for  the  Gurkhas  to 
turn  the  flank.  No  one  for  a  moment  thought  it 
could  be  done. 

The  troops  marched  out  of  camp  at  ten  o'clock. 
One  company  of  the  32nd  Pioneers,  under  Captain 
Cullen,  was  detailed  to  attack  on  the  right,  and  a 
second  company,  under  Captain  Bethune,  to  follow 
the  river-bed,  where  they  were  under  cover  of  the 
high  bank  until  within  400  yards  of  the  wall,  and 
then  rush  the  centre  of  the  position.  The  ist 
Mounted  Infantry,  under  Captain  Ottley,  we<T.  to 
follow  this  company  along  the  valley.  The  guns, 
Maxims,  and  one  company  of  the  32nd  m  reserve, 
occupied  a  small  plateau  in  the  centre.  Half  a 
company  of  the  8th  Gurkhas  were  left  behind  to 
guard  the  camp.  A  second  half-company,  under 
Major  Row,  were  sent  along  the  hill-side  on  the  left 
to  attack  the  enemy's  extreme  right  sangar,  but 
their  progress  over  the  shifting  shale  slopes  and 
jagged  rocks  was  so  slow  that  the  front  attack  did 
not  wait  for  them. 

The  fire  from  the  wall  was  very  heavy,  and  the 


i8o         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

advance  of  Cullen's  and  Bethune's  companies  was 
checked.  Bethune  sent  half  a  company  back,  and 
signalled  to  the  mounted  infantry  to  retire.  Then, 
compelled  by  some  fatal  impulse,  he  changed  his 
mind,  and  with  half  a  company  left  the  cover  of  the 
river-bed  and  rushed  out  into  the  open  within  forty 
yards  of  the  main  wall,  exposed  to  a  withering  fire 
from  three  sides.  His  half-company  held  back, 
and  Bethime  fell  shot  through  the  head  with  only 
four  men  by  his  side — a  bugler,  a  store-office  babu, 
and  two  devoted  Sikhs.  What  the  clerk  was  doing 
there  no  one  knows,  but  evidently  the  soldier  in  the 
man  had  smouldered  in  suppression  among  the 
office  files  and  triumphed  splendidly.  It  was  a 
gallant  reckless  charge  against  uncounted  odds. 
Poor  Bethime  had  learnt  to  despise  the  Tibetans* 
fire,  and  his  contempt  was  not  unnatural.  On  the 
march  to  Gyantse  the  enemy  might  have  been  firing 
blank  cartridges  for  all  the  effect  they  had  left  on 
our  men.  At  Dzama  Tang  Bethune  had  made  a 
frontal  attack  on  a  strong  position,  and  carried  it 
without  losing  a  man.  Against  a  similar  rabble  it 
might  have  been  possible  to  rush  the  wall  with  his 
handful  of  Sikhs,  but  these  new  Kham  levies  who 
held  the  Karo  la  were  a  very  different  type  of  soldier. 


ADVANCE  OF  MISSION  OPPOSED.      i8i 

The  frontal  attack  was  a  terrible  mistake,  as  was 
shown  four  hours  afterwards,  when  the  enemy  were 
driven  from  their  position  without  further  loss  to 
ourselves  by  a  flanking  movement  on  the  right. 

At  twelve  o'clock  Major  Row,  after  a  laborious 
climb,  reached  a  point  on  a  hillside  level  with  the 
sangars,  which  were  strongly  held  on  a  narrow 
ledge  200  yards  in  front  of  him.  Here  he  sent  up 
a  section  of  his  men  under  cover  of  projecting  rocks 
to  get  above  the  sangars  and  fire  down  into  them. 
In  the  meanwhile  some  of  the  enemy  scrambled  on 
to  the  rocks  above,  and  began  throwing  down 
boulders  at  the  Gurkhas,  but  these  either  broke  up 
or  fell  harmless  on  the  shale  slopes  above.  After 
waiting  an  hour,  Major  Row  went  back  himself 
and  found  his  section  checked  half-way  by  the 
stone-throwing  and  shots  from  above ;  they  had 
tried  another  way,  but  found  it  impracticable. 

Keeping  a  few  men  back  to  fire  on  any  stone- 
throwers  who  showed  themselves.  Row  dribbled 
his  men  across  the  difficult  place,  and  in  half  an 
hour  reached  the  rocky  ledge  above  the  sangars  and 
looked  right  down  on  the  enemy.  At  the  first  few 
shots  from  the  Gurkhas  they  began  to  bolt,  and, 
coming  into  the  fire  of  the  men  below,  who  now 


i82  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

rushed  forward,  nearly  every  man — forty  in  all — 
was  killed.  One  or  two  who  escaped  the  fire  found 
their  flight  cut  off  by  a  precipice,  and  in  an  aban- 
donment of  terror  hurled  themselves  down  on  the 
rocks  below.  After  clearing  the  sangar,  the  Gurkhas 
had  only  to  surmount  the  natural  difficulties  of  the 
rocky  and  steep  hill ;  for  though  the  enemy  fired  on 
them  from  the  wall,  their  shooting  was  most  erratic. 
When  at  last  they  reached  a  small  spur  that  over- 
looked the  Tibetan  main  position,  they  found,  to 
their  disgust,  that  each  man  was  protected  from 
their  fire  by  a  high  stone  traverse,  on  the  right- 
hand  of  which  he  lay  secure,  and  fired  through 
loopholes  barely  a  foot  from  the  ground. 

The  Gurkhas  had  accomplished  a  most  difficult 
mountaineering  feat  under  a  heavy  fire ;  they  had 
turned  the  enemy  out  of  their  sangars,  and  after 
four  hours'  cUmbing  they  had  scaled  the  heights 
everyone  thought  inaccessible.  But  their  further 
progress  was  barred  by  a  sheer  cliff;  they  had 
reached  a  cul-de-sac.  Looking  up  from  the  valley, 
it  appeared  that  the  spot  where  they  stood  com- 
manded the  enemy's  position,  but  we  had  not  reck- 
oned on  the  traverses.  ,  This  amazing  advance  in 
the  enemy's  defensive  tactics  had  rendered  their 


ADVANCE  OF  MISSION  OPPOSED.       183 

position  unassailable  from  the  left,  and  made  the 
Gurkhas'  flanking  movement  a  splendid  failure. 

It  was  now  two  o'clock,  and,  except  for  the  cap- 
ture of  the  enemy's  right  sangars,  we  had  done 
nothing  to  weaken  their  opposition.  The  frontal 
and  flanking  attacks  had  failed.  Bethune  was 
killed,  and  seventeen  men.  Our  guns  had  made 
no  impression  on  their  wall.  Looking  down  from 
the  spur  which  overlooked  the  Tibetan  camp  and 
the  valley  beyond,  the  Gurkhas  could  see  a  large 
reinforcement  of  at  least  500  men  coming  up  to 
join  the  enemy.  The  situation  was  critical.  In 
four  hours  we  had  done  nothing,  and  we  knew  that 
if  we  could  not  take  the  place  by  dusk  we  would 
have  to  abandon  the  attack  or  attempt  to  rush 
the  camp  at  night.  That  would  have  been  a  des- 
perate undertaking — 400  men  against  3,000,  a  rush 
at  close  quarters  with  the  bayonet,  in  which  the 
superiority  of  our  modern  rifles  would  be  greatly 
discounted. 

Matters  were  at  this  crisis,  when  we  saw  the 
Tibetans  running  out  of  their  extreme  left  sangars. 
At  twelve  o'clock,  when  the  front  attack  had  failed 
and  the  left  attack  was  apparently  making  no  prog- 
ress, fifteen  men  of  the  32nd  who  were  held  in  re- 


i84  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

serve  were  sent  up  the  hill  on  the  right.  They  had 
reached  a  point  above  the  enemy's  left  forward 
sangar,  and  were  firing  into  it  with  great  effect. 
Twice  the  Tibetans  rushed  out,  and,  coming  under 
a  heavy  Maxim  fire,  bolted  back  again.  The  third 
time  they  fied  in  a  mass,  and  the  Maxims  mowed 
down  about  thirty.  The  capture  of  the  sangars 
was  a  signal  for  a  general  stampede.  From  the 
position  they  had  won  the  Sikhs  could  enfilade 
the  main  wall  itself.  The  Tibetans  only  waited  a 
few  shots  ;  then  they  turned  and  fled  in  three  huge 
bodies  down  the  valley.  Thus  the  fifteen  Sikhs 
on  the  right  saved  the  situation.  The  tension  had 
been  great.  In  no  other  action  during  the  cam- 
paign, if  we  except  Palla,  did  the  success  of  our 
arms  stand  so  long  in  doubt.  Had  we  failed  to 
take  the  wall  by  daylight.  Colonel  Brander's  col- 
umn would  have  been  in  a  most  precarious  position. 
We  could  not  afford  to  retire,  and  a  night  attack 
could  only  have  been  pushed  home  with  heavy  loss. 
Directly  the  flight  began,  the  ist  Mounted  In- 
fantry— forty-two  men,  under  Captain  Ottley — 
rode  up  to  the  wall.  They  were  ten  minutes  mak- 
ing a  breach.  Then  they  poured  into  the  valley 
and  harassed   the   flying  masses,   riding  on   their 


ADVANCE  OF  MISSION  OPPOSED.       185 

flanks  and  pursuing  them  for  ten  miles  to  within 
sight  of  the  Yamdok  Tso.  It  showed  extraordinary- 
courage  on  the  part  of  this  Httle  band  of  Masbis 
and  Gurkhas  that  they  did  not  hesitate  to  hurl 
themselves  on  the  flanks  of  this  enormous  body  of 
men,  like  terriers  on  the  heels  of  a  flock  of  cattle, 
though  they  had  had  experience  of  their  stubborn 
resistance  the  whole  day  long,  and  rode  through 
the  bodies  of  their  fallen  comrades.  Not  a  man 
drew  rein.  The  Tibetans  were  caught  in  a  trap. 
The  hills  that  sloped  down  to  the  valley  afforded 
them  little  cover.  Their  fate  was  only  a  question 
of  time  and  ammunition.  The  mounted  infantry 
returned  at  night  with  only  three  casualties,  having 
killed  over  300  men. 

The  sortie  to  the  Karo  la  was  one  of  the  most 
brilliant  episodes  of  the  campaign.  We  risked  more 
then  than  on  any  other  occasion.  But  the  safety 
of  the  mission  and  many  isolated  posts  on  the  line 
was  imperilled  by  this  large  force  at  the  cross-roads, 
which  might  have  increased  until  it  had  doubled 
or  trebled  if  we  had  not  gone  out  to  disperse  it. 
A  weak  commander  might  have  faltered  and  weighed 
the  odds,  but  Colonel  Brander  saw  that  it  was  a 
moment  to  strike,  and  struck  home.     His  action 


i86  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

was  criticised  at  the  time  as  too  adventurous.  But 
the  sortie  is  one  of  the  many  instances  that  our 
interests  are  best  cared  for  by  men  who  are  beyond 
the  telegraph-poles,  and  can  act  on  their  own  ini- 
tiative without  reference  to  Government  offices  in 
Simla. 

As  the  column  advanced  to  the  Karo  la,  a  mes- 
sage was  received  that  the  mission  camp  at  Gyantse 
had  been  attacked  in  the  early  morning  of  the  5th, 
and  that  Major  Murray's  men — 150  odd  rifles — 
had  not  only  beaten  the  enemy  off,  but  had  made 
three  sorties  from  different  points  and  killed  200. 

With  the  action  at  the  Karo  la  and  the  attack 
on  the  mission  at  Gyantse  began  the  second  phase 
of  the  operations,  during  which  we  were  practically 
besieged,  in  our  own  camp,  and  for  nine  weeks  com- 
pelled to  act  on  the  defensive.  The  courage  of  the 
Tibetans  was  now  proved  beyond  a  doubt.  The 
new  levies  from  Kham  and  Shigatze  were  composed 
of  very  different  men  from  those  we  herded  hke 
sheep  at  Guru.  They  were  also  better  armed  than 
our  previous  assailants,  and  many  of  them  knew 
how  to  shoot.  At  the  same  time  they  were  better 
led.  The  primitive  ideas  of  strategy  hitherto  dis- 
played by  the  Tibetans  gave  place  to  more  advanced 


ADVANCE  OF  MISSION  OPPOSED.       187 

tactics.  The  usual  story  got  wind  that  the  Tibetans 
were  being  led  by  trained  Russian  Buriats.  But 
there  was  no  truth  in  it.  The  altered  conditions 
of  the  campaign,  as  we  may  call  it,  after  it  became 
necessary  to  begin  active  operations,  were  due  to 
the  force  of  circumstances — the  arrival  of  stouter 
levies  from  the  east,  the  great  numerical  superiority 
of  the  enemy,  and  their  strongly  fortified  positions. 

The  operations  at  Gyantse  are  fully  dealt  with 
in  another  chapter,  and  I  will  conclude  this  account 
of  the  opposition  to  our  advance  with  a  descrip- 
tion of  the  attack  on  the  Kangma  post,  the  only 
attempt  on  the  part  of  the  enemy  to  cut  off  our 
line  of  communications.  Its  complete  failure  seems 
to  have  deterred  the  Tibetans  from  subsequent  ven- 
tures of  the  kind. 

From  Ralung,  ten  miles  this  side  of  the  Karo  la, 
two  roads  branch  off  to  India.  The  road  leading 
to  Kangma  is  the  shortest  route ;  the  other  road 
makes  a  detour  of  thirty  miles  to  include  Gyantse. 
Ralung  lies  at  the  apex  of  the  triangle,  as  shown 
in  the  rough  diagram.  Gyantse  and  Kangma  form 
the  two  base  angles. 

If  it  had  been  possible,  a  strong  post  would  have 
been  left  at  the  Karo  la  after  the  action  of  May  6. 


i88         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 


■<7 


KANaUA 


But  our  small  force  was  barely  sufficient  to  garri- 
son Gyantse,  and  we  had  to  leave  the  alternative 
approach  to  Kangma  unguarded.  An  attack  was 
expected  there  i  the  post  was  strongly  fortified, 
and  garrisoned  by  two  companies  of  the  23rd  Pion- 
eers, under  Captain  Pearson. 

The  attack,  which  was  made  on  June  7,  was  un- 
expectedly dramatic.  We  have  learnt  that  the 
Tibetan  has  courage,  but  in  other  respects  he  is 
still  an  unknown  quantity.  In  motive  and  action 
he  is  as  mysterious  and  unaccountable  as  his  para- 
doxical associations  would  lead  us  to  imagine.  In 
dealing  with  the  Tibetans  one  must  expect  the 
unexpected.  They  will  try  to  achieve  the  impossible, 
and  shut  their  eyes  to  the  obvious.  They  have  a 
genius  for  doing  the  wrong  thing  at  the  wrong  time. 
Their  ^lan,  their  dogged  courage,  their  undoubted 
heroism,  their  occasional  acuteness,  their  more  gen- 
eral imbecile  folly  and  vacillation  and  inability  to 
grasp  a  situation,  make  it  impossible  to  say  what 


ADVANCE  OF  MISSION  OPPOSED.       189 

they  will  do  in  any  given  circumstances.  A  few 
dozen  men  will  hurl  themselves  against  hopeless 
odds,  and  die  to  a  man  fighting  desperately  ;  a 
handful  of  impressed  peasants  will  devote  them- 
selves to  death  in  the  defence  of  a  village,  like  the 
old  Roman  patriots.  At  other  times  they  will  for- 
sake a  strongly  sangared  position  at  the  first  shot, 
and  thousands  will  prowl  round  a  camp  at  night, 
shouting  grotesquely,  but  too  timid  to  make  a  deter- 
mined attack  on  a  vastly  outnumbered  enemy. 

The  uncertainty  of  the  enemy  may  be  accounted 
for  to  some  extent  by  the  fact  that  we  are  not  often 
opposed  by  the  same  levies,  which  would  imply 
that  theirs  is  greatly  the  courage  of  ignorance. 
Yet  in  the  face  of  the  fighting  at  Palla,  Naini,  and 
Gyantse  Jong,  this  is  evidently  no  fair  estimate 
of  the  Tibetan  spirit.  The  men  who  stood  in  the 
breach  at  Gyantse  in  that  hell  of  shrapnel  and 
Maxim  and  rifle  fire,  and  dropped  down  stones  on 
our  Gurkhas  as  they  climbed  the  wall,  met  death 
knowingly,  and  were  unterrified  by  the  resources 
of  modern  science  in  war,  the  magic,  the  demons, 
the  unseen,  unimagined  messengers  of  death. 

But  the  men  who  attacked  the  Kangma  post, 
what  parallel  in  history  have  we  for  these  ?    They 


igo         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

came  by  night  many  miles  over  steep  mountain 
cliffs  and  rocky  ravines,  perhaps  silently,  with  deter- 
mined purpose,  weighing  the  odds ;  or,  as  I  like  to 
think,  boastfully,  with  song  and  jest,  saying,  '  We 
will  steal  in  upon  these  English  at  dawn  before 
they  wake,  and  slay  them  in  their  beds.  Then  we 
will  hold  the  fort  and  kill  all  who  come  near.* 

They  came  in  the  gray  before  dawn,  and  hid  in 
a  gully  beside  our  camp.  At  five  the  reveille 
sounded  and  the  sentry  left  the  bastions.  Then 
they  sprang  up  and  rushed,  sword  in  hand,  their 
rifles  slung  behind  their  backs,  to  the  wall.  The 
whole  attack  was  directed  on  the  south-east  front, 
an  unscalable  wall  of  solid  masonry,  with  bastions 
at  each  comer  four  feet  thick  and  ten  feet 
high.  They  directed  their  attack  on  the  bastions, 
the  only  point  on  that  side  they  could  scramble 
over.  They  knew  nothing  of  the  fort  and  its  trac- 
ing. Perhaps  they  had  expected  to  find  us  en- 
camped in  tents  on  the  open  ground.  But  from 
the  shallow  nullah  where  they  lay  concealed,  not 
200  yards  distant,  and  watched  our  sentry,  they 
could  survey  the  uncompromising  front  which  they 
had  set  themselves  to  attack  with  the  naked  sword. 
They  had  no  artillery  or  guncotton  or  materials 


ADVANCE  OF  MISSION  OPPOSED.       191 

for  a  siege,  but  they  hoped  to  scale  the  wall  and 
annihilate  the  garrison  that  held  it.  They  had 
come  from  Lhasa  to  take  Kangma,  and  they  were 
not  going  to  turn  back.  They  came  on  undis- 
mayed, like  men  flushed  with  victory.  The  sepoys 
said  they  must  be  drunk  or  drugged.  They  rushed 
to  the  bottom  of  the  wall,  tore  out  stones,  and  flung 
them  up  at  our  sepoys  ;  they  leapt  up  to  seize  the 
muzzles  of  our  rifles,  and  scrambled  to  gain  a  foot- 
hold and  lift  themselves  on  to  the  parapet ;  they 
fell  bullet-pierced,  and  some  turned  savagely  on 
the  wall  again.  It  was  only  a  question  of  time, 
of  minutes,  and  the  cool  mechanical  fire  of  the 
23rd  Pioneers  would  have  dropped  every  man. 
One  hundred  and  six  bodies  were  left  under  the 
wall,  and  sixty  more  were  killed  in  the  pursuit. 
Never  was  there  such  a  hopeless,  helpless  struggle, 
such  desperate  and  ineffectual  gallantry. 

Almost  before  it  was  light  the  yak  corps  with 
their  small  escort  of  thirty  rifles  of  the  2nd  Gurkhas 
were  starting  on  the  road  to  Kalatso.  They  had 
passed  the  hiding-place  of  the  Tibetans  without 
noticing  the  500  men  in  rusty-coloured  cloaks 
breathing  quietly  among  the  brown  stones.  Then 
the  Tibetans  made  their  charge,  just  as  the  trans- 


192  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

port  had  passed,  and  a  party  of  them  made  for  the 
yaks.  Two  Tibetan  drivers  in  our  service  stood 
directly  in  their  path.  *  Who  are  you  ?  '  cried  one 
of  the  enemy.  *  Only  yak-drivers/  was  the  fright- 
ened answer.  '  Then,  take  that,*  the  Tibetan  said, 
slashing  at  his  arm  with  no  intent  to  kill.  The 
Gurkha  escort  took  up  a  position  behind  a  sangar 
and  opened  fire — all  save  one  man,  who  stood  by  his 
yak  and  refused  to  come  under  cover,  despite  the 
shouts  and  warnings  of  his  comrades.  He  killed 
several,  but  fell  himself,  hacked  to  pieces  with 
swords.  The  Tibetans  were  driven  off,  and  joined 
the  rout  from  the  fort.  The  whole  affair  lasted 
less  than  ten  minutes. 

Our  casualties  were :  the  isolated  Gurkha  killed, 
two  men  in  the  fort  wounded  by  stones,  and  three 
of  the  2nd  Gurkhas  severely  wounded — two  by 
sword-cuts,  one  by  a  bullet  in  the  neck. 

But  what  was  the  flame  that  smouldered  in  these 
men  and  hghted  them  to  action  7  They  might  have 
been  Paladins  or  Crusaders.  But  the  Buddhists 
are  not  fanatics.  They  do  not  stake  eternity  on  a 
single  existence.  They  have  no  Mahdis  or  Jugger- 
naut cars.  The  Tibetans,  we  are  told,  are  not 
patriots.     Pohticians  say  that  they  want  us  in  their 


ADVANCE  OF  MISSION  OPPOSED.       193 

country,  that  they  are  priest-ridden,  and  hate  and 
fear  their  Lamas.  What,  then,  drove  them  on  ? 
It  was  certainly  not  fear.  No  people  on  earth  have 
shown  a  greater  contempt  for  death.  Their  Lamas 
were  with  them  until  the  final  assault.  Twenty 
shaven  polls  were  found  hiding  in  the  nullah  down 
which  the  Tibetans  had  crept  in  the  dark,  and  were 
immediately  despatched.  What  promises  and  ca- 
joleries and  threats  the  holy  men  used  no  one  will 
ever  know.  But  whatever  the  alternative,  their 
simple  followers  preferred  death. 

The  second  phase  of  the  operations,  in  which  we 
had  to  act  on  the  defensive  in  Gyantse,  and  the 
beginning  of  the  third  phase,  which  saw  the  arrival 
of  reinforcements  and  the  collapse  of  the  Tibetan 
opposition,  are  described  by  an  eye-witness  in  the 
next  two  chapters.  During  the  whole  of  these 
operations  I  was  invahded  in  Darjeeling,  owing  to 
a  second  operation  which  had  to  be  performed  on 
my  amputation  wound. 


CHAPTER    IX 

GYANTSE 

[By  Henry  Newman] 

GYANTSE  PLAIN  lies  at  the  intersection  of  four 
great  valleys  running  almost  at  right  angles 
to  one  another.  In  the  north-eastern  comer  there 
emerge  two  gigantic  ridges  of  sandstone.  On  one 
is  built  the  jong,  and  on  the  other  the  monastery. 
The  town  fringes  the  base  of  the  jong,  and  creeps 
into  the  hollow  between  the  two  ridges.  The  plain, 
about  six  miles  by  ten,  is  cultivated  almost  to  the 
last  inch,  if  we  except  a  few  stony  patches  here  and 
there.  There  are,  I  believe,  thirty-three  villages 
in  the  plain.  These  are  built  in  the  midst  of  groves 
of  poplar  and  willow.  At  one  time,  no  doubt,  the 
waters  from  the  four  valleys  united  to  form  a  lake. 
Now  they  have  found  an  outlet,  and  flow  peacefully 
down  Shigatze  way.  High  up  on  the  cold  moun- 
tains one  sees  the  cold  bleached  walls  of  the  Seven 


GYANTSE.  195 

Monasteries,  some  of  them  perched  on  almost  inac- 
cessible chffs,  whence  they  look  sternly  down  on 
the  warmth  and  prosperity  below. 

For  centuries  the  Gyantse  folk  had  lived  self- 
contained  and  happy,  practising  their  simple  arts 
of  agriculture,  and  but  dimly  aware  of  any  world 
outside  their  own.  Then  one  day  there  marched 
into  their  midst  a  column  of  British  troops — white- 
faced  Englishmen,  dark,  Hthe  Gurkhas,  great,  solemn, 
bearded  Sikhs — and  it  was  borne  in  upon  the  wonder- 
ing Gyantse  men  that  beyond  their  frontiers  there 
existed  great  nations — so  great,  indeed,  that  they 
ventured  to  dispute  on  equal  terms  with  the  awful 
personage  who  ruled  from  Lhasa.  It  is  true  that 
from  time  to  time  there  must  have  passed  through 
Gyantse  rumours  of  war  on  the  distant  frontier. 
The  armies  that  we  defeated  at  Guru  and  in  the 
Red  Idol  Gorge  had  camped  at  Gyantse  on  their 
way  to  and  fro.  Gyantse  saw  and  wondered  at 
the  haste  of  Lhasa  despatch-riders.  But  I  question 
whether  any  Gyantse  man  realized  that  events, 
great  and  shattering  in  his  world,  were  impending 
when  the  British  column  rounded  the  corner  of 
Naini  Valley. 

At  first  we  were  received  without  hostility,  or 


196  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

even  suspicion.  The  ruined  jong,  uninhabited  save 
for  a  few  droning  Lamas,  was  surrendered  as  soon 
as  we  asked  for  it.  A  clump  of  buildings  in  a  large 
grove  near  the  river  was  rented  without  demur — 
though  at  a  price — to  the  Commission.  And  when 
the  country-people  found  that  there  was  a  sale  for 
their  produce,  they  flocked  to  the  camp  to  sell. 
The  entry  of  the  British  troops  made  no  difference  to 
the  peace  of  Gyantse  till  the  Lamas  of  Lhasa  em- 
barked on  the  fatal  policy  of  levying  more  troops  in 
Lhasa,  Shigatze,  and  far-away  Kham,  and  sending 
them  down  to  fight.  Then  there  entered  the  peace- 
ful valley  all  the  horrors  of  war — dead  and  maimed 
men  in  the  streets  and  houses,  burning  villages, 
death  and  destruction  of  all  kinds.  Gyantse  Plain 
and  the  town  became  scenes  of  desolation.  To  the 
British  army  in  India  war,  unfortunately,  is  noth- 
ing new,  but  one  can  imagine  what  an  upheaval  this 
business  of  which  I  am  about  to  write  meant  to 
people  who  for  generations  had  hved  in  peace. 

The  incidents  connected  with  the  arrival  of  the 
mission  with  its  escort  at  Gyantse  need  not  be  de- 
scribed in  detail.  On  the  day  of  arrival  we  camped 
in  the  midst  of  some  fallow  fields  about  two  miles 
from  the  jong.    The  same  afternoon  a  Chinese  ofl&- 


GYANTSE.  197 

cial,  who  called  himself  '  General  *  Ma,  came  into 
camp  with  the  news  that  the  jong  was  unoccupied, 
and  that  the  local  Tibetans  did  not  propose  to  offer 
any  resistance.  The  next  morning  we  took  quiet 
possession  of  the  jong,  placing  two  companies  of 
Pioneers  in  garrison.  The  General  with  a  small 
escort  visited  the  monastery  behind  the  fort,  and 
was  received  with  friendliness  by  the  venerable 
Abbot.  Neither  the  villagers  nor  the  towns-people 
showed  any  signs  of  resentment  at  our  presence. 
The  Jongpen  actively  interested  himself  in  the  ques- 
tion of  procuring  an  official  residence  for  Colonel 
Younghusband  and  the  members  of  the  mission. 
There  were  reports  of  the  Dalai  Lama's  representa- 
tives coming  in  haste  to  treat.  Altogether  the  out- 
look was  so  promising  that  nobody  was  surprised 
when,  after  a  stay  of  a  week,  General  Macdonald, 
bearing  in  mind  the  difficulty  of  procuring  supplies 
for  the  whole  force,  announced  his  intention  of  re- 
turning to  Chumbi  with  the  larger  portion  of  the 
escort,  leaving  a  sufficient  guard  with  the  mission. 

The  guard  left  behind  consisted  of  four  com- 
panies of  the  32nd  Pioneers,  under  Colonel  Brander  3 
four  companies  of  the  8th  Gurkhas,  under  Major 
Row;    the  ist  Mounted  Infantry,  under  Captain 


198  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

Ottley ;  and  the  machine  gun  section  of  the  Nor- 
folks,  under  Lieutenant  Hadow.  Mention  should 
also  be  made  of  the  two  7-pounder  mountain-guns 
attached  to  the  8th  Gurkhas,  under  the  command 
of  Captain  Luke. 

Before  the  General  left  for  Chumbi  he  decided 
to  evacuate  the  jong.  The  grounds  on  which  this 
decision  was  come  to  were  that  the  whole  place 
was  in  a  ruinous  and  dangerous  condition,  the  sur- 
roundings were  insanitary,  there  was  only  one  build- 
ing fit  for  human  habitation,  the  water  supply  was 
bad  and  deficient,  and  there  seemed  to  be  no  pros- 
pect of  further  hostihties.  Besides,  from  the  mili- 
tary point  of  view  there  was  some  risk  in  splitting 
up  the  small  guard  to  be  left  behind  between  the 
jong  and  the  mission  post.  However,  the  precau- 
tion was  taken  of  further  dismantling  the  jong. 
The  gateways  and  such  portions  as  seemed  capable 
of  lending  themselves  to  defence,  were  blown  up. 

The  house,  or,  rather,  group  of  houses,  rented  by 
Colonel  Younghusband  for  the  mission  was  situated 
about  100  yards  from  a  well-made  stone  bridge 
over  the  river.  A  beautiful  grove,  mostly  of  willow, 
extended  behind  the  post  along  the  banks  of  the 
river  to  a  distance  of  about  500  yards.     The  jong 


GYANTSE.  199 

lay  about  1,800  yards  to  the  right  front.  There 
were  two  houses  in  the  intervening  space,  built 
amongst  fields  of  iris  and  barley.  Small  groups 
of  trees  were  dotted  here  and  there.  Altogether, 
the  post  was  located  in  a  spot  as  pleasant  as  one 
could  hopd  to  find  in  Tibet. 

For  some  days  before  the  General  left,  all  the 
troops  were  engaged  in  putting  the  post  in  a  state 
of  defence.  It  was  found  that  the  force  to  be  left 
behind  could  be  easily  located  within  the  perimeter 
of  a  wall  built  round  the  group  of  houses.  There 
was  no  room,  however,  for  200  mules  and  their 
drivers,  needed  for  convoy  purposes.  These  were 
placed  in  a  kind  of  horn-work  thrown  out  to  the 
right  front. 

After  the  departure  of  the  General  we  resigned 
ourselves  to  what  we  conceived  would  be  a  monot- 
onous stay  at  Gyantse  of  two  or  three  months, 
pending  the  signing  of  the  treaty.  The  people 
continued  to  be  perfectly  friendly.  A  market  was 
estabUshed  outside  the  post,  to  which  practically 
the  whole  bazaar  from  Gyantse  town  was  removed. 
We  were  able  to  buy  in  the  market,  very  cheap, 
the  famous  Gyantse  carpets,  for  which  enormous 
prices  are  demanded  at  Darjeeling  and  elsewhere 


200  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

in  India.  Unarmed  officers  wandered  freely  about 
Gyantse  town,  and  the  monks  of  Palkhor  Choide, 
the  monastery  behind  the  fort,  wilHngly  conducted 
parties  over  the  most  sacred  spots.  They  even 
readily  sold  some  of  the  images  before  the  altars, 
and  the  silk  screens  which  shrouded  the  forms  of 
the  gigantic  Buddhas.  I  mention  these  facts  about 
the  carpets  and  images  because,  when  hereafter 
they  adorned  Simla  and  Darjeeling  drawing-rooms, 
unkind  people  began  to  say  that  British  officers 
had  wantonly  looted  Palkhor  Choide,  one  of  the 
most  famous  monasteries  in  Tibet. 

A  little  shooting  was  to  be  had,  and  officers  wan- 
dered about  the  plain,  gun  in  hand,  bringing  home 
mountain-hare — a  queer  little  beast  with  a  blue 
rump — duck,  and  pigeon.  Occasionally  an  excursion 
up  one  of  the  side  valleys  would  result  in  the  shooting 
of  a  biurhel  or  of  a  Tibetan  gazelle.  The  country- 
people  met  with  were  all  perfectly  friendly. 

Another  feature  of  those  first  few  peaceful  days 
at  Gyantse  was  the  eagerness  with  which  the  Tibetans 
availed  themselves  of  the  skilled  medical  attendance 
with  the  mission.  At  first  only  one  or  two  men 
wounded  at  the  Red  Idol  Gorge  were  brought  in, 
but  the  skill  of  Captain  Walton,   Indian  Medical 


GYANTSE.  201 

Service,  soon  began  to  be  noised  abroad,  and  every 
morning  the  little  outdoor  dispensary  was  crowded 
with  sufferers  of  all  kinds. 

But  during  the  last  week  in  May  reports  began 
to  reach  Colonel  Younghusband  that,  so  far  from 
attempting  to  enter  into  negotiations,  the  Lhasa 
Government  was  levying  an  army  in  Kham,  and 
that  already  five  or  six  hundred  men  were  camped 
on  the  other  side  of  the  Karo  la,  and  were  busily 
engaged  in  building  a  wall.  Lieutenant  Hodgson 
with  a  small  force  was  sent  to  reconnoitre.  He 
came  back  with  the  news  that  the  wall  was  already 
built,  stretching  from  one  side  of  the  valley  to  the 
other,  and  that  there  were  several  thousand  well- 
armed  men  behind  it.  Both  Colonel  Younghus- 
band and  Colonel  Brander  considered  it  highly  neces- 
sary that  this  gathering  should  be  immediately  dis- 
persed, for  it  is  a  principle  in  Indian  frontier  war- 
fare to  strike  quickly  at  any  tribal  assembly,  in 
order  to  prevent  it  growing  into  dangerous  propor- 
tions. The  possibly  exciting  effect  the  force  on 
the  Karo  la  might  have  on  the  inhabitants  of  Gy- 
antse  had  particularly  to  be  considered.  Accord- 
ingly, on  May  3  Colonel  Brander  led  the  major 
portion  of  the  Gyantse  garrison  towards  the  Karo 
7« 


202  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

la,  leaving  behind  as  a  guard  to  the  post  two  com- 
panies of  Gurkhas,  a  company  of  the  32nd  Pioneers, 
and  a  few  mounted  infantry,  all  under  the  command 
of  Major  Murray. 

I  accompanied  the  Karo  la  column,  and  must 
rely  on  hearsay  as  to  my  facts  with  regard  to  the 
attack  on  the  mission.  We  heard  about  the  attack 
the  night  before  Colonel  Brander  drove  the  Tibetans 
from  their  wall  on  the  Karo  la,  after  a  long  fight 
which  altered  all  our  previous  conceptions  of  the 
fighting  qualities  of  the  Tibetans.  The  courage 
shown  by  the  enemy  naturally  excited  apprehension 
about  the  safety  of  the  mission.  Colonel  Brander 
did  not  stay  to  rest  his  troops  after  their  day  of 
arduous  fighting,  but  began  his  return  march  next 
morning,  arriving  at  Gyantse  on  the  9th. 

The  column  had  been  warned  that  it  was  hkely 
to  be  fired  on  from  the  jong  if  it  entered  camp  by 
the  direct  Lhasa  road.  Accordingly,  we  marched 
in  by  a  circuitous  route,  moving  in  under  cover  of 
the  grove  previously  mentioned.  The  Maxims  and 
guns  came  into  action  at  the  edge  of  the  grove  to 
cover  the  baggage.  But,  though  numbers  of  Ti- 
betans were  seen  on  the  walls  of  the  jong,  not  a 
shot  was  fired. 


GYANTSE.  203 

We  then  learnt  the  story  of  the  attack  on  the 
post.  .  It  appears  that  the  day  after  Colonel  Brander 
left  for  the  Karo  la  (May  3)  certain  wounded  and 
sick  Tibetans  that  we  had  been  attending  informed 
the  mission  that  about  1,000  armed  men  had  come 
down  towards  Gyantse  from  Shigatze,  and  were 
building  a  wall  about  twelve  miles  away.  It  was 
added  that  they  might  possibly  attack  the  post  if 
they  got  to  know  that  the  garrison  had  been  largely 
depleted.  This  news  seemed  to  be  worth  inquiring 
into,  and,  accordingly,  next  day  Major  Murray  sent 
some  mounted  infantry  to  reconnoitre  up  the  Shi- 
gatze road.  The  latter  returned  with  the  infor- 
mation that  they  had  gone  up  the  valley  some 
seven  or  eight  miles,  but  had  found  no  signs  of  any 
enemy. 

The  very  next  morning  the  post  was  attacked 
at  dawn.  It  appears  that  the  Shigatze  force,  about 
1,000  strong,  was  really  engaged  in  building  a  wall 
twelve  miles  away.  Hearing  that  very  few  troops 
were  guarding  the  mission,  its  commander — who,  I 
hear,  was  none  other  than  Khomba  Bombu,  the 
very  man  who  arrested  Sven  Hedin's  dash  to  Lhasa 
— determined  to  make  a  sudden  attack  on  the  post. 
He  marched  his  men  during  the  night,  and  about 


204         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

an  hour  before  sunrise  had  them  crouching  behind 
trees  and  inside  ditches  all  round  the  post. 

The  attack  was  sudden  and  simultaneous.  A 
Gurkha  sentry  had  just  time  to  fire  off  his  rifle 
before  the  Tibetans  rushed  to  our  walls,  and  had 
their  muskets  through  our  loopholes.  The  enemy 
did  not  for  the  moment  attempt  to  scale,  but  con- 
tented themselves  with  firing  into  the  post  through 
the  loopholes  they  had  taken.  This  delay  proved 
fatal  to  their  plans,  for  it  gave  the  small  garrison 
time  to  rise  and  arm.  The  brunt  of  the  Tibetan 
fire  was  directed  on  the  courtyard  of  the  house  where 
the  tents  of  the  members  of  the  mission  were  pitched. 
Major  Murray,  who  had  rushed  out  of  bed  half  clad, 
first  directed  his  attention  to  this  spot.  The  Sikhs, 
emerging  from  their  tents  with  bandolier  and  rifle, 
in  extraordinary  costumes,  were  directed  towards 
the  loopholes.  Some  were  sent  on  the  roof  of  the 
mission-house,  whence  they  could  enfilade  the 
attackers.  Elsewhere  various  junior  officers  had 
taken  command.  Captain  Luke,  who,  owing  to 
sickness,  had  not  gone  on  with  the  Karo  la  column, 
took  charge  of  the  Gurkhas  on  the  south  and  west 
fronts.  Lieutenant  Franklin,  the  medical  officer  of 
the  8th  Gurkhas,  raUied  Gurkhas  and  Pioneers  to 


GYANTSE.  205 

the  loopholes  on  the  east  and  north.  Lieutenant 
Lynch,  the  treasure-chest  officer,  who  had  a  guard 
of  about  twenty  Gurkhas,  took  his  men  to  the  main 
gate  to  the  south.  There  were  at  this  time  in  hos- 
pital about  a  dozen  Sikhs,  who  had  been  badly 
burnt  in  a  lamentable  gunpowder  explosion  a  few 
days  previously.  These  men,  bandaged  and  crippled 
as  they  were,  rose  from  their  couches,  made  their 
painful  way  to  the  tops  of  the  houses,  and  fired  into 
the  enemy  below.  About  a  dozen  Tibetans  had 
just  begun  to  scramble  over  the  wall  by  the  time 
the  defenders  had  manned  the  whole  position,  which 
was  now  not  only  held  by  fighting  men,  but  by 
various  members  of  the  mission,  including  Colonel 
Younghusband,  who  had  emerged  with  revolvers  and 
sporting  guns.  A  few  of  the  enemy  got  inside  the 
defences,  and  were  immediately  shot  down. 

Our  fire  was  so  heavy  and  so  well  directed  that 
it  is  supposed  that  not  more  than  ten  minutes 
elapsed  from  the  time  the  first  shot  was  fired 
to  the  time  the  enemy  began  to  withdraw.  The 
withdrawal,  however,  was  only  to  the  shelter  of 
trees  and  ditches  a  few  hundred  yards  away, 
whence  a  long  but  almost  harmless  fusillade  was 
kept  up  on  the  post.    After  about  twenty  minutes 


2o6  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

of  this  firing,  Major  Murray  determined  on  a  rally. 
Lieutenant  Lynch  with  his  treasure  guard  dashed 
out  from  the  south  gate.  Some  five-and-twenty 
Tibetans  were  discovered  hiding  in  a  small  refuse 
hut  about  fifteen  yards  from  the  gate.  The 
furious  Gurkhas  rushed  in  upon  them  and  killed 
them  all,  and  then  dashed  on  through  the  long 
grove,  clearing  the  enemy  in  front  of  them.  Re- 
turning along  the  banks  of  the  river,  the  same 
party  discovered  another  body  of  Tibetans  hiding 
under  the  arches  of  the  bridge.  Twenty  or  thirty 
were  shot  down,  and  about  fifteen  made  prisoners. 
Similar  success  attended  a  rally  from  the  north- 
east gate  made  by  Major  Murray  and  Lieutenant 
Franklin.  The  enemy  fled  howling  from  their 
hiding-places  towards  the  town  and  jong  as  soon 
as  they  saw  our  men  issue.  They  were  pursued 
almost  to  the  very  walls  of  the  fort.  Indeed,  but 
for  the  fringe  of  houses  and  narrow  streets  at  the 
base  of  the  jong,  Major  Murray  would  have  gone 
on.  The  Tibetans,  however,  turned  as  soon  as 
they  reached  the  shelter  of  walls,  and  it  would 
have  been  madness  to  attack  five  or  six  hundred 
determined  men  in  a  maze  of  alleys  and  passages 
with  only  a  weak  company.     Major  Murray,   ac- 


GYANTSE.  207 

cordingly  made  his  way  back  to  the  post,  picking 
up  a  dozen  prisoners  en  route. 

In  this  affair  our  casualties  only  amounted  to 
five  wounded  and  two  killed.  One  hundred  and 
forty  dead  of  the  enemy  were  counted  outside  the 
camp. 

During  the  course  of  the  day  Major  Murray  sent 
a  flag  of  truce  to  the  jong  with  an  intimation  to 
the  effect  that  the  Tibetans  could  come  out  and 
bury  their  dead  without  fear  of  molestation.  The 
reply  was  that  we  could  bury  the  dead  ourselves 
without  fear  of  molestation.  As  it  was  impossible 
to  leave  all  the  bodies  in  the  vicinity  of  the  camp, 
a  heavy  and  disagreeable  task  was  thrown  on  the 
garrison. 

Towards  sundown  the  enemy  in  the  jong  began 
to  fire  into  the  camp,  and  our  troops  became 
aware  of  the  unpleasant  fact  that  the  Tibetans 
possessed  jingals,  which  could  easily  range  from 
1,800  to  2,000  yards.  It  was  also  realized  that 
the  jong  entirely  dominated  the  post  j  that  our 
walls  and  stockades,  protection  enough  against 
a  direct  assault  from  the  plain,  were  no  protec- 
tion against  bullets  dropped  from  a  height.  So 
for  the  next  four  days,  pending  the  return  of  the 


2o8  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

Karo  la  column,  the  little  garrison  toiled  unceas- 
ingly at  improving  the  defences.  Traverses  were 
built,  the  walls  raised  in  height,  the  gates  strength- 
ened. It  was  discovered  that  the  Tibetan  fire  was 
heaviest  when  we  attempted  to  return  it  by  sniping 
at  figures  seen  on  the  Jong.  Accordingly,  pending 
the  completion  of  the  traverses  and  other  new 
protective  works.  Major  Murray  forbade  any  return 
fire. 

Such  was  the  position  of  affairs  when  the  Karo  la 
column  returned.  One  of  Colonel  Brander's  first 
acts,  after  his  weary  troops  had  rested  for  an  hour 
or  two,  was  to  turn  the  Maxim  on  the  groups  who 
could  be  seen  wandering  about  the  jong.  They 
quickly  disappeared  under  cover,  but  only  to  man 
their  jingals.  Then  began  the  bombardment  of 
the  post,  which  we  had  to  endure  for  nearly  seven 
weeks. 

This  is  the  place  to  speak  of  the  bombardment 
generally,  for  it  would  be  tedious  to  recapitulate 
in  the  form  of  a  diary  incidents  which,  however 
exciting  at  the  time,  now  seem  remarkable  only 
for  their  monotony.  It  may  be  said  at  once  that 
the  bombardment  was  singularly  ineffective.  From 
first  to  last  only  fifteen  men  in  the  post  were  hit. 


GYANTSE.  209 

Of  these  twelve  were  either  killed  or  died  of  the 
wound.  Of  course,  I  exclude  the  casualties  in  the 
fighting,  of  which  I  will  presently  speak,  outside 
the  post.  But  the  futihty  of  the  bombardment 
must  not  be  entirely  put  down  to  bad  marksman- 
ship on  the  part  of  the  Tibetans.  That  our  losses 
were  not  heavier  is  largely  due  to  the  fact  that 
the  garrison  laboured  daily — and  at  first  at  night 
also — in  erecting  protecting  walls  and  traverses. 
Practically  every  tent  had  a  traverse  built  in 
front  of  it.  It  was  found  that  the  homwork  in 
which  the  mules  were  located  came  particularly 
under  fire  of  the  jong.  This  was  pulled  down  one 
dark  night,  and  the  mules  transferred  to  a  fresh 
enclosure  at  the  back  of  the  post.  Strong  para- 
pets of  sand-bags  were  built  on  the  roofs  of  the 
houses.  Every  window  facing  the  jong  was  securely 
blocked  with  mud  bricks.  It  will  be  realized  how 
considerable  was  the  labour  involved  in  building 
the  traverses  when  it  is  remembered  that  the  jong 
looked  down  into  the  post.  The  majority  of  the 
walls  had  to  be  considerably  higher  than  the  tents 
themselves.  They  were  mostly  built  of  stakes  cut 
from  the  grove,  with  two  feet  of  esirth  rammed 
in  between.    After  the  first  week  or  so  the  enemy 


210  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

brought  to  bear  on  the  post  several  brass  cannon, 
throwing  balls  weighing  four  or  five  pounds,  and 
travelling  with  a  velocity  which  enabled  them  to 
penetrate  our  traverses — when  they  struck  them, 
for  the  majority  of  shots  from  the  cannon  whistled 
harmlessly  over  our  heads. 

Practically,  we  did  not  return  the  fire  from  the 
jong.  All  that  was  done  in  this  direction  was  to 
place  one  of  Lieutenant  Hadow's  Maxims  on  the 
roof  of  the  house  occupied  by  the  mission,  and 
thence  to  snipe  during  the  daylight  hours  at  any 
warriors  who  showed  themselves  above  the  walls 
of  the  jong.  Hadow  was  very  patient  and  per- 
sistent with  his  gun,  and  quickly  made  it  clear  to 
the  Tibetans  that,  if  we  were  obhged  to  keep  under 
cover,  so  were  they.  But  our  fire  from  the  post 
was  probably  as  ineffective  as  that  of  the  enemy 
from  the  jong,  for  the  Tibetans  build  walls  with 
extraordinary  rapidity.  Working  mostly  at  night 
in  order  to  avoid  the  mahgnant  Maxim,  the  enemy 
within  a  few  days  almost  altered  the  face  of  the 
Jong.  New  walls,  traverses,  and  covered  ways 
seemed  to  spring  up  with  the  rapidity  of  mush- 
rooms. 

Our  life  during  the  siege,  if  so  the  bombardment 


GYANTSE.  211 

can  be  called,  was  hardly  as  unpleasant  as  people 
might  imagine.  To  begin  with,  we  were  never 
short  of  food — that  is  to  say,  of  Tibetan  barley 
and  meat.  The  commissariat  stock  of  tea — a. 
necessity  in  Tibet — also  never  gave  out.  From 
time  to  time  also  convoys  and  parcel-posts  with 
little  luxuries  came  through.  Again,  the  longest 
period  for  which  we  were  without  a  letter-post 
was  eight  days.  Socially,  the  relations  of  the 
officers  with  one  another  and  with  the  members 
of  the  Commission  were  most  harmonious.  I  make 
a  point  of  mentioning  this  fact,  because  all  those 
who  have  had  any  experience  of  sieges,  or  of 
similar  conditions  where  small  communities  are 
shut  up  together  in  circumstances  of  hardship  and 
danger,  know  how  apt  the  temper  is  to  get  on 
edge,  how  often  small  differences  axe  Hkely  to  give 
rise  to  bitter  animosities.  But  we  had  in  the 
Gyantse  garrison  men  of  such  vast  experience  and 
geniaUty  as  Colonel  Brander,  of  such  high  culture 
and  attainment  as  Colonel  Younghusband,  Captain 
O'Connor,  and  Mr.  Perceval  Landon — the  corre- 
spondent of  The  Times  ;  men  whose  spirits  never 
failed  and  who  found  humour  in  everything,  such 
as  Major  Row,  Captain  Luke,  Captain  Coleridge, 


212  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

Lieutenant  Franklin.  Amongst  the  besieged  was 
Colonel  Waddell,  I.M.S.,  an  Orientalist  and  Sin- 
ologist of  European  fame.  Hence,  in  some  of  its 
aspects  the  Gyantse  siege  was  almost  a  deUghtful 
episode.  In  the  later  days,  when  all  the  outpost 
fighting  occurred,  our  spirits  were  somewhat 
damped,  for  we  had  to  mourn  brave  men  killed 
and  sympathize  with  others  dangerously  wounded. 
Of  course,  one  of  the  first  questions  for  con- 
sideration when  the  Karo  la  column  returned  to 
Gyantse  was  whether  the  enemy  could  or  could 
not  be  turned  out  of  the  Jong.  To  make  a  frontal 
attack  on  the  frowning  face  overlooking  the  post 
would  have  been  foolhardy,  but  Colonel  Brander 
decided  to  make  a  reconnaissance  to  a  monastery 
on  the  high  hills  to  our  right,  whence  the  jong  itself 
could  be  overlooked.  A  subsidiary  reason  for  visit- 
ing this  monastery  was  that  it  was  known  to  have 
afforded  shelter  to  a  number  of  those  who  had  fled 
from  the  attack  on  the  post.  The  hill  was  climbed 
with  every  military  precaution,  but  only  a  few  old 
monks  were  found  in  occupation  of  the  buildings. 
More  disappointing  was  the  fact  that  an  examina- 
tion through  telescopes  of  the  rear  of  the  jong 
showed  that  the  Tibetans  had  been  also  building 


GYANTSE.  213 

indefatigably  there.  A  strong  loopholed  wall  ran 
zigzagging  up  the  side  of  the  rock.  It  was  clear 
that  nothing  could  be  done  till  the  General  returned 
from  Chumbi  with  more  troops  and  guns. 

For  more  than  two  weeks  our  rear  remained 
absolutely  open.  The  post,  carried  by  mounted 
infantry,  came  in  and  went  out  regularly.  Two 
large  convoys  reached  us  unopposed.  The  only 
danger  lay  in  the  fact  that  people  seen  entering 
or  leaving  the  post  came  under  a  heavy  fire  from 
the  Jong.  To  minimize  risks,  departures  from  the 
post  were  always  made  before  dawn. 

During  the  two  weeks  streams  of  men  could  be 
seen  entering  the  jong  from  both  the  Shigatze  and 
Lhasa  roads.  Emboldened  by  numbers,  and  also 
by  our  non-aggressive  attitude,  the  enemy  began 
to  cast  about  for  means  of  taking  the  post.  One 
of  the  first  steps  taken  by  the  Tibetan  General  in 
pursuance  of  this  policy  was  to  occupy  during  the 
night  a  small  house  surrounded  by  trees,  lying  to 
our  left  front,  almost  midway  between  the  jong 
and  the  post.  On  the  morning  of  the  i8th  bullets 
from  a  new  direction  were  whizzing  in  amongst 
us,  and  partly  enfilading  our  traverses.  This  was 
not  to  be  tolerated,  and  the  same  night  arrange- 


214  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

merits  were  made  for  the  capture  of  the  posi- 
tion. 

Five  companies  stole  out  during  the  hours  of 
darkness  and  surrounded  the  house.  The  rush, 
dehvered  at  dawn,  was  left  to  the  Gurkhas.  But 
the  entrance  was  found  blocked  with  stones,  and 
the  enemy  was  thoroughly  awake  by  the  time  the 
Gurkhas  were  under  the  wall.  Luckily,  the  loop- 
holes were  not  so  constructed  as  to  allow  the 
Tibetans  to  fire  their  jingals  down  upon  our  men, 
who  had  only  to  bear  the  brunt  of  showers  of 
stones  thrown  upon  them  from  the  roof.  The 
shower  was  well  directed  enough  to  bruise  a  good 
many  Gurkhas.  Three  officers  were  struck — 
Major  Murray,  Lieutenant  Lynch,  and  Lieutenant 
FrankUn.  I.M.S.  Whilst  the  Gurkhas  were  striv- 
ing to  effect  an  entrance,  the  Pioneer  companies 
deployed  on  the  flanks  came  under  a  heavy  fire 
from  the  jong.  We  had  three  men  hit.  One 
fell  on  a  bit  of  very  exposed  ground,  and  was 
gallantly  dragged  under  cover  by  Colonel  Brander 
and  Captain  Minogue,  Staff  officer. 

It  was  soon  evident  that  the  Gurkhas  would 
never  get  in  without  explosives.  Accordingly,  Lieu- 
tenant Gurdon,   32nd  Pioneers,   was  sent  to  join 


GYANTSE.  215 

them  with  a  box  of  guncotton.  Gurdon  speedily 
blew  a  hole  through  the  wall,  and  the  Gurkhas 
dashed  in  yelling.  The  Tibetans  on  the  roof  could 
easily  at  this  time  have  jumped  off  and  escaped 
towards  the  jong.  But  they  chose  a  braver  part. 
They  sHd  down  into  the  middle  of  the  courtyard, 
and,  drawing  their  swords,  awaited  the  Gurkha 
onset.  I  must  not  describe  the  pitiful  struggle 
that  followed.  The  Tibetans — about  fifty  in  num- 
ber— herded  themselves  together  as  if  to  meet  a 
bayonet  charge,  but  our  troops,  rushing  through 
the  door,  extended  themselves  along  the  edges  of 
the  courtyard,  and  emptied  their  magazines  into 
the  mob.  Within  a  minute  all  the  fifty  were  eith^ 
dead  or  mortally  wounded. 

The  house  was  hereafter  held  by  a  company  of 
Gurkhas  all  through  the  bombardment,  and  proved 
a  great  thorn  in  the  side  of  the  enemy;  for  the 
Gurkhas  often  used  to  sally  out  at  night  and  am- 
buscade parties  of  men  and  convoys  on  the  Shigatze 
road. 


o 


CHAPTER   X 

GYANTSE — continued 

[By  Henry  Newman] 

N  the  afternoon  of  the  day  on  which  the  house 
was  taken  we  were  provided  with  a  new  ex- 
citement— continuous  firing  was  heard  to  the  rear 
of  the  post  about  a  mile  away.  Captain  Ottley 
galloped  out  with  his  mounted  infantry,  and  was 
only  just  in  time  to  save  a  party  of  his  men  who 
were  coming  up  from  Kangma  with  the  letter- 
bags.  These  Sikhs — eight  in  number — were  riding 
along  the  edge  of  the  river,  when  they  were  met  by 
a  fusillade  from  a  number  of  the  enemy  concealed 
amongst  sedges  on  the  opposite  bank.  Before  the 
Sikhs  could  take  cover,  one  man  was  killed,  three 
wounded,  and  seven  out  of  the  eight  horses  shot 
down.  The  remaining  men  showed  rare  courage. 
They  carried  their  wounded  comrades  under  cover 
of  a  ditch,  untied  and  brought  to  the  same  place 


GYANTSE.  217 

the  letter-bags,  and  then  lay  down  and  returned 
the  fire  of  the  enemy.  The  Tibetans,  however, 
were  beginning  to  creep  round,  and  the  ammuni- 
tion of  the  Sikhs  was  running  low,  when  Captain 
Ottley  dashed  up  to  the  rescue.  Without  waiting 
to  consider  how  many  of  the  enemy  might  be 
hiding  in  the  sedge,  Ottley  took  his  twenty  men 
splashing  through  the  river.  Nearly  300  Tibetans 
bolted  out  in  all  directions  Hke  rabbits  from  a 
cover.  The  mounted  infantry,  shooting  and  smit- 
ing, chased  them  to  the  very  edge  of  the  plain. 
On  reaching  hilly  ground  the  enemy,  who  must  have 
lost  about  fifty  of  their  number,  began  to  turn, 
having  doubtless  realized  that  they  were  running 
before  a  handful  of  men.  At  the  same  time  shots 
were  fired  from  villages,  previously  thought  un- 
occupied, on  Ottley  *s  left,  and  a  body  of  match- 
lock men  were  seen  running  up  to  reinforce  from 
a  large  village  on  the  Lhasa  road.  Under  these 
conditions  it  would  have  been  madness  to  continue 
the  fight,  and  Ottley  cleverly  and  skilfully  with- 
drew without  having  lost  a  single  man.  In  the 
meanwhile  a  company  of  Pioneers  had  brought 
in  the  men  wounded  in  the  attack  on  the  postal 
riders. 


2l8         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

This  affair  was  even  more  significant  than  the 
occupation  by  the  enemy  of  the  position  taken  by 
the  Gurkhas  in  the  early  morning.  It  showed 
that  the  Tibetan  General  had  at  last  conceived  a 
plan  for  cutting  off  our  line  of  communications. 
This  was  a  rude  shock.  It  implied  that  the  enemy 
had  received  reinforcements  which  were  to  be 
utilized  for  offensive  warfare  of  the  kind  most 
to  be  feared  by  an  invader.  We  knew  that  so 
long  as  our  ammunition  lasted  there  was  abso- 
lutely no  danger  of  the  post  being  captured.  But 
an  enemy  on  the  lines  would  certainly  cause  the 
greatest  annoyance  to,  and  might  even  cut  off, 
our  convoys.  As  it  would  be  very  difi&cult  to  get 
messages  through,  apprehensions  as  to  our  safety 
would  be  excited  in  the  outer  world.  Further, 
General  Macdonald's  arrangements  for  the  relief  of 
the  mission  would  have  to  be  considerably  modified 
if  he  were  obliged  to  fight  his  way  through  to  us. 

With  the  same  prompt  decision  that  marked  his 
action  with  regard  to  the  gathering  on  the  Karo  la. 
Colonel  Brander  determined  on  the  very  next  day 
to  clear  the  villages  found  occupied  by  the  mounted 
infantry.  As  far  as  could  be  discovered,  the 
villages  were  five  in  number,  all  on  the  right  bank 


GYANTSE.  219 

of  the  river,  and  occupying  a  position  which  could 
be  roughly  outlined  as  an  equilateral  triangle. 
Captain  Ottley  was  sent  round  to  the  rear  of  the 
villages  to  cut  off  the  retreat  of  the  enemy  ;  Captain 
Luke  took  his  two  mountain-guns,  under  cover  of 
the  right  bank  of  the  river,  to  a  position  whence  he 
could  support  the  infantry  attack,  if  necessary,  by 
shell  fire.  Two  companies  of  Pioneers  with  one 
in  reserve  were  sent  forward  to  the  attack. 

The  first  objective  was  two  villages  forming  the 
base  of  the  triangle  of  which  I  have  spoken.  The 
troops  advanced  cautiously,  widely  extended,  but 
both  villages  were  found  deserted.  They  were  set 
on  fire.  Then  Captain  Hodgson  with  a  company 
went  forward  to  the  village  forming  the  apex  of 
the  triangle.  He  came  under  a  flanking  fire  from 
the  villages  on  the  left,  and  had  one  man  severely 
wounded.  The  houses  in  front  seemed  to  be  im- 
occupied,  and  our  right  might  have  been  swung 
round  to  face  this  fire ;  but  Colonel  Brander  was 
determined  to  do  the  work  thoroughly,  and  Hodg- 
son was  directed  to  move  on  and  bum  the  village 
ahead  of  him  before  changing  front.  The  troops 
accordingly  took  no  notice  of  the  flanking  fire, 
and  moved  on  till  they  were  under  the  walls  of 


220         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

the  two  houses  of  which  the  village  was  com- 
posed. 

Suddenly  fire  was  opened  on  our  soldiers  from 
the  upper  windows  of  the  two  houses.  All  the  doors 
were  found  blocked  with  bricks  and  stones.  Two 
Sikhs  dropped,  and  for  the  moment  it  seemed  as 
if  we  would  lose  heavily.  But  Lieutenant  Gurdon 
with  half  a  dozen  men  rushed  up  with  a  box  of 
explosives,  and  blew  a  breach  in  the  wall.  Two 
of  the  party  helping  to  lay  the  fuse  were  killed  by 
shots  fired  from  a  loophole  a  few  feet  above. 
Captain  Hodgson  was  the  first  man  through  the 
breach.  He  was  confronted  by  a  swordsman,  who 
cut  hard  just  as  Hodgson  fired  his  revolver.  The 
man  fell  dead,  but  Hodgson  received  a  severe 
wound  on  the  wrist.  But  this  was  the  only  man 
who  stood  after  the  explosion.  About  thirty  others 
in  the  village  rushed  to  the  roofs  of  the  houses, 
jumped  off,  and  fled  to  the  left.  They  came,  how- 
ever, under  a  very  heavy  fire  as  they  were  running 
away,  and  the  majority  dropped. 

Preparations  were  now  made  for  taking  the  re- 
maining village.  This  was  protected  by  a  high 
loopholed  embankment,  which  sheltered  about 
five  or  six  hundred  of  the  enemy.     The  Pioneers 


GYANTSE.  221 

had  just  extended,  and  were  advancing,  when 
someone  who  happened  to  be  looking  at  the  jong 
through  his  glasses  suddenly  uttered  a  loud  ex- 
clamation. Turning  round,  we  all  saw  a  dense 
stream  of  men,  several  thousands  in  number, 
forming  .up  at  the  base  of  the  rock,  evidently 
with  the  intention  of  rushing  the  mission  post 
whilst  the  majority  of  the  garrison  and  the  guns 
were  engaged  elsewhere.  Colonel  Brander  im- 
mediately gave  the  order  for  the  whole  force  to 
retire  into  the  post  at  the  double.  The  with- 
drawal was  effected  before  the  Tibetans  made 
their  contemplated  rush,  but  we  all  felt  that  it 
was  rather  a  narrow  shave. 

Troops  were  to  have  gone  out  again  the  next 
day  to  clear  the  village  we  had  left  imtaken,  but 
the  mounted  infantry  reconnoitring  in  the  morning 
reported  that  the  enemy  had  fled,  and  that  the 
lines  of  communication  were  again  clear. 

On  the  succeeding  day  a  large  convoy  and  re- 
inforcements under  Major  Peterson,  32nd  Pioneers, 
came  safely  through.  The  additional  troops  in- 
cluded a  section  of  No.  7  (British)  Mountain  Bat- 
tery, under  Captain  Easton  ;  one  and  a  half  com- 
panies of  Sappers  and  Miners,  under  Captain  Shep-' 


222  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

herd  and  Lieutenant  Gctrstin  ;  and  another  company 
of  the  32nd  Pioneers.  Major  Peterson  reported 
that  his  convoy  had  come  under  a  heavy  fire  from 
the  village  and  monastery  of  Naini.  This  monastery 
hes  about  seven  miles  from  Gyantse  in  an  opening 
of  the  valley  just  before  the  road  turns  into  Gyantse 
Plain.  It  holds  about  5,000  monks.  When  the 
column  first  passed  by  it,  the  monks  were  extremely 
friendly,  bringing  out  presents  of  butter  and  eggs, 
and  readily  selling  flour  and  meat.  The  monastery 
is  surrounded  by  a  wall  thirty  feet  high,  and  at 
least  ten  feet  thick.  The  buildings  inside  are  also 
sohdly  built  of  stone.  Altogether  the  position  was 
a  very  difficult  one  to  tackle,  but  Colonel  Brander, 
following  his  usual  pohcy,  decided  that  the  enemy 
must  be  turned  out  of  it  at  all  costs.  Accordingly, 
on  the  24th  a  column,  which  included  Captain 
Easton's  two  guns,  marched  out  to  Naini.  But 
the  monastery  and  the  group  of  buildings  outside  it 
were  found  absolutely  deserted.  The  walls  were 
far  too  heavy  and  strong  to  be  destroyed  by  a  small 
force,  which  had  to  return  before  nightfall,  but 
Captain  Shepherd  blew  up  the  four  towers  at  the 
comers  and  a  portion  of  the  hall  in  which  the  Bud- 
dlias  were  enthroned. 


GYANTSE.  223 

The  27th  provided  a  new  excitement.  About 
1,000  yards  to  the  right  of  the  post  stood  what 
was  known  as  the  Palla  House,  the  residence  of  a 
Tibetan  nobleman  of  great  wealth.  The  building 
consisted  of  a  large  double-storied  house,  sur- 
rounded by  a  series  of  smaller  buildings,  each 
within  a  courtyard  of  its  own.  During  the  night 
the  Tibetans  in  the  jong  built  a  covered  way  ex- 
tending about  half  the  distance  between  the  jong 
and  Palla.  In  the  morning  the  latter  place  was 
seen  to  be  swarming  with  men,  busily  occupied  in 
erecting  defences,  making  loopholes,  and  generally 
engaged  in  work  of  a  menacing  character.  The 
enemy  could  less  be  tolerated  in  Palla  than  in  the 
Ghurka  outpost,  for  fire  from  the  former  would 
have  taken  us  absolutely  in  the  flank,  and  the 
garrison  was  not  strong  enough  to  provide  the 
labour  necessary  for  building  an  entirely  new  series 
of  traverses. 

That  very  night  Colonel  Brander  detailed  the 
troops  that  were  to  take  Psdla  by  assault  at  dawn. 
The  storming-party  was  composed  of  three  com- 
panies of  the  32nd  under  Major  Peterson,  assisted 
by  the  Sappers  and  Miners  with  explosives  under 
Captain  Shepherd.     Our  four  mountain-gims,   the 


224  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

7-pounders  under  Captain  Luke,  and  the  10- 
pounders  under  Captain  Easton,  escorted  by  a 
company  of  Gurkhas,  were  detailed  to  occupy  a 
position  on  a  ridge  which  overlooked  Palla.  The 
troops  fell  in  at  two  in  the  morning.  The  night 
was  pitch-dark,  but  with  such  care  wdre  the  opera- 
tions conducted  that  the  troops  had  made  a  long 
detour,  and  got  into  their  respective  positions 
before  dawn,  without  an  alarm  being  raised. 

Daylight  was  just  breaking  when  Captain  Shep- 
herd crept  up  to  the  wall  of  the  house  on  the  ex- 
treme left,  where  it  was  believed  the  majority  of 
the  enemy  were  located,  and  laid  his  explosives. 
A  tremendous  explosion  followed,  the  whole  side 
of  the  house  falling  in.  A  minute  afterwards, 
and  Palla  was  alarmed  and  firing  furiously  all 
round,  and  even  up  in  the  air.  The  jong  also 
awoke,  and  from  that  time  till  the  village  was  finally 
ours  poured  a  continuous  storm  of  bullets  into 
Palla,  regardless  whether  friend  or  foe  was  hit. 
Our  guns  on  the  ridge  did  their  best  to  quiet  the 
jong,  but  without  much  effect.  Against  Tibetan 
walls,  provided  as  they  are  with  head  cover,  our 
experience  showed  shrapnel  to  be  almost  entirely 
useless. 


GYANTSE  225 

A  company  of  Pioneers  followed  Captain  Shep- 
herd into  the  breach  he  had  made.  But  they 
found  themselves  only  in  a  small  courtyard,  with 
no  means  of  entering  the  rest  of  the  village,  except 
over  or  through  high  walls  lined  by  the  enemy.  All 
that  could  be  done  was  to  blow  in  another  breach. 
The  preparations  for  doing  this  were  attended  with 
a  good  deal  of  danger.  Of  three  men  who  attempted 
to  rush  across  the  courtyard,  two  were  killed  and 
the  third  mortally  wounded.  However,  by  creeping 
along  under  cover  of  the  wall.  Captain  Shepherd  and 
Lieutenant  Garstin  were  able  to  lay  the  guncotton 
and  light  the  fuse  for  another  explosion.  They 
were  fired  at  from  a  distance  of  a  few  yards,  but 
escaped  being  hit  by  a  miracle.  But  the  second 
explosion  only  led  into  another  courtyard,  from 
which  there  was  also  no  exit.  There  was  the  same 
fire  to  be  faced  from  the  next  house  whilst  the 
needful  preparations  were  being  made  for  making 
a  third  breach. 

During  the  time  Shepherd  with  his  gallant  lieu- 
tenants and  equally  gallant  sepoys  was  working 
his  way  in  from  the  left,  the  companies  of  Pioneers 
lining  ditches  and  banks  outside  Palla  were  exposed 
to  a  persistent  fire  from  about  a  hundred  of  the 
8 


226  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

enemy  inside  the  big  two-storied  house  mentioned 
above.  The  men  in  this  house — all  Kham  warriors 
— seemed  to  be  filled  with  an  extraordinary  fury. 
Many  exposed  themselves  boldly  at  the  windows, 
calling  to  our  men  to  come  on.  A  dozen  or  so  even 
cUmbed  to  the  roof  of  the  house,  and  danced  about 
thereon  in  what  seemed  frantic  derision.  There 
was  a  Maxim  on  the  ridge  with  the  mountain-guns, 
the  fire  from  which  put  an  end  to  the  fantastic  dis- 
play. Our  rifle  fire,  however,  seemed  totally  un- 
able to  check  the  Tibetan  warriors  in  the  loopholed 
windows.  They  kept  up  a  fusillade  which  made  a 
rush  impossible.  Major  Peterson  finally,  with  great 
daring,  led  a  few  men  into  the  dwelling  on  the  ex- 
treme  right.  The  escalade  was  managed  by  means 
of  a  ruined  tree  which  projected  from  the  waJl. 
But  Peterson,  Hke  Shepherd,  found  himself  in  a  court- 
yard with  high  walls  which  baified  further  progress. 
The  fight  now  began  to  drag.  Hours  passed 
without  any  signal  incident.  The  Tibetans  were 
greatly  elated  at  the  failure  of  our  troops  to  make 
progress.  They  shouted  and  yelled,  and  were  en- 
couraged by  answering  cheers  from  the  Jong.  Then 
about  mid-day  the  jong  Commandant  conceived  the 
idea  of  reinforcing  Palla.    A  dozen  men  mounted  on 


GYANTSE,  227 

black  mules,  followed  by  about  fifty  infantry,  sud- 
denly dashed  out  from  the  half-completed  covered 
way  mentioned  above,  and  made  for  the  village. 
This  party  was  absolutely  annihilated.  As  soon  as 
it  emerged  from  the  covered  way  it  came  under  the 
fire,  not  only  of  the  troops  round  the  village  and  on 
the  hill,  but  of  the  Maxim  on  the  roof  of  the  mission- 
house.  In  three  minutes  every  single  man  and  mule 
was  down,  except  one  animal  with  a  broken  leg, 
gazing  disconsolately  at  the  body  of  its  master. 

This  disaster  evidently  shook  the  Tibetans  in 
Palla.  Their  fire  slackened.  Captain  Luke  on  the 
ridge  was  then  directed  to  put  some  common  shell 
into  the  roof  of  the  double-storied  house.  He 
dropped  the  shells  exactly  where  they  were  wanted, 
and  so  disconcerted  the  enemy  that  Shepherd  was 
able  to  resume  his  preparations  for  making  a  way 
into  the  Tibetan  stronghold.  But  he  still  had  to 
face  an  awkward  fire,  and  the  three  further  breaches 
he  made  were  attended  by  the  loss  of  several  men, 
including  Lieutenant  Garstin,  shot  through  the 
head.  But  the  last  explosion  led  our  troops  into 
the  big  house.  Tibetan  resistance  then  practically 
ceased.  About  twenty  or  thirty  men  made  an 
attempt  to  get  away  to  the  jong,  but  the  majority 


228         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

were  shot  down  before  they  could  reach  the  covered 
way. 

In  this  affair  our  total  casualties  were  twenty- 
three.  In  addition  to  Lieutenant  Garstin,  we  had 
seven  men  killed.  The  wounded  included  Captain 
O'Connor,  R.A.,  secretary  to  the  mission,  and 
Lieutenant  Mitchell,  32nd  Pioneers.  The  enemy 
must  have  lost  quite  250  in  killed  and  wounded. 
The  position  at  Palla  was  too  important  to  be 
abandoned,  and  for  the  rest  of  the  bombardment 
it  was  held  by  a  company  of  Sikhs.  In  order  to 
provide  free  communication  both  day  and  night. 
Captain  Shepherd,  with  his  usual  energy,  dug  a 
covered  way  from  the  post  to  the  village. 

The  fight  at  Palla  was  the  last  affair  of  any  im- 
portance in  which  the  garrison  was  engaged  pending 
the  arrival  of  the  relieving  force.  The  Tibetans 
had  received  such  a  shock  that  in  future  they  con- 
fined themselves  practically  to  the  defensive,  if  we 
except  five  half-hearted  night  attacks  which  were 
never  anywhere  near  being  pushed  home.  There, 
were  no  more  attempts  to  interrupt  our  lines  of 
communication,  though  later  on  Naini  was  again 
occupied  cis  part  of  the  Tibetan  scheme  for  resisting 
General    Macdonald's    advance.    The    jong    Com- 


GYANTSE.  229 

mandant  devoted  his  energies  chiefly  to  Istrengthen- 
ing  his  already  strong  position. 

The  night  attacks  were  all  very  similar  in  char- 
acter, and  may  be  summed  up  and  dismissed  in  a 
paragraph.  Generally  about  midnight,  bands  of 
Tibetans  would  issue  from  the  jong  and  take  up 
their  position  about  four  or  five  hundred  yards  from 
the  post.  Then  they  would  shout  wildly,  and  fire 
off  their  matchlocks  and  Martini  rifles.  The  troops 
would  immediately  rush  to  their  loopholes,  clad  in 
impossible  garments,  and  wait  shivering  in  the 
cold,  finger  on  trigger,  for  the  rush  that  never  came. 
After  shouting  and  firing  for  about  an  hour,  the 
Tibetans  would  retire  to  the  jong  and  our  troops 
creep  back  to  their  beds.  On  no  occasion  did  the 
enemy  come  close  enough  to  be  seen  in  the  dark. 
We  never"  fired  a  single  shot  from  the  post.  Twice, 
however,  the  Gurkha  outpost  and  the  Sikhs  at 
Palla  were  enabled  to  get  in  a  few  volleys  at  Tibetans 
as  they  slunk  past.  During  the  night  attacks  the 
jong  remained  silent,  except  on  one  occasion,  when 
there  was  so  much  firing  from  the  Gurkha  outpost 
that  the  enemy  thought  we  were  about  to  make  a 
counter-attack.  Every  jingal,  musket,  and  rifle  in 
the  jong  was  then  loosed  off  in  any  and  every 


330  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

direction.  We  even  heard  firing  in  the  rear  of  the 
monastery.  Although  no  one  was  hit  in  this  wild 
fire,  the  volume  of  it  was  ominously  indicative  of 
the  strength  in  which  the  jong  was  held. 

But  even  more  ominous  against  the  day  when 
our  troops  should  be  called  upon  to  take  the  jong 
were  the  defensive  preparations  mentioned  above. 
Nearly  every  morning  we  found  that  during  the 
night  the  enemy  had  built  up  a  new  wall  or  covered 
way  somewhere  on  the  jong  or  about  the  village 
that  fringed  the  base  of  the  rock.  When  the  fortress 
was  fortified  as  strongly  as  Tibetan  wit  could  devise, 
the  jong  Commandant  began  to  fortify  and  place  in 
a  position  of  defence  the  villages  and  monasteries 
on  his  right  and  left.  It  was  calculated  that,  from 
the  small  monastery  perched  on  the  hills  to  his  left 
to  Tsechen  Monastery  on  a  ridge  to  his-  right,  the 
Tibetan  General  had  occupied  and  fortified  a  posi- 
tion with  nearly  seven  miles  of  front. 

Whilst  the  Tibetans  were  engaged  in  making 
these  preparations,  our  garrison  was  busy  collect- 
ing forage  for  the  enormous  number  of  animals 
coming  up  with  the  relief  column.  Our  rear  being 
absolutely  open,  small  parties  with  mules  were  able 
to  collect  quantities  of  hay  from  villages  within  a 


GYANTSE.  231 

radius  of  seven  miles  behind  us.  It  wa3  the  fire 
opened  on  these  parties  when  they  attempted  to 
push  to  the  right  or  left  of  the  jong  which  first  re- 
vealed to  us  the  full  extent  of  the  defensive  position 
occupied  by  the  enemy. 

On  June  6  Colonel  Younghusband  left  the  post 
with  a  returning  convoy,  in  order  to  confer  with 
the  General  at  Chumbi.  This  convoy  was  attacked 
whilst  halting  at  the  entrenched  post  at  Kangma. 
The  enemy  in  this  instance  came  down  from  the 
Karo  la,  and  it  is  for  this  reason  that  I  do  not  in- 
clude the  Kangma  attack  amongst  the  operations 
at  and  around  Gyantse. 

It  was  not  till  June  15  that  we  got  definite  news 
of  the  approaching  advance  of  the  relief  column. 
Reinforcements  had  come  up  to  Chumbi  from  India 
in  the  interval,  and  the  General  was  accompanied 
by  the  2nd  Mounted  Infantry  under  Captain  Peter- 
son, No.  7  British  Mountain  Battery  under  Major 
Fuller,  a  section  of  No.  30  Native  Mountain  Bat- 
tery under  Captain  Marindin,  four  companies  of  the 
Royal  Fusiliers  under  Colonel  Cooper,  four  com- 
panies of  the  40th  Pathans  under  Colonel  Bum,  five 
companies  of  the  23rd  Pioneers  under  Colonel  Hogge, 
and  the  two  remaining  companies  of  the  8th  Gurkhas 


232         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

under  Colonel  Kerr,  together  with  the  usual  medical 
and  other  details. 

The  force  arrived  at  Kangma  on  June  23.  On 
the  25th  a  party  of  mounted  infantry  from  Gyantse 
met  Captain  Peterson's  mounted  infantry  recon- 
noitring at  the  monastery  of  Naini,  previously 
mentioned.  Whilst  greetings  were  being  exchanged 
a  sudden  fire  was  opened  on  our  men  from  the 
monastery,  which  the  enemy  had  apparently  occupied 
and  fortified  during  the  night.  The  position  was 
apparently  held  in  strength,  and  the  mounted  in- 
fantry had  no  other  course  except  to  retire  to  their 
respective  camps.  Captain  Peterson  had  one  man 
mortally  wounded. 

On  the  evening  of  the  26th  the  sentries  at  the 
mission  post  saw  about  twenty  mounted  men,  fol- 
lowed by  two  or  three  hundred  infantry,  issue  from 
the  rear  of  the  jong  and  creep  up  the  hills  on  our 
left  in  the  direction  of  Naini.  It  was  evident  that 
a  determined  effort  was  to  be  made  at  the  monastery 
to  check  the  advance  of  the  relief  column,  which 
was  expected  at  Gyantse  next  day.  Colonel  Brander 
came  to  the  conclusion  that  he  had  found  an  oppor- 
tunity for  catching  the  Tibetans  in  a  trap.  He 
determined  to  send  out  a  force  which  would  block 


GYANTSE.  233 

the  retreat  of  the  enemy  when  they  retired  before 
the  advance  of  the  relief  column.  Accordingly, 
before  dawn  four  companies  of  Pioneers,  four  guns, 
and  the  Maxim  gun  left  the  post,  and  ascended  the 
hills  overlooking  the  monastery.  Captain  Ottley's 
mounted  infantry  were  directed  to  close  the  road 
leading  directly  from  Gyantse  to  the  monastery. 

Colonel  Brander's  forces  were  in  position  some 
hours  before  the  mounted  infantry  of  the  relief 
column  appeared  in  sight.  It  was  discovered  that 
the  enemy  not  only  held  the  monastery,  but  some 
ruined  towers  on  the  hill  above,  and  a  cluster  of 
one-storied  dwellings  in  a  grove  below.  Captain 
Peterson  with  his  mounted  infantry  appeared  in 
front  of  the  monastery  at  eleven  o'clock.  He  had 
with  him  a  company  of  the  40th  Pathans,  and  his 
orders  were  to  clear  the  monastery  with  this  small 
force,  if  the  enemy  made  no  signs  of  a  stubborn 
resistance.  Otherwise  he  was  to  await  the  arrival 
of  more  troops  with  the  mountain-guns. 

Peterson  delivered  his  attack  from  the  left,  having 
dismounted  his  troopers,  who,  together  with  the 
40th  Pathans,  were  soon  very  hotly  engaged.  The 
troops  came  under  a  heavy  fire  both  from  the  mon- 
astery and  from  a  ruined  tower  above  it,  but  ad- 


234  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

vanced  most  gallantly.  When  under  the  walls  of  the 
monastery,  they  were  checked  for  some  time  by  the 
difficulty  of  finding  a  way  in.  In  the  meanwhile, 
hearing  the  heavy  firing,  the  General  and  his  Staff, 
followed  by  Major  Fuller's  battery  and  the  rest  of 
the  40th,  had  hastened  up.  The  battery  came  into 
action  against  the  tower,  and  the  40th  rushed  up 
in  support  of  their  comrades.  Colonel  Brander's 
guns  and  Maxim  on  the  top  of  the  hill  were  also 
brought  into  play.  For  nearly  an  hour  a  furious 
cannonade  and  fusillade  raged.  Then  the  Pathans 
and  Peterson's  troopers,  circling  round  the  walls  of 
the  monastery,  found  a  ramp  up  which  they  could 
climb.  They  swarmed  up,  and  were  quickly  inside 
the  building.  But  the  Tibetans  had  realized  that 
their  retreat  was  cut  off,  and,  instead  of  making 
a  clean  bolt  for  it,  only  retired  slowly  from  room 
to  room  and  passage  to  passage.  Two  companies 
of  the  23rd  were  sent  up  to  assist  in  clearing  the 
monastery.  It  proved  a  perfect  warren  of  dark 
cells  and  rooms.  The  Tibetan  resistance  lasted  for 
over  two  hours.  Bands  of  desperate  swordsmen  were 
found  in  knots  under  trap-doors  and  behind  sharp 
turnings.  They  would  not  surrender,  and  had  to  be 
killed  by  rifle  shots  fired  at  a  distance  of  a  few  feet. 


GYANTSK  235 

While  the  monastery  was  being  cleared,  another 
fight  had  developed  in  the  cluster  of  dwellings  out- 
side it  to  the  right.  From  this  spot  Tibetan  rifle- 
men were  enfilading  our  troops  held  in  reserve.  The 
remaining  companies  of  the  23rd  were  sent  to  clear 
away  the  enemy.  They  took  three  houses,  but 
could  not  effect  an  entrance  into  the  fourth,  which 
was  very  strongly  barricaded.  Lieutenant  Turn- 
bull,  walking  up  to  a  window  with  a  section,  had 
three  men  hit  in  a  few  seconds.  One  man  fell 
directly  imder  the  window.  TumbuU  carried  him 
into  safety  in  the  most  gallant  fashion.  Then  the 
General  ordered  up  the  guns,  which  fired  into  the 
house  at  a  range  of  a  few  hundred  yards.  But  not 
till  it  was  riddled  with  great  gaping  holes  made  by 
common  shell  did  the  fire  from  the  house  cease. 

At  about  three  o'clock  the  Tibetan  resistance 
had  completely  died  away,  and  the  column  resumed 
its  march  towards  Gyantse,  which  was  not  reached 
till  dark.  But  as  the  transport  was  making  its 
slow  way  past  Naini,  about  half  a  dozen  Tibetans 
who  had  remained  in  hiding  in  the  monastery  and 
village  opened  fire  on  it.  Tha  Gurkha  rearguard 
had  a  troublesome  task  in  clearing  these  men  out, 
and  lost  one  man  killed. 


236         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

In  this  affaif  at  Naini  our  casualties  were  six  killed 
and  nine  wounded,  including  Major  Lye,  23rd 
Pioneers,  who  received  a  severe  sword-cut  in  the 
hand. 

The  General's  camp  was  pitched  about  a  mile 
from  the  mission  post,  well  out  of  range  of  the  jong, 
though  our  troops  whilst  crossing  the  river  came 
under  fire  from  some  of  the  bigger  jingals.  The 
next  day  was  one  of  rest,  which  the  troops  badly 
needed  after  their  long  march  from  Chumbi.  The 
Tibetans  in  the  jong  also  refrained  from  firing.  On 
the  29th  the  General  began  the  operations  intended 
to  culminate  in  the  capture  of  the  jong.  His  ob- 
jective was  Tsechen  Monastery,  on  the  extreme 
left.  But  before  the  monastery  could  be  attacked, 
some  twelve  fortified  villages  between  it  and  the 
river  had  to  be  cleared.  It  proved  a  dif&cult  task, 
not  so  much  on  account  of  the  resistance  offered 
by  the  enemy — for  after  a  few  idle  shots  the  Tibetans 
quickly  retired  on  the  monastery — as  because  of  the 
nature  of  the  ground  that  had  to  be  traversed.  The 
whole  country  was  a  network  of  deep  irrigation 
channels  and  water-cuts,  in  the  fording  and  crossing 
of  which  the  troops  got  wet  to  the  skin.  However, 
by  four  in  the  afternoon  all  the  villages  had  been 


GYANTSE.  237 

cleared,  and  the  Fusiliers  were  lying  in  a  long  grove 
under  the  right  front  of  the  monastery. 

It  was  then  discovered  that  not  only  was  Tsechen 
very  strongly  held,  but  that  masses  of  the  enemy 
were  lying  behind  the  rocks  on  the  top  of  the  ridge, 
on  the  summit  of  which  there  was  a  ruined  tower,  also 
held  by  fifty  or  sixty  men.  The  General  sent  two 
companies  of  Gurkhas  to  scale  the  ridge  from  the 
left,  whilst  the  40th  Pathans  were  ordered  to  make 
a  direct  assault  on  the  monastery.  A  hundred 
mounted  infantry  made  their  way  to  the  rear  to  cut 
off  the  retreat  of  the  enemy.  Fuller  and  Marindin 
with  their  guns  covered  the  advance  of  the  infantry. 
Four  Maxims  were  also  brought  into  action.  Our 
guns  made  splendid  practice  on  the  top  of  the 
ridge,  and  time  and  again  we  could  see  the  enemy 
bolting  from  cover.  But  with  magnificent  bravery 
they  would  return  to  oppose  the  advance  of  the 
Gurkhas  creeping  round  their  flank.  The  guns  had 
presently  to  cease  fire  to  enable  the  Gurkhas  to  get 
nearer.  A  series  of  desperate  little  fights  then  took 
place  on  the  top  of  the  ridge,  the  Tibetans  slinging 
and  throwing  stones  when  they  found  they  could 
not  load  their  muskets  quickly  enough.  But  as 
the  Gurkhas  would  not  be  stopped,  the  Tibetans 


238  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

had  to  move.  In  the  meanwhile  the  Pathans  worked 
through  the  monastery  below,  only  meeting  with 
small  resistance  from  a  band  of  men  in  one  house. 
The  Tibetans  fled  in  a  mass  over  the  right  edge  of 
the  ridge  into  the  jaws  of  the  mounted  infantry 
lying  in  wait  below.     Slaughter  followed. 

It  was  now  quite  dark,  and  the  troops  made  their 
way  back  to  camp.  Next  morning  a  party  went 
up  to  Tsechen,  found  it  entirely  deserted,  and  set 
fire  to  it.  The  taking  of  the  monastery  cost  us  the 
lives  of  Captain  Craster,  40th  Pathans,  and  two 
sepoys.  Our  wounded  numbered  ten,  including 
Captains  Bliss  and  Humphrej^,  8th  Gurkhas. 

On  July  I  the  General  intended  assaulting  the 
jong,  but  in  the  interval  the  jong  Commandant  sent 
in  a  flag  of  truce.  He  prayed  for  an  armistice  pend- 
ing the  arrival  of  three  delegates  who  were  posting 
down  from  Lhasa  with  instructions  to  make  peace. 
As  Colonel  Younghusband  had  been  directed  to  lose 
no  opportunity  of  bringing  affairs  to  an  end  at 
Gyantse,  the  armistice  was  granted,  and  two  da5rs 
afterwards  the  delegates,  all  Lamas,  were  received 
in  open  durbar  in  a  large  room  in  the  mission  post. 
Colonel  Younghusband,  after  having  satisfied  him- 
self that  the  delegates  possessed  proper  credentials. 


GYANTSE.  239 

made  them  a  speech.  He  reviewed  the  history  of 
the  mission,  pointing  out  that  we  had  only  come 
to  Gyantse  because  of  the  obstinacy  and  evasion  of 
the  Tibetan  officials,  who  could  easily  have  treated 
with  us  at  Khamba  Jong  and  again  at  Tuna,  had 
they  cared  to.  We  were  perfectly  willing  to  come  to 
terms  here,  and  it  rested  with  the  peace  delegates 
whether  we  went  on  to  Lhasa  or  not.  Young- 
husband  then  informed  the  delegates  that  he  was 
prepared  to  open  negotiations  on  the  next  day. 
The  delegates  were  due  at  eleven  next  morning,  but 
they  did  not  put  in  an  appearance  till  three.  They 
were  then  told  that  as  a  preliminary  they  must 
surrender  the  jong  by  noon  on  the  succeeding  day. 
They  demurred  a  great  deal,  but  the  Commissioner 
was  quite  firm,  and  they  went  away  downcast,  with 
the  assurance  that  if  the  jong  was  not  surrendered 
we  should  take  it  by  force.  Younghusband,  how- 
ever, added  that  after  the  capture  of  the  fort  he 
was  perfectly  willing  to  open  negotiations  again. 

Next  day,  shortly  after  noon,  a  signal  gun  was 
fired  to  indicate  that  the  armistice  was  at  an  end, 
and  the  General  forthwith  began  his  preparations 
to  stcrm  the  formidable  hill  fortress.  The  Tibetans 
had  taken  advantage  of  the  armistice  to  build  more 


240         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

walls  and  sangars.  No  one  could  look  at  the 
bristling  jong  without  realizing  how  difficult  was 
the  task  before  our  troops,  and  without  anxiety  as 
to  the  outcome  of  the  assault  in  killed  and  wounded. 
But  we  all  knew  that  the  jong  had  to  be  taken,  what- 
ever the  cost. 

Operations  began  in  the  afternoon,  the  General 
making  a  demonstration  against  the  left  face  of  the 
jong  and  Palkhor  Choide  Monastery.  Fuller's  bat- 
tery took  up  a  position  about  i,6oo  yards  from  the 
jong.  Five  companies  of  infantry  were  extended 
on  either  flank.  Both  the  j  ong  and  monastery  opened 
fire  on  our  troops,  and  we  had  one  man  mortally 
wounded.  The  General's  intention,  however,  was 
only  to  deceive  the  Tibetans  into  thinking  that  we 
intended  to  assault  from  that  side.  As  soon  as  dusk 
fell,  the  troops  were  withdrawn  and  preparations 
made  for  the  real  assault. 

The  south-eastern  face  of  the  rock  on  which  the 
jong  is  built  is  most  precipitous,  yet  this  was  ex- 
actly the  face  which  the  General  decided  to  storm. 
His  reasons,  I  imagine,  were  that  the  fringe  of  houses 
at  the  base  of  the  rock  was  thinnest  on  this  side, 
and  that  the  very  multiplicity  of  sangars  and  walls 
that  the  enemy  had  built  prevented  their  having 


GYANTSE.,  241 

the  open  field  of  fire  necessary  to  stop  a  rash. 
Moreover,  down  the  middle  of  the  rock  ran  a  deep 
fissure  or  cleft,  which  was  commanded,  the  General 
noticed,  by  no  tower  or  loopholed  wall.  At  two 
points,  however,  the  Tibetans  had  built  walls  across 
the  fissure.  The  first  of  these  the  General  believed 
could  be  breached  by  our  artillery.  Our  troops 
through  that  could  work  their  way  round  to  either 
flank,  and  so  into  the  heart  of  the  jong. 

The  plan  of  operations  was  very  simple.  Before 
dawn  three  columns  were  to  rush  the  fringe  of 
houses  at  the  base.  Then  was  to  follow  a  storm 
of  artillery  fire  directed  on  all  the  salient  points  of 
the  jong,  after  which  our  guns  were  to  make  a 
breach  in  the  lower  wall  across  the  cleft  up  which 
the  storming-party  was  later  on  to  climb. 

The  action  turned  out  exactly  as  was  planned, 
with  the  exception  that  the  fighting  lasted  much 
longer  than  was  expected,  for  the  Tibetans  made 
a  heroic  resistance.  The  troops  were  astir  shortly 
after  midnight.  The  night  was  very  dark,  and  the 
necessary  deployment  of  the  three  columns  took 
some  hours.  However,  an  hour  before  dawn  the 
troops  had  begun  their  cautious  advance,  the 
General  and  his  Staff  taking  up  their  p^  ition  at 


243  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

Palla.  The  alarm  was  not  given  till  our  leading 
files  were  within  twenty  yards  of  the  fringe  of 
houses  at  the  base  of  the  rock.  The  storm  of  fire 
which  then  burst  from  the  jong  was  an  alarming 
indication  of  the  strength  in  which  it  was  held. 
The  heavy  jingals  were  all  directed  on  Palla,  and 
the  General  and  his  Staff  had  many  narrow  escapes. 
As  on  the  previous  occasion  when  the  jong  bom- 
barded us  at  night,  there  were  moments  when  every 
building  in  it  seemed  outlined  in  flame. 

Of  the  three  columns,  only  that  on  the  extreme 
left,  Gurkhas  under  Major  Murray,  was  able  to  get 
in  at  once.  The  other  two  columns  were  for  the 
time  being  checked,  so  bullet-swept  was  the  open 
space  they  had  to  cross.  From  time  to  time  small 
parties  of  two  or  three  dashed  across  in  the  dark, 
and  gained  the  shelter  of  the  walls  of  the  houses  in 
front.  There  were  barely  twenty  men  and  half  a 
dozen  officers  across  when  Captain  Shepherd  blew 
in  the  walls  of  the  house  most  strongly  held.  The 
storming-party  came  under  a  most  heavy  fire  from 
the  jong  above.  Among  those  hit  was  Lieutenant 
Gurdon,  of  the  32nd.  He  was  shot  through  the 
head,  and  died  almost  immediately.  The  breach 
made  by  Shepherd  was  the  point  to  which  most  ol 


GYANTSE.  243 

the  men  of  the  centre  and  right  columns  made,  but 
their  progress  became  very  slow  when  daylight 
appeared  and  the  Tibetans  could  see  what  they 
were  firing  at.  It  was  not  till  nearly  nine  o'clock 
that  the  whole  fringe  of  houses  at  the  base  of  the 
front  face  of  the  rock  was  in  our  possession. 

Then  followed  several  hours  of  cannonading  and 
small-arms  fire.  The  position  the  troops  had  now 
won  was  commanded  almost  absolutely  from  the 
jong.  It  was  found  impossible  to  return  the 
Tibetan  fire  from  the  roofs  of  the  houses  we  had 
occupied  without  exposing  the  troops  in  an  un- 
necessary degree,  but  loopholes  were  hastily  made 
in  the  walls  of  the  rooms  below,  and  the  40th  Pathans 
were  sent  into  a  garden  on  the  extreme  right,  where 
some  cover  was  to  be  had.  Colonel  Campbell,  com- 
manding the  first  line,  was  able  to  show  the  enemy 
that  our  marksmen  were  still  in  a  position  to  pick 
off  such  Tibetans  as  were  rash  enough  to  unduly 
expose  themselves.  In  the  meanwhile,  Luke's  guns 
on  the  extreme  right.  Fuller's  battery  at  Palla,  and 
Marindin's  guns  at  the  Gurkha  outpost  threw  a 
stream  of  shrapnel  on  all  parts  of  the  jong. 

But  it  was  not  till  four  o'clock  in  the  afternoon 
that  the  General  decided  that  the  time  had  come 


244  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

to  make  the  breach  aforementioned.  The  reserve 
companies  of  Gurkhas  and  Fusiliers  were  sent  across 
from  Palla  in  the  face  of  very  heavy  jingal  and 
rifle  fire,  and  took  cover  in  the  houses  we  had  occu- 
pied. In  the  meanwhile  Fuller  was  directed  to 
make  the  breach.  So  magnificent  was  the  shooting 
made  by  his  guns  that  a  dozen  rounds  of  common 
shell,  planted  one  below  the  other,  had  made  a  hole 
large  enough  for  active  men  to  clamber  through. 
The  enemy  quickly  saw  the  purport  of  the  breach. 
Dozens  of  men  could  be  distinctly  seen  hurrying 
to  the  wall  above  it. 

Then  the  Gurkhas  and  Fusiliers  began  their  perilous 
ascent.  The  nimble  Gurkhas,  led  by  Lieutenant 
Grant,  soon  outpaced  the  Fusiliers,  and  in  ten  brief 
minutes  forty  or  fifty  of  them  were  crouching  under 
the  breach.  The  Tibetans,  finding  their  fire  could 
not  stop  us,  tore  great  stones  from  the  walls  arid 
rolled  them  down  the  cleft.  Dozens  of  men  were  hit 
and  bruised.  Presently  Grant  was  through  the  breach, 
followed  by  fifteen  or  twenty  flushed  arid  shouting 
men.  The  breach  won,  the  only  thought  of  the  enemy 
was  flight.  They  made  their  way  by  the  back  of 
the  jong  into  the  monastery.  By  six  o'clock  every 
building  in  the  great  fortress  was  in  our  possession. 


GYANTSE-  245 

Our  casualties  in  this  affair  were  forty-three-^ 
Lieutenant  Gurdon  and  seven  men  killed,  and 
twelve  officers,  including  the  gallant  Grant,  and 
twenty-three  men  wounded.  These  casualties  ex- 
clude a  number  of  men  cut  and  bruised  with  stones. 

Next  morning  the  monastery  was  found  deserted. 
It  was  reported  that  the  bulk  of  the  enemy  had 
fled  to  Dongtse,  about  ten  miles  up  the  Shigatze 
road.  A  column  was  sent  thither,  but  found  the 
place  empty,  except  for  a  very  humble  and  sub- 
missive monk. 

On  the  14th,  having  waited  for  over  a  week  in 
the  hope  of  the  peace  delegates  putting  in  an  ap- 
pearance, the  force  started  on  its  march  to  Lhasa. 


CHAPTER    XI 

gossip  on  the  road  to  the  front 

Ari,  Sikkim, 
June  24. 

I  WRITE  in  an  old  forest  rest-house  on  the  borders 
of  British  Bhutan. 

The  place  is  quiet  and  pastoral;  climbing  roses 
overhang  the  roof  and  invade  the  bedrooms  ;  martins 
have  built  their  nests  in  the  eaves ;  cuckoos  are 
calling  among  the  chestnuts  down  the  hill.  Outside 
is  a  flower-garden,  gay  with  geraniums  and  petunias 
and  familiar  English  plants  that  have  overrun  their 
straggling  borders  and  scattered  themselves  in  the 
narrow  plot  of  grass  that  fringes  the  forest.  Some 
Government  officer  must  have  planted  them  years 
ago,  and  left  them  to  fight  it  out  with  Nature  and 
the  caretaker. 

The  forest  has  encroached,  and  it  is  hard  to  say 
where  Nature's  hand  or  Art's  begins  and  ends. 
Beside  a  rose-bush  there  has  sprung  up  the  solid 


GOSSIP  ON  THE  ROAD.  247 

pink  club  of  the  wild  ginger,  and  from  a  bed  of 
amaryllis  a  giant  arum  raises  itself  four  feet  in  its 
dappled,  snake-like  sheath.  Gardens  have  most 
charm  in  spots  like  this,  where  their  mingled  trim- 
ness  and  neglect  contrast  with  the  insolent  unconcern 
of  an  encroaching  forest. 

At  Ari  I  am  fifty  miles  from  Darjeeling,  on  the 
road  to  Lhasa. 

On  June  21  I  set  my  face  to  Lhasa  for  the  second 
time.  I  took  another  route  to  Chumbi,  via  Kalim- 
pong  and  Pedong  in  British  Bhutan.  The  road  is 
no  further,  but  it  compasses  some  arduous  ascents. 
On  the  other  hand  it  avoids  the  low,  malarious 
valleys  of  Sikkim,  where  the  path  is  constantly 
carried  away  by  slips.  There  is  less  chance  of  a 
block,  and  one  is  above  the  cholera  zone.  The 
Jelap  route,  which  I  strike  to-morrow,  is  closed, 
owing  to  cholera  and  landslips,  so  that  I  shall  not 
touch  the  line  of  conmiunications  until  within  a 
few  miles  of  Chumbi,  in  which  time  my  wound  will 
have  had  a  week  longer  to  heal  before  I  risk  a  medical 
examination  and  the  chance  of  being  sent  back. 
The  relief  column  is  due  at  Gyantse  in  a  few  days ; 
it  depends  on  the  length  of  the  operations  there 
whether  I  catch  the  advance  to  Lhasa. 


248  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

Through  avoiding  the  Nathu-la  route  to  Chumbi 
I  had  to  arrange  my  own  transport.  In  DarjeeHng 
my  cooUes  bolted  without  putting  a  pack  on  their 
backs.  More  were  secured  ;  these  disappeared  in 
the  night  at  Kalimpong  without  waiting  to  be  paid. 
Pack-ponies  were  hired  to  replace  them,  but  these 
are  now  in  a  state  of  collapse.  Arguing,  and  hag- 
gling, and  hectoring,  and  blarneying,  and  persuading 
are  wearisome  at  all  times,  but  more  especially  in 
these  close  steamy  valleys,  where  it  is  too  much 
trouble  to  lift  an  eyelid,  and  the  air  induces  an 
almost  immoral  state  of  lassitude,  in  which  one  is 
tempted  to  dole  out  silver  indifferently  to  anyone 
who  has  it  in  his  power  to  oil  the  wheels  of  life.  I 
could  fill  a  whole  chapter  with  a  jeremiad  on  trans- 
port, but  it  is  enough  to  indicate,  to  those  who  go 
about  in  vehicles,  that  there  are  men  on  the  road 
to  Tibet  now  who  would  beggar  themselves  and 
their  families  for  generations  for  a  macadamized 
highway  and  two  hansom  cabs  to  carry  them  and 
their  belongings  smoothly  to  Lhasa.  Before  I 
reached  Kalimpong  I  wished  I  had  never  left  the 
'  radius.'  No  one  should  embark  on  Asiatic  travel 
who  is  not  thoroughly  out  of  harmony  with  civiliza- 
tion. 


GOSSIP  ON  THE  ROAD.  249 

The  servant  question  is  another  difficulty.  No 
native  bearer  wishes  to  join  the  field  force.  Why 
should  he  ?  He  has  to  cook  and  pack  and  do 
the  work  of  three  men  ;  he  has  to  make  long,  ex- 
hausting marches  j  he  is  exposed  to  hunger,  cold, 
and  fatigue  ;  he  may  be  under  fire  every  day ; 
and  he  knows  that  if  he  falls  into  the  hands  of  the 
Tibetans,  Hke  the  unfortunate  servants  of  Captain 
Parr  at  Gyantse,  he  will  be  brutally  murdered  and 
cut  up  into  mincemeat.  In  return  for  which  he 
is  fed  and  clothed,  and  earns  ten  rupees  more  a 
month  than  he  would  in  the  security  of  his  own 
home.  After  several  unsuccessful  trials,  I  have 
found  one  Jung  Bir,  a  Nepali  bearer,  who  is  at- 
tached to  me  because  I  forget  sometimes  to  ask  for 
my  bazaar  account,  and  do  not  object  to  his  being 
occasionally  drunk.  In  Tibet  the  poor  fellow  will 
have  little  chance  of  drinking. 

My  first  man  lost  his  nerve  altogether,  and,  when 
told  to  work,  could  only  whine  out  that  his  father 
and  mother  were  not  with  him.  My  next  applicant 
was  an  opium-eater,  prematurely  bent  and  aged, 
with  the  dazed  look  of  a  toad  that  has  been  in- 
carcerated for  ages  in  a  rock,  and  is  at  last  restored 
to  light  and  the  world  by  the  blow  of  a  mason's 


250         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

hammer.  He  wanted  money  to  buy  more  dreams, 
and  for  this  he  was  wilHng  to  expose  his  poor  old 
body  to  hardships  that  would  have  killed  him  in 
a  month.  Jung  Bir  was  a  Gurkha  and  more 
martial.  His  first  care  on  being  engaged  was 
to  buy  a  long  and  heavy  chopper — '  for  making 
mince,'  he  said  ;  but  I  knew  it  was  for  the  Tibetans. 
To  reach  Ari  one  has  to  descend  twice,  crossing 
the  Teesta  at  700  feet,  and  the  Russett  Chu  at 
1,500  feet.  These  valleys  are  hotter  than  the 
plains  of  India.  The  streams  run  east  and  west, 
and  the  cliffs  on  both  sides  catch  the  heat  of  the 
early  morning  sun  and  hold  it  all  day.  The 
closeness,  the  refraction  from  the  rocks,  and  the 
evaporation  of  the  water,  make  the  atmosphere 
almost  suffocating,  and  one  feels  the  heat  the 
more  intensely  by  the  change  from  the  bracing  air 
above.  Crossing  the  Teesta,  one  enters  British 
Bhutan,  a  strip  of  land  of  less  than  300  square 
miles  on  the  left  bank  of  the  river.  It  was  ceded 
to  us  with  other  territories  by  the  treaty  of  1865 ; 
or,  in  plain  words,  it  was  annexed  by  us  as  a  pun- 
ishment for  the  outrage  on  Sir  Ashley  Eden,  the 
British  Envoy,  who  was  captured  and  grossly 
insulted   by   the    Bhutanese   at    Punakha   in   the 


GOSSIP  ON  THE  ROAD.  25T 

previous  year.  The  Bhutanese  were  as  arrogant, 
exclusive,  and  impossible  to  deal  with,  in  those 
days,  as  the  Tibetans  are  to-day.  Yet  they  have 
been  brought  into  line,  and  are  now  our  friends. 
Why  should  not  the  Tibetans,  who  are  of  the 
same  stock,  yield  themselves  to  enlightenment  ? 
Their  evolution  would  be  no  stranger. 

Nine  miles  above  the  Teesta  bridge  is  Kalim- 
pong,  the  capital  of  British  Bhutan,  and  virtually 
the  foreign  mart  for  what  trade  passes  out  of  Tibet. 
The  Tomos  of  the  Chumbi  Valley,  who  have  the 
monopoly  of  the  carr5dng,  do  not  go  further  south 
than  this.  At  Kalimpong  I  found  a  horse-dealer 
with  a  good  selection  of  *  Bhutia  tats.'  These  ex- 
cellent little  beasts  are  now  well  known  to  be  as 
strong  and  plucky  a  breed  of  mountain  ponies  as 
can  be  found  anywhere.  I  discovered  that  their 
fame  is  not  merely  modern  when  I  came  across 
what  must  be  the  first  reference  to  them  in  his- 
tory in  the  narrative  of  Master  Ralph  Fitch,  Eng- 
land's pioneer  to  India.  '  These  northern  mer- 
chants,' says  Fitch,  speaking  of  the  Bhutia,  '  report 
that  in  their  countrie  they  haue  very  good  horses, 
but  they  be  htle.'  The  Bhutias  themselves,  equally 
ubiquitous  in  the  Sikkim  Himalayas,  but  not  equally 


252  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

indispensable,  Fitch  describes  to  the  letter.  At 
Kalimpong  I  found  them  dirty,  lazy,  good-natured, 
independent  rascals,  possessed,  apparently,  of  wealth 
beyond  their  deserts,  for  hard  work  is  as  alien 
to  their  character  as  straight  dealing.  Even  the 
drovers  will  pay  a  coolie  good  wages  to  cut  grass  for 
them  rather  than  walk  a  mile  downhill  to  fetch  it 
themselves. 

The  main  street  of  Kalimpong  is  laid  out  in 
the  correct  boulevard  style,  with  young  trees  pro- 
tected by  tubs  and  iron  raihngs.  It  is  dominated 
by  the  church  of  the  Scotch  Mission,  whose  steeple 
is  a  landmark  for  miles.  The  place  seems  to  be 
overrun  with  the  healthiest-looking  English  chil- 
dren I  have  seen  anywhere,  whose  parents  are 
given  over  to  very  practical  good  works. 

I  took  the  Bhutan  route  chiefly  to  avoid  running 
the  gauntlet  of  the  medicals  j  but  another  induce- 
ment was  the  prospect  of  meeting  Father  Des- 
godins,  a  French  Roman  Cathohc,  Vicar  Apostolic 
of  the  Roman  CathoUc  Mission  to  Western  Tibet, 
who,  after  fifty  years*  intimacy  with  various  Mongol 
types,  is  probably  better  acquainted  with  the 
Tibetans  than  any  other  living  European. 

I  met  Father  Desgodins  at  Pedong.    The  rest- 


GOSSIP  ON  THE  ROAD.  253 

house  here  looks  over  the  valley  to  his  sym- 
metrical French  presbytery  and  chapel,  perched  on 
the  hillside  amid  waving  maize-fields,  whose  spring 
verdure  is  the  greenest  in  the  world.  Scattered 
over  the  fields  are  thatched  Lamas'  houses  and 
low-storied  gompas,  with  overhanging  eaves  and 
praying-flags — *  horses  of  the  wind,'  as  the  Tibetans 
picturesquely  call  them,  imagining  that  the  prayers 
inscribed  on  them  are  carried  to  the  good  god, 
whoever  he  may  be,  who  watches  their  particular 
fold  and  fends  off  intruding  spirits  as  well  as  material 
invaders. 

Behind  the  presbytery  are  terraced  rice-fields, 
irrigated  by  perennial  streams,  and  bordered  by 
thick  artemisia  scrub,  which  in  the  hot  sim,  after 
rain,  sends  out  an  aromatic  scent,  never  to  be 
dissociated  in  travellers'  dreams  and  reveries 
from  these  great  southern  slopes  of  the  Himalayas. 

Pdre  Desgodins  is  an  erect  old  gentleman  with 
quiet,  steely  gray  eyes  and  a  tawny  beard  now 
turning  gray.  He  is  known  to  few  Englishmen, 
but  his  adventurous  travels  in  Tibet  and  his  de- 
voted, strenuous  life  are  known  throughout  Europe. 

He  was  sent  out  from  France  to  the  Tibet  Mis- 
sion shortly  after  the  murder  of  Krick  and  Bourry 


354  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA 

by  the  Mishmis.  Failing  to  enter  Tibet  from  the 
south  through  Sikkim,  he  made  preparations  for  an 
entry  by  Ladak.  His  journey  was  arrested  by  the 
Indian  Mutiny,  when  he  was  one  of  the  besieged 
at  Agra.  He  afterwards  penetrated  Western  Tibet 
as  far  as  Khanam,  but  was  recalled  to  the  Chinese 
side,  where  he  spent  twenty-two  perilous  and  adven- 
turous years  in  the  estabUshment  of  the  mission  at 
Batang  and  Bonga.  The  mission  was  burnt  down 
and  the  settlement  expelled  by  the  Lamas.  In  1888 
Father  Desgodins  was  sent  to  Pedong,  his  present 
post,  as  Pro-vicar  of  the  Mission  to  Western  Tibet. 

With  regard  to  the  present  situation  in  Tibet, 
Father  Desgodins  expressed  astonishment  at  our 
policy  of  folded  arms. 

*  You  have  missed  the  occasion/  he  said  ;  '  you 
should  have  made  your  treaty  with  the  Tibetans 
themselves  in  1888,  You  could  have  forced  them 
to  treat  then,  when  they  were  unprepared  for  a 
military  invasion.  You  should  have  said  to  them ' 
— here  Pere  Desgodins  took  out  his  watch — *  "  It 
is  now  one  o'clock.  Sign  that  treaty  by  five,  or 
we  advance  to-morrow."  What  could  they  have 
done  ?  Now  you  are  too  late.  They  have  been 
preparing  for  this  for  the  last  fifteen  years.' 


GOSSIP  ON  THE  ROAD.  255 

Father  Desgodins  was  right.  It  is  the  old  story 
of  ill-advised  conciliation  and  forbearance.  We 
were  afraid  of  the  bugbear  of  China.  The  British 
Government  says  to  her  victim  after  the  chastise- 
ment :  *  You've  had  your  lesson.  Now  run  off 
and  be  good.*  And  the  spoilt  child  of  arrested 
civilization  runs  off  with  his  tongue  in  his  cheek 
and  learns  to  make  new  arms  and  friends.  The 
British  Government  in  the  meantime  sleeps  in 
smug  complacency,  and  Exeter  Hall  is  appeased. 

*  But  why  did  you  not  treat  with  the  Tibetans 
themselves  ?  *  Pere  Desgodins  asked.  *  China  !  * — 
here  he  made  an  expressive  gesture — *  I  have 
known  China  for  fifty  years.  She  is  not  your 
friend.*  Of  course  it  is  to  the  interest  of  China 
to  keep  the  tea  monopoly,  and  to  close  the  market 
to  British  India.  Travellers  on  the  Chinese  borders 
are  given  passports  and  promises  of  assistance, 
but  the  natives  of  the  districts  they  traverse  are 
ordered  to  turn  them  back  and  place  every  obstacle 
in  their  way.  Nobody  knows  this  better  than 
Father  Desgodins,  China's  policy  is  the  same 
with  nations  as  with  individuals.  She  will  always 
profess  willingness  to  help,  but  protest  that  her 
subjects  are  unmanageable  and  out  of  hand.    Why, 


256  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

then,  deal  with  China  at  all  ?  We  can  only  answer 
that  she  had  more  authority  in  Lhasa  in  1888. 
Moreover,  we  were  more  afraid  of  offending  her 
susceptibilities.    But  that  bubble  has  burst. 

Others  who  hold  different  views  from  P^re  Des- 
godins  say  that  this  very  unruliness  of  her  vassal 
ought  to  make  China  welcome  our  intervention 
in  Tibet,  if  we  engage  to  respect  her  claims  there 
when  we  have  subdued  the  Lamas.  This  policy 
might  certainly  point  a  temporary  way  out  of  the 
muddle,  whereby  we  could  save  our  face  and  be 
rid  of  the  Tibet  incubus  for  perhaps  a  year.  But 
the  plan  of  leaving  things  to  the  suzerain  Power 
has  been  tried  too  often. 

As  I  rode  down  the  Pedong  street  from  the  pres- 
bytery someone  called  me  by  name,  and  a  little, 
smiling,  gnome-like  man  stepped  out  of  a  white- 
washed office.  It  WcLS  Phuntshog,  a  Tibetan 
friend  whom  I  had  known  six  years  previously 
on  the  North-East  frontier.  I  dismounted,  ex- 
pecting entertainment. 

The  office  was  bare  of  furniture  save  a  new 
writing-table  and  two  chairs,  but  heaped  round 
the  walls  were  piles  of  cast  steel  and  iron  plates 
and  files  and  pipes  for  bellows.    Phuntshog  ex- 


GOSSIP  ON  THE  ROAD.  257 

plained  that  he  was  frontier  trade  examiner,  and 
that  the  steel  had  been  purchased  in  Calcutta 
by  a  Lama  last  year,  and  was  confiscated  on  the 
frontier  as  contraband.  It  was  material  for  an 
armoury.  The  spoilt  child  was  making  new  arms, 
like  the  schoolboy  who  exercises  his  muscle  to 
avenge  himself  after  a  beating. 

"  Do  you  get  much  of  this  sort  of  thing  ?  '  I 
asked. 

*  Not  now,'  he  said ;  *  they  have  given  up  trying 
to  get  it  through  this  way.* 

A  few  years  ago  eight  Mohammedans,  experts 
in  rifle  manufacture,  had  been  decoyed  from  a 
Calcutta  factory  to  Lhasa.  Two  had  died  there, 
and  one  I  traced  at  Yatung.  His  wife  had  not 
been  allowed  to  pass  the  barrier,  but  he  was  given 
a  Tibetan  helpmate.  The  wife  lived  some  months 
at  Yatung,  and  used  to  receive  large  instalments 
from  her  husband ;  once,  I  was  told,  as  much  as 
Rs.  1,400.  But  he  never  came  back.  The  Tibetans 
have  learned  to  make  rifles  for  themselves  now. 
Phuntshog  had  a  story  about  another  suspicious 
character,  a  mysterious  Lama  who  arrived  in  Dar- 
jeeling  in  1901  from  Calcutta  with  5,000  alms 
bowls  for  Tibet,  which  he  said  he  had  purchased 
9 


258  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

in  Germany.  The  man  was  detained  in  Darjeeling 
five  months  under  police  espionage,  and  finally  sent 
back  to  Calcutta. 

Our  Intelligence  Department  on  this  frontier  is 
more  alert  than  it  used  to  be.  Dorjieff,  Phuntshog 
told  me,  had  been  to  Darjeeling  twice,  and  stayed 
in  a  trader's  house  at  Kalimpong  several  days.  He 
wore  the  dress  of  a  Lama.  The  ostensible  object 
of  his  journey  was  to  visit  the  sacred  Chorten  at 
Khatmandu  and  the  shrines  of  Benares.  He 
visited  these,  and  was  known  to  spend  some  time 
in  Calcutta.  On  the  occasion  of  the  mission  to 
St.  Petersburg  Dorjieff  and  his  colleagues  entered 
India  through  Nepal,  took  train  to  Bombay,  and 
shipped  thence  to  Odessa.  The  discovery  of  the 
Lamas'  visit  to  India  was  almost  simultaneous 
with  their  departure  from  Bombay. 

Phuntshog  is  not  an  admirer  of  our  Tibetan 
policy.  We  ought  to  have  laid  ourselves  out,  he 
said,  to  influence  the  Lamas  by  secret  agents,  as 
Russia  did.  There  was  no  chance  of  a  com- 
promise now ;  they  would  fight  to  the  death. 
Phuntshog  said  much  more  which  I  suspected  was 
inspired  by  the  daily  newspapers,  so  I  questioned 
him  as  to  the  feelings  of  the  natives  of  the  district. 


GOSSIP  ON  THE  ROAD.  259 

'  The  feeling  of  patriotism  is  extinct,'  he  said ; 
and  he  looked  at  his  stomach,  showing  that  he 
spoke  the  truth.  ^  We  Tibetan  British  subjects 
are  fed  well  and  paid  well  by  your  Government. 
We  want  nothing  more.  My  family  are  here. 
Now  I  have  no  trade  to  examine.'  His  eyes 
slowly  surveyed  the  room,  glanced  over  his  office 
table,  with  its  pen  and  ink  and  blank  paper,  lit 
on  the  150  maunds  of  cast-steel,  and  finally  rested 
on  two  volumes  by  his  elbow. 

*  Do  you  read  much  ?  '  I  asked. 

'  Sometimes,'  he  said.  ^  I  have  learnt  a  good 
deal  from  these  books.' 

They  were  the  Holy  Bible  and  Miss  Braddon's 
'  Dead  Men's  Shoes.' 

'  Phuntshog,'  I  said,  *  you  are  a  psychological 
enigma.  Your  mind  is  like  that  cast-iron  huddled 
in  the  comer  there,  bought  in  an  enlightened 
Western  city  and  destined  for  your  benighted 
Lhasa,  but  stuck  halfway.  Only  it  was  going 
the  other  way.  You  don't  understand  ?  Neither 
doL' 

And  here  at  Ari,  as  I  look  across  the  valley  of 
the  Russett  Chu  to  Pedong,  and  hear  the  vesper 
bell,  I  cannot  help  thinking  of  that  strange  con- 


26o         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

flict  of  minds — the  devotee  who,  seeing  further 
than  most  men,  has  cared  nothing  for  the  things 
of  this  incarnation,  and  Phuntshog,  the  strange 
hybrid  product  of  restless  Western  energies,  stir- 
ring and  muddying  the  shallows  of  the  Eastern 
mind.    Or  are  they  depths  ? 

Who  knows  ?  I  know  nothing,  only  that  these 
men  are  inscrutable,  and  one  cannot  see  into  their 
hearts. 


CHAPTER  XII 

TO   THE   GREAT  RIVER 

I  REACHED  Gyantse  on  July  12.  The  advance 
to  Lhasa  began  on  the  14th.  As  might  be  ex- 
pected from  the  tone  of  the  delegates,  peace  negotia- 
tions fell  through.  The  Lhasa  Government  seemed 
to  be  chaotic  and  conveniently  inaccessible.  The 
Dalai  Lama  remained  a  great  impersonality,  and 
the  four  Shapes  or  Councillors  disclaimed  all  re- 
sponsibility. The  Tsong-du,  or  National  Assembly, 
who  virtually  governed  the  country,  had  sent  us  no 
communication.  The  delegates'  attitude  of  non 
possumus  was  not  assumed.  Though  these  men 
were  the  highest  officials  in  Tibet,  they  could  not 
guarantee  that  any  settlement  they  might  make 
with  us  would  be  faithfully  observed.  There 
seemed  no  hope  of  a  solution  to  the  deadlock  except 
by  absolute  militarism.  If  the  Tibetans  had 
fought  so  stubbornly  at  Gyantse,  what  fanaticism 


262  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

might  we  not  expect  at  Lhasa  !  Most  of  us  thought 
that  we  could  only  reach  the  capital  through  the 
most  awful  carnage.  We  pictured  the  40,000  monks 
of  Lhasa  hurling  themselves  defiantly  on  our  camp. 
We  saw  them  mown  down  by  Maxims,  lanes  of 
dead.  A  hopeless  struggle,  and  an  ugly  page  in 
military  history.  Still,  we  must  go  on  ;  there  was 
no  help  for  it.  The  blood  of  these  people  was  on 
their  own  heads. 

We  left  Gyantse  on  the  14th,  and  plunged  into 
the  unknown  towards  Lhasa,  which  we  had  reason 
to  believe  lay  in  some  hidden  valley  150  miles 
to  the  north,  beyond  the  unexplored  basin  of  the 
Tsangpo.  Every  position  on  the  road  was  held. 
The  Karo  la  had  been  enormously  strengthened, 
and  was  occupied  by  2,000  men.  The  enemy's 
cavahy,  which  we  had  never  seen,  were  at  Nagartse 
Jong.  Gubshi,  a  dilapidated  fort,  only  nineteen 
miles  on  the  road,  was  held  by  several  hundred. 
The  Tibetans  intended  to  dispute  the  passage  of 
the  Brahmaputra,  and  there  were  other  strong 
positions  where  the  path  skirted  the  Kyi-chu  for 
miles  beneath  overhanging  rocks,  which  were  care- 
fully prepared  for  booby-traps.  We  had  to  launch 
ourselves    into    this   intensely    hostile   region    and 


TO  THE  GREAT  RIVER.  263 

compel  some  people — ^we  did  not  know  whom — to 
attach  their  signatures  and  seals  to  a  certain  parch- 
ment which  was  to  bind  them  to  good  behaviour  in 
the  future,  and  a  recognition  of  obligations  they 
had  hitherto  disavowed. 

Our  force  consisted  of  eight  companies  of  the 
8th  Gurkhas,  five  companies  of  the  32nd  Pioneers, 
four  companies  of  the  40th  Pathans,  four  com- 
panies of  the  Royal  Fusiliers,  two  companies  of 
Mounted  Infantry,  No.  30,  British  Mountain  Bat- 
tery, a  section  of  No.  7  Native  Mountain  Battery, 
1st  Madras  Sappers  and  Miners,  machine-gun 
section  of  the  Norfolks,  and  details.*  The  23rd 
Pioneers,  to  their  disgust,  were  left  to  garrison 
Gyantse.  The  transport  included  mule,  yak,  donkey, 
and  coolie  corps. 

The  first  three  marches  to  Ralung  were  a  repeti- 
tion of  the  country  between  Kalatso  and  Gyantse 
— in  the  valley  a  strip  of  irrigated  land,  green  and 
gold,  with  alternate  barley  and  mustard  fields 
between  hillsides  bare  and  verdureless  save  for 
tufts  of  larkspur,  astragalus,  and  scattered  yellow 
poppies.     To    Gyantse    one    descends    2,000    feet 

♦  Companies  of  Pathans  and  Gurkhas  were  left  to  garrison 
Ralung,  Nagartse,  Pehte,  Chaksam,  and  Toilxing  Bridge. 


264  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

from  a  country  entirely  barren  of  trees  to  a  valley 
of  occasional  willow  and  poplar  groves ;  while 
from  Gyantse,  as  one  ascends,  the  clusters  of  trees 
become  fewer,  until  one  reaches  the  treeless  zone 
again  at  Ralung  (15,000  feet).  The  last  grove  is 
at  Gubchi. 

I  quote  some  notes  of  the  march  from  my  diary : 
'July  14. — ^The  villages  by  the  roadside  are 
deserted  save  for  old  women  and  barking  dogs. 
The  Tibetans  came  down  from  the  Karo  la  and 
impressed  the  villagers.  Many  have  fled  into  the 
hills,  and  are  hiding  among  the  rocks  and  caves. 
Our  pickets  fired  on  some  to-night.  Seeing  their 
heads  bobbing  up  and  down  among  the  rocks,  they 
thought  they  were  surrounded.  Many  of  the 
fugitives  were  women.  Luckily,  none  were  hit. 
They  were  brought  into  camp  whimpering  and 
salaaming,  and  became  embarrassingly  grateful 
when  it  was  made  clear  to  them  that  they  were 
not  to  be  tortured  or  killed,  but  set  free.  They 
were  called  back,  however,  to  give  information 
about  grain,  and  thought  their  last  hour  had 
come.' 

*  July  16. — ^AU  the  houses  between  Gubchi  and 
Ralung  are  decorated  with  diagonal  blue,  red,  and 


TO  THE  GREAT  RIVER.  265 

white  stripes,  characteristic  of  the  Ning-ma  sect 
of  Buddhists.  They  remind  me  of  the  walls  of 
Damascus  after  the  visit  of  the  German  Emperor. 
Heavy  rain  falls  every  day.  Last  night  we  camped 
in  a  wet  mustard-field.  It  is  impossible  to  keep 
our  bedding  dry.' 

From  Ralung  the  valley  widens  out,  and  the 
country  becomes  more  bleak.  We  enter  a  plateau 
frequented  by  gazelle.  Cultivation  ceases.  The 
ascent  to  the  Karo  Pass  is  very  gradual.  The 
path  takes  a  sudden  turn  to  the  east  through  a 
narrow  gorge. 

On  the  17th  we  camped  under  the  Karo  la  in 
the  snow  range  of  Noijin  Kang  Sang,  at  an  eleva- 
tion of  1,000  feet  above  Mont  Blanc.  The  pass 
was  free  of  snow,  but  a  magnificent  glacier  de- 
scended within  500  feet  of  the  camp.  We  lay 
within  four  miles  of  the  enemy's  position.  Most 
of  us  expected  heavy  fighting  the  next  morning, 
as  we  knew  the  Tibetans  had  been  strengthening 
their  defences  at  the  Karo  la  for  some  days.  Vol- 
leys were  fired  on  our  scouts  on  the  i6th  and  17th. 
The  old  wall  had  been  extended  east  and  west 
until  it  ended  in  vertical  cliffs  just  beneath  the 
snow-line.    A  second  barrier  had  been  built  further 


266  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

on,  and  sangars  constructed  on  every  prominent 
point  to  meet  flank  attacks.  The  wall  itself  was 
massively  strong,  and  it  was  approached  by  a  steep 
cliff,  up  which  it  was  impossible  to  make  a  sus- 
tained charge,  as  the  rarefied  air  at  this  elevation 
(16,600  feet)  leaves  one  breathless  after  the  slightest 
exertion.  The  Karo  la  was  the  strongest  position 
on  the  road  to  Lhasa.  If  the  Tibetans  intended  to 
make  another  stand,  here  was  their  chance. 

In  the  messes  there  was  much  discussion  as  to 
the  seriousness  of  the  opposition  we  were  likely 
to  meet  with.  The  flanking  parties  had  a  long 
and  difficult  climb  before  them  that  would  take 
them  some  hours,  and  the  general  feeling  was 
that  we  should  be  lucky  if  we  got  the  transport 
through  by  noon.  But  when  one  of  us  suggested 
that  the  Tibetans  might  fail  to  come  up  to  the 
scratch,  and  abandon  the  position  without  firing 
a  shot,  we  laughed  at  him  ;  but  his  conjecture  was 
very  near  the  mark. 

At  7  a.m.  the  troops  forming  the  line  of  advance 
moved  into  position.  The  disposition  of  the  enemy's 
sangars  made  a  turning  movement  extremely  diffi- 
cult, but  a  frontal  attack  on  the  wall,  if  stubbornly 
resisted,  could  not  be  carried  without  severe  loss. 


TO  THE  GREAT  RIVER.  267 

General  Macdonald  sent  flanking  parties  of  the 
8th  Gurkhas  on  both  sides  of  the  valley  to  scale 
the  heights  and  turn  the  Tibetan  position,  and 
despatched  the  Royal  Fusihers  along  the  centre 
of  the  valley  to  attack  the  wall  when  the  opposition 
had  been  weakened. 

Stretched  on  a  grassy  knoll  on  the  left,  enjoying 
the  sunshine  and  the  smell  of  the  warm  turf,  we 
civilians  watched  the  whole  affair  with  our  glasses. 
It  might  have  been  a  picnic  on  the  Surrey  downs 
if  it  were  not  for  the  tap-tap  of  the  Maxim,  like  a 
distant  woodpecker,  in  the  valley,  and  the  occasional 
report  of  the  lo-pounders  by  our  side,  which  made 
the  valleys  and  cliffs  reverberate  Hke  thunder. 

The  Tibetans'  ruse  was  to  open  fire  from  the 
wall  directly  our  troops  came  into  view,  and  then 
evacuate  the  position.  They  thus  delayed  the  pur- 
suit while  we  were  waiting  for  the  scaHng-party  to 
ascend  the  heights. 

At  nine  o'clock  the  Gurkhas  on  the  left  signalled 
that  no  enemy  were  to  be  seen.  At  the  same  time 
Colonel  Cooper,  of  the  Royal  Fusiliers,  hehographed 
that  the  wall  was  unoccupied  and  the  Tibetans  in 
full  retreat.  The  mounted  infantry  were  at  once 
called  up  for  the  pursuit.     Meanwhile  one  or  two 


268  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

jingals  and  some  Tibetan  marksmen  kept  up  an 
intermittent  fire  on  the  right  flanking  party  from 
clefts  in  the  overhanging  cHffs.  A  battery  repUed 
with  shrapnel,  covering  our  advance.  These  pickets 
on  the  left  stayed  behind  and  engaged  our  right 
flanking  party  until  eleven  o'clock.  To  turn  the 
position  the  Gurkhas  chmbed  a  parallel  ridge,  and 
were  for  a  long  time  under  fire  of  their  jingals. 
The  last  part  of  the  ascent  was  along  the  edge  of  a 
glacier,  and  then  on  to  the  shoulder  of  the  ridge  by 
steps  which  the  Gurkhas  cut  in  the  ice  with  their 
kukris,  helping  one  another  up  with  the  butts  of 
their  rifles.  They  carried  rope  scaUng-ladders,  but 
these  were  for  the  descent.  At  11.30  Major  Murray 
and  his  two  companies  of  Gurkhas  appeared  on  the 
heights,  and  possession  was  taken  of  the  pass.  The 
ridge  that  the  Tibetans  had  held  was  apparently 
deserted,  but  every  now  and  then  a  man  was  seen 
crouching  in  a  cave  or  behind  a  rock,  and  was  shot 
down.  One  Kham  man  shot  a  Gurkha  who  was 
looking  into  the  cave  where  he  was  hiding.  He 
then  ran  out  and  held  up  his  thumbs,  expecting 
quarter.  He  was  rightly  cut  down  with  kukris. 
The  dying  Gurkha's  comrades  rushed  the  cave,  and 
drove  six  more  over  the  precipice  without  using 


TO  THE  GREAT  RIVER.  269 

steel  or  powder.  They  fell  sheer  300  feet.  Another 
Gurkha  cut  off  a  Tibetan's  head  with  his  own  sword. 
On  several  occasions  they  hesitated  to  soil  their 
kukris  when  they  could  despatch  their  victims  in 
any  other  way. 

On  a  further  ridge,  a  heart-breaking  ascent  of 
shale  and  boulders,  we  saw  two  or  three  hundred 
Tibetans  ascending  into  the  clouds.  We  had  marked 
them  at  the  beginning  of  the  action,  before  we 
knew  that  the  wall  was  unoccupied.  Even  then 
it  was  oiear  that  the  men  were  fugitives,  and  had 
no  thought  of  holding  the  place.  We  could  see 
them  hours  afterwards,  with  our  glasses,  crouching 
under  the  cliffs.  We  turned  shrapnel  and  Maxims 
on  them ;  the  hillsides  began  to  move.  Then  a 
company  of  Pathans  was  sent  up,  and  despatched 
over  forty.  It  was  at  this  point  I  saw  an  act  of 
heroism  which  quite  changed  my  estimate  of  these 
men.  A  group  of  four  were  running  up  a  cliff,  under 
fire  from  the  Pathans  at  a  distance  of  about  500 
yards.  One  was  hit,  and  his  comrade  stayed  be- 
hind to  carry  him.  The  two  unimpeded  Tibetans 
made  their  escape,  but  the  rescuer  could  only  shamble 
along  with  difficulty.  He  and  his  wounded  com- 
rade were  both  shot  down. 


270         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

The  i8th  was  a  disappointing  day  to  our  soldiers. 
But  the  action  was  of  great  interest,  owing  to  the 
altitude  in  which  our  flanking  parties  had  to  operate. 
There  is  a  saying  on  the  Indian  frontier :  *  There  is 
a  hill ;  send  up  a  Gurkha.'  These  sturdy  little  men 
are  splendid  mountaineers,  and  ^^dll  climb  up  the 
face  of  a  rock  while  the  enemy  are  rolling  down 
stones  on  them  as  coolly  as  they  will  rush  a  wall 
under  heavy  fire  on  the  flat.  Their  arduous  climb 
took  three  and  a  half  hours,  and  was  a  real  moun- 
taineering feat.  The  cave  fighting,  in  which  they 
had  three  casualties,  took  place  at  19,000  feet,  and 
this  is  probably  the  highest  elevation  at  which  an 
action  has  been  fought  in  history. 

A  few  of  the  Tibetans  fled  by  the  highroad,  along 
which  the  mounted  infantry  pursued,  killing  twenty 
and  taking  ten  prisoners.  I  asked  a  native  officer 
how  he  decided  whom  to  spare  or  kill,  and  he  said 
he  killed  the  men  who  ran,  and  spared  those  who 
came  towards  him.  The  destiny  that  preserved  the 
lives  of  our  ten  Kham  prisoners  when  nearly  the 
whole  of  the  levy  perished  reminded  me  in  its  capri- 
ciousness  of  Caliban's  whim  in  Setebos  : 

'  Let  twenty  pass,  and  stone  the  twenty-first. 
Loving  not,  hating  not,  just  choosing  so.' 


TO  THE  GREAT  RIVER.  271 

These  Kham  men  were  in  our  mounted  infantry 
camp  until  the  release  of  the  prisoners  in  Lhasa, 
and  made  themselves  useful  in  many  ways — loading 
mules,  carrying  us  over  streams,  fetching  wood  and 
water,  and  fodder  for  our  horses.  They  were  fed 
and  cared  for,  and  probably  never  fared  better  in 
their  lives.  When  they  had  nothing  to  do,  they 
would  sit  down  in  a  circle  and  discuss  things  resign- 
edly— the  English,  no  doubt,  and  their  ways,  and 
their  own  distant  country.  Sometimes  they  would 
ask  to  go  home ;  their  mothers  and  wives  did  not 
know  if  they  were  alive  or  dead.  But  we  had  no 
guarantee  that  they  would  not  fight  us  again. 
Now  they  knew  the  disparity  of  their  arms  they 
nlight  shrink  from  further  resistance,  yet  there  was 
every  chance  that  the  Lamas  would  compel  them 
to  fight.  They  became  quite  popular  in  the  camp, 
these  wild,  long-haired  men,  they  were  so  good- 
humoured,  gentle  in  manner,  and  ready  to  help. 

I  was  sorry  for  these  Tibetans.  Their  struggle 
was  so  hopeless.  They  were  brave  and  simple, 
and  none  of  us  bore  the  shghtest  vindictiveness 
against  them.  Here  was  all  the  brutality  of  war, 
and  none  of  the  glory  and  incentive.  These  men 
were  of  the  same  race  as  the  people  I  had  been  liv- 


272  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

ing  amongst  at  Darjeeling — cheerful,  jolly  fellows 
— and  I  had  seen  their  crops  ruined,  their  houses 
burnt  and  shelled,  the  dead  lying  about  the  thresh- 
olds of  what  were  their  homes,  and  all  for  no  fault 
of  their  own — only  because  their  leaders  were  politi- 
cally impossible,  which,  of  course,  the  poor  fellows 
did  not  know,  and  there  was  no  one  to  tell  them. 
They  thought  our  advance  an  act  of  unprovoked 
aggression,  and  they  were  fighting  for  their  homes. 
Fortunately,  however,  this  slaughter  was  begin- 
ning to  put  the  fear  of  God  into  them.  We  never 
saw  a  Tibetan  within  five  miles  who  did  not  carry 
a  huge  white  flag.  The  second  action  at  the  Karo 
la  was  the  end  of  the  Tibetan  resistance.  The  fall 
of  Gyantse  Jong,  which  they  thought  unassailable, 
seems  to  have  broken  their  spirit  altogether.  At 
the  Karo  la  they  had  evidently  no  serious  intention 
of  holding  the  position,  but  fought  like  men  driven 
to  the  front  against  their  will,  with  no  confidence 
or  heart  in  the  business  at  all.  The  friendly  Bhu- 
tanese  told  us  that  the  Tibetans  would  not  stand 
where  they  had  once  been  defeated,  and  that  levies 
who  had  once  faced  us  were  not  easily  brought  into 
the  field  again.  These  were  casual  generaUzations, 
no  doubt,  but  they  contained  a  great  deal  of  truth. 


TO  THE  GREAT  RIVER.  273 

The  Kham  men  who  opposed  us  at  the  first  Karo 
la  action,  the  Shigatze  men  who  attacked  the  mis- 
sion in  May,  and  the  force  from  Lhasa  who  hurled 
themselves  on  Kangma,  were  all  new  levies.  Many 
of  our  prisoners  protested  very  strongly  against 
being  released,  fearing  to  be  exposed  again  to  our 
bullets  and  their  own  Lamas. 

On  the  1 8th  we  reached  Nagartse  Jong,  and 
found  the  Shapes  awaiting  us.  They  met  us  in 
the  same  impracticable  spirit.  We  were  not  to 
occupy  the  jong,  and  they  were  not  empowered  to 
treat  with  us  unless  we  returned  to  Gyantse.  It 
was  a  repetition  of  Khamba  Jong  and  Tuna.  In 
the  afternoon  a  durbar  was  held  in  Colonel  Young- 
husband's  tent,  when  the  Tibetans  showed  them- 
selves appallingly  futile  and  childish.  They  did 
not  seem  to  realize  that  we  were  in  a  position  to 
dictate  terms,  and  Colonel  Younghusband  had  to 
repeat  that  it  was  now  too  late  for  any  compromise, 
and  the  settlement  must  be  completed  at  Lhasa. 

From  Nagartse  we  held  interviews  with  these 
tedious  delegates  at  almost  every  camp.  They 
exhausted  everyone's  patience  except  the  Com- 
missioner's. For  days  they  did  not  yield  a  point, 
and  refused  even  to  discuss  terms  unless  we  returned 


274  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

to  Gyantse.  But  their  protests  became  more  urgent 
as  we  went  on,  their  tone  less  minatory.  It  was 
not  until  we  were  within  fifty  miles  of  Lhasa  that 
the  Tibetan  Government  deigned  to  enter  into  com- 
munication with  the  mission.  At  Tamalung  Colonel 
Younghusband  received  the  first  communication 
from  the  National  Assembly  ;  at  Chaksam  arrived 
the  first  missive  the  British  Government  had  ever 
received  from  the  Dalai  Lama.  During  the  delay 
at  the  ferry  the  councillors  practically  threw  them- 
selves on  Colonel  Younghusband's  mercy.  They 
said  that  their  lives  would  be  forfeited  if  we  pro- 
ceeded, and  dwelt  on  the  severe  punishment  they 
might  incur  if  they  failed  to  conclude  negotiations 
satisfactorily.  But  Colonel  Younghusband  was  equal 
to  every  emergency.  It  would  be  impossible  to  find 
another  man  in  the  British  Empire  with  a  person- 
ality so  calculated  to  impress  the  Tibetans.  He  sat 
through  every  durbar  a  monument  of  patience  and 
inflexibility,  impassive  as  one  of  their  own  Buddhas. 
Priests  and  councillors  found  that  appeals  to  his 
mercy  were  hopeless.  He,  too,  had  orders  from  his 
King  to  go  to  Lhasa  ;  if  he  faltered,  his  fife  also  was 
at  stake )  decapitation  would  await  him  on  his 
return.    That  was  the  impression  he  purposely  gave 


TO  THE  GREAT  RIVER.  275 

them.  It  curtailed  palaver.  How  in  the  name  of 
all  their  Buddhas  were  they  to  stop  such  a  man  ? 

The  whole  progress  of  negotiations  put  me  in  mind 
of  the  coercion  of  very  naughty  children.  The  Lamas 
tried  every  guile  to  reduce  his  demands.  They  would 
be  cajoling  him  now  if  he  had  not  given  them  an  ulti- 
matum, and  if  they  had  not  learnt  by  six  weeks* 
contact  and  intercourse  with  the  man  that  shuffling 
was  hopeless,  that  he  never  made  a  promise  that  was 
not  fulfilled,  or  a  threat  that  was  not  executed. 
The  Tibetan  treaty  was  the  victory  of  a  personality, 
the  triumph  of  an  impression  on  the  least  impres- 
sionable people  in  the  world.     But  I  anticipate. 

While  the  Shapes  were  holding  Colonel  Young- 
husband  in  conference  at  Nagartse,  their  cavalry 
were  escorting  a  large  convoy  on  the  road  to  Lhasa. 
Our  mounted  infantry  came  upon  them  six  miles 
beyond  Nagartse,  and  as  they  were  rounding  them 
up  the  Tibetans  foolishly  fired  on  them.  We  cap- 
tured eighty  riding  and  baggage  ponies  and  mules 
and  fourteen  prisoners,  and  killed  several.  They 
made  no  stand,  though  they  were  well  armed  with 
a  medley  of  modern  rifles  and  well  mounted.  This 
was  actually  the  last  shot  fired  on  our  side.  The 
delegates  had  been  full  of  assurances  that  the  coun- 


276  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

try  was  clear  of  the  enemy,  hoping  that  the  convoy 
would  get  well  away  while  they  delayed  us  with 
fruitless  protests  and  reiterated  demands  to  go 
back.  While  they  were  palavering  in  the  tent, 
they  looked  out  and  saw  the  Pathans  go  past  with 
their  rich  yellow  silks  and  personal  baggage  looted 
in  the  brush  with  the  cavalry.  Their  consterna- 
tion was  amusing,  and  the  situation  had  its  element 
of  humour.  A  servant  rushed  to  the  door  of  the 
tent  and  deUvered  the  whole  tale  of  woe.  A  mounted 
infantry  officer  arrived  and  explained  that  our  scouts 
had  been  fired  on.  After  this,  of  course,  there  was 
no  talk  of  anything  except  the  restitution  of  the 
loot.  The  Shapes  deserved  to  lose  their  kit.  I  do 
not  remember  what  was  arranged,  but  if  any  readers 
of  this  record  see  a  gorgeous  yellow  cloak  of  silk  and 
brocade  at  a  fancy-dress  ball  in  London,  I  advise 
them  to  ask  its  history. 

This  last  encounter  with  the  Tibetans  is  especially 
interesting,  as  they  were  the  best-armed  body  of  men 
we  had  met.  The  weapons  we  captured  included 
a  Winchester  rifle,  several  Lhasa-made  Martinis,  a 
bolt  rifle  of  an  old  Austrian  pattern,  an  Enghsh- 
made  muzzle-loading  riile,  a  12-bore  breech-loading 
shot-gun,  some  Eley's  ammunition,  and  an  English 


TO  THE  GREAT  RIVER.  277 

gun-case.  The  reports  of  Russian  arms  found  in 
Tibet  have  been  very  much  exaggerated.  During 
the  whole  campaign  we  did  not  come  across  more 
than  thirty  Russian  Government  rifles,  and  these 
were  weapons  that  must  have  drifted  into  Tibet 
from  Mongoha,  just  as  rifles  of  British  pattern  found 
their  way  over  the  Indian  frontier  into  Lhasa. 
Also  it  must  be  remembered  that  the  weapons  locally 
made  in  Lhasa  were  of  British  pattern,  and  manu- 
factured by  experts  decoyed  from  a  British  factory. 
Had  these  men  been  Russian  subjects,  we  should 
have  regarded  their  presence  in  Lhasa  as  an  un- 
questionable proof  of  Muscovite  assistance.  Jeal- 
ousy and  suspicion  make  nations  wilfully  blind. 
Russia  fully  beUeves  that  we  are  giving  underhand 
assistance  to  the  Japanese,  and  many  Englishmen, 
who  are  unbiassed  in  other  questions,  are  ready  to 
believe,  without  the  slightest  proof,  that  Russia 
has  been  supplying  Tibet  with  arms  and  generals. 
We  had  been  informed  that  large  quantities  of  Rus- 
sian rifles  had  been  introduced  into  the  country, 
and  it  was  rumoured  that  the  Tibetans  were  reserv- 
ing these  for  the  defence  of  Lhasa  itself.  But  it  is 
hardly  credible  that  they  should  have  sent  levies 
against  us  armed  with  their  obsolete  matchlocks 


278  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

when  they  were  well  supplied  with  Wfeapons  of  a 
modern  pattern.  Russian  intrigue  Was  active  iti 
Lhasa,  but  it  had  not  gone  so  far  as  open  armament. 

At  Nagartse  we  came  across  the  great  Yamdok 
or  Palti  Lake,  along  the  shores  of  which  winds  the 
foad  to  Lhasa.  Nagartse  Jong  is  a  striking  old 
keep,  built  on  a  bluff  promontofy  of  hill  stretching 
out  t6wards  the  blue  waters  of  the  lake.  In  the 
distance  we  saw  the  crag-perched  mtonastery  of 
Samdihg,  where  lives  the  mysterious  Dorje  Phagmd, 
the  incarnation  of  the  goddess  Tara. 

The  wild  mountain  scenery  of  the  Yamdok  Tso, 
the  most  romantic  in  Tibet,  has  naturally  inspired 
many  legends.  When  Samding  was  threatened  by 
the  Dzungarian  invaders  early  in  the  eighteenth 
century,  Dorje  Phagmo  miraculously  converted  her- 
self and  all  her  attendant  monks  atid  nuns  into 
pigs.  Serung  Dandub^  the  Dzungarian  chief,  finding 
the  monastery  deserted,  said  that  he  would  not 
loot  a  place  guarded  only  by  swine,  whereupon 
Dorje  Phagmo  again  metamorphosed  herself  and 
her  satellites.  The  terrified  invaders  prostrated 
themselves  iti  awe  before  the  goddess,  and  presented 
the  monastery  with  the  most  priceless  gifts.  Simi- 
larly^  the  Abbot  of  Pehte  saved  the  fortress  and 


TO  THE  GREAT  RIVER.  279 

towa  from  another  band  of  invaders  by  giving  the 
lake  the  appearance  of  green  pasturelands,  into 
which  the  Dzungarians  galloped  and  were  engulfed. 
I  quote  these  tales,  which  have  been  mentioned  in 
nearly  every  book  on  Tibet,  as  typical  of  the  coun- 
try. Doubtless  similar  legends  will  be  current  in 
a  few  years  about  the  British  to  account  for  the 
sparing  of  Samding,  Nagartse,  and  Pehte  Jong. 

Special  courtesy  was  shown  the  monks  and  nuns 
of  Samding,  in  recognition  of  the  hospitahty  afforded 
Sarat  Chandra  Dass  by  the  last  incarnation  of  Dorje 
Phagmo,  who  entertained  the  Bengali  traveller, 
and  saw  that  he  was  attended  to  and  cared  for 
through  a  serious  illness.  A  letter  was  sent  Dorje 
Phagmo,  asking  if  she  would  receive  three  British 
officers,  including  the  antiquary  of  the  expedition. 
But  the  present  incarnation,  a  girl  of  six  or  seven 
years,  was  invisible,  and  the  convent  was  reported 
to  be  bare  of  ornament  and  singularly  disappoint- 
ing.    There  were  no  pigs. 

If  only  one  were  without  the  incubus  of  an  army, 
a  month  in  the  Noijin  Kang  Sang  country  and  the 
Yamdok  Plain  would  be  a  delightful  experience. 
But  when  one  is  accompanying  a  column  one  loses 
more  than  half  the  pleasure  of  travel.     One  has  to 


28o         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

get  up  at  a  fixed  hour — generally  uncomfortably 
early — breakfast,  and  pack  and  load  one's  mules 
and  see  them  started  in  their  allotted  place  in  the 
line,  ride  in  a  crowd  all  day,  often  at  a  snail's  pace, 
and  halt  at  a  fixed  place.  Shooting  is  forbidden 
on  the  line  of  march.  When  alone  one  can  wander 
about  with  a  gun,  pitch  camp  where  one  likes,  make 
short  or  long  marches  as  one  likes,  shoot  or  fish  or 
loiter  for  days  in  the  same  place.  The  spirit  which 
impels  one  to  travel  in  wild  places  is  an  impulse, 
conscious  or  unconscious,  to  be  free  of  laws  and 
restraints,  to  escape  conventions  and  social  obliga- 
tions, to  temporarily  throw  one's  self  back  into 
an  obsolete  phase  of  existence,  amidst  surroundings 
which  bear  little  mark  of  the  arbitrary  meddling 
of  man.  It  is  not  a  high  ideal,  but  men  often  de- 
ceive themselves  when  they  think  they  make  expe- 
ditions in  order  to  add  to  science,  and  forsake  the 
comforts  of  life,  and  endure  hunger,  cold,  fatigue, 
and  lonehness,  to  discover  in  exactly  what  parallel 
of  unknown  country  a  river  rises  or  bends  to  some 
particular  point  of  the  compass.  How  many  trav- 
ellers are  there  who  would  spend  the  same  time  in  an 
office  poring  over  maps  or  statistics  for  the  sake  of 
geography  or  any  other  science  ?     We  like  to  have 


TO  THE  GREAT  RIVER.  281 

a  convenient  excuse,  and  make  a  virtue  out  of  a 
hobby  or  an  instinct.  But  why  not  own  up  that 
one  travels  for  the  glamour  of  the  thing  ?  In  pre- 
vious wanderings  my  experience  had  always  been 
to  leave  a  base  with  several  different  objectives  in 
view,  and  to  take  the  route  that  proved  most  allur- 
ing when  met  by  a  choice  of  roads — some  old  de- 
serted city  or  ruined  shrine,  some  lake  or  marshland 
haunted  by  wild-fowl  that  have  never  heard  the 
crack  of  a  gun,  or  a  strip  of  desert  where  one  must 
calculate  how  to  get  across  with  just  sufficient  sup- 
plies and  no  margin.  I  like  to  drift  to  the  magnet 
of  great  watersheds,  lofty  mountain  passes,  fron- 
tiers where  one  emerges  among  people  entirely 
different  in  habit  and  belief  from  folk  the  other 
side,  but  equally  convinced  that  they  are  the  only 
enlightened  people  on  earth.  Often  in  India  I  had 
dreamed  of  the  great  inland  waters  of  Tibet  and 
Mongoha,  the  haunts  of  myriads  of  duck  and  geese 
— Yamdok  Tso,  Tengri  Nor,  Issik  Kul,  names  of 
romance  to  the  wild-fowler,  to  be  breathed  with 
reverence  and  awe.  I  envied  the  great  flights  of 
mallard  and  pochard  winging  northward  in  March 
and  April  to  the  unknown  ■  and  here  at  last  I  was 
camping  by  the  Yamdok  Tso  itself — with  an  army. 


282  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

Yet  I  have  digressed  to  grumble  at  the  only 
means  by  which  a  sight  of  these  hidden  waters 
was  possible.  When  we  passed  in  July,  there  were 
no  wild-fowl  on  the  lake  except  the  bar-headed 
geese  and  Brahminy  duck.  The  ruddy  sheldrake, 
or  Brahminy,  is  found  all  over  Tibet,  and  will  be 
associated  with  the  memory  of  nearly  every  march 
and  camping-ground.  It  is  distinctly  a  Buddhist 
bird.  From  it  is  derived  the  title  of  the  established 
Church  of  the  Lamas,  the  Abbots  of  which  wear 
robes  of  ruddy  sheldrake  colour,  Gelug-pa.*  In 
Burmah  the  Brahminy  is  sacred  to  Buddhism  as  a 
symbol  of  devotion  and  fidelity,  and  it  was  figured 
on  Asoka's  pillars  in  the  same  emblematical  char- 
acter.! The  Brahminy  is  generally  found  in  pairs, 
and  when  one  is  shot  the  other  will  often  hover 
round  till  it  falls  a  victim  to  conjugal  love.  In 
India  the  bird  is  considered  inedible,  but  we  were 
glad  of  it  in  Tibet,  and  discovered  no  trace  of  fishy 
flavour. 

Early  in  April,  when  we  passed  the  Bam  Tso 
and  Kala  Tso  we  found  the  lakes  frequented  by 
nearly  all  the  common  migratory  Indian  duck ; 
and  again,   on  our  return  large  flights  came  in. 

♦  Waddell,  '  Lamaism  in  Tibet,'  p.  200.  f  J'Wi.,  p.  409. 


TO  THE  GREAT  RIVER.  283 

But  during  the  summer  months  nothing  remained 
except  the  geese  and  sheldrake  and  the  goosander, 
which  is  resident  in  Tibet  and  the  Himalayas.  I 
take  it  that  no  respectable  duck  spends  the  summer 
south  of  the  Tengri  Nor.  At  Lhasa,  mallard,  teal, 
gadwall,  and  white-eyed  pochard  were  coming  in 
from  the  north  as  we  were  leaving  in  the  latter 
half  of  September,  and  followed  us  down  to  the 
plains.  They  make  shorter  flights  than  I  imagined, 
and  longer  stays  at  their  fashionable  Central  Asian 
watering-places. 

We  marched  three  days  along  the  banks  of  the 
Yamdok  Tso,  and  halted  a  day  at  Nagartse.  Duck 
were  not  plentiful  on  the  lake.  Black-headed  gulls 
and  redshanks  were  common.  The  fields  of  blue 
borage  by  the  villages  were  an  exquisite  sight. 
On  the  22nd  we  reached  Pehte.  The  jong,  a  medi- 
eval fortress,  stands  out  on  the  lake  like  Chillon, 
only  it  is  more  crumbling  and  dilapidated.  The 
courtyards  are  neglected  and  overgrown  with 
nettles.  Soldiers,  villagers,  both  men  and  women, 
had  run  away  to  the  hills  with  their  flocks  and  valu- 
ables. Only  an  old  man  and  two  boys  were  left 
in  charge  of  the  chapel  and  the  fort.  The  hide 
fishing-boats   were   sunk,    or    carried   over   to   the 


284         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

other  side.  On  July  24  we  left  the  lake  near  the 
village  of  Tamalung,  and  ascended  the  ridge  on  our 
left  to  the  Khamba  Pass,  1,200  feet  above  the  lake 
level.  A  sudden  turn  in  the  path  brought  us  to 
the  saddle,  and  we  looked  down  on  the  great  river 
that  has  been  guarded  from  European  eyes  for 
nearly  a  century.  In  the  heart  of  Tibet  we  had 
found  Arcadia — not  a  detached  oasis,  but  a  continu- 
ous strip  of  verdure,  where  the  Tsangpo  cleaves  the 
bleak  hills  and  desert  tablelands  from  west  to  east. 

All  the  valley  was  covered  with  green  and  yellow 
cornfields,  with  scattered  homesteads  surrounded 
by  clusters  of  trees,  not  dwarfish  and  stunted  in 
the  struggle  for  existence,  but  stately  and  spread- 
ing— trees  that  would  grace  the  valley  of  the  Thames 
or  Severn. 

We  had  come  through  the  desert  to  Arcady. 
When  we  left  Phari,  months  and  months  before, 
and  crossed  the  Tang  la,  we  entered  the  desert. 

Tuna  is  built  on  bare  gravel,  and  in  winter-time 
does  not  boast  a  blade  of  grass.  Within  a  mile 
there  are  stunted  bushes,  dry,  withered,  and  sap- 
less, which  lend  a  sustenance  to  the  gazelle  and 
wild  asses,  beasts  that  from  the  beginning  have 
chosen  isolation,  and,  like  the  Tibetans,  who  people 


TO  THE  GREAT  RIVER.  285 

the  same  waste,  are  content  with  spare  diet  so 
long  as  they  are  left  alone. 

Every  Tibetan  of  the  tableland  is  a  hermit  by 
choice,  or  some  strange  hereditary  instinct  has 
impelled  him  to  accept  Nature's  most  niggard 
gifts  as  his  birthright,  so  that  he  toils  a  lifetime 
to  win  by  his  own  labour  and  in  scanty  measure 
the  necessaries  which  Nature  deals  lavishly  else- 
where, herding  his  yaks  on  the  waste  lands,  tilling 
the  unproductive  soil  for  his  meagre  crop  of  barley, 
and  searching  the  hillsides  for  yak-dung  for  fuel 
to  warm  his  stone  hut  and  cook  his  meal  of 
flour. 

Yet  north  and  south  of  him,  barely  a  week*s 
journey,  are  warm,  fertile  valleys,  luxuriant  crops, 
unstinted  woodlands,  where  Mongols  like  himself 
accept  Nature's  largess  philosophically  as  the  most 
natural  thing  in  the  world. 

It  seems  as  if  some  special  and  economical  law 
of  Providence,  such  a  law  as  makes  at  least  one 
man  see  beauty  in  every  type  of  woman,  even  the 
most  unlovely,  had  ordained  it,  so  that  no  comer 
of  the  ecirth,  not  even  the  Sahara,  Tadmor,  Tuna, 
or  Guru,  should  lack  men  who  devote  themselves 
blindly  and  without  question  to  live  there,   and 


286  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

care  for  what  one  might  think  God  Himself  had 
forgotten  and  overlooked. 

These  men — Bedouin,  Tibetans,  and  the  like — 
enjoy  one  thing,  for  which  they  forego  most  things 
that  men  crave  for,  and  that  is  freedom.  They  do 
not  possess  the  gifts  that  cause  strife,  and  divisions, 
and  law-making,  and  political  parties,  and  changes 
of  Government.  They  have  too  little  to  share. 
Their  country  is  invaded  only  at  intervals  of  cen- 
turies. On  these  occasions  they  fight  bravely,  as 
their  one  inheritance  is  at  stake.  But  they  are 
bigoted  and  benighted  ;  they  have  not  kept  time 
with  evolution,  and  so  they  are  defeated.  The 
conservatism',  the  exclusiveness,  that  has  kept  them 
free  so  long  has  shut  the  door  to  '  progress,'  which, 
if  they  were  enlightened  and  introspective,  they 
would  recognise  as  a  pestilence  that  has  infected 
one  half  of  the  world  at  the  expense  of  the  other, 
making  both  unhappy  and  discontented. 

The  Tuna  Plain  is  like  the  Palmyra  Desert  at 
the  point  where  one  comes  within  view  of  the 
snows  of  Lebanon.  It  is  not  monotonous ;  there 
is  too  much  play  of  light  and  shade  for  that. 
Everywhere  the  sun  shines,  the  mirage  dances ; 
the  white  calcined  plain  becomes  a  flock  of  fright- 


TO  THE  GREAT  RIVER.  287 

ened  sheep  hurrying  down  the  wind  ;  the  stunted 
sedge  by  the  lakeside  leaps  up  like  a  squadron 
in  ambush  and  sweeps  rapidly  along  without  ever 
approaching  nearer.  Sometimes  a  herd  of  wild 
asses  is  mingled  in  the  dance,  grotesquely  magni- 
fied ;  stones  and  nettles  become  walls  and  men. 
All  the  country  is  elusive  and  unreal. 

A  few  miles  beyond  Guru  the  road  skirts  the 
Bamtso  Lake,  which  must  once  have  filled  the 
whole  valley.  Now  the  waters  have  receded,  as 
the  process  of  desiccation  is  going  on  which  has 
entirely  changed  the  geographical  features  of 
Central  Asia,  and  caused  the  disappearance  of 
great  expanses  of  water  like  the  Koko  Nor,  and 
the  dwindling  of  lakes  and  river  from  Khotan  to 
Gobi.  The  Roof  of  the  World  is  becoming  less  and 
less  inhabitable. 

From  the  desert  to  Arcady  is  not  a  long  journey, 
but  armies  travel  slowly.  After  months  of  wait- 
ing and  delay  we  reached  the  promised  land.  It 
was  all  suddenly  unfolded  to  our  view  when  we 
stood  on  the  Khamba  la.  Below  us  was  a  purely 
pastoral  landscape.  Beyond  lay  hills  even  more 
barren  and  verdureless  than  those  we  had  crossed. 
But   every  mile   or   so   green   fan-shaped   valleys. 


288  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

irrigated  by  clear  streams,  interrupted  the  barren- 
ness, opening  out  into  the  main  valley  east  and 
west  with  perfect  symmetry.  To  the  north-east 
flowed  the  Kyi  Chu,  the  valley  in  which  Lhasa 
lay  screened,  only  fifty-six  miles  distant. 

To  the  south  of  the  pass  lay  the  great  Yamdok 
Lake,  wild  and  beautiful,  its  channels  twining 
into  the  dark  interstices  of  the  hills — valleys  of 
mystery  and  gloom,  where  no  white  man  has 
ever  trod.  Lights  and  shadows  fell  caressingly 
on  the  lake  and  hills.  At  one  moment  a  peak 
was  ebony  black,  at  another — as  the  heavy  clouds 
passed  from  over  it,  and  the  sun's  rays  illumined 
it  through  a  thin  mist — golden  as  a  field  of  butter- 
cups. Often  at  sunset  the  grassy  cones  of  the 
hills  glow  like  gilded  pagodas,  and  the  Tibetans, 
I  am  told,  call  these  sunlit  plots  the  *  golden 
ground.' 

In  bright  sunlight  the  lake  is  a  deep  turquoise 
blue,  but  at  evening  time  transient  lights  and 
shades  fleet  over  it  with  the  moving  clouds,  light 
forget-me-not,  deep  purple,  the  azure  of  a  butter- 
fly's wing — then  all  is  swept  away,  immersed  in 
gloom,  before  the  dark,  menacing  storm-clouds. 

On  the  25th  I  crossed  the  river  with  the  ist 


TO  THE  GREAT  RIVER.  289 

Mounted  Infantry  and  40th  Pathans.  My  tent  is 
pitched  on  the  roof  of  a  rambling  two-storied 
house,  under  the  shade  of  a  great  walnut-tree. 
Crops,  waist-deep,  grow  up  to  the  walls — barley, 
wheat,  beans,  and  peas.  On  the  roof  are  garden 
flowers  in  pots,  hollyhocks,  and  marigolds.  The 
cornfields  are  bright  with  English  wild-flowers — 
dandelions,  buttercups,  astragalus,  and  a  purple 
Michaelmas  daisy. 

There  is  no  village,  but  farmhouses  are  dotted 
about  the  valley,  and  groves  of  trees — walnut  and 
peach,  and  poplar  and  willow — enclosed  within 
stone  walls.  Wild  birds  that  are  almost  tame  are 
nesting  in  the  trees — black  and  white  magpies, 
crested  hoopoes,  and  turtle-doves.  The  groves 
are  irrigated  like  the  fields,  and  carpeted  with  flowers. 
Homelike  butterflies  frequent  them,  and  honey- 
bees. 

Everything  is  homelike.  There  is  no  mystery 
in  the  valley,  except  its  access,  or,  rather,  its  in- 
accessibility. We  have  come  to  it  through  snow 
passes,  over  barren,  rocky  wildernesses ;  we  have 
won  it  with  toil  and  suffering,  through  frost  and 
rain  and  snow  and  blistering  sun. 

And  now  that  we  had  found  Arcady,  I  would 
10 


290  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

have  stayed  there.  Lhasa  was  only  four  marches 
distant,  but  to  me,  in  that  mood  of  almost  im- 
moral indolence,  it  seemed  that  this  strip  of  ver- 
dure, with  its  happy  pastoral  scenes,  was  the  most 
impassable  barrier  that  Nature  had  planted  in  our 
path.  Like  the  Tibetans,  she  menaced  and  threat- 
ened us  at  first,  then  she  turned  to  us  with  smiles 
and  cajoleries,  entreating  us  to  stay,  and  her 
seduction  was  harder  to  resist. 

****** 
To  trace  the  course  of  the  Tsangpo  River  from 
Tibet  to  its  outlet  into  Assam  has  been  the  goal 
of  travellers  for  over  a  century.  Here  is  one  of 
the  few  unknown  tracts  of  the  world,  where  no 
white  man  has  ever  penetrated.  Until  quite 
recently  there  was  a  hot  controversy  among  geo- 
graphers as  to  whether  the  Tsangpo  was  the  main 
feeder  of  the  Brahmaputra  or  reappeared  in  Burmah 
as  the  Irawaddy.  All  attempts  to  explore  the 
river  from  India  have  proved  fruitless,  owing  to  the 
intense  hostility  of  the  Abor  and  Passi  Minyang 
tribes,  who  oppose  all  intrusion  with  their  poisoned 
arrows  and  stakes,  sharp  and  formidable  as  spears, 
cunningly  set  in  the  ground  to  entrap  invaders ; 
while  the  vigilance  of  the  Lamas  has  made  it  im- 


TO  THE  GREAT  RIVER.  291 

possible  for  any  European  to  get  within  150  miles 
of  the  Tsangpo  Valley  from  Tibet.  It  was  not 
until  1882  that  all  doubt  as  to  the  identity  of  the 
Tsangpo  and  Brahmaputra  was  set  aside  by  the 
survey  of  the  native  explorer  A.  K.  And  the 
course  of  the  Brahmaputra,  or  Dihong,  as  it  is 
called  in  Northern  Assam,  was  never  thoroughly 
investigated  until  the  explorations  of  Mr.  Needham, 
the  Political  Officer  at  Sadiya,  and  his  trained 
Gurkhas,  who  penetrated  northwards  as  far  as 
Gina,  a  village  half  a  day's  journey  beyond  Passi 
Ghat,  and  only  about  seventy  miles  south  of  the 
point  reached  by  A.  K,  from  Tibet. 

The  return  of  the  British  expedition  from  Tibet 
was  evidently  the  opportunity  of  a  century  for 
the  investigation  of  this  unexplored  country.  We 
had  gained  the  hitherto  inaccessible  base,  and 
were  provided  with  supplies  and  transport  on  the 
spot ;  we  had  no  opposition  to  expect  from  the 
Tibetans,  who  were  naturally  eager  to  help  us 
out  of  the  country  by  whatever  road  we  chose, 
and  had  promised  to  send  officials  with  us  to  their 
frontier  at  Gyala  Sendong,  who  would  forage  for 
us  and  try  to  impress  the  villagers  into  our  service. 
The  hostile  tribes  beyond  the  frontier  were  not  so 


292  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

likely  to  resist  an  expedition  moving  south  to  their 
homes  after  a  successful  campaign  as  a  force 
entering  their  country  from  our  Indian  frontier. 
In  the  latter  case  they  would  naturally  be  more 
suspicious  of  designs  on  their  independence.  The 
distance  from  Lhasa  to  Assam  was  variously  esti- 
mated from  500  to  700  miles.  I  think  the  cal- 
culations were  influenced,  perhaps  unconsciously, 
by  sympathy  with,  or  aversion  from,  the  enterprise. 

The  Shapes,  it  is  true,  though  they  promised  to 
help  us  if  we  were  determined  on  it,  advised  us 
emphatically  not  to  go  by  the  Tsangpo  route. 
They  said  that  the  natives  of  their  own  outlying 
provinces  were  bandits  and  cut-throats,  practi- 
cally independent  of  the  Lhasa  Government, 
while  the  savages  beyond  the  frontier  were  dan- 
gerous people  who  obeyed  no  laws.  The  Shapes' 
notions  as  to  the  course  of  the  river  were  most 
vague.  When  questioned,  they  said  there  was  a 
legend  that  it  disappeared  into  a  hole  in  the  earth. 
The  country  near  its  mouth  was  inhabited  by 
savages,  who  went  about  unclothed,  and  fed  on 
monkeys  and  reptiles.  It  was  rumoured  that  they 
were  homed  like  animals,  and  that  mothers  did 


TO  THE  GREAT  RIVER.  293 

not  know  their  ovvn  children.  But  this  they  could 
not  vouch  for. 

It  was  believed  that  tracks  of  a  kind  existed 
from  village  to  village  all  along  the  route,  but 
these,  of  course,  after  a  time  would  become  im- 
practicable for  pack  transport.  The  mules  would 
have  to  be  abandoned,  and  sent  back  to  Gyantse 
by  our  guides,  or  presented  to  the  Tibetan  officials 
who  accompanied  us.  Then  we  were  to  proceed 
by  forced  marches  through  the  jungle,  with  coolie 
transport  if  obtainable;  if  not,  each  man  was  to 
carry  rice  for  a  few  days.  The  distance  from  the 
Tibet  frontier  to  Sadiya  is  not  great,  and  the  un- 
explored country  is  reckoned  not  to  be  more  than 
seven  stages.  The  force  would  bivouac,  and,  if 
their  advance  were  resisted,  would  confine  them- 
selves solely  to  defensive  tactics.  In  case  of  op- 
position, the  greatest  difficulty  would  be  the  care 
of  the  wounded,  as  each  invalid  would  need  four 
carriers.  Thus,  a  few  casualties  would  reduce 
enormously  the  fighting  strength  of  the  escort. 

But  opposition  was  unlikely.  Mr.  Needham, 
who  has  made  the  tribes  of  the  Dihong  Valley 
the  study  of  a  lifetime,  and  succeeded  to  some 
extent  in  gaining  their  confidence,  considered  the 


294  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

chances  of  resistance  small.  He  would,  he  said, 
send  messages  to  the  tribes  that  the  force  coming 
through  their  country  from  the  north  were  his 
friends,  that  they  had  been  engaged  in  a  punitive 
expedition  against  the  Lamas  (whom  the  Abors 
detested),  that  they  were  returning  home  by  the 
shortest  route  to  Assam,  and  had  no  designs  on 
the  territory  they  traversed.  It  was  proposed 
that  Mr.  Needham  should  go  up  the  river  as  far 
as  possible  and  furnish  the  party  with  supplies. 

All  arrangements  had  been  made  for  the  ex- 
ploring-party,  which  was  to  leave  the  main  force 
at  Chaksam  Ferry,  and  was  expected  to  arrive  in 
Sadiya  almost  simultaneously  with  the  winding 
up  of  the  expedition  at  Siliguri.  Captain  Ryder, 
R.E.,  was  to  command  the  party,  and  his  escort 
was  to  be  made  up  of  the  8th  Gurkhas,  who  had 
long  experience  of  the  Assam  frontier  tribes,  and 
were  the  best  men  who  could  be  chosen  for  the 
work.  Officers  were  selected,  supply  and  trans- 
port details  arranged,  everything  was  in  readiness, 
when  at  the  last  moment,  only  a  day  or  two  before 
the  party  was  to  start,  a  message  was  received 
from  Simla  refusing  to  sanction  the  expedition. 
Colonel  Younghusband  was  entirely  in  favour  of 


TO  THE  GREAT  RIVER.  295 

it,  but  the  military  authorities  had  a  clean  slate  ; 
they  had  come  through  so  far  without  a  single 
disaster,  and  it  seemed  that  no  scientific  or  geo- 
graphical considerations  could  have  any  weight 
with  them  in  their  determination  to  take  no  risks. 
Of  course  there  were  risks,  and  always  must  be 
in  enterprises  of  the  kind  ;  but  I  think  the  cir- 
cumstances of  the  moment  reduced  them  to  a 
minimum,  and  that  the  results  to  be  obtained 
from  the  projected  expedition  should  have  entirely 
outweighed  them. 

In  European  scientific  circles  much  was  expected 
of  the  Tibetan  expedition.  But  it  has  added  very 
little  to  science.  The  surveys  that  were  made 
have  done  little  more  than  modify  the  previous 
investigations  of  native  surveyors.* 

*  The  only  expedition  sanctioned  is  that  which  is  now  ex- 
ploring the  little-known  trade  route  between  Gyantse  and  Gar- 
tok,  where  a  mart  has  been  opened  to  us  by  the  recent  Tibetan 
treaty.  The  party  consists  of  Captain  Ryder,  R.E.,  in  command. 
Captain  Wood,  R.E.,  Lieutenant  Bailey,  of  the  32nd  Pioneers, 
and  six  picked  men  of  the  8th  Gurkhas.  They  follow  the  main 
feeder  of  the  Tsangpo  nearly  500  miles,  then  strike  into  the  high 
lacustrine  tableland  of  Western  Tibet,  passing  the  great  Man- 
sarowar  Lake  to  Gartok ;  thence  over  the  Indus  watershed,  and 
down  the  Sutlej  Valley  to  Simla,  where  they  are  expected  about 
the  end  of  January.  The  party  will  be  able  to  collect  useful 
information  about  the  trade  resources  of  the  covintry ;  but  the 
route  has  already  been  mapped  by  Nain  Singh,  the  Indian  sur« 


296  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

An  expedition  to  the  mountains  bordering  the 
Tengri  Nor,  only  nine  days  north  of  Lhasa,  would 
have  linked  all  the  unknown  country  north  of  the 
Tsang  po  with  the  tracts  explored  by  Sven  Hedin, 
and  left  the  map  without  a  hiatus  in  four  degrees 
of  longitude  from  Cape  Comorin  to  the  Arctic 
Ocean.  But  military  considerations  were  para- 
mount. 

For  myself,  the  abandonment  of  the  expedition 
was  a  great  disappointment.  I  had  counted  on 
it  as  early  as  February,  and  had  made  all  prepara- 
tions to  join  it. 

veyor,  and  the  geographical  results  of  the  expedition  will  be 
small  compared  with  what  would  have  been  derived  from  the 
projected  Tengri  Nor  and  Brahmaputra  trips. 


CHAPTER   XIII 

LHASA  AND   ITS  VANISHED  DEITY 

THE  passage  of  the  river  was  difficult  and  dan- 
gerous. If  we  had  had  to  depend  on  the 
four  Berthon  boats  we  took  with  us,  the  crossing 
might  have  taken  weeks.  But  the  good  fortune 
that  attended  the  expedition  throughout  did  not 
fail  us.  At  Chaksam  we  found  the  Tibetans  had 
left  behind  their  two  great  ferry-boats,  quaint  old 
barges  with  horses'  heads  at  the  prow,  capacious 
enough  to  hold  a  hundred  men.  The  Tibetan 
ferrymen  worked  for  us  cheerfully.  A  number 
of  hide  boats  were  also  discovered.  The  transport 
mules  were  swum  over,  and  the  whole  force  was 
across  in  less  than  a  week. 

But  the  river  took  its  toll  most  tragically.    The 
current  is  swift  and  boisterous ;    the  eddies  and 
whirlpools   are   dangerously  uncertain.    Two   Ber- 
thon boats,  bound  together  into  a  raft,  capsized, 
lo  a 


298  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

and  Major  Bretherton,  chief  supply  and  transport 
officer,  and  two  Gurkhas  were  drowned.  It 
seemed  as  if  the  genius  of  the  river,  offended  at 
our  intrusion,  had  claimed  its  price  and  carried 
off  the  most  valuable  life  in  the  force.  It  was 
Major  Bretherton 's  foresight  more  than  anything 
that  enabled  us  to  reach  Lhasa.  His  loss  was 
calamitous. 

We  left  our  camp  at  the  ferry  on  July  31,  and 
started  for  Lhasa,  which  was  only  forty-three 
miles  distant.  It  was  difficult  to  believe  that  in 
three  days  we  would  be  looking  on  the  Potala. 

The  Kyi  Chu,  the  holy  river  of  Lhasa,  flows  into 
the  Tsangpo  at  Chushul,  three  miles  below  Chak- 
sam  ferry,  where  our  troops  crossed.  The  river 
is  almost  as  broad  as  the  Thames  at  Greenwich, 
and  the  stream  is  swift  and  clear.  The  valley  is 
cultivated  in  places,  but  long  stretches  are  bare 
and  rocky.  Sand-dunes,  overgrown  with  artemisia 
scrub,  extend  to  the  margin  of  cultivation,  leaving 
a  well-defined  line  between  the  green  cornfields  and 
the  barren  sand.  The  crops  were  ripening  at  the 
time  of  our  advance,  and  promised  a  plentiful 
harvest. 

For  many  miles  the  road  is  cut  out  of  a  pre- 


LHASA'S  VANISHED  DEITY.  299 

cipitous  cliff  above  the  river.  A  few  hundred 
men  could  have  destroyed  it  in  an  afternoon,  and 
delayed  our  advance  for  another  week.  Newly- 
built  sangars  at  the  entrance  of  the  gorge  showed 
that  the  Tibetans  had  intended  to  hold  it.  But 
they  left  the  valley  in  a  disorganized  state  the 
day  we  reached  the  Tsangpo.  Had  they  fortified 
the  position,  they  might  have  made  it  stronger 
than  the  Karo  la. 

The  heat  of  the  valley  was  almost  tropical. 
Summer  by  the  Kyi  Chu  River  is  very  different 
from  one's  first  conceptions  of  Tibet.  To  escape 
the  heat,  I  used  to  write  my  diary  in  the  shade  of 
gardens  and  willow  groves.  Hoopoes,  magpies, 
and  huge  black  ravens  became  inquisitive  and 
confidential.  I  have  a  pile  of  little  black  note- 
books I  scribbled  over  in  their  society,  dirty  and 
torn  and  soiled  with  pressed  flowers.  For  a  pic- 
ture of  the  valley  I  will  go  to  these.  One's  freshest 
impressions  are  the  best,  and  truer  than  remi- 
niscences. 

Nethang. 

In  the  most  fertile  part  of  the  Kyi  Chu  Valley, 
where  the  fields  are  intersected  in  all  directions 
by   clear-running   streams   bordered   with   flowers. 


300  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

in  a  grove  of  poplars  where  doves  were  singing 
all  day  long,  I  found  Atisa's  tomb. 

It  was  built  in  a  large,  plain,  bam-like  building, 
clean  and  sweet-smelling  as  a  granary,  and  inno- 
cent of  ornament  outside  and  in.  It  was  the  only 
clean  and  simple  place  devoted  to  religion  I  had 
seen  in  Tibet. 

In  every  house  and  monastery  we  entered  on  the 
road  there  were  gilded  images,  tawdry  paintings, 
demons  and  she-devils,  garish  frescoes  on  the 
wall,  hideous  grinning  devil-masks,  cdl  the  Lama's 
spurious  apparatus  of  terrorism. 

These  were  the  outward  S5mibols  of  demonolatry 
and  superstition  invented  by  scheming  priests  as 
the  fabric  of  their  sacerdotalism.  But  this  was 
the  resting-place  of  the  Reformer,  the  true  son 
of  Buddha,  who  came  over  the  Himalayas  to  preach 
a  religion  of  love  and  mercy. 

I  entered  the  building  out  of  the  glare  of  the 
sun,  expecting  nothing  but  the  usual  monsters 
and  abortions — ^just  as  one  is  dragged  into  a  church 
in  some  tourist-ridden  land,  where,  if  only  for  the 
sake  of  peace,  one  must  cast  an  apathetic  eye  at  the 
lions  of  the  country.  But  as  the  tomb  gradually 
assumed  shape  in  the  dim  light,  I  knew  that  there 


LHASA'S  VANISHED  DEITY.  301 

was  someone  here,  a  priest  or  a  community,  who 
understood  Atisa,  who  knew  what  he  would  have 
wished  his  last  resting-place  to  be  ;  or  perhaps  the 
good  old  monk  had  left  a  will  or  spoken  a  plain 
word  that  had  been  handed  down  and  remembered 
these  thousand  years,  and  was  now,  no  doubt, 
regarded  as  an  eccentric's  whim,  that  there  must 
be  no  gods  or  demons  by  his  tomb,  nothing  ab- 
normal, no  pretentiousness  of  any  kind.  If  his 
teaching  had  lived,  how  simple  and  honest  and 
different  Tibet  would  be  to-day  ! 

The  tomb  was  not  beautiful — a  large  square 
plinth,  supporting  layers  of  gradually  decreasing 
circumference  and  forming  steps  two  feet  in  height, 
the  last  a  platform  on  which  was  based  a  sub- 
stantial vat-like  structure  with  no  ornament  or 
inscription  except  a  thin  line  of  black  pencilled 
saints.  By  climbing  up  the  layers  of  masonry 
I  found  a  pair  of  slant  eyes  gazing  at  nothing 
and  hidden  by  a  curve  in  the  stone  from  gazers 
below.    This  was  the  only  painting  on  the  tomb. 

Never  in  the  thousand  years  since  the  good  monk 
Was  laid  to  rest  at  Nethang  had  a  white  man  entered 
this  shrine.  To-day  the  courtyard  was  crowded 
with  mules  and  drivers  :    Hindus  and  Pathans  in 


302  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

British  uniform ;    they  were  ransacking  the  place 
for  com.    A  transport  officer  was  shouting  : 

*  How  many  bags  have  you,  babu  ?  * 

*  A  hundred  and  seven,  sir.* 

'  Remember,  if  anyone  loots,  he  will  get  fifty 
beyni  *  (stripes  with  the  cat-o '-nine-tails). 

Then  he  turned  to  me. 

'  What  the  devil  is  that  old  thief  doing  over 
there  ?  '  he  said,  and  nodded  at  a  man  with  archaeo- 
logical interests,  who  was  peering  about  in  a  dark 
corner  by  the  tomb.     '  There  is  nothing  more  here.* 

*  He  is  examining  Atisa's  tomb.* 

*  And  who  the  devil  is  Atisa  ?  ' 

And  who  is  he  ?  Merely  a  name  to  a  few  dry- 
as-dust  pedants.  Everything  human  he  did  is 
forgotten.  The  faintest  ripple  remains  to-day 
from  that  stone  cast  into  the  stagnant  waters  so 
many  years  ago.  A  few  monks  drone  away  their 
days  in  a  monastery  close  by.  In  the  courtyard 
there  is  a  border  of  hollyhocks  and  snapdragon  and 
asters.  Here  the  unsavoury  guardians  of  Atisa's 
tomb  watch  me  as  I  write,  and  wonder  what  on 
earth  I  am  doing  among  them,  and  what  spell  or 
mantra  I  am  inscribing  in  the  little  black  book 
that  shuts  so  tightly  with  a  clasp. 


LHASA'S  VANISHED  DEITY.  303 

TOILUNG. 

To-morrow  we  reach  Lhasa. 

A  few  hours  ago  we  caught  the  first  glunpse 
of  the  Potala  Palace,  a  golden  dome  standing 
out  on  a  bluff  rock  in  the  centre  of  the  valley. 
The  city  is  not  seen  from  afar  perched  on  a  hill 
like  the  great  monasteries  and  Jongs  of  the  coun- 
try. It  is  literally  *  hidden.'  A  rocky  promontory 
projects  from  the  bleak  hills  to  the  south  like  a 
screen,  hiding  Lhasa,  as  if  Nature  conspired  in  its 
seclusion.  Here  at  a  distance  of  seven  miles  we 
can  see  the  Potala  and  the  Lamas'  Medical  College. 

Trees  and  undulating  ground  shut  out  the  view 
of  the  actual  city  until  one  is  within  a  mile  of  it. 

To-morrow  we  camp  outside.  It  is  nearly  a 
hundred  years  since  Thomas  Manning,  the  only 
Englishman  (until  to-day)  who  ever  saw  Lhasa, 
preceded  us.  Our  journey  has  not  been  easy,  but 
we  have  come  in  spite  of  everything. 

The  Lamas  have  opposed  us  with  all  their  material 
and  spiritual  resources.  They  have  fought  us  with 
medieval  weapons  and  a  medley  of  modern  fire- 
arms. They  have  held  Commination  Services, 
recited  mantras,  and  cursed  us  solemnly  for  days. 
Yet  we  have  come  on. 


304  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

They  have  sent  delegates  and  messengers  of 
every  rank  to  threaten  and  entreat  and  plead 
with  us — emissaries  of  increasing  importance  as 
we  have  drawn  nearer  their  capital,  until  the 
Dalai  Lama  despatched  his  own  Grand  Chamber- 
lain and  Grand  Secretary,  and,  greater  than  these, 
the  Ta  Lama  and  Yutok  Shap6,  members  of  the 
ruling  Council  of  Five,  whose  sacred  persons  had 
never  before  been  seen  by  European  eyes.  To- 
morrow the  Amban  himself  comes  to  meet  Colonel 
Younghusband.  The  Dalai  Lama  has  sent  him  a 
letter  sealed  with  his  own  seal. 

Every  stretch  of  road  from  the  frontier  to  Lhasa 
has  had  its  symbol  of  remonstrance.  Cairns  and 
chortens,  and  mani  walls  and  praying-flags,  demons 
painted  on  the  rock,  v^Titings  on  the  wall,  white 
stones  piled  upon  black,  have  emitted  their  ray 
of  protest  and  malevolence  in  vain. 

The  Lamas  knew  we  must  come.  Hundreds  of 
years  ago  a  Buddhist  saint  wrote  it  in  his  book 
of  prophecies,  Ma-ong  Lung-Ten,  which  may  be 
bought  to-day  in  the  Lhasa  book-shops.  He  pre- 
dicted that  Tibet  would  be  invaded  and  conquered 
by  the  Philings  (Europeans),  when  all  of  the  true 
religion  would  go  to  Chang  Shambula,  the  Northern 


LHASA'S  VANISHED  DEITY.  305 

Paradise,  and  Buddhism  would  become  extinct  in 
the  country. 

And  now  the  Lamas  beHeve  that  the  prophecy 
will  be  fulfilled  by  our  entry  into  Lhasa,  and  that 
their  religion  will  decay  before  foreign  influence. 
The  Dalai  Lama,  they  say,  will  die,  not  by  violence 
or  sickness,  but  by  some  spiritual  visitation.  His 
spirit  will  seek  some  other  incarnation,  when  he 
can  no  longer  benefit  his  people  or  secure  his  coun- 
try, so  long  sacred  to  Buddhists,  from  the  contam- 
ination of  foreign  intrusion. 

The  Tibetans  are  not  the  savages  they  are  de- 
picted. They  are  civilized,  if  medieval.  The  coun- 
try is  governed  on  the  feudal  system.  The  monks 
are  the  overlords,  the  peasantry  their  serfs.  The 
poor  are  not  oppressed.  They  and  the  small  tenant 
farmers  work  ungrudgingly  for  their  spiritual  mas- 
ters, to  whom  they  owe  a  blind  devotion.  They 
are  not  discontented,  though  they  give  more  than 
a  tithe  of  their  small  income  to  the  Church.  It  must 
be  remembered  that  every  family  contributes  at 
least  one  member  to  the  priesthood,  so  that,  when 
we  are  inclined  to  abuse  the  monks  for  consuming 
the  greater  part  of  the  country's  produce,  we  should 
remember  that  the  laymen  are  not  the  victims  of 


3o6  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

class  prejudice,  the  plebeians  groaning  under  the 
burden  of  the  patricians,  so  much  as  the  servants 
of  a  community  chosen  from  among  themselves,  and 
with  whom  they  are  connected  by  family  ties. 

No  doubt  the  Lamas  employ  spiritual  terrorism 
to  maintain  their  influence  and  preserve  the  tem- 
poral government  in  their  hands  ;  and  when  they 
speak  of  their  rehgion  being  injured  by  our  intru- 
sion, they  are  thinking,  no  doubt,  of  another  un- 
veiling of  mysteries,  the  dreaded  age  of  material- 
ism and  reason,  when  little  by  little  their  ignorant 
serfs  will  be  brought  into  contact  with  the  facts 
of  hfe,  and  begin  to  question  the  justness  of  the 
relations  that  have  existed  between  themselves 
and  their  rulers  for  centuries.  But  at  present  the 
people  are  medieval,  not  only  in  their  system  of 
government  and  their  rehgion,  their  inquisition, 
their  witchcraft,  their  incantations,  their  ordeals 
by  fire  and  boihng  oil,  but  in  every  aspect  of  their 
daily  hfe. 

I  question  if  ever  in  the  history  of  the  world  there 
has  been  another  occasion  when  bigotry  and  dark- 
ness have  been  exposed  with  such  abruptness  to  the 
inroad  of  science,  when  a  barrier  of  ignorance  created 
by  jealousy  and  fear  as  a  screen  between  two  peoples 


LHASA'S  VANISHED  DEITY.  307 

living  side  by  side  has  been  demolished  so  suddenly 
to  admit  the  light  of  an  advanced  civilization. 

The  Tibetans,  no  doubt,  will  benefit,  and  many 
abuses  will  be  swept  away.  Yet  there  will  always 
be  people  who  will  hanker  after  the  medieval  and 
romantic,  who  will  say :  *  We  men  are  children. 
Why  could  we  not  have  been  content  that  there 
was  one  mystery  not  unveiled,  one  country  of  an 
ancient  arrested  civilization,  and  an  established 
Church  where  men  are  still  guided  by  sorcery  and 
incantations,  and  direct  their  mundane  affairs  with 
one  eye  on  a  grotesque  spirit  world,  which  is  the 
most  real  thing  in  their  lives — a  land  of  topsy-turvy 
and  inverted  proportions,  where  men  spend  half 
their  Hves  mumbling  unintelligible  mantras  and 
turning  mechanical  prayers,  and  when  dead  are 
cut  up  into  mincemeat  and  thrown  to  the  dogs 
and  vultures  ?  ' 

To-morrow,  when  we  enter  Lhasa,  we  will  have 
unveiled  the  last  mystery  of  the  East.  There  are 
no  more  forbidden  cities  which  men  have  not  mapped 
and  photographed.  Our  children  will  laugh  at 
modern  travellers'  tales.  They  will  have  to  turn 
again  to  GulHver  and  Haroun  al  Raschid.  And 
they  wall  soon  tire  of  these.     For  now  that  there 


3o8  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

are  no  real  mysteries,  no  unknown  land  of  dreams, 
where  there  may  still  be  genii  and  mahatmas  and 
bottle-imps,  that  kind  of  literature  will  be  tolerated 
no  longer.  Children  will  be  sceptical  and  matter- 
of-fact  and  disillusioned,  and  there  will  be  no  sale 
for  fairy-stories  any  more. 

But  we  ourselves  are  children.  Why  could  we 
not  have  left  at  least  one  city  out  of  bounds  ? 

Lhasa, 
August  3. 

We  reached  Lhasa  to-day,  after  a  march  of  seven 
miles,  and  camped  outside  the  city.  As  we  ap- 
proached, the  road  became  an  embankment  across 
a  marsh.  Butterflies  and  dragon-flies  were  hovering 
among  the  rushes,  clematis  grew  in  the  stonework 
by  the  roadside,  cows  were  grazing  in  the  rich 
pastureland,  redshanks  were  calHng,  a  flight  of  teal 
passed  overhead  ;  the  whole  scene  was  most  home- 
hke,  save  for  the  bare  scarred  chffs  that  jealously 
preclude  a  distant  view  of  the  city. 

Some  of  us  cUmbed  the  Chagpo  Ri  and  looked 
down  on  the  city.  Lhasa  lay  a  mile  in  front  of 
us,  a  mass  of  huddled  roofs  and  trees,  dominated 
by  -the  golden  dome  of  the  Jokhang  Cathedral. 


LHASA'S  VANISHED  DEITY.  309 

It  must  be  the  most  hidden  city  on  earth.  The 
Chagpo  Ri  rises  bluffly  from  the  river-bank  hke  a 
huge  rock.  Between  it  and  the  Potala  hill  there 
is  a  narrow  gap  not  more  than  thirty  yards  wide. 
Over  this  is  built  the  Pargo  Kaling,  a  typical  Tibetan 
chorten,  through  which  is  the  main  gateway  into 
Lhasa.  The  city  has  no  walls,  but  beyond  the 
Potala,  to  complete  the  screen,  stretches  a  great 
embankment  of  sand  right  across  the  valley  to  the 
hills  on  the  north. 


Lhasa, 
August  4. 
An  epoch  in  the  world's  history  was  marked  to- 
day when  Colonel  Younghusband  entered  the  city 
to  return  the  visit  of  the  Chinese  Amban.  He  was 
accompanied  by  all  the  members  of  the  mission, 
the  war  correspondents,  and  an  escort  of  two  com- 
panies of  the  Royal  Fusiliers  and  the  2nd  Mounted 
Infantry.  Half  a  company  of  mounted  infantry, 
two  guns,  a  detachment  of  sappers,  and  four  com- 


310  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

panics  of  infantry  were  held  ready  to  support  the 
escort  if  necessary. 

In  front  of  us  marched  and  rode  the  Amban's 
escort — his  bodyguard,  dressed  in  short  loose  coats 
of  French  gray,  embroidered  in  black,  with  various 
emblems ;  pikemen  clad  in  bright  red  with  black 
embroidery  and  black  pugarees  ;  soldiers  with  pikes 
and  scythes  and  three  -  pronged  spears,  on  all  of 
which  hung  red  banners  with  devices  embroidered 
in  black. 

We  found  the  city  squahd  and  filthy  beyond 
description,  undrained  and  unpaved.  Not  a  single 
house  looked  clean  or  cared  for.  The  streets  after 
rain  are  nothing  but  pools  of  stagnant  water  fre- 
quented by  pigs  and  dogs  searching  for  refuse. 
Even  the  Jokhang  appeared  mean  and  squahd  at 
close  quarters,  whence  its  golden  roofs  were  invisible. 
There  was  nothing  picturesque  except  the  marigolds 
and  hollyhocks  in  pots  and  the  doves  and  singing- 
birds  in  wicker  cages. 

The  few  Tibetans  we  met  in  the  street  were 
strangely  inciurious.  A  baker  kneading  dough 
glanced  at  us  casually,  and  went  on  kneading. 
A  woman  weaving  barely  looked  up  from  her  work. 

The  streets  were  almost  deserted,   perhaps  by 


LHASA'S  VANISHED  DEITY.  311 

order  of  the  authorities  to  prevent  an  outbreak. 
But  as  we  returned  small  crowds  had  gathered  in 
the  doorways,  women  were  peering  through  win- 
dows, but  no  one  followed  or  took  more  than  a 
listless  interest  in  us.  The  monks  looked  on  sullenly. 
But  in  most  faces  one  read  only  indifference  and 
apathy.  One  might  think  the  entry  of  a  foreign 
army  into  Lhasa  and  the  presence  of  English  Polit- 
ical Officers  in  gold-laced  uniform  and  beaver  hats 
were  everyday  events. 

The  only  building  in  Lhasa  that  is  at  all  impos- 
ing is  the  Potala. 

It  would  be  misleading  to  say  that  the  palace 
dominated  the  city,  as  a  comparison  would  be  im- 
plied— a  picture  conveyed  of  one  building  stand- 
ing out  signally  among  others.  This  is  not  the 
case. 

The  Potala  is  superbly  detached.  It  is  not  a 
palace  on  a  hill,  but  a  hill  that  is  also  a  palace. 
Its  massive  walls,  its  terraces  and  bastions  stretch 
upwards  from  the  plain  to  the  crest,  as  if  the  great 
bluff  rock  were  merely  a  foundation-stone  planted 
there  at  the  divinity's  nod.  The  divinity  dwells 
in  the  palace,  and  underneath,  at  the  distance  of 
a  furlong  or  two,  humanity  is  huddled  abjectly  in 


312         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

squalid  smut-begrimed  houses.  The  proportion  is 
that  which  exists  between  God  and  man. 

If  one  approached  within  a  league  of  Lhasa, 
saw  the  glittering  domes  of  the  Potala,  and  turned 
back  without  entering  the  precincts,  one  might 
still  imagine  it  an  enchanted  city,  shining  with 
turquoise  and  gold.  But  having  entered,  the  illu- 
sion is  lost.  One  might  think  devout  Buddhists  had 
excluded  strangers  in  order  to  preserve  the  myth 
of  the  city's  beauty  and  mystery  and  wealth,  or 
that  the  place  was  consciously  neglected  and  de- 
faced so  as  to  offer  no  allurements  to  heretics,  just 
as  the  repulsive  women  one  meets  in  the  streets 
smear  themselves  over  with  grease  and  cutch  to 
make  themselves  even  more  hideous  than  Nature 
ordained. 

The  place  has  not  changed  since  Manning  visited 
it  ninety  years  ago,  and  wrote : — '  There  is  nothing 
striking,  nothing  pleasing,  in  its  appearance.  The 
habitations  are  begrimed  with  smut  and  dirt.  The 
avenues  are  full  of  dogs,  some  growling  and  gnawing 
bits  of  hide  that  lie  about  in  profusion,  and  emit  a 
charnel  -  house  smell  j  others  Umping  and  looking 
livid  ;  others  ulcerated  ;  others  starved  and  dying, 
and  pecked  at  by  ravens ;  some  dead  and  preyed 


LHASA'S  VANISHED  DEITY.  313 

upon.  In  short,  everything  seems  mean  and  gloomy, 
and  excites  the  idea  of  something  unreal.'  That  is 
the  Lhasa  of  to-day.  Probably  it  was  the  same  cen- 
turies ago. 

Above  all  this  squalor  the  Potala  towers  superbly. 

Its  golden  roofs,  shining  in  the  sun  like  tongues 
of  fire,  are  a  landmark  for  miles,  and  must  inspire 
awe  and  veneration  in  the  hearts  of  pilgrims  com- 
ing from  the  desert  parts  of  Tibet,  Kashmir,  and 
MongoHa  to  visit  the  sacred  city  that  Buddha  has 
blessed. 

The  secret  of  romance  is  remoteness,  whether  in 
time  or  space.  If  we  could  be  thrown  back  to  the 
days  of  Agincourt  we  should  be  enchanted  at  first, 
but  after  a  week  should  vote  everything  common- 
place and  dull.  Falstaff,  the  beery  lout,  would  be 
an  impossible  companion,  and  Prince  Hal  a  tire- 
some young  cub  who  wanted  a  good  dressing-down. 
In  travel,  too,  as  one  approaches  the  goal,  and  the 
country  becomes  gradually  familiar,  the  husk  of 
romance  falls  oH.  Childe  Roland  must  have  been 
sadly  disappointed  in  the  Dark  Tower ;  filth  and 
familiarity  very  soon  destroyed  the  romance  of 
Lhasa. 

But  romance  still  clings  to  the  Potala.     It  is  still 


314  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

remote.  Like  Imray,  its  sacred  inmate  has  achieved 
the  impossible.  Divinity  or  no,  he  has  at  least  the 
divine  power  of  vanishing.  In  the  material  West, 
as  we  like  to  call  it,  we  know  how  hard  it  is  for  the 
humblest  subject  to  disappear,  in  spite  of  the  con- 
fused hub  of  traffic  and  intricate  network  of  communi- 
cations. Yet  here  in  Lhasa,  a  city  of  dreamy  repose, 
a  King  has  escaped,  been  spirited  into  the  air,  and 
nobody  is  any  the  wiser. 

When  we  paraded  the  city  yesterday,  we  made 
a  complete  circuit  of  the  Potala.  There  was  no 
one,  not  even  the  humblest  follower,  so  unimagin- 
ative that  he  did  not  look  up  from  time  to  time 
at  the  frowning  cliff  and  thousand  sightless  win- 
dows that  concealed  the  unknown.  Those  hidden 
corridors  and  passages  have  been  for  centuries, 
and  are,  perhaps,  at  this  very  moment,  the  scenes 
of  unnatural  piety  and  crime. 

Within  the  precincts  of  Lhasa  the  taking  of  Ufe 
in  any  form  is  sacrilege.  Buddha's  first  law  was, 
'  Thou  shalt  not  kill ' ;  and  life  is  held  so  sacred 
by  his  devout  followers  that  they  are  careful  not 
to  kill  the  smallest  insect.  Yet  this  palace,  where 
dwells  the  divine  incarnation  of  the  Bodhisat,  the 
head  of  the  Bhuddist  Church,  must  have  witnessed 


LHASA'S  VANISHED  DEITY.  315 

more  murders  and  instigations  to  crime  than  the 
most  blood-stained  castle  of  medieval  Europe. 

Since  the  assumption  of  temporal  power  by  the 
fifth  Grand  Lama  in  the  middle  of  the  seventeenth 
century,  the  whole  history  of  the  Tibetan  hierarchy 
has  been  a  record  of  bloodshed  and  intrigue.  The 
fifth  Grand  Lama,  the  first  to  receive  the  title 
of  Dalai,  was  a  most  unscrupulous  ruler,  who  secured 
the  temporal  power  by  inciting  the  Mongols  to  in- 
vade Tibet,  and  received  as  his  reward  the  king- 
ship. He  then  established  his  claim  to  the  god- 
head by  tampering  with  Buddhist  history  and 
writ.  The  sixth  incarnation  was  executed  by  the 
Chinese  on  account  of  his  profligacy.  The  seventh 
was  deposed  by  the  Chinese  as  privy  to  the  murder 
of  the  regent.  After  the  death  of  the  eighth,  of 
whom  I  can  learn  nothing,  it  would  seem  that  the 
tables  were  turned :  the  regents  systematically 
murdered  their  charge,  and  the  crime  of  the  seventh 
Dalai  Lama  was  visited  upon  four  successive  incarna- 
tions. The  ninth,  tenth,  eleventh,  and  twelfth  all 
died  prematurely,  assassinated,  it  is  beUeved,  by 
their  regents. 

There  are  no  legends  of  malmsey-butts,  secret 
smotherings,    and    hired    assassins.     The    children 


3i6         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

disappeared ;  they  were  absorbed  into  the  Uni- 
versal Essence ;  they  were  Hterally  too  good  to 
live.  Their  regents  and  protectors,  monks  only 
less  sacred  than  themselves,  provided  that  the 
spirit  in  its  yearning  for  the  next  state  shoula  not 
be  long  detained  in  its  mortal  husk.  No  questions 
were  asked.  How  could  the  devout  trace  the 
comings  and  goings  of  the  divine  Avalokita,  the 
Lord  of  Mercy  and  Judgment,  who  ordains  into 
what  heaven  or  hell,  demon,  god,  hero,  mollusc, 
or  ape,  their  spirits  must  enter,  according  to  their 
sins  ? 

So,  when  we  reached  Lhasa  the  other  day,  and 
heard  that  the  thirteenth  incarnation  had  fled,  no 
one  was  surprised.  Yet  the  wonder  remains.  A 
great  Prince,  a  god  to  thousands  of  men,  has  been 
removed  from  his  palace  and  capital,  no  one  knows 
whither  or  when.  A  ruler  has  disappeared  who 
travels  with  every  appanage  of  state,  inspiring  awe 
in  his  prostrate  servants,  whose  movements,  one 
would  think,  were  watched  and  talked  about  more 
than  any  Sovereign's  on  earth.  Yet  fear,  or  loyalty, 
or  ignorance  keeps  every  subject  tongue-tied. 

We  have  spies  and  informers  everywhere,  and 
there  are  men  in  Lhasa  who  would  do  much  to 


LHASA'S  VANISHED  DEITY.  317 

please  the  new  conquerors  of  Tibet.  There  are 
also  witless  men,  who  have  eyes  and  ears,  but,  it 
seems,  no  tongues. 

But  so  far  neither  avarice  nor  witlessness  has 
betrayed  anything.  For  all  we  know,  the  Dalai 
Lama  may  be'  still  in  his  palace  in  some  hidden 
chamber  in  the  rock,  or  maybe  he  has  never  left 
his  customary  apartments,  and  still  performs  his 
daily  offices  in  the  Potala,  confident  that  there  at 
least  his  sanctity  is  inviolable  by  unbeHevers. 

The  British  Tommy  in  the  meanwhile  parades 
the  streets  as  indifferently  as  if  they  were  the  New 
Cut  or  Lambeth  Palace  Road.  He  looks  up  at 
the  Potala,  and  says :  '  The  old  bloke's  done  a 
bunk.  Wish  we'd  got  'im ;  we  might  get  'ome 
then.' 

Lhasa, 
August  — . 

We  had  been  in  Lhasa  nearly  three  weeks  before 
we  could  discover  where  the  Dalai  Lama  had  fled. 
We  know  now  that  he  left  his  palace  secretly  in  the 
night,  and  took  the  northern  road  to  Mongolia. 
The  Buriat,  Dorjieff  met  him  at  Nagchuka,  on  the 
verge  of  the  great  desert  that  separates  inhabited 
Tibet  from  Mongolia,  100  miles  from  Lhasa.    On 


3i8  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

the  20th  the  Amban  told  us  that  he  had  already 
left  Nagchuka  twelve  days,  and  was  pushing  on 
across  the  desert  to  the  frontier. 

I  have  been  trying  to  find  out  something  about 
the  private  life  and  character  of  the  Grand  Lama. 
But  asking  questions  here  is  fruitless ;  one  can 
learn  nothing  intimate.  And  this  is  just  what 
one  might  expect.  The  man  continues  a  bogie,  a 
riddle,  undivinable,  impersonal,  remote.  The  people 
know  nothing.  They  have  bowed  before  the  throne 
as  men  come  out  of  the  dark  into  a  blinding  light. 
Scrutiny  in  their  view  would  be  vain  and  blasphem- 
ous. The  Abbots,  too,  will  reveal  nothing ;  they 
will  not  and  dare  not.  When  Colonel  Younghus- 
band  put  the  question  direct  to  a  head  Lama  in 
open  durbar,  '  Have  you  news  of  the  Dalai  Lama  ? 
Do  you  know  where  he  is  ?  '  the  monk  looked  slowly 
to  left  and  right,  and  answered,  *  I  know  nothing.' 
'  The  ruler  of  your  country  leaves  his  palace  and 
capital,  and  you  know  nothing  ?  '  the  Commis- 
sioner asked.  '  Nothing,'  answered  the  monk, 
shuffling  his  feet,  but  without  changing  colour. 

From  various  sources,  which  differ  surprisingly 
little,  I  have  a  fairly  clear  picture  of  the  man's 
face  and  figure.     He  is  thick-set,  about  five  feet 


LHASA'S  VANISHED  DEITY.  319 

nine  inches  in  height,  with  a  heavy  square  jaw, 
nose  remarkably  long  and  straight  for  a  Tibetan, 
eyebrows  pronounced  and  turning  upwards  in  a 
phenomenal  manner — probably  trained  so,  to  make 
his  appearance  more  forbidding — face  pock-marked, 
general  expression  resolute  and  sinister.  He  goes 
out  very  little,  and  is  rarely  seen  by  the  people, 
except  on  his  annual  visit  to  Depung,  and  during 
his  migrations  between  the  Summer  Palace  and 
the  Potala.  He  was  at  the  Summer  Palace  when 
the  messenger  brought  the  news  that  our  advance 
was  inevitable,  but  he  went  to  the  Potala  to  put 
his  house  in  order  before  projecting  himself  into 
the  unknown. 

His  face  is  the  index  of  his  character.  He  is  a 
man  of  strong  personality,  impetuous,  despotic, 
and  intolerant  of  advice  in  State  affairs.  He  is 
constantly  deposing  his  Ministers,  and  has  estranged 
from  himself  a  large  section  of  the  upper  classes, 
both  ecclesiastical  and  official,  owing  to  his  way- 
ward and  headstrong  disposition.  As  a  child  he 
was  so  precociously  acute  and  resolute  that  he 
survived  his  regent,  and  so  upset  the  traditional 
policy  of  murder,  being  the  only  one  out  of  the 
last  five  incarnations  to  reach  his  majority.     Since 


320         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

he  took  the  government  of  the  country  into  his 
own  hands,  he  has  reduced  the  Chinese  suzerainty 
to  a  mere  shadow,  and,  with  fatal  results  to  him- 
self, consistently  insulted  and  defied  the  British. 
His  inchnation  to  a  rapprochement  with  Russia  is 
not  shared  by  his  Ministers. 

The  only  glimpse  I  have  had  into  the  man  him- 
self was  reflected  in  a  conversation  with  the  Nepalese 
Resident,  a  podgy  little  man,  very  ugly  and  good- 
natured,  with  the  manners  of  a  French  comedian 
and  a  face  generally  expanded  in  a  broad  grin. 
He  shook  with  laughter  when  I  asked  him  if  he 
knew  the  Dalai  Lama,  and  the  idea  was  really  in- 
tensely funny,  this  mercurial,  irreverent  little  man 
hobnobbing  with  the  divine.  *  I  have  seen  him,' 
he  said,  and  exploded  again.  *  But  what  does  he 
do  all  day  ?  '  I  asked.  The  Resident  puckered  up 
his  brow,  aping  abstraction,  and  began  to  wave  his 
hand  in  the  air  solemnly  with  a  slow  circular  move- 
ment, mumbling  *  Om  man  Padme  om  *  to  the  revolu- 
tions of  an  imaginary  praying-wheel.  He  was  im- 
mensely pleased  with  the  effort  and  the  effect  it 
produced  on  a  sepoy  orderly.  *  But  has  he  no  in- 
terests or  amusements  ?  *  I  asked.  The  Resident 
could  think  of  none.     But  he  told  me  a  story  to 


LHASA'S  VANISHED  DEITY.  321 

illustrate  the  dulness  of  the  man,  for  whom  he  evi- 
dently had  no  reverence.  On  his  return  from  his 
last  visit  to  India,  the  Maharaja  of  Nepal  had  given 
him  a  phonograph  to  present  to  the  Priest-King. 
The  impious  toy  was  introduced  to  the  Holy  of 
HoUes,  and  the  Dalai  Lama  walked  round  it  un- 
easily, as  it  emitted  the  strains  of  English  band 
music,  and  raucously  repeated  an  indelicate  Bhutan- 
ese  song.  After  sitting  a  long  while  in  deep  thought 
he  rose  and  said  he  could  not  Hve  with  this  voice 
without  a  soul ;  it  must  leave  his  palace  at  once. 
The  rejected  phonograph  found  a  home  with  the 
Chinese  Amban,  to  whom  it  was  presented  with 
due  ceremonial  the  same  day.  '  The  Lama  is  gumar* 
the  Resident  said,  using  a  Hindustani  word  which 
may  be  translated,  according  to  our  charity,  by 
anything  between  *  boorish  *  and  '  unenlightened.' 
I  was  glad  to  meet  a  man  in  this  city  of  evasive- 
ness whose  views  were  positive,  and  who  was  eager 
to  communicate  them.  Through  him  I  tracked  the 
shadow,  as  it  were,  of  this  impersonahty,  and  found 
that  to  many  strangers  in  Lhasa,  and  perhaps  to 
a  few  Lhasans  themselves,  the  divinity  was  all  clay, 
a  palpable  fraud,  a  pompous  and  puritanical  dull- 
ard masquerading  as  a  god. 
II 


322  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

For  my  own  part,  I  think  the  oracle  that  coun- 
selled his  flight  wiser  than  the  statesmen  who  object 
that  it  was  a  political  mistake.  He  has  lost  his 
prestige,  they  say.  But  imagine  him  dragged  into 
durbar  as  a  signatory,  gazed  at  by  profane  eyes, 
the  subject  of  a  few  days*  gossip  and  comment, 
then  sunk  into  commonplace,  stripped  of  his  mys- 
tery hke  this  city  of  Lhasa,  through  which  we  now 
saunter  familiarly,  wondering  when  we  shall  start 
again  for  the  wilds. 

To  escape  this  ordeal  he  has  fled,  and  to  us, 
at  least,  his  flight  has  deepened  the  mystery  that 
envelops  him,  and  added  to  his  dignity  and  re- 
moteness ;  to  thousands  of  mystical  dreamers  it 
has  preserved  the  effulgence  of  his  godhead  im- 
soiled  by  contact  with  the  profane  world. 

From  our  camp  here  the  Potala  draws  the  eye 
like  a  magnet.  There  is  nothing  but  sky  and 
marsh  and  bleak  hill  and  palace.  When  we  look 
out  of  our  tents  in  the  morning,  the  sun  is  striking 
the  golden  roof  like  a  beacon  light  to  the  faithful. 
Nearly  every  day  in  August  this  year  has  opened 
fine  and  closed  with  storm-clouds  gathering  Irom 
the  west,  through  which  the  sun  shines,  bathing 
the    eastern  valley  in  a  soft,  pearly  light.     The 


LHASA'S  VANISHED  DEITY.  323 

western  horizon  is  dark  and  lowering,  the  eastern 
peaceful  and  serene.  In  this  division  of  darkness 
and  light  the  Potala  stands  out  like  a  haven,  not 
flaming  now,  but  faintly  luminous  with  a  restful 
mystic  light,  soothing  enough  to  rob  Buddhist 
metaphysics  of  its  pessimism  and  induce  a  mood, 
even  in  unbelievers,  in  which  one  is  content  to 
merge  the  individual  and  become  absorbed  in  the 
universal  spirit  of  Nature. 

No  wonder  that,  when  one  looks  for  mystery  in 
Lhasa,  one's  thoughts  dwell  solely  on  the  Dalai 
Lama  and  the  Potala.  I  cannot  help  dwelling 
on  the  flight  of  the  thirteenth  incarnation.  It 
plunges  us  into  medievalism.  To  my  mind,  there  is 
no  picture  so  romantic  and  engrossing  in  modem 
history  as  that  exodus,  when  the  spiritual  head  of 
the  Buddhist  Church,  the  temporal  ruler  of  six 
millions,  stole  out  of  his  palace  by  night  and  was 
borne  away  in  his  palanquin,  no  one  knows  on 
what  errand  or  with  what  impotent  rage  in  his 
heart.  The  flight  was  really  secret.  No  one  but 
his  immediate  confidants  and  retainers,  not  even 
the  Amban  himself,  knew  that  he  had  gone.  I 
can  imagine  the  awed  attendants,  the  burying  of 
treasure,  the  locking  and  sealing  of  chests,  faint 


324         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

lights  flickering  in  the  passages,  hurried  footsteps 
in  the  corridors,  dogs  barking  intermittently  at 
this  unwonted  bustle — I  feel  sure  the  'Priest-King 
kicked  one  as  he  stepped  on  the  terrace  for  the 
last  time.  Then  the  procession  by  moonlight  up 
the  narrow  valley  to  the  north,  where  the  roar  of 
the  stream  would  drown  the  footsteps  of  the 
palanquin-bearers. 

A  month  afterwards  I  followed  on  his  track, 
and  stood  on  the  Phembu  Pass  twelve  miles  north 
of  Lhasa,  whence  one  looks  down  on  the  huge  belt 
of  mountains  that  lie  between  the  Brahmaputra 
and  the  desert,  so  packed  and  huddled  that  their 
crests  look  like  one  continuous  undulating  plain 
stretching  to  the  horizon.  Looking  across  the 
valley,  I  could  see  the  northern  road  to  Mongolia 
winding  up  a  feeder  of  the  Phembu  Chu.  They 
passed  along  here  and  over  the  next  range,  and 
across  range  after  range,  until  they  reached  the 
two  conical  snow-peaks  that  stand  out  of  the  plain 
beside  Tengri  Nor,  a  hundred  miles  to  the  north. 
For  da)^  they  skirted  the  great  lake,  and  then,  as 
if  they  feared  the  Nemesis  of  our  offended  Raj 
could  pursue  them  to  the  end  of  the  earth,  broke 
into  the  desert,  across  which  they  must  be  hurrying 


LHASA'S  VANISHED  DEITY.  325 

now  toward  the  great  mountain  chain  of  Burkhan 
Buddha,  on  the  southern  limits  of  Mongolia. 

Lhasa, 

August  19. 

The  Tibetans  are  the  strangest  people  on  earth. 
To-day  I  discovered  how  they  dispose  of  their 
dead. 

To  hold  life  sacred  and  benefit  the  creatures  are 
the  laws  of  Buddha,  which  they  are  supposed  to 
obey  most  scrupulously.  And  as  they  think  they 
may  be  reborn  in  any  shape  of  mammal,  bird,  or 
fish,  they  are  kind  to  living  things. 

During  the  morning  service  the  Lamas  repeat 
a  prayer  for  the  minute  insects  which  they  have 
swallowed  inadvertently  in  their  meat  and  drink, 
and  the  formula  insures  the  rebirth  of  these  mi- 
crobes in  heaven.  Sometimes,  when  a  Lama's 
life  is  despaired  of,  the  monks  will  ransom  a  yak 
or  a  bullock  from  the  shambles,  and  keep  him  a 
pensioner  in  their  monastery,  praying  the  good 
Buddha  to  spare  the  sick  man's  life  for  the  life 
ransomed.  Yet  they  eat  meat  freely,  all  save 
the  G^lug-pa,  or  Reformed  Church,  and  square 
their  conscience  with  their  appetite  by  the  pretexjt 


326         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

that  the  sin  rests  with  the  outcast  assassin,  the 
public  butcher,  who  will  be  bom  in  the  next  in- 
carnation as  some  tantalized  spirit  or  agonized 
demon.    That,  however,  is  his  own  affair. 

But  it  is  when  a  Tibetan  dies  that  his  charity 
to  the  creatiu-es  becomes  really  practical.  Then, 
by  his  own  tacit  consent  when  living,  his  body  is 
given  as  a  feast  to  the  dogs  and  vultures.  This 
is  no  casual  or  careless  gift  to  avoid  the  trouble  of 
burial  or  cremation.  All  creatures  who  have  a 
taste  for  these  things  are  invited  to  the  cere- 
mony, and  the  corpse  is  carved  to  their  Hking 
by  an  expert,  who  devotes  his  life  to  the  prac- 
tice. 

When  a  Tibetan  dies  he  is  left  three  days  in  his 
chamber,  and  a  slit  is  made  in  his  skull  to  let  his 
soul  pass  out.  Then  he  is  rolled  into  a  ball^. 
wrapped  in  a  sack,  or  silk  if  he  is  rich,  packed 
into  a  jar  or  basket,  and  carried  along  to  the  music 
of  conch  shells  to  the  ceremonial  stone.  Here  a 
Lama  takes  the  corpse  out  of  its  vessel  and  wrap- 
pings, and  lays  it  face  downwards  on  a  large  flat 
slab,  and  the  pensioners  prowl  or  hop  round,  waiting 
for  their  dole.  They  are  quite  tame.  The  Lamas 
stand  a  httle  way  apart,  and  see  that  strict  eti- 


LHASA'S  VANISHED  DEITY.  327 

quette  is  observed  during  the  entertainment.  The 
carver  begins  at  the  ankle,  and  cuts  upwards, 
throwing  little  strips  of  flesh  to  the  guests ;  the 
bones  he  throws  to  a  second  attendant,  who  pounds 
them  up  with  a  heavy  stone. 

I  passed  the  place  to-day  as  I  rode  in  from  a 
reconnaissance.  The  slab  lies  a  stone's-throw  to 
the  left  of  the  great  northern  road  to  Tengri  Nor 
and  Mongolia,  about  two  miles  from  the  city. 

A  group  of  stolid  vultures,  too  demoralized  to 
range  in  search  of  carrion,  stood  motionless  on 
a  rock  above,  waiting  the  next  dispenser  of 
charity. 

A  few  ravens  hopped  about  sadly ;  they,  too, 
were  evidently  pauperized.  One  magpie  was  pry- 
ing round  in  suspicious  proximity,  and  dogs  conscious 
of  shame  slunk  about  without  a  bark  in  them, 
and  nosed  the  ground  diligently.  They  are  always 
there,  waiting. 

There  was  hardly  a  stain  on  the  slab,  so  quick 
and  eager  are  the  applicants  for  charity.  Only 
a  few  rags  lay  around,  too  poor  to  be  carried 
away. 

I  have  not  seen  the  ceremony,  and  I  have  no 
mind  to.    My  companion  this  morning,  a  hardened 


328         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

young  subaltern  who  was  fighting  nearly  every 
day  in  April,  May,  and  June,  and  has  seen  more 
bloodshed  than  most  veterans,  saw  just  as  much 
as  I  have  described.  He  then  felt  very  ill,  dug 
his  spurs  into  his  horse,  and  rode  away. 


CHAPTER   XIV 

THE   CITY  AND   ITS  TEMPLES 

BY  the  first  week  in  September  I  had  visited  all 
the  most  important  temples  and  monasteries 
in  Lhasa.  We  generally  went  in  parties  of  four  and 
five,  and  a  company  of  Sikhs  or  Pathans  was  left 
in  the  courtyard  in  case  of  accidents.  We  were 
well  armed,  as  the  monks  were  sullen,  though  I 
do  not  think  they  were  capable  of  any  desperate 
fanaticism.  If  they  had  had  the  abandon  of 
dervishes,  they  might  have  rushed  our  camp  long 
before.  They  missed  their  chance  at  Gyantse, 
when  a  night  attack  pushed  home  by  overwhelm- 
ing numbers  could  have  wiped  out  our  little  garri- 
son. In  Lhasa  there  was  the  one  case  of  the 
Lama  who  ran  amuck  outside  the  camp  with  the 
coat  of  mail  and  huge  paladin's  sword  concealed 
beneath  his  cloak,  a  medieval  figure  who  thrashed 
the  air  with  his  brand  like  a  flail  in  sheer  lust  of 


330  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

blood.  He  was  hanged  medievally  the  next  day 
within  sight  of  Lhasa,  Since  then  the  exploit 
has  not  been  repeated,  but  no  one  leaves  the  peri- 
meter unarmed. 

I  have  written  of  the  squalor  of  the  Lhasa  streets. 
The  environs  of  the  city  are  beautiful  enough — 
willow  groves  intersected  by  clear-running  streams, 
walled-in  parks  with  palaces  and  fish-ponds,  marshes 
where  the  wild-duck  flaunt  their  security,  and  ripe 
barley-fields  stretching  away  to  the  hills.  In 
September  the  trees  were  wearing  their  autumn 
tints,  the  willows  were  mostly  a  sulphury  yellow, 
and  in  the  pools  beneath  the  red-stalked  poly- 
gonum and  burnished  dock-leaf  glowed  in  brilliant 
contrast.  Just  before  dusk  there  was  generally  a 
storm  in  the  valley,  which  only  occasionally  reached 
the  city ;  but  the  breeze  stirred  the  poplars,  and 
the  silver  under  the  leaves  glistened  brightly  against 
the  background  of  clouds.  Often  a  rainbow  hung 
over  the  Potala  like  a  nimbus. 

On  the  Lingkhor,  or  circular  road,  which  winds 
round  Lhasa,  we  saw  pilgrims  and  devotees  moving 
slowly  along  in  prayer,  always  keeping  the  Potala 
on  their  right  hand.  The  road  is  only  used  for 
devotion.    One  meets  decrepit  old  women  and  men. 


THE  CITY  AND  ITS  TEMPLES.        331 

halting  and  limping  and  slowly  revolving  their 
prayer-wheels  and  mumbling  charms.  I  never  saw 
a  healthy  yokel  or  robust  Lama  performing  this 
rite.  Nor  did  I  see  the  pilgrims  whom  one  reads  of 
as  circumambulating  the  city  on  their  knees  by  a 
series  of  prostrations,  bowing  their  heads  in  the 
dust  and  mud.  All  the  devotees  are  poor  and 
ragged,  and  many  blind.  It  seems  that  the  people 
of  Lhasa  do  not  begin  to  think  of  the  next  in- 
carnation until  they  have  nothing  left  in  this. 

When  one  leaves  the  broad  avenues  between  the 
walls  of  the  groves  and  pleasure-gardens,  and 
enters  the  city,  one's  senses  are  offended  by  every- 
thing that  is  unsightly  and  unclean.  Pigs  and 
pariah  dogs  are  nosing  about  in  black  oozy  mud. 
The  houses  are  solid  but  dirty.  It  is  hard  to 
believe  that  they  are  whitewashed  every  year. 

Close  to  the  western  entrance  are  the  huts  of 
the  Ragyabas,  beggars,  outcasts,  and  scavengers, 
who  cut  up  the  dead.  The  outer  walls  of  their 
houses  are  built  of  yak-horns. 

Some  of  the  houses  had  banks  of  turf  built  up 
outside  the  doors,  with  borders  of  English  flowers. 
The  dwellings  are  mostly  two  or  three  storied. 
Bird-cages  hang  from  the  windows. 


332  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

The  outside  of  the  cathedral  is  not  at  all  im- 
posing. From  the  streets  one  cannot  see  the 
golden  roof,  but  only  high  blank  walls,  and  at 
the  entrance  a  forest  of  dingy  pillars  beside  a 
massive  door.  The  door  is  thrown  open  by  a 
sullen  monk,  and  a  huge  courtyard  is  revealed 
with  more  dingy  pillars  that  were  once  red.  The 
entire  wall  is  covered  with  paintings  of  Buddhist 
myth  and  symbolism.  The  colours  are  subdued 
and  pleasing.  In  the  centre  of  the  yard  are 
masses  of  hollyhocks,  marigolds,  nasturtiums,  and 
stocks.  Beside  the  flower-borders  is  a  pyra- 
midical  structure  in  which  are  burnt  the  leaves 
of  juniper  and  pine  for  sacrifice. 

The  cloisters  are  two-storied ;  on  the  upper 
floor  the  monks  have  their  cells.  Looking  up, 
one  can  see  hundreds  of  them  gazing  at  us  with 
interest  over  the  banisters.  The  upper  story,  as 
in  every  temple  in  Tibet,  is  coated  with  a  dark 
red  substance  which  looks  like  rough  paint,  but 
is  really  sacred  earth,  pasted  on  to  evenly-clipped 
brushwood  so  as  to  seem  like  a  continuation  of  the 
masonry.  On  the  face  of  the  wall  are  emblems  in 
gilt,  Buddhist  symbols,  like  our  Prince  of  Wales*' 
feathers,  sun  and  crescent  moon,  and  various  other 


THE  CITY  AND  ITS  TEMPLES.        333 

devices  A  heavy  curtain  of  yak-hair  hangs  above 
the  entrance-gate.  On  the  roof  are  large  cylinders 
draped  in  yak-hair  cloth  topped  by  a  crescent  or 
a  spear.  Every  monastery  and  jong,  and  most 
houses  in  Tibet,  are  ornamented  with  these.  When 
one  first  sees  them  in  the  distance  they  look  like 
men  walking  on  the  roof. 

Generally  one  ascends  steps  from  the  outer  court- 
yard to  the  temple,  but  in  the  Jokhang  the  floors 
are  level.  We  enter  the  main  temple  by  a  dark 
passage.  The  great  doorway  that  opens  into  the 
street  has  been  closed  behind  us,  but  we  leave  a 
company  of  Pathans  in  the  outer  yard,  as  the  monks 
are  sullen.  Our  party  of  four  is  armed  with 
revolvers. 

Service  is  being  held  before  the  great  Buddhas 
as  we  enter,  and  a  thunderous  harmony  like  an 
organ-peal  breaks  the  interval  for  meditation. 
The  Abbot,  who  is  in  the  centre,  leans  forward 
from  his  chair  and  takes  a  bundle  of  peacock- 
feathers  from  a  vase  by  his  side.  As  he  points 
it  to  the  earth  there  is  a  clashing  of  cymbals,  a 
beating  of  drums,  and  a  blowing  of  trumpets  and 
conch  shells. 

Then  the  music  dies  away  like  the  reverbera- 


334  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

tion  of  cannon  in  the  hills.  The  Abbot  begins  the 
chant,  and  the  monks,  facing  each  other  like 
singing-men  in  a  choir,  repeat  the  litany.  They 
have  extraordinary  deep,  devotional  voices,  at 
once  unnatural  and  impressive.  The  deepest  bass 
of  the  West  does  not  approach  it,  and  their  sense 
of  time  is  perfect. 

The  voice  of  the  thousand  monks  is  like  the 
drone  of  some  subterranean  monster,  musically 
plaintive — the  wail  of  the  Earth  God  praying  for 
release  to  the  God  of  the  Skies. 

The  chant  sounds  like  the  endless  repetition  of 
the  same  formula ;  the  monks  sway  to  it  rhythmi- 
cally. The  temple  would  be  dark  if  it  were  not 
for  the  flickering  of  many  thousands  of  votive 
candles  and  butter  lamps.  Rows  upon  rows  of 
them  are  placed  before  every  shrine. 

In  an  inner  temple  we  found  the  three  great 
images  of  the  Buddhist  trinity — the  Buddhas  of 
the  past,  present,  and  future.  The  images  were 
greater  than  life-size,  and  set  with  jewels  from 
foot  to  crown.  As  in  the  cloisters  of  an  English 
cathedral,  there  were  Uttle  side-chapels,  which 
held  sacred  relics  and  shrines. 

There   were   lamps   of   gold,    and   solid   golden 


THE  CITY  AND  ITS  TEMPLES.        335 

bowls  set  on  altars,  and  embossed  salvers  of  copper 
and  bronze. 

A  hanging  grille  of  chainwork  protected  the 
precincts  from  sacrilege,  and  an  extended  hand, 
bloody  and  menacing,  was  stretched  from  the 
wall,  terrible  enough  when  suddenly  revealed  in 
that  dim  light  to  paralyze  and  strike  to  earth 
with  fright  any  profane  thief  who  would  dare  to 
enter. 

In  the  upper  story  we  found  a  place  which  we 
called  *  Hell,'  where  some  Lamas  were  worshipping 
the  demon  protectress  of  the  Grand  Lama.  The 
music  here  was  harsh  and  barbaric.  There  were 
displayed  on  the  pillars  and  walls  every  freak  of 
diabolical  invention  in  the  shape  of  scrolls  and 
devil-masks.  The  obscene  object  of  this  worship 
was  huddled  in  a  comer — a  dwarfish  abortion, 
hideous  and  malignant  enough  for  such  rites. 

All  about  the  Lamas*  feet  ran  little  white  mice 
searching  for  grain.  They  are  fed  daily,  and  are 
scrupulously  reverenced,  as  in  their  frail  white 
bodies  the  souls  of  the  previous  guardians  of  the 
shrine  are  believed  to  be  reincarnated. 

In  another  temple  we  found  the  Lamas  holding 
service  in  worship  of  the  many-handed   Buddha, 


336  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

Avalokitesvara.  The  picture  of  the  god  hung 
from  pillars  by  the  altar.  The  chief  Lamas  were 
wearing  peaked  caps  picturesquely  coloured  with 
subdued  blue  and  gold,  and  vestments  of  the 
same  hue.  The  lesser  Lamas  were  bare-headed, 
and  their  hair  was  cropped. 

When  we  first  entered,  an  acolyte  was  pouring 
tea  out  of  a  massive  copper  pot  with  a  turquoise 
on  the  spout.  Each  monk  received  his  tea  in  a 
wooden  bowl,  and  poured  in  barley-flour  to  make 
a  paste. 

During  this  interval  no  one  spoke  or  wliispered. 
The  footsteps  of  the  acolytes  were  noiseless.  Only 
the  younger  ones  looked  up  at  us  self-consciously 
as  we  watched  them  from  a  latticed  window  in  the 
corridor  above. 

Centuries  ago  this  service  was  ordained,  and  the 
intervals  appointed  to  further  the  pursuit  of  truth 
through  silence  and  abstraction.  The  monks  sat 
there  quiet  as  stone.  They  had  seen  us,  but  they 
were  seemingly  oblivious. 

One  wondered,  were  they  pursuing  truth  or  were 
they  petrified  by  ritual  and  routine  ?  Did  they 
regard  us  as  immaterial  reflexes,  imsubstantial 
and  illusory,   passing   shadows  of  the  world  cast 


THE  CITY  AND  ITS  TEMPLES.         337 

upon  them  by  an  instant's  illusion,  to  pass  away 
again  into  the  unreal,  while  they  were  absorbed 
in  the  contemplation  of  changeless  and  universal 
truths  ?  Or  were  we  noted  as  food  for  gossip 
and  criticism  when  their  self-imposed  ordeal  was 
done  ? 

The  reek  of  the  candles  was  almost  suffocating. 
*  Thank  God  I  am  not  a  Lama !  *  said  a  subaltern 
by  my  side.  An  Afridi  Subadar  let  the  butt  of 
his  rifle  clank  from  his  boot  to  the  pavement. 

At  these  calls  to  sanity  we  clattered  out  of  this 
unholy  atmosphere  of  dreams  as  if  by  an  unques- 
tioned impulse  into  the  bright  sunshine  outside. 

In  the  bazaar  there  is  a  gay  crowd.  The  streets 
are  thronged  by  as  good-natured  a  mob  as  I  have 
met  anywhere.  Sullenness  and  distrust  have  van- 
ished. Officers  and  men.  Tommies,  Gurkhas,  Sikhs, 
and  Pathans,  are  stared  at  and  criticised  good- 
humouredly,  and  their  accoutrements  fingered  and 
examined.  It  is  a  bright  and  interesting  crowd, 
full  of  colour.  In  a  comer  of  the  square  a  street 
singer  with  a  guitar  and  dancing  children  attracts 
a  small  crowd.  His  voice  is  a  rich  baritone,  and 
he  yodels  like  the  Tyrolese.  The  crowd  is  parted 
by  a  Shap6  riding  past  in  gorgeous  yellow  silks  and 


338  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

brocades,  followed  by  a  mounted  retinue  whose 
head-gear  would  be  the  despair  of  an  operatic 
hatter.  They  wear  red  lamp-shades,  yellow  motor- 
caps,  exaggerated  Gainsboroughs,  inverted  cooking- 
pots,  coal-scuttles,  and  medieval  helmets.  And 
among  this  topsy-turvy,  which  does  not  seem  out  of 
place  in  Lhasa,  the  most  eccentrically  hatted  man 
is  the  Bhutanese  Tongsa  Penlop,  who  parades  the 
streets  in  an  English  gray  felt  hat. 

The  Mongolian  caravan  has  arrived  in  Lhasa, 
after  crossing  a  thousand  miles  of  desert  and  moun- 
tain tracks.  The  merchants  and  drivers  saunter 
about  the  streets,  trying  not  to  look  too  rustic. 
But  they  are  easily  recognisable — tall,  sinewy  men, 
very  independent  in  gait,  with  faces  burnt  a  dark 
brick  red  by  exposure  to  the  wind  and  sun.  I 
saw  one  of  their  splendidly  robust  women,  clad  in  a 
sheepskin  cloak  girdled  at  the  waist,  bending  over  a 
cloth  stall,  and  fingering  samples  as  if  shopping 
were  the  natural  business  of  her  life. 

On  fine  days  the  wares  are  spread  on  the  cobbles 
of  the  street,  and  the  coloured  cloth  and  china 
make  a  pretty  show  against  the  background  of 
garden  flowers.  At  the  doors  of  the  shops  stand 
pale  Nuwaris,  whose  ancestors  from  Nepal  settled 


THE  CITY  AND  ITS  TEMPLES.        339 

in  Lhasa  generations  ago.  They  wear  a  flat 
brown  cap,  and  a  dull  russet  robe  darker  than 
that  of  the  Lamas.  The  Cashmiri  shopkeepers 
are  turbaned,  and  wear  a  cloak  of  butcher's  blue. 
They  and  the  Nuwaris  and  the  Chinese  seem  to 
monopolize  the  trade  of  the  city. 

British  officers  haunt  bazaars  searching  for 
curios,  but  with  very  little  success.  Lhasa  has 
no  artistic  industries ;  nearly  all  the  knick-knacks 
come  from  India  and  China.  Cloisonne  ware  is 
rare  and  expensive,  as  one  hsis  to  pay  for  the 
1,800  miles  of  transport  from  Peking.  Religious 
objects  are  not  sold.  Turquoises  are  plentiful, 
but  coarse  and  inferior.  Hundreds  of  paste  imita- 
tions have  been  bought.  There  is  a  certain  sale 
for  amulets,  rings,  bells,  and  ornaments  for  the 
hair,  but  these  and  the  brass  and  copper  work 
can  be  bought  for  half  the  price  in  the  Darjeeling 
bazaar.  The  few  relics  we  have  found  of  the 
West  must  have  histories.  In  the  cathedral  there 
was  a  bell  with  the  inscription  '  Te  Deum  lauda- 
mus,'  probably  a  rehc  of  the  Capuchins.  In  the 
purlieus  of  the  city  we  found  a  bicycle  without 
tyres,  and  a  sausage-machine  made  in  Birmingham. 

With  the  exception  of  the  cathedral,   most  of 


340  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

the  temples  and  monasteries  are  on  the  outskirts 
of  the  city.  There  is  a  sameness  about  these 
places  of  worship  that  would  make  description 
tedious.  Only  the  Ramo-ch6  and  Moru  temples, 
which  are  solely  devoted  to  sorcery,  are  different. 
Here  one  sees  the  other  soul-side  of  the  people. 

The  Ramo-ch6  is  as  dark  and  dingy  as  a  vault. 
On  each  side  of  the  doorway  are  three  gigantic 
tutelary  demons.  In  the  vestibule  is  a  collection 
of  bows,  arrows,  chain-armour,  stag-horns,  stuffed 
animals,  scrolls,  masks,  skulls,  and  all  the  para- 
phernalia of  devil-worship.  On  the  left  is  a  dark 
recess  where  drums  are  being  beaten  by  an  unseen 
choir. 

A  Lama  stands,  chalice  in  hand,  before  a  deep 
aperture  cut  in  the  wall  like  a  buttery  hatch,  and 
illumined  by  dim,  flickering  candles,  which  reveal 
a  malignant  female  fiend.  As  a  second  priest 
pours  holy  water  into  a  chalice,  the  Lama  raises 
it  solemnly  again  and  again,  muttering  spells  to 
propitiate  the  fury. 

In  the  hall  there  are  neither  ornaments,  gods, 
hanging  canopies,  nor  scrolls,  as  in  the  other 
temples.  There  is  neither  congregation  nor  priests. 
The   walls   are   apparently   black   and   unpainted, 


THE  CITY  AND  ITS  TEMPLES.        341 

but  here  and  there  a  lamp  reveals  a  Gorgon's  head, 
a  fiend's  eye,  a  square  inch  or  two  of  pigment  that 
time  has  not  obscured. 

The  place  is  immemorially  old.  There  are  huge 
vessels  of  carved  metal  and  stone,  embossed,  like 
the  roof,  with  griffins  and  skulls,  which  probably 
date  back  to  before  the  introduction  of  Buddhism 
into  Tibet,  and  are  survivals  of  the  old  Bon  re- 
ligion. There  is  nothing  bright  here  in  colour  or 
sound,  nothing  vivid  or  animated. 

Stricken  men  and  women  come  to  remove  a 
curse,  vindictive  ones  to  inflict  one,  bereaved  ones 
to  pay  the  initiated  to  watch  the  adventures  of 
the  soul  in  purgatory  and  guide  it  on  its  passage 
to  the  new  birth,  while  demons  and  furies  are 
lurking  to  snatch  it  with  fiery  claws  and  drag  it 
to  hell. 

All  these  beings  must  be  appeased  by  magic 
rites.  So  in  the  Ramo-ch6  there  is  no  rapture  of 
music,  no  communion  with  Buddha,  no  beatitudes, 
only  solitary  priests  standing  before  the  shrines 
and  mumbling  incantations,  dismal  groups  of  two 
or  three  seated  Buddha-fashion  on  the  floor,  and 
casting  spells  to  exercise  a  deciding  influence,  as 
they  hope,  in  the  continual  warfare  which  is  being 


342  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

waged  between  the  tutelary  and  malignant  deities 
for  the  prize  of  a  soul. 

In  the  chancel  of  the  temple,  behind  the  altar,  is 
a  massive  pile  of  masonry  stretching  from  floor 
to  roof,  under  which,  as  folk  believe,  an  abysmal 
chasm  leads  down  to  hell.  Round  this  there  is  a 
dark  and  narrow  passage  which  pilgrims  circum. 
ambulate.  The  floor  and  walls  are  as  slippery  as 
ice,  worn  by  centuries  of  pious  feet  and  groping 
hands.  One  old  woman  in  some  urgent  need  is 
drifting  round  and  round  abstractedly. 

Elsewhere  one  might  linger  in  the  place  fasci- 
nated, but  here  in  Lhasa  one  moves  among  mys- 
teries casually ;  for  one  cannot  wonder,  in  this 
isolated  land  where  the  elements  are  so  aggressive, 
among  these  deserts  and  wildernesses,  heaped 
mountain  chains,  and  impenetrable  barriers  of 
snow,  that  the  children  of  the  soil  believe  that 
earth,  air,  and  water  are  peopled  by  demons  who 
are  struggling  passionately  over  the  destinies  of 
man. 

I  will  not  describe  any  more  of  the  Lhasa  temples. 
One  shrine  is  very  like  another,  and  details  would  be 
tedious.  Personally,  I  do  not  care  for  systematic 
sightseeing,   even   in   Lhasa,   but   prefer   to  loiter 


THE  CITY  AND  ITS  TEMPLES.        343 

about  the  streets  and  bazaars,  and  the  gardens  out- 
side the  city,  watch  the  people,  and  enjoy  the  at- 
mosphere of  the  place.  The  religion  of  Tibet  is 
picturesque  enough  in  an  unwholesome  way,  but  to 
inquire  how  the  layers  of  superstition  became  added 
to  the  true  faith,  and  trace  the  growth  of  these 
spurious  accretions,  I  leave  to  archaeologists.  Per- 
haps one  reader  in  a  hundred  will  be  interested  to 
know  that  a  temple  was  built  by  the  illustrious 
Konjo,  daughter  of  the  Emperor  Tai-Tsung  and  wife 
of  King  Srong-btsangombo,  but  I  think  the  other 
ninety  and  nine  will  be  devoutly  thankful  if  I  omit 
to  mention  it. 

Yet  one  cannot  leave  the  subject  of  the  Lhasa 
monasteries  without  remarking  on  the  striking 
resemblance  between  Tibetan  Lamaism  and  the 
Romish  Church.  The  resemblance  cannot  be  ac- 
cidental. The  burning  of  candles  before  altars, 
the  sprinkling  of  holy  water,  the  chanting  of 
hymns  in  alternation,  the  giving  ahns  and  saying 
Masses  for  the  dead,  must  have  their  origin  in  the 
West.  We  know  that  for  many  centuries  large 
Christian  communities  have  existed  in  Western 
China  near  the  Tibetan  frontier,  and  several  Roman 
Catholic  missionaries  have  penetrated  to  Lhasa  and 


344  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

other  parts  of  Tibet  during  the  last  three  centuries. 
As  early  as  1641  the  Jesuit  Father  Grueber  visited 
Lhasa,  and  recorded  that  the  Lamas  wore  caps  and 
mitres,  that  they  used  rosaries,  bells,  and  censers, 
and  observed  the  practice  of  confession,  penance, 
and  absolution.  Besides  these  points  common  to 
Roman  Catholicism,  he  noticed  the  monastic  and 
conventual  system,  the  tonsure,  the  vows  of  poverty, 
chastity,  and  obedience,  the  doctrine  of  incarnation 
and  the  Trinity,  and  the  belief  in  purgatory  and 
paradise.* 

We  occasionally  saw  a  monk  with  the  refined 
ascetic  face  of  a  Roman  Caxdinal.    Te  Rinpoche, 

♦  It  is  interesting  to  compare  Gnieber's  account  with  the 
journal  of  Father  Rubruquis,  who  travelled  in  Mongolia  in  the 
thirteenth  century.     In  1253  he  wrote  of  the  Lamas  : 

*  All  their  priests  had  their  heads  shaven  quite  over,  and  they 
are  clad  in  saffron -coloured  garments.  Being  once  shaven, 
they  lead  an  unmarried  life  from  that  time  forward,  and  they 
live  a  hundred  or  two  of  them  in  one  cloister.  .  .  .  They  have 
with  them  also,  whithersoever  they  go,  a  certain  string,  with  a 
hundred  or  two  hundred  nutshells  thereupon,  much  like  our 
beads  which  we  carry  about  with  us  ;  and  they  do  alwajrs  mutter 
these  words,  "  Om  mani  pectavi  (om  mani  padme  hom) " — 
"  God,  Thou  knowest,"  as  one  of  them  expounded  it  to  me  ; 
and  so  often  do  they  expect  a  reward  at  God's  hands  as  they 
pronounce  these  words  in  remembrance  of  God.  ...  I  made 
a  visit  to  their  idol  temple,  and  found  certain  priests  sitting  in 
the  outward  portico,  and  those  which  I  saw  seemed,  by  their 
shaven  beards,  as  if  they  had  been  our  covmtrymen  ;  they  wore 
certain  ornaments  upon  their  heads  like  mitres  made  of  paper.' 


THE  CITY  AND  ITS  TEMPLES.        345 

the  acting  regent,  was  an  example.  One  or  two 
looked  as  if  they  might  be  humane  and  benevolent 
— men  who  might  make  one  accept  the  gentle  old 
Lama  in  *  Kim  *  as  a  not  impossible  fiction ;  but 
most  of  them  appeared  to  me  to  be  gross  and 
sottish.  I  must  confess  that  during  the  protracted 
negotiations  at  Lhasa  I  had  little  sympathy  with 
the  Lamas.  It  is  a  mistake  to  think  that  they 
keep  their  country  closed  out  of  any  religious 
scruple.  Buddhism  in  its  purest  form  is  not  e::- 
clusive  or  fanatical.  Sakya  Muni  preached  a  mis- 
sionary religion.  He  was  Christlike  in  his  universal 
love  and  his  desire  to  benefit  all  living  creatures. 
But  Buddhism  in  Tibet  has  become  more  and  more 
degenerate,  and  the  Lamaist  Church  is  now  little 
better  than  a  political  mechanism  whose  chief 
function  is  the  uncompromising  exclusion  of  for- 
eigners. The  Lamas  know  that  intercourse  with 
other  nations  must  destroy  their  influence  with  the 
people. 

And  Tibet  is  really  ruled  by  the  Lamas.  Out- 
side Lhasa  are  the  three  great  monasteries  of 
Depung,  Sera,  and  Gaden,  whose  Abbots,  backed 
by  a  following  of  nearly  30,000  armed  and  bigoted 
monks,  maintain  a  preponderating  influence  in  the 


346  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

national  assembly.*  These  men  wield  a  greatei' 
influence  than  the  four  Shapes  or  the  Dalai  Lama 
himself,  and  practically  dictate  the  policy  of  the 
country. 

The  three  great  monasteries  are  of  ancient  founda- 
tion, and  intimately  associated  with  the  history  of 
the  country.  They  are,  in  fact,  ecclesiastical 
Universities,!  and  resemble  in  many  ways  our 
Universities  of  Oxford  and  Cambridge.  The  Uni- 
versities are  divided  into  colleges.  Each  has  its 
own  Abbot,  or  Master,  and  disciplinary  staff.    The 

*  '  It  may  be  asked  how  the  monastic  influence  is  brought 
to  bear  on  a  Government  in  which  three  out  of  the  four  princi- 
pal Ministers  (Shap6)  are  laymen.  The  fact  seems  to  be  that 
lying  behind  the  Tak  Lama,  the  Shap6s,  and  all  the  machinery 
of  the  Tibetan  Government,  as  we  have  hitherto  been  acquainted 
with  it,  there  is  an  institution  called  the  "  Tsong-du-chembo," 
or  "  Tsong-dugze-tsom,"  which  may  reasonably  be  compared 
with  what  we  call  a  "  National  Assembly,"  or,  as  the  word 
implies,  "  Great  Assembly."  It  is  constituted  of  the  Kenpas 
or  Abbots  of  the  three  great  monasteries,  representatives  from 
the  four  lings  or  small  monasteries  actually  in  Lhasa  city,  and 
from  all  the  other  monasteries  in  the  province  of  U  ;  and  besides 
this,  all  the  ofl&cials  of  the  Government  are  present — laymen  and 
ecclesiastics  alike — to  the  number  of  several  hundreds.' — Cap- 
tain O'Connor's  Diary  at  Khamba  Jong  (Tibetan  Blue-Book, 
1904). 

t  I  have  derived  most  of  my  information  regarding  the  disci- 
pline and  constitution  of  Depung  from  '  Lamaism  in  Tibet,'  by 
Colonel  Augustine  Waddell,  who  accompanied  the  expedition 
as  ArchiBologist  and  Principal  Medical  Officer. 


THE  CITY  AND  ITS  TEMPLES.         347 

undergraduates,  or  candidates  for  ordination,  must 
attend  lectures  and  chapels,  and  pass  examinations 
in  set  books,  which  they  must  learn  from  cover  to 
cover  before  they  can  take  their  degree.  Failure 
in  examination,  as  well  as  breaches  in  discipline 
and  manners,  are  punished  by  flogging.  Corporal 
punishment  is  also  dealt  out  to  the  unfortunate 
tutors,  who  are  held  responsible  for  their  pupils' 
omissions.  If  a  candidate  repeatedly  fails  to  pass 
his  examination,  he  is  expelled  from  the  University, 
and  can  only  enter  again  on  payment  of  increased 
fees.  The  three  leading  Universities  are  empowered 
to  confer  degrees  which  correspond  to  our  Bachelor 
and  Doctor  of  Divinity.  The  monks  live  in  rooms 
in  quadrangles,  and  have  separate  messing  clubs, 
but  meet  for  general  worship  in  the  cathedral.  If 
their  code  is  strictly  observed,  which  I  very  much 
doubt,  prayers  and  tedious  religious  observances 
must  take  up  nearly  their  whole  day.  But  the 
Lamas  are  adept  casuists,  and  generally  manage 
to  evade  the  most  irksome  laws  of  their  scriptures. 

Soon  after  our  arrival  in  Lhasa  we  had  occasion 
to  visit  Depung,  which  is  probably  the  largest 
monastery  in  the  world.  It  stands  in  a  natural 
amphitheatre  in  the  hillside  two  miles  from  the 


348  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

city,  a  huge  collection  of  temples  and  monastic 
buildings,  larger,  and  certainly  more  imposing, 
than  most  towns  in  Tibet. 

The  University  was  founded  in  1414,  during  the 
reign  of  the  first  Grand  Lama  of  the  Reformed 
Church.  It  is  divided  into  four  colleges,  and  con- 
tains nearly  8,000  monks,  amongst  whom  there 
is  a  large  Mongolian  community.  The  fourth 
Grand  Lama,  a  Mongolian,  is  buried  within  the 
precincts.  The  fifth  and  greatest  Dalai  Lama, 
who  built  the  Potala  and  was  the  first  to  combine 
the  temporal  and  spiritual  power,  was  an  Abbot 
of  Depung.  The  reigning  Dalai  Lama  visits  De- 
pung  annually,  and  a  palace  in  the  university  is 
reserved  for  his  use.  The  Abbot,  of  course,  is  a 
man  of  very  great  political  influence. 

All  these  facts  I  have  collected  to  show  that  the 
monks  have  some  reason  to  be  proud  of  their 
monastery  as  the  first  in  Tibet.  One  may  forgive 
them  a  little  pride  in  its  historic  distinctions. 
Even  in  our  own  alma  mater  we  meet  the  best 
of  men  who  seem  to  gather  importance  from  old 
traditions  and  association  with  a  long  roll  of  dis- 
tinguished names.  What,  then,  can  we  expect  of 
this   Tibetan   community,    the   most    conservative 


THE  CITY  AND  ITS  TEMPLES.        349 

in  a  country  that  has  prided  itself  for  centuries 
on  its  bigotry  and  isolation — ^men  who  are  ignorant 
of  science,  literature,  history,  politics,  everything, 
in  fact,  except  their  own  narrow  priestcraft  and 
confused  metaphysics  ?  We  call  the  Tibetan  *  im- 
possible.' His  whole  education  teaches  him  to  be  so, 
and  the  more  educated  he  is  the  more  *  impossible  ' 
he  becomes. 

Imagine,  then,  the  consternation  at  Depung 
when  a  body  of  armed  men  rode  up  to  the  monas- 
tery and  demanded  supplies.  We  had  refrained 
from  entering  the  monasteries  of  Lhasa  and  its 
neighbourhood  at  the  request  of  the  Abbots  and 
Shapes,  but  only  on  condition  that  the  monks 
should  bring  in  supplies,  which  were  to  be  paid 
for  at  a  liberal  rate.  The  Abbots  failed  to  keep 
their  promise,  supplies  were  not  forthcoming,  and 
it  became  necessary  to  resort  to  strong  measures. 
An  officer  was  sent  to  the  gate  with  an  escort  of 
three  men  and  a  letter  saying  that  if  the  provisions 
were  not  handed  over  within  an  hour  we  would 
break  into  the  monastery  and  take  them,  if  neces- 
sary, by  force.  The  messengers  were  met  by  a 
crowd  of  excited  Lamas,  who  refused  to  accept 
the  letter,  waved  them  away,  and  rolled  stones 


350  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

towards  them  menacingly,  as  an  intimation  that 
they  were  prepared  to  fight.  As  the  messengers 
rode  away  the  tocsin  was  heard,  warning  the  vil- 
lagers, women  and  children,  who  were  gathered 
outside  with  market  produce,  to  depart. 

General  Macdonald  with  a  strong  force  of  British 
and  native  troops  drew  up  within  1,300  yards  of 
the  monastery,  guns  were  trained  on  Depung,  the 
infantry  were  deployed,  and  we  waited  the  expira- 
tion of  the  period  of  grace  intimated  in  the  letter. 
An  hour  passed  by,  and  it  seemed  as  if  military 
operations  were  inevitable,  when  groups  of  monks 
came  out  with  a  white  flag,  carrying  baskets  of 
eggs  and  a  complimentary  scarf. 

Even  in  the  face  of  this  military  display  they 
began  to  temporize.  They  bowed  and  chattered 
and  protested  in  their  usual  futile  manner,  and 
condescended  so  far  as  to  say  they  would  talk 
the  matter  over  if  we  retired  at  once,  and  send  the 
supplies  to  oiu*  camp  the  next  day,  if  they  came 
to  a  satisfactory  decision.  The  Lamas  are  trained 
to  wrangle  and  dispute  and  defer  and  vacillate.* 

•  The  highest  degree  which  is  coaferred  on  the  Lamas  by 
their  Universities  is  the  Rabs-jam-pa  (verbally  overflowing 
endlessly). — Waddell,  '  Lamaism  in  Tibet.' 


THE  CITY  AND  ITS  TEMPLES.        351 

They  seem  to  think  that  speech  was  made  only 
to  evade  conclusions.  The  curt  ultimatum  was 
repeated,  and  the  deputation  was  removed  gently 
by  two  impassive  sepoys,  still  chattering  like  a 
flock  of  magpies. 

In  the  meanwhile  we  sat  and  waited  and  smoked 
our  pipes,  and  wondered  if  there  were  going  to  be 
another  Guru.  It  seemed  the  most  difficult  thing 
in  the  world  to  save  these  poor  fools  from  the 
effects  of  their  obstinate  folly.  The  time-limit 
had  nearly  expired,  the  two  batteries  were  ad- 
vanced 300  yards,  the  gunners  took  their  sights 
again,  and  trained  the  lo-pounders  on  the  very 
centre  of  the  monastery. 

There  were  only  five  minutes  more,  and  we  were 
stirred,  according  to  our  natures,  by  pity  or  ex- 
asperation or  the  swift  primitive  instinct  for  the 
dramatic,  which  sweeps  away  the  humanities,  and 
leaves  one  to  the  conflict  of  elemental  pas- 
sions. 

At  last  a  thin  line  of  red-robed  monks  was  seen 
to  issue  from  the  gate  and  descend  the  hill,  each 
carrying  a  bag  of  suppUes.  The  crisis  was  over, 
and  we  were  spared  the  necessity  of  inflicting  a 
cruel  punishment.     I  waited  to  see  the  procession. 


352  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

a  group  of  sullen  ecclesiastics,  who  had  never 
bowed  or  submitted  to  external  influence  in  their 
lives,  carrying  on  their  backs  their  unwilling  con- 
tribution to  the  support  of  the  first  foreign  army 
that  had  ever  intruded  on  their  seclusion.  It 
must  have  been  the  most  humiliating  day  in  the 
history  of  Depung. 

It  must  be  admitted  that  it  was  not  a  moment 
when  the  monks  looked  their  best.  Yet  I  could 
not  help  comparing  their  appearance  with  that 
of  the  simple  honest-looking  peasantry.  Many  of 
them  looked  sottish  and  degraded ;  other  faces 
showed  cruelty  and  cunning ;  their  brows  were 
contracted  as  if  by  perpetual  scheming ;  some 
were  almost  simian  in  appearance,  and  looked 
as  if  they  could  not  harbour  a  thought  that  was 
not  animal  or  sensual.  They  waddled  in  their 
walk,  and  their  right  arms,  exposed  from  the 
shoulder,  looked  soft  and  flabby,  as  if  they  had 
never  done  an  honest  day's  work  in  their  Ufe. 

One  man  had  the  face  of  an  inquisitor — round, 
beady  eyes,  puffed  cheeks,  and  thin,  tightly-shut 
mouth. 

How  they  hated  us !  If  one  of  us  fell  into  their 
hands  secretly,  I  have  no  doubt  they  would  rack 


THE  CITY  AND  ITS  TEMPLES.        353 

him  limb  from  limb,  or  cut  him  into  small  pieces 
with  a  knife. 

The  Depung  incident  shows  how  difficult  it  was 
to  make  any  headway  with  the  Tibetans  without 
recourse  to  arms.  We  were  present  in  the  city 
to  insist  on  compliance  with  our  demands.  But 
an  amicable  settlement  seemed  hopeless,  and  we 
could  not  stay  in  Lhasa  indefinitely.  What  if 
these  monks  were  to  say,  '  You  may  stay  here 
if  you  like.  We  will  not  molest  you,  but  we 
refuse  to  accept  your  terms  ? '  We  could  only 
retire  or  train  our  guns  on  the  Potala.  Retreat 
was,  of  course,  impossible. 


CHAPTER   XV 

THE     SETTLEMENT 

THE  political  deadlock  continued  until  within 
a  week  of  the  signing  of  the  treaty. 

For  a  long  time  no  responsible  delegates  were 
forthcoming.  The  Shapes,  who  were  weak  men 
and  tools  of  the  fugitive  Dalai  Lama,  protested 
that  any  treaty  they  might  make  with  us  would 
result  in  their  disgrace.  If,  on  the  other  hand, 
they  made  no  treaty,  and  we  were  compelled  to 
occupy  the  Potala,  or  take  some  other  step  offen- 
sive to  the  hierarchy,  their  ruin  would  be  equally 
certain.     Ruin,  in  fact,  faced  them  in  any  case. 

The  highest  officials  in  Tibet  visited  Colonel 
Younghusband,  expressed  their  eagerness  to  see 
differences  amicably  settled,  and,  when  asked  to 
arrange  the  simplest  matter,  said  they  were  afraid 
to  take  on  themselves  the  responsibility.  And  this 
was  not  merely  astutw-  evasiveness.    It  was  really  a 


THE  SETTLEMENT.  355 

fact  that  there  was  no  one  in  Lhasa  who  dared 
commit  himself  by  an  action  or  assurance  of  any 
kind. 

Yet  there  existed  some  kind  of  irresponsible  dis- 
organized machine  of  administration  which  some- 
times arrived  at  a  decision  about  matters  of  the 
moment.  The  National  Assembly  was  sufficiently 
of  one  mind  to  depose  and  imprison  the  Ta  Lama, 
the  ecclesiastical  member  of  Council.  His  disgrace 
was  due  to  his  failure  to  persuade  us  to  return  to 
Gyantse. 

The  National  Assembly  held  long  sessions  daily, 
and  after  more  than  a  week  of  discussion  they 
began  to  realize  that  there  was  at  least  one  aim 
that  was  common  to  them  all — that  the  English 
should  be  induced  to  leave  Lhasa.  They  then 
appointed  accredited  delegates,  whose  decisions, 
they  said,  would  be  entirely  binding  on  the  Dalai 
Lama,  should  he  come  back.  The  Dalai  Lama 
had  left  his  seal  with  Te  Rinpoche,  the  acting 
regent,  but  with  no  authority  to  use  it. 

The  terms  of  the  treaty  were  disclosed  to  the 
Amban,  who  communicated  them  to  the  Tsong-du. 
The  Tsong-du  submitted  the  draft  of  their  reply 
to  the  Amban  before  it  was  presented  to  Colonel 


356         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

Yoimghusband.  The  first  reply  of  the  Assemblv 
to  our  demands  ought  to  be  preser\-ed  as  a  historic 
epitome  of  national  character.  The  indemnity, 
they  said,  ought  to  be  paid  by  us,  and  not  by  them. 
We  had  invaded  their  territory,  and  spoiled  their 
monasteries  and  lands,  and  should  bear  the  cost. 
The  question  of  trade  marts  they  were  obstinately 
opposed  to  ;  but,  provided  we  carried  out  the  other 
terms  of  the  treaty  to  their  satisfaction,  they 
would  consider  the  advisability  of  conceding  us  a 
market  at  Rinchengong,  a  mile  and  a  half  beyond 
the  present  one  at  Yatung.  They  would  not  be 
prepared,  however,  to  make  this  concesskm  unless 
we  undertook  to  pay  for  what  we  purchased  on 
the  spot,  to  re^)ect  their  womeii.  and  to  refrain 
from  looting.  Road-making  they  could  not  aDow, 
as  the  blasting  and  upheaval  oi  soil  oiffcaified 
their  gods  and  brought  trouble  on  tiie  neighbour- 
hood.  The  tekgr^h-wiie  was  against  their  cus- 
toms, and  objectionaUe  on  rdigioos  grounds. 
With  regard  to  foreign  relations,  tbey  had  never 
bad  any  dealings  with  an  outside  race,  and  tbey 
intoided  to  preserve  this  -poHcy  so  long  as  tbey 
were  not  oompdkd  to  seek  pfotectkni  from  an- 
other Power. 


THE  SETTLEMENT.  357 

The  tone  of  the  reply  indicates  the  attitude  of 
the  Tibetans.  Obstinacy  could  go  no  further. 
The  document,  however,  was  not  forwarded  offi- 
cially to  the  Commissioner,  but  returned  to  the 
Assembly  by  the  Amban  as  too  impertinent  for 
transmission.  The  Amban  explained  to  Colonel 
Younghusband  that  the  Tibetans  regarded  the 
negotiations  in  the  light  of  a  huckster's  bargain. 
They  did  not  realize  that  we  were  in  a  position 
to  enforce  terms,  and  that  our  demands  were  un- 
conditional, but  thought  that  by  opening  negotia- 
tions in  an  unconciliatory  manner,  and  asking  for 
more  than  they  expected,  they  might  be  able  to 
effect  a  compromise  and  escape  the  full  exaction  of 
the  penalty. 

The  first  concession  on  the  part  of  the  Tibetans 
was  the  release  of  the  two  Lachung  men,  natives 
of  Sikkim  and  British  subjects,  who  had  been 
captured  and  beaten  at  Tashilunpo  in  July,  1903, 
while  the  Commission  was  waiting  at  Khamba 
Jong.  Their  liberation  was  one  of  the  terms  of 
the  treaty.  Colonel  Yoimghusband  made  the  re- 
lease the  occasion  of  an  impressive  durbar,  in 
which  he  addressed  a  solemn  warning  to  the  Tibetans 
on  the  sanctity'  of  the  British  subject.    The  im- 


358         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

prisonment  of  the  two  men  from  Sikkim,  he  said 
was  the  most  serious  offence  of  which  the  Tibetans 
had  been  guilty.  It  was  largely  on  that  account 
that  the  Indian  Government  had  decided  to  advance 
to  Gyantse.  The  prisoners  were  brought  straight 
from  the  dungeon  to  the  audience-hall.  They  had 
been  incarcerated  in  a  dark  underground  cell  for 
more  than  a  year,  and  they  knew  nothing  of  the 
arrival  of  the  English  in  Lhasa  until  the  morning 
when  Colonel  Younghusband  told  them  they  were 
free  by  the  command  of  the  King-Emperor.  I 
shall  never  forget  the  scene — the  bewilderment 
and  delight  of  the  prisoners,  their  drawn,  blanched 
features,  and  the  sullen  acquiescence  of  the  Tibetans, 
who  learnt  for  the  first  time  the  meaning  of  the  old 
Roman  boast,  *  Civis  Romanus  sum.' 

On  August  20  Colonel  Yoxmghusband  received 
through  the  Amban  the  second  reply  to  our  demands. 
The  tone  of  the  delegates  was  still  impossible,  though 
slightly  modified  and  more  reasonable.  Several 
durbars  followed,  but  they  did  not  advance  the 
negotiations.  Instead  of  discussing  matters  vital 
to  the  settlement,  the  Tibetan  representatives 
would  arrive  with  all  the  formalities  and  ceremoniaJ 
of  durbar  to  beg  us  not  to  cut  grass  in  a  particular 


THE  SETTLEMENT.  359 

field,  or  to  request  the  return  of  the  empty  grain- 
bags  to  the  monasteries.  The  Amban  said  that 
he  had  met  with  nothing  but  shuffling  from  the 

*  barbarians  '  during  his  term  of  office.    They  were 

*  dark  and  cunning  adepts  at  prevarication,  children 
in  the  conduct  of  affairs.' 

The  counsellors,  however,  began  to  show  signs 
of  wavering.  They  were  evidently  eager  to  come 
to  terms,  though  they  still  hoped  to  reduce  our 
demands,  and  tried  to  persuade  the  Commis- 
sioner to  agree  to  conditions  proposed  by  them- 
selves. 

Throughout  this  rather  trying  time  our  social 
relations  with  the  Tibetans  were  of  a  thoroughly 
friendly  character.  The  Shapes  and  one  or  two 
of  the  leading  monks  attended  race-meetings  and 
gjnnkanas,  put  their  money  on  the  totalizator, 
and  seemed  to  enjoy  their  day  out.  When  their 
ponies  ran  in  the  visitors'  race,  the  members  of 
Council  temporarily  forgot  their  stiffness,  waddled 
to  the  rails  to  see  the  finish,  and  were  genuinely 
excited.  They  were  entertained  at  lunch  and  tea 
by  Colonel  Younghusband,  and  were  invited  to  a 
Tibetan  theatrical  performance  given  in  the  court- 
yard of  the  Lhalu  house,  which  became  the  head- 


36o         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

quarters  of  the  mission.  On  these  occasions  they 
were  genial  and  friendly,  and  appreciated  our 
hospitaUty. 

The  humbler  folk  apparently  bore  us  no  vindic- 
tiveness,  and  showed  no  signs  of  resenting  our  pres- 
ence in  the  city.  Merchants  and  storekeepers 
profited  by  the  exaggerated  prices  we  paid  for 
everything  we  bought.  Trade  in  Lhasa  was  never 
brisker.  The  poor  were  never  so  Uberally  treated. 
One  day  a  merry  crowd  of  them  were  collected 
on  the  plain  outside  the  city,  and  largess  was  dis- 
tributed to  more  than  ii,ooo.  Every  babe  in  arms 
within  a  day's  march  of  Lhasa  was  brought  to  the 
spot,  and  received  its  dole  of  a  tanka  (5d.). 

I  think  the  Tibetans  were  genuinely  impressed 
with  our  humanity  during  this  time,  and  when,  on 
the  eve  of  our  departure,  the  benign  and  vener- 
able Te  Rinpoche  held  his  hands  over  General  Mac- 
donald  in  benediction,  and  solemnly  blessed  him 
for  his  clemency  and  moderation  in  sparing  the 
monasteries  and  people,  no  one  doubted  his  thank- 
fulness was  sincere.  The  golden  Buddha  he  pre- 
sented to  the  General  was  the  highest  pledge  of 
esteem  a  Buddhist  priest  could  bestow. 

When,    on    September    i,    the    Tibetans,    after 


THE  SETTLEMENT.  361 

nearly  a  month's  palaver,  had  accepted  only  two 
of  the  terms  of  the  treaty,*  Colonel  Younghusband 
decided  that  the  time  had  come  for  a  guarded  ulti- 
matum. He  told  the  delegates  that,  if  the  terms 
were  not  accepted  in  full  within  a  week,  he  would 
consult  General  Macdonald  as  to  what  measures 
it  would  be  necessary  to  take  to  enforce  compli- 
ance. Their  submission  was  complete,  and  im- 
mediate. 

Colonel  Younghusband  had  achieved  a  diplo- 
matic triumph  of  the  highest  order.  If  the  ulti- 
matum had  been  given  three  weeks,  or  even  a  fort- 
night, earlier,  I  believe  the  Tibetans  would  have 
resisted.  When  we  reached  Lhasa  on  August  3, 
the  Nepalese  Resident  said  that  10,000  armed  monks 
had  been  ready  to  oppose  us  if  we  had  decided  to 
quarter  ourselves  inside  the  city,  and  they  had 
only  dispersed  when  the  Shapes  who  rode  out  to 
meet  us  at  Toilung  returned  with  assurances  that 
we  were  going  to  camp  outside.  At  one  time  it 
seemed  impossible  to  make  any  progress  with  nego- 
tiations without  further  recourse  to  arms.  But 
patience  and  diplomacy  conquered.     We  had  shown 

♦The  liberation  of  the  Lachimg  men  aad  the  destruction  of 
the  Yatung  and  Gob-sorg  barriers. 
12  a 


362  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

the  Tibetans  we  could  reach  Lhasa  and  yet  respect 
their  reUgion,  and  left  an  impression  that  our  strength 
was  tempered  with  humanity. 

The  treaty  was  signed  in  the  Potala  on  August  7, 
in  the  Dalai  Lama's  throne-room.  The  Tibetan 
signatories  were  the  acting  regent,  who  affixed  the 
seal  of  the  Dalai  Lama ;  the  four  Shap& ;  the 
Abbots  of  the  three  great  monasteries,  Depung, 
Sera,  and  Gaden ;  and  a  representative  of  the 
National  Assembly.  The  Amban  was  not  em- 
powered to  sign,  as  he  awaited  *  formal  sanction ' 
from  Peking.  Lest  the  treaty  should  be  after- 
wards disavowed  through  a  revolution  in  Govern- 
ment, the  signatories  included  representatives  of 
every  organ  of  administration  in  Lhasa. 

On  the  afternoon  of  the  7th  our  troops  Uned  the 
causeway  on  the  west  front  of  the  Potala.  Towards 
the  summit  the  rough  and  broken  road  became  an 
ascent  of  slippery  steps,  where  one  had  to  walk 
crabwise  to  prevent  faUing,  and  plant  one's  feet 
on  the  crevices  of  the  age-worn  flagstones,  where 
grass  and  dock-leaves  gave  one  a  securer  foothold. 
Then  through  the  gateway  and  along  a  maze  of 
sHppery  passages,  dark  as  Tartarus,  but  illumined 
dimly   by   flickering   butter   lamps  held   by   aged 


THE  SETTLEMENT.  363 

monks,  impassive  and  inscrutable.  In  the  audience- 
chamber  Colonel  Younghusband,  General  Macdonald, 
and  the  Chinese  Amban  sat  beneath  the  throne  of 
the  Dalai  Lama.  On  either  side  of  them  were  the 
British  Political  Officer  and  Tibetan  signatories. 
In  another  comer  were  the  Tongsa  Penlop  of  Bhutan 
and  his  lusty  big-boned  men,  and  the  dapper  Httle 
Nepalese  Resident,  wreathed  in  smiles.  British 
officers  sat  round  forming  a  circle.  Behind  them 
stood  groups  of  Tommies,  Sikhs,  Gurkhas,  and 
Pathans.  In  the  centre  the  treaty,  a  voluminous 
scroll,  was  laid  on  a  table,  the  cloth  of  which  was 
a  Union  Jack. 

When  the  terms  had  been  read  in  Tibetan,  the 
signatories  stepped  forward  and  attached  their 
seals  to  the  three  parallel  columns  written  in  Eng- 
Ush,  Tibetan,  and  Chinese.  They  showed  no  trace 
of  suUenness  and  displeasure.  The  regent  smiled 
as  he  added  his  name. 

After  the  signing  Colonel  Younghusband  ad- 
dressed the  Tibetans : 

*  The  convention  has  been  signed.  We  are  now 
at  peace,  and  the  misunderstandings  of  the  past 
are  over.  The  bases  have  been  laid  for  mutual 
good  relations  in  the  future. 


364  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

'  In  the  convention  the  British  Government  have 
been  careful  to  avoid  interfering  in  the  smallest 
degree  with  your  religion.  They  have  annexed 
no  part  of  your  territory,  have  made  no  attempt 
to  interfere  in  your  internal  affairs,  and  have  fully 
recognised  the  continued  suzerainty  of  the  Chinese 
Government.  They  have  merely  sought  to  in- 
sure— 

'  I.  That  you  shall  abide  by  the  treaty  made  by 
the  Amban  in  1890. 

'  2.  That  trade  relations  between  India  and 
Tibet,  which  are  no  less  advantageous  to  you  than 
to  us,  should  be  established  as  they  have  been 
with  every  other  part  of  the  Chinese  Empire,  and 
with  every  other  country  in  the  world  except  Tibet. 

*  3.  That  British  representatives  should  be  treated 
with  respect  in  future. 

'  4.  That  you  should  not  depart  from  your  tra- 
ditional poUcy  in  regard  to  poUtical  relations  with 
other  countries. 

*  The  treaty  which  has  now  been  made  I  promise 
you  on  behalf  of  the  British  Government  we  will 
rigidly  observe,  but  I  also  warn  you  that  we  will  as 
rigidly  enforce  it.  Any  infringement  of  it  will  be 
severely  punished  in  the  end,  and  any  obstruction 


THE  SETTLEMENT.  365 

of  trade,  any  disrespect  or  injury  to  British  sub- 
jects, will  be  noticed  and  reparation  exacted. 

*  We  treat  you  well  when  you  come  to  India. 
We  do  not  take  a  single  rupee  in  Customs  duties 
from  your  merchants.  We  allow  any  of  you  to 
travel  and  reside  wherever  you  will  in  India.  We 
preserve  the  ancient  buildings  of  the  Buddhist 
faith,  and  we  expect  that  when  we  come  to  Tibet 
we  shall  be  treated  with  no  less  consideration  and 
respect  than  we  show  you  in  India. 

'  You  have  found  us  bad  enemies  when  you  have 
not  observed  your  treaty  obligations  and  shown 
disrespect  to  the  British  Raj.  You  will  find  us 
equally  good  friends  if  you  keep  the  treaty  and 
show  us  civility. 

*  I  hope  that  the  peace  which  has  at  this  moment 
been  established  between  us  will  last  for  ever,  and 
that  we  may  never  again  be  forced  to  treat  you 
as  enemies. 

*  As  the  first  token  of  peace  I  will  ask  General 
Macdonald  to  release  all  prisoners  of  war.  I  ex- 
pect that  you  on  your  part  will  set  at  liberty  all 
those  who  have  been  imprisoned  on  account  of 
dealings  with  us.* 

At  the  conclusion  of  the  speech,  which  was  inter- 


366  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

preted  to  the  Tibetans  sentence  by  sentence,  and 
again  in  Chinese,  the  Shapes  expressed  their  inten- 
tion to  observe  the  treaty  faithfully.* 

*  The  following  is  a  draft  of  the  terms  as  communicated  by 
The  Times  Correspondent  at  Peking.  The  terms  have  not  yet 
been  disclosed  in  their  final  form,  but  I  imderstand  that  Dr. 
Morrison's  summary  contains  the  gist  of  them  : 

'  I.  Tibetans  to  re-erect  boundary -stones  at  the  Tibet  fron- 
tier. 

'  2.  Tibetans  to  establish  marts  at  Gyangtse,  Yatung,  Gartok, 
and  facilitate  trade  with  India. 

•  3.  Tibet  to  appoint  a  responsible  official  to  confer  with  the 
British  officials  regarding  the  alteration  of  any  objectionable 
features  of  the  treaty  of  1893. 

'  4.  No  further  Customs  duties  to  be  levied  upon  merchandise 
after  the  tariff  shall  have  been  agreed  upon  by  Great  Britain 
and  the  Tibetans. 

'  5.  No  customs  stations  to  be  established  on  the  route  between 
the  Indian  frontier  and  the  three  marts  mentioned  above,  where 
officials  shall  be  appointed  to  facilitate  diplomatic  and  commercial 
intercourse. 

•  6.  Tibet  to  pay  an  indemnity  of  £500,000  in  three  annual 
Instalments,  the  first  to  be  paid  on  January  i,  1906. 

'  7.  British  troops  to  occupy  the  Chumbi  Valley  for  three  years, 
or  until  such  time  as  the  trading  posts  are  satisfactorily  estab- 
lished and  the  indemnity  liquidated  in  full. 

'  8.  All  forts  between  the  Indian  frontier  on  routes  traversed 
by  merchants  from  the  interior  of  Tibet  to  be  demolished. 

*  9.  Without  the  consent  of  Great  Britain  no  Tibetan  territory 
shall  be  sold,  leased,  or  mortgaged  to  any  foreign  Power  what- 
soever ;  no  foreign  Power  whatsoever  shall  be  permitted  to 
concern  itself  with  the  administration  of  the  government  of 
Tibet,  or  any  other  affairs  therewith  connected ;  no  foreign 
Power  shall  be  permitted  to  send  either  official  or  non-official 
persons  to  Tibet — no  matter  in  what  pursuit  they  may  be  en- 
gaged— to  assist  in  the  conduct  of  Tibetan  afiairs ;    no  foreign 


THE  SETTLEMENT.  367 

The  next  day  in  durbar  a  scene  was  enacted 
which  reminded  one  of  a  play  before  the  curtain 
falls,  when  the  characters  are  called  on  the  stage 
and  apprised  of  their  changed  fortunes,  and  every- 
thing ends  happily.  Among  the  mutual  pledges 
and  concessions  and  evidences  of  goodwill  that 
followed  we  secured  the  release  of  the  pohtical 
captives  who  had  been  imprisoned  on  account  of 
assistance  rendered  British  subjects.  An  old  man 
and  his  son  were  brought  into  the  hall  looking 
utterly  bowed  and  broken.  The  old  man's  chains 
had  been  removed  from  his  hmbs  that  morning 
for  the  first  time  in  twenty  years,  and  he  came  in 
blinking  at  the  unaccustomed  light  like  a  blind 
man  miraculously  restored  to  sight.     He  had  been 

Power  shall  be  permitted  to  construct  roads  or  railways  or  erect 
telegraphs  or  open  mines  anywhere  in  Tibet. 

'  In  the  event  of  Great  Britain's  consenting  to  another  Power 
constructing  roads  or  railways,  opening  mines,  or  erecting  tele- 
graphs. Great  Britain  will  make  a  full  examination  on  her  own 
account  for  carrying  out  the  arrangements  proposed.  No  real 
piopeity  or  land  containing  minerals  or  precious  metals  in  Tibet 
shall  be  mortgaged,  exchanged,  leased,  or  sold  to  any  foreign 
Power. 

*  10.  Of  the  two  versions  of  the  treaty,  the  English  text  to  be 
regarded  as  operative.' 

The  ninth  clause,  which  precludes  Russian  interference  and 
consequent  absorption,  is  of  course  the  most  vital  article  of 
the  treaty. 


368         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA; 

the  steward  of  the  Phalla  estate  near  Dongste  j 
his  offence  was  hospitality  shown  to  Sarat  Chandra 
Das  in  1884.  An  old  monk  of  Sera  was  released 
next.  He  was  so  weak  that  he  had  to  be  supported 
into  the  room.  His  offence  was  that  he  had  been 
the  teacher  of  Kawa  Guchi,  the  Japanese  traveller 
who  visited  Lhasa  in  the  disguise  of  a  Chinese  pil- 
grim. We  who  looked  on  these  sad  relics  of  human- 
ity felt  that  their  restitution  to  hberty  was  in  it- 
self sufl&cient  to  justify  our  advance  to  Lhasa. 

On  August  14  the  Amban  posted  in  the  streets 
of  Lhasa  a  proclamation  that  the  Dalai  Lama  was 
deposed  by  the  authority  of  the  Chinese  Emperor, 
owing  to  the  desertion  of  his  trust  at  a  national 
crisis.  Temporal  power  was  vested  in  the  hands 
of  the  National  Assembly  and  the  regent,  while 
the  spiritual  power  was  transferred  to  Panchen 
Rinpoche,  the  Grand  Lama  of  Tashilunpo,  who  is 
venerated  by  Buddhists  as  the  incarnation  of 
Amitabha,  and  held  as  sacred  as  the  Dalai  Lama 
himself.  The  Tashe  Lama,  as  he  is  called  in  Europe, 
has  always  been  more  accessible  than  the  Dalai 
Lama.  It  was  to  the  Tashe  Lama  that  Warren 
Hastings  despatched  the  missions  of  Bogle  and 
Turner,  and  the  intimate  friendship  that  grew  up 


THE  SETTLEMENT.  369 

between  George  Bogle  and  the  reigning  incarna- 
tion is  perhaps  the  only  instance  of  such  a  tie  exist- 
ing between  an  Englishman  and  a  Tibetan.  The 
officials  of  the  Tsang  province,  where  the  Tashe 
Lama  resides,  are  not  so  bigoted  as  the  Lhasa  oli- 
garchy. It  was  a  minister  of  the  Tashe  Lama  who 
invited  Sarat  Chandra  Das  to  Shigatze,  learnt  the 
Roman  characters  from  him,  and  sat  for  hours 
listening  to  his  talk  about  languages  and  scientific 
developments.  The  exile  of  this  man,  and  the 
execution  of  the  Abbot  of  Dongste,  who  was  drowned 
in  the  Tsangpo,  for  hospitality  shown  to  the  Bengali 
explorer,  are  the  most  recent  marks  of  the  differ- 
ence in  attitude  between  the  Lhasans  and  the  people 
of  Tsang. 

The  present  incarnation  has  not  shown  himself 
bitterly  anti-foreign.  During  the  operations  in  Tibet 
he  remained  as  neutral  and  inactive  as  safety  per- 
mitted, and  it  is  not  impossible  that  the  hope  of 
Mr.  Ular  may  be  realized,  and  an  Anglophile  Bud- 
dhist Pope  established  at  Shigatze.  Herein  lies  a 
possible  simplification  of  the  Tibetan  problem, 
which  has  already  lost  some  of  its  complexity  by 
the  flight  of  the  Dalai  Lama  to  Urga. 

In  estimating  the  practical  results  of  the  Tibet 


370         THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

Expedition,  we  should  not  attach  too  much  im- 
portance to  the  exact  observance  of  the  terms  of 
the  treaty.  Trade  marts  and  roads,  and  telegraph- 
wires,  and  open  communications  are  important 
issues,  but  they  were  never  our  main  objective. 
What  was  really  necessary  was  to  make  the  Tibetans 
understand  that  they  could  not  afford  to  trifle  with 
us.  The  existence  of  a  truculent  race  on  our  borders 
who  imagined  that  they  were  beyond  the  reach  of 
our  displeasure  was  a  source  of  great  political  danger. 
We  went  to  Tibet  to  revolutionize  the  whole  policy 
of  the  Lhasa  oligarchy  towards  the  Indian  Govern- 
ment. 

The  practical  results  of  the  mission  are  these: 
The  removal  of  a  ruler  who  threatened  our  security 
and  prestige  on  the  North-East  frontier  by  over- 
tures to  a  foreign  Power ;  the  demonstration  to 
the  Tibetans  that  this  Power  is  unable  to  support 
them  in  their  pohcy  of  defiance  to  Great  Britain, 
and  that  their  capital  is  not  inaccessible  to  British 
troops. 

We  have  been  to  Lhasa  once,  and  if  necessary 
we  can  go  there  again.  The  knowledge  of  this  is 
the  most  effectual  leverage  we  could  have  in  re- 
moving future  obstruction.     In  deaUng  with  people 


THE  SETTLEMENT.  371 

like  the  Tibetans,  the  only  sure  basis  of  respect 
is  fear.  They  have  flouted  us  for  nearly  twenty 
years  because  they  have  not  believed  in  our  power 
to  punish  their  defiance.  Out  of  this  contempt 
grew  the  Russian  menace,  to  remove  which  was  the 
real  object  of  the  Tibet  Expedition.  Have  we  re- 
moved it  ?  Our  verdict  on  the  success  or  failure 
of  Lord  Curzon's  Tibetan  policy  should,  I  think, 
depend  on  the  answer  to  this  question. 

There  can  be  no  doubt  that  the  despatch  of 
British  troops  to  Lhasa  has  shown  the  Tibetans 
that  Russia  is  a  broken  reed,  her  agents  utterly 
unreliable,  and  her  friendship  nothing  but  a  hollow 
pretence.  The  British  expedition  has  not  only 
frustrated  her  designs  in  Tibet :  it  has  made  clear 
to  the  whole  of  Central  Asia  the  insincerity  of  her 
pose  as  the  Protector  of  the  Buddhist  Church. 

But  the  Tibetans  are  not  an  impressionable 
people.  Their  conduct  after  the  campaign  of 
1888  shows  us  that  they  forget  easily.  To  make 
the  results  of  the  recent  expedition  permanent, 
Lord  Curzon's  original  pohcy  should  be  carried 
out  in  full,  and  a  Resident  with  troops  left  in  Lhasa. 
It  will  be  objected  that  this  forward  policy  is  too 
fraught  with  possibilities  of  political  trouble,  and 


372  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

too  costly  to  be  worth  the  end  in  view.  But  half- 
measures  are  generally  more  expensive  and  more 
dangerous  in  the  long-run  than  a  bold  policy  con- 
sistently carried  out. 

We  have  left  a  trade  agent  at  Gyantse  with  an 
escort  of  fifty  men,  as  well  as  four  or  five  companies 
at  Chumbi  and  Phari  Jong,  at  distances  of  lOO  and 
130  miles.  But  no  vigilance  at  Gyantse  can  keep 
the  Indian  Government  informed  of  Russian  or 
Chinese  intrigue  in  Lhasa.  Lhasa  is  Tibet,  and 
there  alone  can  we  watch  the  ever-shifting  panto- 
mime of  Tibetan  politics  and  the  manoeuvres  of 
foreign  Powers.  If  we  are  not  to  lose  the  ground 
we  have  gained,  the  foreign  relations  of  Tibet  must 
stand  under  British  surveillance. 

But  putting  aside  the  question  of  vigilance,  our 
prestige  requires  that  there  should  be  a  British 
Resident  in  Lhasa.  That  we  have  left  an  officer 
at  Gyantse,  and  none  at  Lhasa,  will  be  interpreted 
by  the  Tibetans  as  a  sign  of  weakness. 

Then,  again,  diplomatic  relations  with  Tibet  can 
only  continue  a  farce  while  we  are  ignorant  of  the 
pohtical  situation  in  Lhasa.  Influences  in  the 
capital  grow  and  decay  with  remarkable  rapidity. 
"The  Lamas  are  adepts  in  intrigue.    When  we  left 


THE  SETTLEMENT.  373 

Lhasa,  the  best-informed  of  our  pohtical  officers 
could  not  hazard  a  giiess  as  to  what  party  would 
be  in  power  in  a  month's  time,  whether  the  Dalai 
Lama  would  come  back,  or  in  what  manner  his 
deposition  would  affect  our  future  relations  with 
the  country.  We  only  knew  that  our  departure  from 
Lhasa  was  likely  to  be  the  signal  for  a  conflict  of 
political  factions  that  would  involve  a  state  of  con- 
fusion. The  Dalai  Lama  still  commanded  the 
loyalty  of  a  large  body  of  monks.  Sera  Monastery 
was  known  to  support  him,  while  Gaden,  though 
it  contained  a  party  who  favoured  the  deposed 
Shata  Shap6,  numbered  many  adherents  to  bis 
cause.  The  only  political  figure  who  had  no  follow- 
ing or  influence  of  any  kind  was  the  unfortunate 
Amban.*  Whatever  party  gains  the  upper  hand, 
the  position  of  the  Chinese  Amban  is  not  enviable. 

At  the  moment  of  writing  China  has  not  signed 
the  treaty ;  she  may  do  so  yet,  but  her  signature 
is  not  of  vital  importance.  The  Tibetans  will 
decide  for  themselves  whether  it  is  safe  to  provoke 
QUI  hostility.     If  they  decide  to  defy  us,  then  of 

*  The  Amban  or  Chinese  Resident  in  Lhasa  is  in  the  same 
position  as  a  British  Resident  in  the  Court  of  a  protected  chief 
in  India.  Of  late  years,  however,  the  Amban's  authority  has  been 
little  more  than  nominal. 


374  THE  UNVEILING  OF  LHASA. 

course  trouble  may  arise  from  their  refusing  to 
recognize  the  treaty  of  1904  on  the  pretext  that 
it  was  not  signed  by  the  Amban. 

It  will  be  remembered  that  after  the  campaign 
of  1888  the  convention  we  drew  up  in  Calcutta  was 
signed  by  China,  and  afterwards  repudiated  by 
Tibet.  For  many  years  the  Tibetans  have  ignored 
China's  suzerainty,  and  refused  to  be  bound  by 
a  convention  drawn  up  by  her  in  their  behalf  ; 
but  now  the  plea  of  suzerainty  is  convenient,  they 
may  use  it  as  a  pretext  to  escape  their  new  obliga- 
tions. 

It  is  even  possible  that  the  Amban  advised  the 
Tibetan  delegates  in  Lhasa  to  agree  to  any  terms 
we  asked,  if  they  wanted  to  be  rid  of  us,  as  any 
treaty  we  might  make  with  them  would  be  invalid 
without  the  acquiescence  of  China.  Thus  the 
'  vicious  circle '  revolves,  and  a  more  admirable 
poHtical  device  from  the  Chino-Tibetan  point  of 
view  cannot  be  conceived. 

But  the  permanence  of  the  new  conditions  in 
Tibet  does  not  depend  on  China.  If  the  Tibetans 
think  they  are  still  able  to  flout  us,  they  will  do 
so,  and  one  pretext  will  serve  as  well  as  another. 
But   if   they  have  learnt  that   our  displeasure  is 


THE  SETTLEMENT.  375 

dangerous  they  will  take  care  not  to  provoke  it 
again. 

The  success  or  failure  of  the  recent  expedition 
depends  on  the  impression  we  have  left  on  the 
Tibetans.  If  that  impression  is  to  be  lasting,  we 
must  see  that  our  interests  are  well  guarded  in 
Lhasa,  or  in  a  few  months  we  may  lose  the  ground 
we  gained,  with  what  cost  and  danger  to  ourselves 
only  those  who  took  part  in  the  expedition  can 
understand. 


THE  END. 


PRINTED   IN   GREAT   BRITAIN. 


Established  1798 


T.  NELSON 
&  SONS,  Ltd. 

PRINTERS    AND 
PUBLISHERS 


THE 

NELSON    LIBRARY 

OF    NOTABLE    BOOKS. 


Uniform  in  Price  with  this  Volume. 


AUREABT    ISSUED, 

FROM   A  COLLEGE  WINDOW.  A.  C  Benson. 

Mr.  Benson  is  unquestionably  the  most  popular  essayist 
of  to-day.  Everything  that  comes  from  his  pen  has  an 
indefinable  charm  and  a  peculiar  fascination. 

WILD  ANIMALS   I   HAVE   KNOWN. 

Ernest  Thompson  Seton. 
"These  stories  are  true.  The  animals  in  this  book 
were  all  real  characters.  They  lived  the  lives  I  have 
depicted,  and  showed  the  stamp  of  heroism  and  per- 
sonality." 

SELF-SELECTED   ESSAYS.  Augustine  Birrell. 

The  author's  pointed  humour,  easy  charm  of  style,  and 
acute  grasp  of  detail  give  him  a  front  place  among 
contemporary  men  of  letters. 
II 


FROM   FIJI   TO  THE   CANNIBAL  ISLANDS. 

Beatrice  Grimshaw. 

The  author  takes  us  along  with  her  on  a  delightful 
journey  in  which  strange  new  lands  are  continually 
being  opened  out  before  our  eyes.  What  she  sees  and 
describes,  her  experiences  and  adventures,  and  her  re- 
flections, are  all  equally  entrancing.  Miss  Grimshaw 
has  a  lively  and  humorous  style.  She  seizes  the 
essentials,  and  imparts  to  the  reader  a  vast  amount  of 
information  in  a  tlioroughly  entertaining  way.  Under 
her  plucky  and  expert  guidance  we  explore  Fiji  and 
see  the  life  of  the  people  :  we  are  not  afraid  to  pay 
a  visit  to  the  "mysterious,  murderous  New  Hebrides, 
where  no  one  goes  " ;  we  interview  a  cannibal  chief — 
in  short,  we  are  initiated  into  the  many  mysteries  of 
the  remotest  islands  of  the  world. 

THE   LAND   OF   FOOTPRINTS. 

Stewart  Edward  White. 

"  What  does  a  rhino  look  like,  where  he  lives,  and  what 
did  you  do  the  first  time  one  came  at  you  ?  I  don't 
want  you  to  tell  me  as  though  I  were  either  an  old 
hunter  or  an  admiring  audience,  or  as  though  you  were 
afraid  somebody  might  think  you  were  making  too 
much  of  the  matter.  I  want  to  know  how  you  really 
felt  Were  you  scared  or  nervous  ?  or  did  you  become 
cool?  Tell  me  frankly  just  how  it  was,  so  I  can  see 
the  thing  as  happening  to  a  common  everyday  human 
being.  Then,  even  at  second-hand  and  at  ten  thousand 
miles'  distance,  I  can  enjoy  it  actually,  humanly,  even 
though  vicariously,  speculating  a  bit  over  my  pipe  as 
to  how  I  would  have  liked  it  myself."  The  author 
endeavours  to  fulfil  this  ideal. 
Ill 


A  PERSONAL   RECORD.  Joseph  Conrad. 

The  autobiography  of  one  of  the  most  remarkable 
figures  in  modern  EngHsh  letters. 

EPISODES  OF  THE  REVOLUTION  IN  BRITTANY. 

G.  Lenotre. 
M.  Lenotre  has  attained  great  popularity  in  France  as 
a  picturesque  writer  of  history.  In  this  volume  he  has 
culled  from  unpublished  documents  some  stirring  tales 
of  Brittany's  part  in  the  Revolution. 

LIVES   OF  THE    HUNTED.  E.  Thompson  Seton. 

A  classic  in  the  imaginative  interpretation  of  animal 
life.  Mr.  Thompson  Seton,  who  is  a  naturalist  of  the 
first  order,  gives  the  life  stories  of  various  animals,  and 
his  keen  sympathy  makes  them  as  dramatic  as  a  human 
romance. 

THE   GREAT  ARMADA.  Richard  Hale. 

A  careful  study  of  the  origin,  progress,  and  defeat  of 
Philip's  great  expedition.  The  author  deals  attractively 
with  a  subject  of  which  patriotic  Englishmen  can  never 
tire. 

ADVENTURES  ON  THE  ROOF  OF  THE  WORLD. 

Mrs.  Aubrey  Le  Blond. 

A  second  series  of  Mrs.  Aubrey  Le  Blond's  vivid  stories 
of  mountaineering  adventure. 

THE  STORY  OF  THE  MALAKAND  FIELD  FORCE. 

Winston  S.  Churchill. 

This  was  Mr.  Churchill's  first  published  book.  It  is 
a  fine  piece  of  military  history,  dealing  with  an  episode 
in  the  Indian  frontier  wars. 

IV 


A  TRAMP'S   SKETCHES.  Stephen  Graham. 

In  these  sketches  of  peasant  life  in  remote  Russian 
provinces  Mr.  Graham  reveals  a  world  of  extraordinary 
interest  and  charm — a  world  almost  wholly  unknown  to 
the  Western  reader. 

THE  JOURNAL  OF  THE  DE  GONCOURTS. 

This  book  contains  innumerable  portraits  and  anecdotes 
of  such  men  and  women  as  Renan,  Victor  Hugo,  Zola, 
Daudet,  Turgenev,  Sainte-Beuve,  Gambetta,  and  Sarah 
Bernhardt. 

TRUE   TALES   OF   MOUNTAIN   ADVENTURE. 

Mrs.  Aubrey  Le  Blond. 
In  this  volume  Mrs.  Le  Blond  tells,  for  the  benefit  of 
those  who  are  not  mountaineers,  some  of  the  great 
stories  of  mountaineering. 

GRAIN   OR  CHAFF?  A.  C.  Plowden. 

Mr.  Plowden  has  long  been  famous  as  one  of  the  most 
popular  and  witty  of  the  London  Police  Court  magis- 
trates. His  "  Recollections  "  are  full  of  shrewd  sayings 
and  excellent  stories. 

LIFE   AT   THE   ZOO.  C.  J.  Cornish. 

The  Zoo  is  one  of  our  great  national  playgrounds,  and 
Mr.  C.  J.  Cornish,  who  had  few  rivals  as  a  naturalist, 
provides  in  this  volume  a  most  instructive  and  fascinat- 
ing guide. 

FAMOUS  MODERN  BATTLES.  Captain  Atteridge. 
This  book  may  be  taken  as  an  appendix  to  Creasy's 
"  Decisive  Battles  of  the  World."  Captain  Atteri<^ge 
describes  those  battles  which  have  most  materially 
shaped  the  destiny  of  the  nations  of  to-day — such  as 
the  Alma,  Solferino,  Gettysburg,  Gravelotte,  Omdurman, 
and  the  recent  fights  in  the  Balkan  War.  The  book  is 
fully  provided  with  excellent  maps. 
V 


IN  INDIA.  G.  W.  Steevens. 

This  is  probably,  after  "With  Kitchener  to  Khartum," 
the  most  brilliant  of  the  late  Mr.  Steevens's  books.  He 
went  to  India  when  Lord  Curzon  went  out,  and  spent 
some  months  traversing  the  peninsula  and  turning  his 
searchlight  on  the  conditions  of  native  and  European 
life.  Those  familiar  with  the  country  have  declared 
that  no  other  book  is  so  accurate,  and  one  critic  has 
said  that  the  reader  can  almost  smell  the  East  in  Mr. 
Steevens's  pages. 

REMINISCENCES     OF     SIR     HENRY     HAWKINS 
(LORD    BRAMPTON). 

The  late  Lord  Brampton  was  the  most  original  figure  on 
the  Bench  during  the  last  twenty  years,  and  when  at 
the  Bar  he  was  employed  in  nearly  every  notable  case, 
from  the  Tichborne  Case  downwards.  In  popular 
estimation  "Henry  Hawkins"  enjoyed  a  fame  which 
no  lawyer  has  probably  ever  equalled.  His  "  Reminis- 
cences," edited  by  a  distinguished  brother  lawyer,  is  a 
fascinating  record  of  a  great  legal  career,  and  a  mine  of 
good  stories  and  good  sayings. 

THE    ALPS  FROM    END   TO    END. 

Sir  William  Martin  Conway. 
This  story  of  the  complete  traverse  of  the  Alps  from 
the  Maritime  Alps  to  the  Tyrol  is  a  delightful  holiday 
book,  and  the  best  introduction  that  could  be  found  to 
the  scenery  of  the  "  Playground  of  Europe."  Sir  Martin 
Conway  is  not  only  a  famous  traveller  and  mountaineer, 
but  an  admirable  writer,  and  no  one  can  reproduce 
more  vividly  the  charms  of  a  landscape  and  the  atmos- 
phere of  the  different  mountain  regions. 
VI 


FIFTEEN    CHAPTERS    OF    AUTOBIOGRAPHY. 

G.  W.  E.  Russell. 
Mr.  G.  W.  E.  Russell  gives  us  in  this  book  some 
sketches  from  an  autobiography,  telling  us  of  his  days 
at  Harrow  and  Oxford  and  in  Parliament.  The  volume 
is  full  of  excellent  stories  and  much  brilliant  character- 
ization. 

CRUISE    OF    THE    "ALERTE."  E.  F.  Knight. 

This  book  tells  of  the  adventures  of  a  small  yacht  in 
South  American  waters.  It  is  one  of  the  most  vivid 
and  delightful  of  modern  books  of  travel. 

LIFE  AT  THE  ZOO.  C.  J.  Cornish. 

The  Zoo  is  one  of  our  great  national  playgrounds,  and 
Mr.  C.  J.  Cornish,  who  had  few  rivals  as  a  naturalist, 
provides  in  this  volume  a  most  instructive  and  fascinat- 
ing guide. 

THE   FOUR   MEN.  Hilaire  Belloc. 

What  "The  Path  to  Rome"  did  for  Central  Europe 
Mr.  Belloc's  new  book  does  in  equally  pleasant  fashion 
for  the  south  country  of  England. 

THE  CRUISE  OF  THE  "FALCON."  E.  F.  Knight. 
Mr.  E.  F.  Knight's  tale  of  his  cruise  in  distant  South 
American  waters  in  a  small  yacht  is  one  of  the  classics 
of  sea  adventure. 

COLLECTED  POEMS  OF  HENRY  NEWBOLT. 
This  volume  is  the  reprint  of  Mr.  Newbolt's  earlier 
works — "The  Island  Race"  (which  includes  "Admirals 
All ")  and  "  The  Sailing  of  the  Long  Ships."  Equally 
with  Mr.  Kipling,  Mr.  Newbolt  is  the  poet  of  English 
endeavour,  and  many  of  his  verses,  such  as  "Drake's 
Drum,"  have  long  been  classics.  All  lovers  of  poetry 
will  welcome  a  collection  of  some  of  the  most  inspiring 
songs  in  the  language. 

VII 


NELSON     LIBRARY 
NOTABLE   BOOKS. 


Ob 


CONDENSED    LIST. 


Collections  and  Recollections. 

The  Great  Boer  War. 

Dean  Hole's  "Memories." 

Life  of  Gladstone. 

Psalms  in  Human  Life. 

Wild  Life  in  a  Southern  County. 

The  Forest. 

The  Golden  Age. 

Sir  Henry  Hawkins's  Reminis- 
cences. 

Selected  Essays. 

Life  of  Lord  Russell  of  Killowen. 

Making  of  Modern  Egypt. 

From  the  Cape  to  Cairo. 

Life  of  Alexander  Hamilton. 

A  Book  about  the  Garden. 

Culture  and  Anarchy. 

Collections  and  Recollections  (2nd 
Series). 

Life  of  Frank  Buckland. 

A  Modern  Utopia. 

With  Kitchener  to  Khartum. 

Unveiling  of  Lhasa. 

Life  of  Lord  Dufferin. 

Life  of  Dean  Stanley. 

Popular  Astronomy. 

Dream  Days. 

Round  the  World  on  a  Wheel. 

Path  to  Rome. 

The  Life  of  Canon  Ainger. 

A  Social  Departure. 

Reminiscences  of  Lady  Dorothy 
Nevill. 

Literature  and  Dogma. 


Letters  and  Recollections  of  Sir 

Walter  Scott. 
Sermons    by    the    Rev.     C.     H. 

Spurgeon. 
My  Confidences. 
Sir  Frank  Lockwood. 
The  Making  of  a  Frontier. 
Life  of  General  Gordon. 
Collected  Poems  of  Henry  Newbolt. 
Pot-Pourri  from  a  Surrey  Garden. 
The  Ring  and  the  Book. 
The  Alps  from  End  to  End. 
The  English  Constitution. 
In  India. 

The  Life  of  Cobden. 
The  Life  of  Parnell. 
Havelock's  March. 
Up  from  Slavery. 
Recollections  of  the  Rt.  Hon.  Sir 

Algernon  West. 
Great  Englishmen  of  1 6th  Century. 
Where  Black  Rules  White. 
Historical  Mysteries. 
The  Strenuous  Life. 
Memories  Grave  and  Gay. 
Life  of  Danton. 
Felicity  in  France. 
A  Pocketful  of  Sixpences. 
The  Romance  of  a  Proconsul  (Sir 

George  Grey). 
A  Book  about  Roses. 
Random  Reminiscences. 
The  London  Police  Courts. 
The  Amateur  Poacher, 


VIII 


NELSON  LIBRARY  OF  NOTABLE  BOOKS 

Life  at  the  Zoo.  (^^«^'««*^). 


The  Bancrofts. 

At  the  Works. 

Mexico  as  I  Saw  It. 

Eighteenth  Century  Vignettes. 

The  Great  Andes  of  the  Equator. 

Early  History  of  C.  J.  Fox. 

Through  the  Heart  of  Patagonia. 

Browning  as  a  Religious  Teacher. 

Paris  to  New  York. 

Life  of  Lewis  Carroll. 

A  Naturalist  in  the  Guianas. 

The  Mantle  of  the  East. 

Letters  of  Dr.  John  Brown. 

Jubilee  Book  of  Cricket. 

By  Desert  Ways  to  Baghdad. 

Some  Old  Love  Stories. 

Fields,  Factories,  and  Workshops. 

Life  of  Lord  Lawrence. 

Problems  of  Poverty. 

The  Burden  of  the  Balkans. 

Life  and  Letters  of  Lord  Macaulay. 

— L  and  H. 
What  I  Saw  in  Russia. 
Wild  England  of  To-day. 
Leaves  from  an  Inspector's  Logbook. 
Through  Finland  in  Carts. 
The  Voyage  of  the  **  Discovery." — 

I.  and  II. 
My  Climbs  in  the  Alpsand  Caucasus. 
John  Bright. 

Sea  Wolves  of  the  Mediterranean. 
Poverty. 

Famous  Modern  Battles. 
The  Cruise  of  the  *'  Falcon." 
A.K.H.B.  (A  Volumeof  Selections.) 
The  People  of  the  Abyss. 
Grain  or  Chaff? 


The  Four  Men. 

Cruise  of  the  "Alerte." 

Four  French  Adventurers. 

A  Reaping. 

Fifteen  Chapters  of  Autobiography. 

15,000  Miles  in  a  Ketch. 

Known  to  the  Police. 

The  Story  of  My  Struggles. 

The  City  of  the  World. 

The  Panama  Canal. 

The  Island. 

The  Pleasant  Land  of  France. 

The  River  War. 

True  Tales  of  Mountain  Adventure. 

The  Journal  of  the  De  Goncourts. 

A  Tramp's  Sketches. 

The  Cabin. 

Red  Fox. 

The  Great  Armada. 

Adventures  on  Roof  of  the  World. 

Story  of  the  Malakand  Field  Force. 

In  an  Enchanted  Island. 

Folk  of  the  Furrow. 

The  Eye-Witness. 

Napoleon  :  The  Last  Phase. 

The  Life  of  Lord  Lyons. 

A  Personal  Record. 

Episodes  of  the  French  Revolution 

in  Brittany. 
Lives  of  the  Hunted. 
From  Fiji  to  the  Cannibal  Islands. 
Self-Selected  Essays. 
From  a  College  Window. 
A  Lodge  in  the  Wilderness. 
Wild  Animals  I  have  known. 
The  Land  of  Footprints. 


THOMAS    NELSON    AND    SONS,    Ltd., 

London,  Edinburgh,  and  New  York. 


R 

CO 

w 

H 

C\i      = 

O      ! 

<— 1 

CO 

t> 

<M 

«0 

fH 

1 


1 


£5 


a>: 


1 

o 

Pi 
O 

o 

w 

< 
2; 

Q 

University  of  Toronto 
L'brary 


DO  NOT 

REMOVE 

THE 

CARD 

FROM 

THIS 

POCKET 


Acme  Library  Card  Pocket 

Under  Pat.  "Ref.  Index  FUf" 

Made  by  LIBRARY  BUREAU